Second thoughts and opinions.

Second thoughts and opinions.

Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes

Aloha Everyone, working on acquiring my first deal!

I apologize for such a lengthy post. Wife and I had recently changed our lives around by paying off all our debt of $90k, and fixing our credit scores. We still have a substantial amount of capital on the side to invest into real estate. I've been educating a lot lately on REI. Our initial plan was to purchase a multi-unit home on Maui to house hack. However, the market here is supper expensive. We have reached out to about six lenders with pre-approval numbers that we are happy about but understand that its not enough to buy a home and only enough to buy a condo which is not in our criteria.

My pivot here is to start investing in STR's and acquire a passive income to afford these multi-unit LTR's on Maui and in other states across the U.S.

You might be thinking "Why not just buy the condo on Maui and do STR from it?" I have analyzed countless properties here on the island and the math is just not mathing. Purchase price is very high, and HOA fees are out of this world.

Ive done my research on STR's and picked three locations where the numbers make sense and are affordable based on the capital we have. These three locations are; Kauai, HI | Florida (Destin, Kissimmee and Orlando) | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania I have networked with experienced investors in the STR field and are being very helpful with providing a gameplan into STR. For right now I was directed to choose one location which would be Kauai, HI

I guess what Im asking for is opinions from others that also have experience in STR's (Airbnb) if I'm on the right track here. Thank you and looking forward to connecting with you.

4Reply
783 views

Most Popular Reply

Nicholas L.Pro Member
Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
5mo

@Brandonlee Kuhaulua

just to challenge your proposal a little - you want to buy an STR to generate 'passive income,' to buy LTRs with?!

STRs aren't passive.

and investing from thousands of miles away just because you've done some networking is spectacularly high risk.

am i missing something?

See this reply in the discussion

26 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Melissa HartvigsenBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Beaverton, OR · Member since 2020 · 192 posts · 159 votes
    5mo

    Hello @Brandonlee Kuhaulua,

    What metrics you're using to narrow down your locations to; Kauai, HI | Florida (Destin, Kissimmee and Orlando) | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania? Are you looking at your cash on cash return projections, cash flow, occupancy rate, average daily rate, income to purchase price ratio, which has the most STR friendly regulations?

    Each of your identified markets has a different price point to enter the market, seasonal occupancy variances are different, and the average returns in each market are also different. For example, the Kissimmee Florida market offers the potential for more year-round stable travel due to the nearby theme parks, when compared to Pittsburgh which has peak and off-peak seasons. Between the two, Florida has a higher cost of entry than Pittsburgh. I believe in Kauai which is your top choice, has the highest average daily rate for bookings on Airbnb relative to the other two markets you identified.

    If you opt for Pennsylvania, why not choose a market ranked higher than Pittsburg? For example, back at the end of 2024 rabu ranked Pittsburgh 10th in the state of Pennsylvania for Airbnb performance projections for 2025.

    https://rabbu.com/blog/best-short-term-rental-markets-in-pennsylvania

    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Melissa Hartvigsen:

      Hello @Brandonlee Kuhaulua,

      What metrics you're using to narrow down your locations to; Kauai, HI | Florida (Destin, Kissimmee and Orlando) | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania? Are you looking at your cash on cash return projections, cash flow, occupancy rate, average daily rate, income to purchase price ratio, which has the most STR friendly regulations?

      Each of your identified markets has a different price point to enter the market, seasonal occupancy variances are different, and the average returns in each market are also different. For example, the Kissimmee Florida market offers the potential for more year-round stable travel due to the nearby theme parks, when compared to Pittsburgh which has peak and off-peak seasons. Between the two, Florida has a higher cost of entry than Pittsburgh. I believe in Kauai which is your top choice, has the highest average daily rate for bookings on Airbnb relative to the other two markets you identified.

