Why Does Everybody Want Passive Income From the Most Active Business in the World?

Why Does Everybody Want Passive Income From the Most Active Business in the World?

Real Estate Coach · Miami, FL · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 487 votes

I know a man who bought a rental property because he was tired of working for a living. He wanted passive income.

Six months later, he knew three plumbers by their first names, had developed strong opinions about water heaters, and was spending Sunday afternoons discussing somebody else's toilet. I asked him how retirement was going. He told me to go to hell.

There's something wonderfully optimistic about the phrase passive income in real estate. Buy a property. Find tenants. Collect rent. Watch your bank account grow while you develop an interest in fishing. Then the air conditioner dies in August. The tenant calls. The contractor doesn't answer. The replacement part is on back order. And suddenly your passive income has developed a very active personality.

Of course, somebody will immediately point out that you should hire a property manager. Excellent idea. Now somebody else gets the calls about the toilet. But you still have to hire the manager, pay the manager, make sure the manager is doing his job, approve major expenses, and occasionally find a new manager because the first one turned out to be considerably more passive than the income.

So what exactly have we made passive? Not the building. It still needs maintenance. Not the tenants. They still need attention. Not the business. Somebody still has to operate it. We've simply moved the work around. And there's nothing wrong with that. Delegating operations is how businesses grow. A well-managed rental portfolio can require relatively little day-to-day involvement from its owner.

But that's not quite the same as income appearing out of thin air. Somebody is doing the work. Either you're paying them, or you're doing it yourself and conveniently forgetting to put your own labor on the expense sheet. Maybe the problem isn't rental property investing. It's the fantasy that ownership somehow eliminates the need for management.

Passive income isn't necessarily income without work. It's income from work that doesn't necessarily have to be yours. And if the numbers only look attractive because you've valued your own time at zero, perhaps you've bought yourself a job with an unusually expensive entrance fee.

So here's my question. When we call rental income passive, are we describing the investment, or merely announcing that we've found somebody else to answer the phone?

1Reply
974 views

Most Popular Reply

Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
Moderator
Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
3w

Depending on the property and how you manage it will depend on how passive it is. If you are buying a Class A rental with a property manager and give them a high budget to fix something, then yes, it can be extremely passive. For example, I have a rental and a condo that are very passive, and I do pay a property manager, probably too much, to basically do nothing. When something does happen, that one time, they deal with it, and I don't have to. To me, that is worth the expense.

A lot of these strategies, subject to, seller finance, carrying the note, or short-term rental, I do not really see these as being very passive. To me, passive is like owning a stock. My 401(k). The only thing I do is potentially change asset or investment on something that is liquid. For real estate, unless you're investing in a fund, which is one where the investor has no control, most of real estate is not passive.

7e investments53 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

17 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • New to Real Estate · Asheville, NC · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 6 votes
    3w

    I think the idea is that it’s “mostly” passive. More passive to do those mentioned tasks a few hours a week, than 40. It’s all about proper systems in place, where I think most people fail at.

  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    3w

    Depending on the property and how you manage it will depend on how passive it is. If you are buying a Class A rental with a property manager and give them a high budget to fix something, then yes, it can be extremely passive. For example, I have a rental and a condo that are very passive, and I do pay a property manager, probably too much, to basically do nothing. When something does happen, that one time, they deal with it, and I don't have to. To me, that is worth the expense.

    A lot of these strategies, subject to, seller finance, carrying the note, or short-term rental, I do not really see these as being very passive. To me, passive is like owning a stock. My 401(k). The only thing I do is potentially change asset or investment on something that is liquid. For real estate, unless you're investing in a fund, which is one where the investor has no control, most of real estate is not passive.

