Cyberhomes.com vs. Zillow.com. The battle of the century!!!

Cyberhomes.com vs. Zillow.com. The battle of the century!!!

Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes

Ok, not really... :mrgreen: But what I WAS wondering... I've heard people suggest those two sites for finding comps for wholesaling before you can afford a subscription service. Thing is, cyberhomes alwyas seems 20%-60% Lower than zillow. What the heck is a guy supposed to do with that?? :roll: So I was wondering if anybody had a favorite. I know that neither one of them are great, but which one, if you were forced to pick, would you use to start? Thanks!

1Reply
110 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
17y

Like Josh said, there are no shortcuts. Here is an example:

I put in an address where I know the value, here is the breakdown per site:

Zillow: $159k
Epraissal: $147,539
CyberHomes: $112,110

Actual Value: $100k

Talk about throwing money away...cyber homes was close but that 12k could cost me a deal or cut into my profits. The problem with those sites, like others mentioned is they use old comps and if you know your area you can most likely discount some that are too far away just by looking at the street name.

In a market that is rapidly changing you simply cannot afford to rely on outdated data, you need to know what the home is worth TODAY, not last year.

Jeff

See this reply in the discussion

34 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Financial Advisor · Tampa Area, FL · Member since 2008 · 956 posts · 214 votes
    17y

    i use them to look at the recent sales for comparable properties. be cautious and make sure u look at the dates of said sales...i've noticed that zillow uses a lot from 07.

    i also sometimes look at eppraisal.com for this

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Thanks Josh! I don't believe we've met :) So you basically just disregard the "zestimate" or whatever number the site gives you, and just straight go to the comps? I've noticed that about those sites as well. With the 2 year old comps. How is that useful to anyone, I wonder? :) Anyway, keep 'em comin guys!

  • Real Estate Investor · Audubon, PA · Member since 2009 · 13k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    17y

    Try this thread for a bunch of BP links I posted regarding getting comps:

    http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/103/topics/39825-investor-making-an-offer-on-a-short-sale

    And don't forget to vote for that post if you find it worthwhile.

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Thanks Steve, I'm on it!

  • Real Estate Investor · Dale City, VA · Member since 2008 · 317 posts · 77 votes
    17y

    I believe Zillow uses dart boards for their Zestimates. Their comps are pretty good. You can also use Eppraisal, Cyberhomes and a few other free sites for comps.

    Zillow doesn't seem to distinquish between the different types of houses within a geographic area. (At least they don't around me.) You can have townhouses on one block at one price and SFD houses on the next and Zillow will lump them together to get the Zestimate. As a result, Zestimates for townhouses around my house are way overinflated.

    You can also use tax record data. Last year, around me, the tax assessments were too high compared to ARVs. This year, assessed values were cut in half (actually more than half). So now the assessed values are about 2/3 of the ARV. If you know how the tax assessments compare to ARVs, you may be able to quickly come up with ARV.

    Happy estimating!

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y

    Hey Joe,

    I don't like either of those sites but if I had to pick one I would use cyberhomes. Zillow seems to use the county appraised value which in my area is way higher then the true comps.

    I know it's easier to use a website to try and get comps, especially at night when businesses are closed but I would recommend getting in contact with a title company in your area. I have a local title company that is willing to pull comps for me, no charge. The thing I like about their comps vs a realtor is they show ALL sales, not just MLS.

    One word of caution though, I don't ask for "comps", I ask for ALL sales within a one mile radius for the last 90 days and then I sort the data and find my own comps. Hope that helps.

    Jeff

  • Real Estate Investor · Atlanta , GA · Member since 2009 · 70 posts · 15 votes
    17y

    !. Eprassal (about right on target)
    2. Cyberhomes (good most of the time)
    3. Zillow (out there flapping)

  • Joshua D.Pro Member
    BiggerPockets Founder · HI · Member since 2008 · 16k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    17y

    Guys - As I always say, there are no shortcuts. Don't forget that!

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y

    Like Josh said, there are no shortcuts. Here is an example:

    I put in an address where I know the value, here is the breakdown per site:

    Zillow: $159k
    Epraissal: $147,539
    CyberHomes: $112,110

    Actual Value: $100k

    Talk about throwing money away...cyber homes was close but that 12k could cost me a deal or cut into my profits. The problem with those sites, like others mentioned is they use old comps and if you know your area you can most likely discount some that are too far away just by looking at the street name.

    In a market that is rapidly changing you simply cannot afford to rely on outdated data, you need to know what the home is worth TODAY, not last year.

    Jeff

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Thanks guys! Jeff, will a title company that you have not yet worked with do that for you? Who would you speak with to get that done?

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Joseph Ziolkowski:
    Thanks guys! Jeff, will a title company that you have not yet worked with do that for you? Who would you speak with to get that done?


    YES! They want your business. Almost any of the title agents can pull them up for you. Mine will email them too me or fax them.