      If you opt for Pennsylvania, why not choose a market ranked higher than Pittsburg? For example, back at the end of 2024 rabu ranked Pittsburgh 10th in the state of Pennsylvania for Airbnb performance projections for 2025.

      https://rabbu.com/blog/best-short-term-rental-markets-in-pen... Melissa,

      Thank you for reaching out. Ive been running comps through Rabbu.com, Aribnb.com, AirDNA.com and came across these three locations categorized under the following, "Is this a place you like?" (Pittsburgh PA), "Is this a place where it meets your capital and the numbers make sense?" (Florida - Kissimme, Orlando, Destin), and "Is this a place where you have a little bit of all; Desire, Affordability and Returns?" (Kauai, HI). I have narrowed down my location as Kauai, HI.

      You are definitely correct about Pittsburgh PA. I chose that market personally because I'm a Steelers fan lol. Chose Florida because not only did the numbers make sense but also the location is more affordable than Hawai'i and in certain locations, brings the tropical feeling of home.

      I chose Kauai, HI as my first because I found an affordable location where I had also stayed at in an Airbnb. Expenses and returns all fall in my criteria.

      I guess you can say, I'm just second guessing it. The real thought I'm having is "Am I on the right track?" Should I acquire three cheaper properties out of state with the same or less numbers in return or should I start locally with one to two properties gathering experience before investing out of state?


  • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
    5mo

     before investing out of state?

  • Rental Property Investor · Waikapu, HI · Member since 2018 · 305 posts · 197 votes
    5mo

    Aloha Brandonlee,

    I started with STRs here on Maui, and hit financial freedom in 5 years because of it.  Since then we've transitioned to other assets and classes, but depending on your time horizon will determine a lot.  We run a real estate meetup every month here on Maui.  Had one yesterday.  Would've been great to see you there, it's free and all levels of investors show up.  Some out of state investors, some local etc. 

    That said, don't take the numbers you're seeing on AirDNA or Rabbu or anything like that as gospel. Reach out to people locally that are actually doing. Many are happy to share their data, what's working and what ideas they have. I've seen numbers on AirDNA that are so far from what my actuals are that it's made me laugh. 

    Network. That's the biggest thing here. Talk to people who are full time investors not just guys who "have an airbnb." I'm not trying to dissuade you, but honestly, there are properties available right now on Maui that are good deals. The numbers have come down substantially, the political environment is clearing up and the opportunities are there. Not to mention sellers are SUPER motivated.  Kauai may look better right now, or Big Island or lots of other places, but when Maui gets back on track with tourism (and it will) Maui STRs will be every bit as lucrative.  Plus the appreciation from buying at a discount (right now) is huge.  We've made millions on appreciation alone in the last couple years. 

    You definitely need to know what to buy, but there are opportunities on our island right now.  Not saying you have to, but knowing what metrics and data to be looking at and knowing your time horizon is key. 

    Good luck!  Hope to see you at a meetup sometime soon!

    Aloha!

    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Mike Neubauer:

      Aloha Brandonlee,

      I started with STRs here on Maui, and hit financial freedom in 5 years because of it.  Since then we've transitioned to other assets and classes, but depending on your time horizon will determine a lot.  We run a real estate meetup every month here on Maui.  Had one yesterday.  Would've been great to see you there, it's free and all levels of investors show up.  Some out of state investors, some local etc. 

      That said, don't take the numbers you're seeing on AirDNA or Rabbu or anything like that as gospel. Reach out to people locally that are actually doing. Many are happy to share their data, what's working and what ideas they have. I've seen numbers on AirDNA that are so far from what my actuals are that it's made me laugh. 

      Network. That's the biggest thing here. Talk to people who are full time investors not just guys who "have an airbnb." I'm not trying to dissuade you, but honestly, there are properties available right now on Maui that are good deals. The numbers have come down substantially, the political environment is clearing up and the opportunities are there. Not to mention sellers are SUPER motivated.  Kauai may look better right now, or Big Island or lots of other places, but when Maui gets back on track with tourism (and it will) Maui STRs will be every bit as lucrative.  Plus the appreciation from buying at a discount (right now) is huge.  We've made millions on appreciation alone in the last couple years. 