    7e investments53 Reviews
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    3w

    some rental RE can be.. like NNN deals. Or as mentioned A class in expensive areas. But returns on those are not as high as ( at least on paper) SFRs in the C D class and investors dont really understand the difference until they jump in. My banker and I fish a few times a year and in between bites when we are chatting this always comes up. He owns a 12 unit and a few other SFR's and he just laughs when I tell them about how things are portrayed on BP and investors think they can buy rentals and its all going to work out for them in this passive investment.. its anything but passive for most rentals. Not that is hard your generally not doing hard labor but sit back and get mailbox money not realistic for most

  • Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 153 posts · 78 votes
    3w

    I think it's mostly the second one. After almost 14 years in real estate and 7 as an investor, I'd say rentals are semi passive at best. With a decent PM at 8 to 10 percent of rent, my own time is maybe an hour or two a month per door, but only because I set up the systems up front. The people who get burned are the ones who count rent minus mortgage and forget to budget for vacancy, repairs and the PM fee. If the deal still cash flows after you pay someone to answer the phone, then it's passive enough. If it only works when you do the work yourself, you bought a job.

  • Member since 2026 · 149 posts · 42 votes
    3w

    Rent is as passive as the systems behind it. I spent years around a 90-unit operation, and the rent showed up every month whether anyone felt like working or not - but only because somebody had already done the work: screening, solid leases, preventive maintenance, and reserves for the big-ticket items. The owners who get burned skip that setup and then act surprised when the phone rings.

    A manager moves the phone calls, it doesn't remove them. You're now managing the manager, which is a smaller job but still a job.

    The honest frame: rentals are an operating business where income can become mostly passive after the systems and reserves are in place, not on day one.

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3w

    I disagree; real estate can be very passive cashflow if you buy Class A 2 to 4 units and avoid working-class or low income towns. For my North Side Chicago four-unit property, I spend maybe 20 to 30 hours a YEAR managing it. The tenants are on autopay, they take good care of the place, and I only lease to 680 plus credit tenants who have never even needed a late notice. I have tenants meet a contractor or give out the lockbox when repairs are needed; all done by text. The compounded rent growth over time has now created strong cash flow of around $3,000 net a month off that one building alone. I had a very similar 4 unit in a cashflow lower income area that place was NOT passive and I sold it thankfully somehow for double what I paid. Stay in good areas and its passive.

  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 697 votes
    3w

    Jimmy's point about forgetting vacancy, repairs and the PM fee is the real gap, and it shows up on the books quickly. On a $1,600 rent, a 10% PM fee is $160 a month, plus a vacancy allowance of 5% is $80, plus maybe $100 a month for repairs. That's $340 before the mortgage, which is more than a lot of people budget.

    Separately, your own time never appears on the books, so I'd keep a simple log of hours per property for a couple of months. If it's 10 hours a month and the property nets $200, that's $20 an hour, and now you're comparing it to a job.

    That log also matters for taxes, since time and involvement can affect how losses are treated. Keep it real and dated.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
  • Investor · Florence, AL · Member since 2026 · 7 posts · 1 vote
    3w

    A useful ownership metric might be hours required per month alongside cash distributed after management fees and reserves. Delegation can reduce routine work, but an escalation plan for major repairs and unexpected expenses still needs an owner. How do you define that boundary with a manager?

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    3w

    Either the owner has to have great systems or the PMC they hire has to.

    If neither has systems it's crashing & burning.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    3w

    @Drago Stanimirovic I think part of the problem is that "passive" means different things to different people. For one owner it means never hearing about a repair. For another it means approving every expense over a few hundred dollars but never talking to a guest or tenant. I've done all three strategies, and how passive each one feels has depended as much on the owner as on the property.

    My first purchase was two duplexes in a less-than-desirable part of Orlando. Tenants often paid weekly and there were constant issues. Nothing about that was passive. Looking back, the location was the problem, so I'd back up what Henry said about where you buy.

    Today most of my units are furnished and set up for 30+ day stays, with short stays filling the gaps, and I co-host STRs for other owners. Nobody should call STR passive. It's a hospitality business: pricing, guest messages, cleanings, restocking, reviews. Mid-term sits in the middle. There are fewer turns than STR but more than a 12-month lease. Extensions do a lot of the work there. I leave a window open after each stay so a guest can extend, and every extension is one less turnover to coordinate.

