Ready to buy my first house hack

Ready to buy my first house hack

Member since 2023 · 9 posts · 8 votes

I'm looking for some advice on what to have in order before buying my first house hack. I've been waiting for the moment where I'm ready to buy for so long, but now I'm feeling unprepared. I'm 23, steady job, single income, and plan to buy a duplex and house hack. I've already been approved by my lender for a conventional 5% down loan and have about $20K set aside for downpayment and closing costs and $10K in an emergency fund (hoping this is enough). I plan to invest local to where I am now, Fox Valley/Green Bay/Appleton WI area. 

Does anyone have advice on what to have in order before really beginning to look and make an offer? I already have a realtor and my next steps are to find a property management company, but I don't really know what to expect for expenses like lawn care or other initial costs. Do I need to set up a separate business bank account or credit card for this purchase, where does the rent money go? What should I be keeping in mind for when taxes come around? What type of insurance should I be thinking about if I'm owner occupying? What else am I forgetting?

I feel like I might be getting caught up in analysis paralysis right now, so any advice from people who have house hacked before would be greatly appreciated!

4Reply
540 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · New Braunfels, TX · Member since 2021 · 291 posts · 257 votes
4mo
Quote from @Abby Gruendemann:

I'm looking for some advice on what to have in order before buying my first house hack. I've been waiting for the moment where I'm ready to buy for so long, but now I'm feeling unprepared. I'm 23, steady job, single income, and plan to buy a duplex and house hack. I've already been approved by my lender for a conventional 5% down loan and have about $20K set aside for downpayment and closing costs and $10K in an emergency fund (hoping this is enough). I plan to invest local to where I am now, Fox Valley/Green Bay/Appleton WI area. 

Does anyone have advice on what to have in order before really beginning to look and make an offer? I already have a realtor and my next steps are to find a property management company, but I don't really know what to expect for expenses like lawn care or other initial costs. Do I need to set up a separate business bank account or credit card for this purchase, where does the rent money go? What should I be keeping in mind for when taxes come around? What type of insurance should I be thinking about if I'm owner occupying? What else am I forgetting?

I feel like I might be getting caught up in analysis paralysis right now, so any advice from people who have house hacked before would be greatly appreciated!

You don’t need a property manager. Get a lawn mower and mow your own lawn. As long as your job can support the payment of the duplex on its own it’s not an issue. Your taxes should be built into your mortgage. That’s what PITI stands for. Make sure what you buy has a roof that will last ten more years. Same for AC/heat. Go do it!
See this reply in the discussion

21 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · New Braunfels, TX · Member since 2021 · 291 posts · 257 votes
    4mo
    Quote from @Abby Gruendemann:

    I'm looking for some advice on what to have in order before buying my first house hack. I've been waiting for the moment where I'm ready to buy for so long, but now I'm feeling unprepared. I'm 23, steady job, single income, and plan to buy a duplex and house hack. I've already been approved by my lender for a conventional 5% down loan and have about $20K set aside for downpayment and closing costs and $10K in an emergency fund (hoping this is enough). I plan to invest local to where I am now, Fox Valley/Green Bay/Appleton WI area. 

    Does anyone have advice on what to have in order before really beginning to look and make an offer? I already have a realtor and my next steps are to find a property management company, but I don't really know what to expect for expenses like lawn care or other initial costs. Do I need to set up a separate business bank account or credit card for this purchase, where does the rent money go? What should I be keeping in mind for when taxes come around? What type of insurance should I be thinking about if I'm owner occupying? What else am I forgetting?

    I feel like I might be getting caught up in analysis paralysis right now, so any advice from people who have house hacked before would be greatly appreciated!