      You definitely need to know what to buy, but there are opportunities on our island right now.  Not saying you have to, but knowing what metrics and data to be looking at and knowing your time horizon is key. 

      Good luck!  Hope to see you at a meetup sometime soon!

      Aloha!


       Aloha Mike, 

      Thank you for your valuable response. There is no coincidence that I have been recommended by a few reputable real estate investors to attend the monthly meetups hosted by you and Caroline. Due to my work schedule, it's been challenging to attend. No excuses here, my wife and I will be at the next one. We would definitely be interested in networking a little more with you on the STR sector here on Maui.

      Mahalo.

    • Rental Property Investor · Waikapu, HI · Member since 2018 · 305 posts · 197 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Brandonlee Kuhaulua:
      Quote from @Mike Neubauer:

      Aloha Brandonlee,

      I started with STRs here on Maui, and hit financial freedom in 5 years because of it.  Since then we've transitioned to other assets and classes, but depending on your time horizon will determine a lot.  We run a real estate meetup every month here on Maui.  Had one yesterday.  Would've been great to see you there, it's free and all levels of investors show up.  Some out of state investors, some local etc. 

      That said, don't take the numbers you're seeing on AirDNA or Rabbu or anything like that as gospel. Reach out to people locally that are actually doing. Many are happy to share their data, what's working and what ideas they have. I've seen numbers on AirDNA that are so far from what my actuals are that it's made me laugh. 

      Network. That's the biggest thing here. Talk to people who are full time investors not just guys who "have an airbnb." I'm not trying to dissuade you, but honestly, there are properties available right now on Maui that are good deals. The numbers have come down substantially, the political environment is clearing up and the opportunities are there. Not to mention sellers are SUPER motivated.  Kauai may look better right now, or Big Island or lots of other places, but when Maui gets back on track with tourism (and it will) Maui STRs will be every bit as lucrative.  Plus the appreciation from buying at a discount (right now) is huge.  We've made millions on appreciation alone in the last couple years. 

      You definitely need to know what to buy, but there are opportunities on our island right now.  Not saying you have to, but knowing what metrics and data to be looking at and knowing your time horizon is key. 

      Good luck!  Hope to see you at a meetup sometime soon!

      Aloha!


       Aloha Mike, 

      Thank you for your valuable response. There is no coincidence that I have been recommended by a few reputable real estate investors to attend the monthly meetups hosted by you and Caroline. Due to my work schedule, it's been challenging to attend. No excuses here, my wife and I will be at the next one. We would definitely be interested in networking a little more with you on the STR sector here on Maui.

      Mahalo.

      Awesome!  Looking forward to meeting you guys. Connect with me on IG too if you’re on it. I’m much more active over there. @OurFamilyInvests , @MikeyNeu 

      Aloha!
  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    5mo

    Forget about Orlando & Kissimmee right now. I have a house there and it's been lousy the last 3 years and there's a ton of inventory and bottom feeders renting super cheap. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Ryan MoyerBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orlando Kissimmee Davenport Salt Lake City, Park City · Member since 2019 · 996 posts · 1k+ votes
    5mo

    I have 25 in Kissimmee and also have some experience and Destin.

    Straight away, Destin is an appreciation/lifestyle market. If cash flow is your goal, it's not the right place. If lifestyle or appreciation are your goal it can be great.

    Kissimmee you really have to have at LEAST $100k+ to invest into theming to compete. With that, it can be okay. But it's still not going to be the top market for cash flow. Can be decent cash flow alongside other advantages such as lifestyle (if you like visiting Disney), more stable year round income (not relegated to one high season where a maintenance issue could knock out a huge chunk of your annual revenue), and very little regulation risk (if you buy in the approved STR resorts) and little long term demand risk (people will always visit Disney).

    For pure cashflow, probably none of the ones you picked are the ideal spot. Cash flow means random tertiary markets no one has ever heard of where the competition is low. If you're looking for more than just cash flow you have to weigh those other points like entry price, regulation risk, appreciation, etc.