    Jeff

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Awesome! So would you just call them out of the blue? Stop in? Sorry if the question seems stupid :)

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Joseph Ziolkowski:
    Awesome! So would you just call them out of the blue? Stop in? Sorry if the question seems stupid :)

    Yeah I call whenever I need comps. There is a title company that I don't know anyone at and I've never been in before but they pull comps for me in that county. It's all about being able to quickly build rapport with someone as well as being polite and respectful.

    I'm sure there are lots of title companies in your area and they are all competing for business. Title companies want to take care of investors and realtors. What other type of buyer is going to have them close multiple deals a year? Retail buyers see them maybe two or three times in their life so from a business perspective it makes sense to take care of the people that feed you.

    Jeff

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Thanks Jeff, I will give that a try. Do you call them about every property you are thinking about making an offer on?

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y

    Not every property, I live in a small town and I know the comps pretty well. Some rural areas are tough though because alot of them have acreage vs a small "city" lot and usually very few comps to compare.

    What I like to do to stay on top of it is look every couple weeks at recent sales. I also keep track of what the realtors are doing, especially with REO's. On some of the REO's I make notes every time they lower a price so I can follow it along. You'd be amazed at how often a realtor will start 40-50k above where they should, then they lower the price as the market falls but still remain too high. It's like they're in denial about what the true value of these homes are. Oh well, that's another topic.

    Bottom line is you need to study your target area thoroughly so you know the comps as good or better then the realtors for that area.

    Jeff

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y

    Another thing to point out; since I know my market I can get within $20k of any property in my area, which allows me to feel out a seller and see if it is worth my time and theirs to dig deeper into the comps to make a solid offer.

    Example:

    I got a call from a lady last week that has a "fixer" she wants to sell, I know the ARV is approx. $140 - 150K, she said its needs a full remodel: roof, kitchen, bath, floors, paint in and out, etc. Without seeing the house I knew I could offer no more then $70 - 80k. When I asked what she wanted she told me $135k, so no need to pull comps on that one. Make sense?

    Jeff

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Sure does, thanks Jeff! Even when I was newer than I am now, your advice was always solid. When you say that every couple of weeks you check recent sales. Do you get that info from the title company, a realtor, or somewhere else? Sorry to ask so many questions, but I feel like we're on a roll here :)

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Joseph Ziolkowski:
    Sure does, thanks Jeff! Even when I was newer than I am now, your advice was always solid. When you say that every couple of weeks you check recent sales. Do you get that info from the title company, a realtor, or somewhere else? Sorry to ask so many questions, but I feel like we're on a roll here :)

    Glad to help Joe. Depends on the county. There is one county near me that I can view all sales online through the county website. In my county I need to call the title company or a realtor. You might be able to have the tax assessor print a list for you, I've never asked though.

    Another thing I do is always look on the mls and craigslist, you'll see the same homes week after week and once they start to disappear from the listings you can go to the county site and see if it was sold. That's also a good way to find buyers...if your watching the REO's on the mls, you can follow them along until they sell and see who is buying them up. In my area there is one guy that is buying like crazy, I see his name on 80% or more of the recent REO sales. This obviously also helps you learn your market better.

    Jeff

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Great idea! I like the county idea. I'm just trying to figure out a way to organize the info. My county isn't the best about that.

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y

    Yeah my county sucks too, that's why the title company is so helpful. The main thing is getting accurate data asap.

    Jeff

  • Real Estate Investor · St. Louis, MO · Member since 2008 · 443 posts · 91 votes
    17y

    I would average the two and add in a few more. Go with an average of as many as you can and hope like heck they are close enough.

    Brian Haskins

  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Brian Haskins:
    I would average the two and add in a few more. Go with an average of as many as you can and hope like heck they are close enough.

    Brian Haskins

    Why take a chance and potentially loose a deal when you can get accurate data from a title company, realtor, or tax assessor??

    Jeff

  • Real Estate Investor · Audubon, PA · Member since 2009 · 13k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Jeff And Cheray Warner:
    ...

    Why take a chance and potentially loose a deal when you can get accurate data from a title company, realtor, or tax assessor??

    Jeff



    Using "accurate" to describe "tax assessor" just doesn't seem correct in most cases. Getting sold data for comparables from the county recorder of deeds would be a more accurate county gov't source for this type of data.
  • Real Estate Investor · North Central Arkansas · Member since 2009 · 509 posts · 178 votes
    17y

    Steve,

    I'm referring to obtaining a list of SOLD properties from the tax assessor, NOT the tax assessed value. In my county I can obtain a list of SOLD homes from the tax assessor, but I still prefer the title company.

    Jeff

  • Inspector · Alsip, IL · Member since 2008 · 361 posts · 75 votes
    17y

    Thanks guys, this is all very helpful! Please keep the ideas flowing here. It would be sweet if this were a go-to post for this topic!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.