    You don’t need a property manager. Get a lawn mower and mow your own lawn. As long as your job can support the payment of the duplex on its own it’s not an issue. Your taxes should be built into your mortgage. That’s what PITI stands for. Make sure what you buy has a roof that will last ten more years. Same for AC/heat. Go do it!
    • Lender · AZ · Member since 2022 · 148 posts · 95 votes
      4mo
      Quote from @Mike Kirby:
      Quote from @Abby Gruendemann:

      I'm looking for some advice on what to have in order before buying my first house hack. I've been waiting for the moment where I'm ready to buy for so long, but now I'm feeling unprepared. I'm 23, steady job, single income, and plan to buy a duplex and house hack. I've already been approved by my lender for a conventional 5% down loan and have about $20K set aside for downpayment and closing costs and $10K in an emergency fund (hoping this is enough). I plan to invest local to where I am now, Fox Valley/Green Bay/Appleton WI area. 

      Does anyone have advice on what to have in order before really beginning to look and make an offer? I already have a realtor and my next steps are to find a property management company, but I don't really know what to expect for expenses like lawn care or other initial costs. Do I need to set up a separate business bank account or credit card for this purchase, where does the rent money go? What should I be keeping in mind for when taxes come around? What type of insurance should I be thinking about if I'm owner occupying? What else am I forgetting?

      I feel like I might be getting caught up in analysis paralysis right now, so any advice from people who have house hacked before would be greatly appreciated!

      You don’t need a property manager. Get a lawn mower and mow your own lawn. As long as your job can support the payment of the duplex on its own it’s not an issue. Your taxes should be built into your mortgage. That’s what PITI stands for. Make sure what you buy has a roof that will last ten more years. Same for AC/heat. Go do it!
      This ^. Don't overcomplicate this and have it lead to unnecessary fear. You sound like you are intelligent. For the questions that you have just think of logical answers. That will be more than enough to get you started.
  • Andrew PostellPro Member
    Lender · Fort Worth, TX · Member since 2016 · 8k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4mo

    @Abby Gruendemann buying a house has to be something that you feel comfortable doing.  Don't let anyone talk you into it or our of it - it's your decision and it's has to feel right.  Trust your instincts.  I would encourage you to lean on your partners here.  They should be able to give you all the information, facts, and answer all your questions for you.  If you have all the information you need, you can make a good decision.  If you have good partners and good information, then that's what all of us need to start.  Sounds like you may have it?  Trust your instincts!  You can also reach out to me if you want anything specific answered.  Here to help!

  • Aaron ZimmermanBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4mo

    There's a lot you're not going to know when first buying your first property. Your job is to mitigate your risks. 

    You do that by:

    1. Educating yourself through podcasts, books, and in person meetups. 

    2. networking so that you know who to call for various issues. At a minimum, just to buy a property, youll want a realtor, lender, and insurance agent. Once you have the property, it's up to you to appropriately service. You'll need the following people:

    1. Handyman

    2. contractor (depending on if you're doing rehab).

    3. HVAC technican

    4. appliance repair 

    5. electrician. 

    6. cleaners (for turnovers) 

    On insurance, youll want to walk this through with your insurance agent but you should get preferential home owner rates. 

    For taxes, pm me and I can provide you with a spreadsheet I use to keep track of income and expenses. As a cpa, I would not let taxes be your initial worry but they do need to get taken care of eventually. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4mo

    I agree with everyone here, don't go the property manager route. It is important that you self manage so that you learn the ins and outs of the business. This way when you do hire a PM in the future, you know how to set expectations and can see through the BS. 

    I also wouldn't overcomplicate it. That is a common thing I notice. You can have just a regular separate account to put the rent and expenses through. And that's only if you really want to. If you track the accounting well, then you could in theory put it in your own account. Once it comes a full on separate rental, then for sure have the separate account.

    I would just jump in and get the property and work through it. The best education is experience. Don't overextend yourself financially and understand this isn't a sprint, it is a marathon. 

    In terms of expenses such as lawn care, ask your Realtor and then shop around. Lean on your Realtor. If they don't know these things, then find a new one. A good Realtor knows that this is a relationship to help you build out a portfolio. 