    Feel free to pick my brain on Kissimmee, I'm happy to share anything I know even here publicly.

    Cosmic Vacations4.9177 Reviews
    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Ryan Moyer:

      I have 25 in Kissimmee and also have some experience and Destin.

      Straight away, Destin is an appreciation/lifestyle market. If cash flow is your goal, it's not the right place. If lifestyle or appreciation are your goal it can be great.

      Kissimmee you really have to have at LEAST $100k+ to invest into theming to compete. With that, it can be okay. But it's still not going to be the top market for cash flow. Can be decent cash flow alongside other advantages such as lifestyle (if you like visiting Disney), more stable year round income (not relegated to one high season where a maintenance issue could knock out a huge chunk of your annual revenue), and very little regulation risk (if you buy in the approved STR resorts) and little long term demand risk (people will always visit Disney).

      For pure cashflow, probably none of the ones you picked are the ideal spot. Cash flow means random tertiary markets no one has ever heard of where the competition is low. If you're looking for more than just cash flow you have to weigh those other points like entry price, regulation risk, appreciation, etc.

      Feel free to pick my brain on Kissimmee, I'm happy to share anything I know even here publicly.


       Thank you for this comment, Ryan this is very helpful. I truly appreciate this; I will re-evaluate and look at other markets as well. I have about $200k to invest into real estate. Cashflow is my goal at the moment. My ultimate goal is resigning from my job and giving my all to acquiring assets in the real estate sector. I will definitely be reaching out to connect with you more.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    5mo
    Quote from @Brandonlee Kuhaulua:

    Aloha Everyone, working on acquiring my first deal!

    I apologize for such a lengthy post. Wife and I had recently changed our lives around by paying off all our debt of $90k, and fixing our credit scores. We still have a substantial amount of capital on the side to invest into real estate. I've been educating a lot lately on REI. Our initial plan was to purchase a multi-unit home on Maui to house hack. However, the market here is supper expensive. We have reached out to about six lenders with pre-approval numbers that we are happy about but understand that its not enough to buy a home and only enough to buy a condo which is not in our criteria.

    My pivot here is to start investing in STR's and acquire a passive income to afford these multi-unit LTR's on Maui and in other states across the U.S.

    You might be thinking "Why not just buy the condo on Maui and do STR from it?" I have analyzed countless properties here on the island and the math is just not mathing. Purchase price is very high, and HOA fees are out of this world.

    Ive done my research on STR's and picked three locations where the numbers make sense and are affordable based on the capital we have. These three locations are; Kauai, HI | Florida (Destin, Kissimmee and Orlando) | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania I have networked with experienced investors in the STR field and are being very helpful with providing a gameplan into STR. For right now I was directed to choose one location which would be Kauai, HI

    I guess what Im asking for is opinions from others that also have experience in STR's (Airbnb) if I'm on the right track here. Thank you and looking forward to connecting with you.


    Be VERY careful investing OOS!

    Esp[ecially if you are a newbie.

    Safest is always to invest in your backyard, or somewhere you can relatively easy get to. 

    Investing OOS, requires you to put your trust in others to do what's in you best interests.

    Unfortunately, via incompetence and/or deceit. many OOS investors are screwed by those they choose to trust:(

    If you invest OOS, assume everyone is lying to you about everything until you research & verify otherwise!

    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:
      Quote from @Brandonlee Kuhaulua:

      Aloha Everyone, working on acquiring my first deal!

      I apologize for such a lengthy post. Wife and I had recently changed our lives around by paying off all our debt of $90k, and fixing our credit scores. We still have a substantial amount of capital on the side to invest into real estate. I've been educating a lot lately on REI. Our initial plan was to purchase a multi-unit home on Maui to house hack. However, the market here is supper expensive. We have reached out to about six lenders with pre-approval numbers that we are happy about but understand that its not enough to buy a home and only enough to buy a condo which is not in our criteria.

      My pivot here is to start investing in STR's and acquire a passive income to afford these multi-unit LTR's on Maui and in other states across the U.S.