    On Clinton's question about where the owner's job ends and the manager's begins, I don't think there's one definitive answer, because it depends on what "passive" means to that owner. Some want to sign off on every repair. Others just want the monthly statement and a call when something major comes up. A really good manager works within the owner's guidelines instead of forcing everyone into the same setup. So the useful step is to put those guidelines in writing at the start: what the manager can approve alone, what needs a call first, and how much stays in reserves.

    Whatever "passive" means to you, the deal still has to work after you pay someone to do the active part. That's the rule I use when I buy: the property has to at least break even as a long-term rental, without counting tax benefits. I also underwrite it with my company as the manager, so a management fee is in the numbers from day one even though I'm the one doing the work. That way, if I want to sell or refinance down the road, the management cost is already allocated and the numbers hold up for a buyer or a lender.

    Disclosure: I co-host STRs for other owners.

  • Real Estate Agent · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 632 posts · 363 votes
    3w

    More like we've found someone else to answer the phone! The work doesn't disappear just because a property manager handles it. The owner still has to make decisions, approve expenses, and keep an eye on things. It's definitely more hands-off, but calling it completely passive is a stretch.More like we've found someone else to answer the phone! The work doesn't disappear just because a property manager handles it. The owner still has to make decisions, approve expenses, and keep an eye on things. It's definitely more hands-off, but calling it completely passive is a stretch.

  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 976 posts · 357 votes
    3w

    @Drago Stanimirovic the water heater line got me. Ours have never been passive. The closest we've come is systems. Our HVAC company services every unit in September on a retainer, so we aren't finding problems on the first cold night, and we use AI agents to track every lease date and renewal on one simple dashboard. Still work, just fewer surprises. Enjoyed this one.

    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme549 Reviews
  • Member since 2022 · 71 posts · 69 votes
    3w

    My 14 units ( 2 properties) are relatively easy to manage myself but they are not passive. All tenants have my cell # and they will call at 10 pm or 6am when the heat in their apartment malfunctions. I've had several fire alarm calls, a flood due to a broken water main, roof leaks etc. Then there are tenant disagreements, parking issues ( one building is next to my bank and they love to call me when a tenant or guest parks too long in a bank spot.), etc.

    My main business is a car wash/detail shop/used car lot. The car wash is another business where people think it's "passive income", "absentee owner", "cash cow". The car wash business can indeed be passive if you are ok with owning a dump, where the equipment is broken and the trash is left to blow around the parking lot. I take pride in my wash, so I do the work required to make it look great and to keep everything working as it should.

    I didn't invest in real estate for 'easy money'. I invested to build long-term wealth. My real estate business isn't overly hard; it gets better and gains value based on how much effort I put into it.

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 340 posts · 83 votes
    3w

    Drago, you've nailed the gap. Hiring a manager doesn't make it passive, it moves you from fixing toilets to supervising the people who do. That's still a real improvement, but only if you set it up to run without you chasing it.

    Here's what separates an owner who stays hands-off from one who ends up micromanaging. First, agree on a repair approval limit in writing, so small items get handled without a phone call and large ones come to you with an estimate. Second, get a monthly owner statement with the invoices behind it, and spot check a couple each month. Third, track a few numbers: days vacant, how long maintenance takes to close, and how often you hear from the manager. If any of those drift, you'll know before it costs you.

    The owners I see struggle usually never defined what good looks like, so everything becomes a judgment call. Define it once, review monthly, and your involvement drops to about an hour. Happy to compare notes by message.

    Real Property Management Optimal 525 Reviews
  • Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 287 posts · 48 votes
    2w

    Ha, rentals are passive right up until the first 2 AM call. After two decades in property management I'd say the folks who stay happiest build a small crew they trust and keep good notes, so the work turns into a routine instead of a surprise.

    Randy, Bunklow

  • Flipper/Rehabber · CA · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2w

    "ThE mOsT aCtIvE BuSiNeSs in ThE woRld "

    😆

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.