  • Real Estate Broker · New York, NY · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4mo

    Hey Abby,

    Before making an offer, I'd focus on knowing your numbers inside and out. Account for maintenance, vacancies, insurance, taxes, and other operating expenses, not just the mortgage. I'd also talk with an insurance agent about the right policy for an owner-occupied duplex and find a CPA so you know how to keep good records from day one.

    I'd also start thinking about life after closing. Have a plan for marketing the other unit, screening tenants, collecting rent, and handling maintenance. Those systems will make your first house hack much smoother.

    Best of luck to you, and feel free to connect with my - my DMs are always open!

  • Ryan SpathBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Boise, ID · Member since 2017 · 610 posts · 387 votes
    4mo
    Quote from @Abby Gruendemann:

    I'm looking for some advice on what to have in order before buying my first house hack. I've been waiting for the moment where I'm ready to buy for so long, but now I'm feeling unprepared. I'm 23, steady job, single income, and plan to buy a duplex and house hack. I've already been approved by my lender for a conventional 5% down loan and have about $20K set aside for downpayment and closing costs and $10K in an emergency fund (hoping this is enough). I plan to invest local to where I am now, Fox Valley/Green Bay/Appleton WI area. 

    Does anyone have advice on what to have in order before really beginning to look and make an offer? I already have a realtor and my next steps are to find a property management company, but I don't really know what to expect for expenses like lawn care or other initial costs. Do I need to set up a separate business bank account or credit card for this purchase, where does the rent money go? What should I be keeping in mind for when taxes come around? What type of insurance should I be thinking about if I'm owner occupying? What else am I forgetting?

    I feel like I might be getting caught up in analysis paralysis right now, so any advice from people who have house hacked before would be greatly appreciated!


    I've found that most first-time house hackers are more prepared than they think, and it sounds like you're in a solid position. You're already approved for financing, have money set aside for your down payment, closing costs, and an emergency fund, which is more than many buyers have when they start. At this point, I'd focus on understanding the numbers property taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, vacancy, lawn care, and future capital expenses and make sure the deal still makes sense with realistic assumptions. Since you'll be owner-occupying, talk with an insurance agent about the right policy for an owner-occupied duplex, and while you don't need an LLC or business bank account to get started, I do recommend opening a separate checking account for the property to keep rental income and expenses organized for tax time. I'd also build a team now, including a good inspector, insurance agent, handyman, plumber, HVAC technician, and a CPA familiar with real estate investing. Most importantly, don't let analysis paralysis keep you on the sidelines. No first deal is perfect, and you'll learn more from owning your first house hack than you ever will from trying to prepare for every possible scenario. Focus on buying a property with strong fundamentals and solid numbers, and the rest becomes much easier with experience.

  • Homeowner · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 3 votes
    4mo

    You might be more ready than you think. $20K for entry plus a separate $10K emergency fund at 23 puts you ahead of most people who post here after closing.

    On your specific questions, from someone who bought a duplex and lives in one of the units:

    Expenses that surprised me the first year: 

    Boiler, that was a rough one. 

    Plumber and Electrician coming in to deal with some clogs (a drain snake visit, which I've done myself a few times since), and the fact that when something breaks in the other unit you're paying retail for a plumber on their schedule, not yours. 

    I set aside $200/month for repairs and vacancy from day one and it made smaller surprises a non-event. If your inspection is clean, your first year is usually the cheapest one you'll ever have its wise to budget like it isn't, though.

    Self-manage the first one. You live there. A property manager costs 8-10% of rent to answer calls you'd hear through the wall anyway. Screening the tenant well matters ten times more than who handles the toilet call.

    Accounting: Not totally necessary but may be helpful to have a separate checking account for everything property-related, from day one. Rent in, expenses out, nothing else touches it. Come tax time, your (or your preparer's) life is simple: the rented unit's share of expenses and depreciation goes on Schedule E, your side doesn't. I work in corporate accounting and even so I'd say: have a tax preparer do year one so you see how the split works. Not tax advice, confirm with a CPA.

    Insurance: you want a policy written for an owner-occupied two-unit, not a regular homeowner's policy. Say those words to the agent. Get a quote before you're under contract, since duplex premiums vary more than people expect.