      You might be thinking "Why not just buy the condo on Maui and do STR from it?" I have analyzed countless properties here on the island and the math is just not mathing. Purchase price is very high, and HOA fees are out of this world.

      Ive done my research on STR's and picked three locations where the numbers make sense and are affordable based on the capital we have. These three locations are; Kauai, HI | Florida (Destin, Kissimmee and Orlando) | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania I have networked with experienced investors in the STR field and are being very helpful with providing a gameplan into STR. For right now I was directed to choose one location which would be Kauai, HI

      I guess what Im asking for is opinions from others that also have experience in STR's (Airbnb) if I'm on the right track here. Thank you and looking forward to connecting with you.


      Be VERY careful investing OOS!

      Esp[ecially if you are a newbie.

      Safest is always to invest in your backyard, or somewhere you can relatively easy get to. 

      Investing OOS, requires you to put your trust in others to do what's in you best interests.

      Unfortunately, via incompetence and/or deceit. many OOS investors are screwed by those they choose to trust:(

      If you invest OOS, assume everyone is lying to you about everything until you research & verify otherwise!


       God bless you Drew. Thank you for this comment. I currently live on Maui, HI. I have about $200k to invest but that would be it which would maybe be enough for a condo here. now before you go searching up condos on Maui, the worse place would be "Harbour Lights" trust me. All other condos especially those on the beach front and on the south side of Maui are high risk for flooding and erosion. However, I believe I could find one here locally there's no doubt. My thought process out of state was to acquire more than just one property in one market to diversify. But lately, I've been really leaning on getting an investment locally. 

    • Drew SygitBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Brandonlee Kuhaulua:
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:
      Quote from @Brandonlee Kuhaulua:

      Aloha Everyone, working on acquiring my first deal!

      I apologize for such a lengthy post. Wife and I had recently changed our lives around by paying off all our debt of $90k, and fixing our credit scores. We still have a substantial amount of capital on the side to invest into real estate. I've been educating a lot lately on REI. Our initial plan was to purchase a multi-unit home on Maui to house hack. However, the market here is supper expensive. We have reached out to about six lenders with pre-approval numbers that we are happy about but understand that its not enough to buy a home and only enough to buy a condo which is not in our criteria.

      My pivot here is to start investing in STR's and acquire a passive income to afford these multi-unit LTR's on Maui and in other states across the U.S.

      You might be thinking "Why not just buy the condo on Maui and do STR from it?" I have analyzed countless properties here on the island and the math is just not mathing. Purchase price is very high, and HOA fees are out of this world.

      Ive done my research on STR's and picked three locations where the numbers make sense and are affordable based on the capital we have. These three locations are; Kauai, HI | Florida (Destin, Kissimmee and Orlando) | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania I have networked with experienced investors in the STR field and are being very helpful with providing a gameplan into STR. For right now I was directed to choose one location which would be Kauai, HI

      I guess what Im asking for is opinions from others that also have experience in STR's (Airbnb) if I'm on the right track here. Thank you and looking forward to connecting with you.


      Be VERY careful investing OOS!

      Esp[ecially if you are a newbie.

      Safest is always to invest in your backyard, or somewhere you can relatively easy get to. 

      Investing OOS, requires you to put your trust in others to do what's in you best interests.

      Unfortunately, via incompetence and/or deceit. many OOS investors are screwed by those they choose to trust:(

      If you invest OOS, assume everyone is lying to you about everything until you research & verify otherwise!


       God bless you Drew. Thank you for this comment. I currently live on Maui, HI. I have about $200k to invest but that would be it which would maybe be enough for a condo here. now before you go searching up condos on Maui, the worse place would be "Harbour Lights" trust me. All other condos especially those on the beach front and on the south side of Maui are high risk for flooding and erosion. However, I believe I could find one here locally there's no doubt. My thought process out of state was to acquire more than just one property in one market to diversify. But lately, I've been really leaning on getting an investment locally. 


      ALways better to get some experience locally, then invest OOS.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Paia, HI · Member since 2016 · 479 posts · 311 votes
    5mo

    Curious how Kauai is a better market for you than Maui? Is it lower price point? Higher occupancy? 

    i do know a couple of pms on Kauai who approached me a couple of years ago about brokering their business. I'll dig up their contact info for you

    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Loren Clive:

      Curious how Kauai is a better market for you than Maui? Is it lower price point? Higher occupancy? 

      i do know a couple of pms on Kauai who approached me a couple of years ago about brokering their business. I'll dig up their contact info for you


      Aloha Loren, Thank you for your comment. Truly means a lot and the help is appreciated. I have been re-evaluating my search here on Maui I will most likely look into a STR here locally.

      Aloha. 

  • Nicholas L.Pro Member
    Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    5mo

    @Brandonlee Kuhaulua

    just to challenge your proposal a little - you want to buy an STR to generate 'passive income,' to buy LTRs with?!

    STRs aren't passive.

    and investing from thousands of miles away just because you've done some networking is spectacularly high risk.

    am i missing something?

    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Nicholas L.:

      @Brandonlee Kuhaulua

      just to challenge your proposal a little - you want to buy an STR to generate 'passive income,' to buy LTRs with?!

      STRs aren't passive.

      and investing from thousands of miles away just because you've done some networking is spectacularly high risk.

      am i missing something?

      Aloha Nicholas, Thank you for your comment. 

      My initial decision for investing into real estate is to generate cashflow and accomplish generational wealth. My reason for looking out of state is because, where I am located, the median price for a home is $1.75mill. I wanted to use the capital I have of $200k to diversify my assets in different locations that were cheaper. But aye, things may change real soon as I am re-valuating my local market and networking with experienced and reputable investors. 
    • Real Estate Consultant · Denver, CO · Member since 2021 · 667 posts · 389 votes
      4mo
      Quote from @Nicholas L.:

      @Brandonlee Kuhaulua

      just to challenge your proposal a little - you want to buy an STR to generate 'passive income,' to buy LTRs with?!

      STRs aren't passive.

      and investing from thousands of miles away just because you've done some networking is spectacularly high risk.

      am i missing something?


      STRs can be passive or active investments. In order to be active, the yearly average rental must be 7 days or less, the owner MUST keep detailed records of doing at least 100 hours managing the rental and more than any other person/entity. 100% Bonus Depreciation is available if purchased in some specific past years or any year after 1/20/25. The STR is automatically active if the owner is a qualified RE Professional. STR are always depreciated over 39 years, not 27.5...this is a common mistake by owners and their tax professionals and can trigger an IRS audit.

      If purchasing a STR in a state other than the one you live in is suspect. The IRS will want to know how you devoted 100 hours in personally managing a property that is not in your state.

    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      4mo
      Quote from @Bonnie Griffin Kaake:
      Quote from @Nicholas L.:

      @Brandonlee Kuhaulua

      just to challenge your proposal a little - you want to buy an STR to generate 'passive income,' to buy LTRs with?!

      STRs aren't passive.

      and investing from thousands of miles away just because you've done some networking is spectacularly high risk.

      am i missing something?


      STRs can be passive or active investments. In order to be active, the yearly average rental must be 7 days or less, the owner MUST keep detailed records of doing at least 100 hours managing the rental and more than any other person/entity. 100% Bonus Depreciation is available if purchased in some specific past years or any year after 1/20/25. The STR is automatically active if the owner is a qualified RE Professional. STR are always depreciated over 39 years, not 27.5...this is a common mistake by owners and their tax professionals and can trigger an IRS audit.

      If purchasing a STR in a state other than the one you live in is suspect. The IRS will want to know how you devoted 100 hours in personally managing a property that is not in your state.

      Aloha Bonnie,
      Thank you for sharing that info regarding the IRS. I did not know about that. Will do deeper research on the matter. Thank you again for your help. 
  • Jamie DietzBusiness Member
    Lender · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2015 · 176 posts · 90 votes
    5mo

    I live, invest, and lend in Pittsburgh, including owning several short-term rentals. It's likely the least expensive market you mentioned, but you really need to understand the neighborhoods to make an STR pencil out.

    One other thing to keep in mind: STRs are not passive investments—not even close. Even if you hire a property manager, you still need to actively manage the systems, pricing, marketing, and operations to make them successful.

    Happy to chat if you have any questions about the Pittsburgh market.

    Next Door Capital516 Reviews
    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      4mo
      Quote from @Jamie Dietz:

      I live, invest, and lend in Pittsburgh, including owning several short-term rentals. It's likely the least expensive market you mentioned, but you really need to understand the neighborhoods to make an STR pencil out.

      One other thing to keep in mind: STRs are not passive investments—not even close. Even if you hire a property manager, you still need to actively manage the systems, pricing, marketing, and operations to make them successful.

      Happy to chat if you have any questions about the Pittsburgh market.


       Aloha Jamie, 

      Thank you for your advice on the Pittsburgh market. I will DM you. Happy to chat. Thank you. 

  • Melissa HaworthBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · The Panhandle | The Emerald Coast | Panama City Beach | Destin · Member since 2017 · 299 posts · 112 votes
    4mo

    Hey Brandon,

    First, congratulations to you and your wife. Paying off $90k in debt, improving your credit, and building investment capital is a huge accomplishment. A lot of people talk about investing in real estate, but you've already demonstrated the discipline it takes to be successful long-term.

    I actually think you're making a smart decision by pivoting instead of forcing a house hack on Maui just because that was the original plan. One of the biggest mistakes I see new investors make is becoming emotionally attached to a strategy rather than following the numbers.

    Since my market is Florida's Emerald Coast, I'll speak specifically to Destin. What attracts many investors here is that you can still find properties that generate strong vacation rental income without some of the acquisition costs and HOA fees that can make Hawaii so challenging. Destin also benefits from a well-established tourism industry, beautiful beaches, and a consistent stream of visitors throughout much of the year.

    That said, I would encourage you to think beyond projected Airbnb revenue. Look closely at insurance costs, property management, local regulations, and what your exit strategy would be if the STR market softened. The investors who do well in this space are usually the ones who underwrite conservatively and have multiple plans for the property.

    One thing I really like about your approach is that you're narrowing your focus. If I were in your shoes, I'd pick one market and become an expert in it before branching out. Whether that's Kauai or Destin, there's a huge advantage in knowing a market inside and out rather than trying to learn four markets at once.

    From what you've shared, it sounds like you're approaching this thoughtfully and not chasing shiny objects. That's a great sign for a first-time investor. Keep analyzing deals, keep talking to local operators, and don't feel pressured to buy until the numbers make sense. The right first deal is worth waiting for.

    Wishing you and your wife the best on your investing journey!

    • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 6 votes
      4mo
      Quote from @Melissa Haworth:

      Hey Brandon,

      First, congratulations to you and your wife. Paying off $90k in debt, improving your credit, and building investment capital is a huge accomplishment. A lot of people talk about investing in real estate, but you've already demonstrated the discipline it takes to be successful long-term.

      I actually think you're making a smart decision by pivoting instead of forcing a house hack on Maui just because that was the original plan. One of the biggest mistakes I see new investors make is becoming emotionally attached to a strategy rather than following the numbers.

      Since my market is Florida's Emerald Coast, I'll speak specifically to Destin. What attracts many investors here is that you can still find properties that generate strong vacation rental income without some of the acquisition costs and HOA fees that can make Hawaii so challenging. Destin also benefits from a well-established tourism industry, beautiful beaches, and a consistent stream of visitors throughout much of the year.

      That said, I would encourage you to think beyond projected Airbnb revenue. Look closely at insurance costs, property management, local regulations, and what your exit strategy would be if the STR market softened. The investors who do well in this space are usually the ones who underwrite conservatively and have multiple plans for the property.

      One thing I really like about your approach is that you're narrowing your focus. If I were in your shoes, I'd pick one market and become an expert in it before branching out. Whether that's Kauai or Destin, there's a huge advantage in knowing a market inside and out rather than trying to learn four markets at once.

      From what you've shared, it sounds like you're approaching this thoughtfully and not chasing shiny objects. That's a great sign for a first-time investor. Keep analyzing deals, keep talking to local operators, and don't feel pressured to buy until the numbers make sense. The right first deal is worth waiting for.

      Wishing you and your wife the best on your investing journey!


       Aloha Melissa, 

      Sending my Aloha spirit your way. Thank you for your words of support and encouragement. Looking forward to connecting more and will update you on the progress. 

  • Realtor · Kihei, HI · Member since 2026 · 5 posts · 0 votes
    4mo

    Aloha, Brandonlee.

    First, congratulations to you and your wife for paying down the debt and getting yourselves into a position to invest. That takes discipline.

    I would be careful calling STR income passive, especially off-island or out of state. Even with a manager, you are still depending on pricing, reviews, maintenance, guest experience, local regulations and the right property type. That is a lot to learn on a first deal.

    Since you are already on Maui, there is something to be said for investing in a market you can see firsthand, even if the numbers are tougher. If you do find deals on Kauai or the mainland, I would make sure you have actual operator numbers, not just projections, and a clear backup plan if the STR income does not meet expectations.

    If cash flow is the main goal, I would be extra careful with any market where the return only works under strong occupancy or perfect management. Your first deal should still give you enough financial and personal bandwidth to work through the learning curve.

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4mo
    Quote from @Brandonlee Kuhaulua:

    Aloha Everyone, working on acquiring my first deal!

    I apologize for such a lengthy post. Wife and I had recently changed our lives around by paying off all our debt of $90k, and fixing our credit scores. We still have a substantial amount of capital on the side to invest into real estate. I've been educating a lot lately on REI. Our initial plan was to purchase a multi-unit home on Maui to house hack. However, the market here is supper expensive. We have reached out to about six lenders with pre-approval numbers that we are happy about but understand that its not enough to buy a home and only enough to buy a condo which is not in our criteria.

    My pivot here is to start investing in STR's and acquire a passive income to afford these multi-unit LTR's on Maui and in other states across the U.S.

    You might be thinking "Why not just buy the condo on Maui and do STR from it?" I have analyzed countless properties here on the island and the math is just not mathing. Purchase price is very high, and HOA fees are out of this world.

    Ive done my research on STR's and picked three locations where the numbers make sense and are affordable based on the capital we have. These three locations are; Kauai, HI | Florida (Destin, Kissimmee and Orlando) | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania I have networked with experienced investors in the STR field and are being very helpful with providing a gameplan into STR. For right now I was directed to choose one location which would be Kauai, HI

    I guess what Im asking for is opinions from others that also have experience in STR's (Airbnb) if I'm on the right track here. Thank you and looking forward to connecting with you.

    Happy to have you here! First off, congrats on paying off $90k in debt and rebuilding your credit—that puts you in a much stronger position than a lot of first-time investors. I think your biggest strength right now is that you're willing to pivot instead of forcing a deal that doesn't pencil out. My only caution would be not to choose a market based solely on today's Airbnb numbers. Before buying, I'd dig into local regulations, seasonality, insurance costs, cleaning and management expenses, and what occupancy looks like outside the peak months. I'd also make sure the property still has a reasonable exit strategy if STR rules change or you eventually need to convert it to a long-term rental. If you've narrowed it to Kauai, spend some time talking with local managers and reviewing actual owner statements rather than relying only on projections. Since you're open to investing out of state, I'd also keep an open mind about markets beyond the vacation destinations. Some investors find that steady long-term cash flow in growing markets can be a lower-risk way to build capital before jumping into STRs. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!
  • Walnut Creek, CA · Member since 2010 · 52 posts · 3 votes
    2mo

    How is it going so far on Kauai? 

    I have one condo unit on sale near Kaiser in Kahului.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.