    The analysis paralysis usually isn't about data — it's that no spreadsheet will say "yes, definitely." At some point a decent deal you actually buy beats the perfect one you keep modeling. hit me up if you want to know more, and good luck!

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4mo
    Quote from @Abby Gruendemann:

    I'm looking for some advice on what to have in order before buying my first house hack. I've been waiting for the moment where I'm ready to buy for so long, but now I'm feeling unprepared. I'm 23, steady job, single income, and plan to buy a duplex and house hack. I've already been approved by my lender for a conventional 5% down loan and have about $20K set aside for downpayment and closing costs and $10K in an emergency fund (hoping this is enough). I plan to invest local to where I am now, Fox Valley/Green Bay/Appleton WI area. 

    Does anyone have advice on what to have in order before really beginning to look and make an offer? I already have a realtor and my next steps are to find a property management company, but I don't really know what to expect for expenses like lawn care or other initial costs. Do I need to set up a separate business bank account or credit card for this purchase, where does the rent money go? What should I be keeping in mind for when taxes come around? What type of insurance should I be thinking about if I'm owner occupying? What else am I forgetting?

    I feel like I might be getting caught up in analysis paralysis right now, so any advice from people who have house hacked before would be greatly appreciated!

    Welcome to BP, Abby! Honestly, it sounds like you're in a much better position than you think. At 23 with financing lined up, money set aside, and a clear strategy, you've already checked off a lot of the big items. I'd focus on understanding your numbers before anything else. Get estimates for taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, vacancy, and repairs so you know what your true monthly costs look like instead of just the mortgage payment. Since you'll be owner-occupying, ask your insurance agent about a homeowner policy that covers the rental unit as well. I wouldn't worry about setting up an LLC or separate business bank account right away for your first house hack. Many people simply collect rent into a separate checking account dedicated to the property to keep everything organized, then track income and expenses throughout the year for tax time. I'd also budget for small upfront costs that are easy to overlook like locks, smoke detectors, cleaning, basic tools, and a few unexpected repairs after closing. It sounds like you're experiencing normal first-deal nerves more than being unprepared. At some point, you'll learn more by owning your first property than by reading another 20 forum posts. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!

  • Property Manager · Warsaw · Member since 2026 · 107 posts · 38 votes
    4mo

    Totally normal to feel this way — it means you're taking it seriously. Quick hits:

    Before you buy:

    • Separate business checking account for rent/expenses — keeps taxes and your personal life clean. A dedicated card too, even if it's just a personal one used only for the property.
    • Bump emergency fund thinking: aim for 3-6 months of total mortgage PITI, not just personal expenses, once you close. $10K is a start but tight for a duplex — build it back up fast post-close.
    • Budget 1-2% of property value/year for maintenance/capex reserves, separate from emergency fund.

    Expenses people forget:

    • Lawn care/snow removal (Wisconsin — budget real money for plowing), landscaping
    • Vacancy/turnover costs between tenants
    • Property management fees (usually 8-12% of rent if you go that route)
    • Higher utilities if you're covering common areas
    • PMI until you hit 20-22% equity

    Insurance: landlord/owner-occupied duplex policy (not standard homeowners) — covers the rental unit's liability. Umbrella policy is smart once you have a tenant. Require renters insurance from your tenant too.

    Taxes: You'll split expenses between personal (your unit) and rental (their unit) by square footage. Track everything — mileage, repairs, mgmt fees, depreciation on the rental portion. Talk to a CPA who knows real estate before year one, not after.

    Rent money: goes into that separate business account, not your personal checking — makes bookkeeping and taxes way easier.

    You sound prepared. Analysis paralysis is real, but you've done the hard parts (lender approval, realtor, capital). Go look at properties — you'll learn faster in the field than by reading more.

    • Member since 2023 · 9 posts · 8 votes
      4mo

       Thank you so much for the detailed breakdown, this response was extremely helpful!

  • Nicholas L.Pro Member
    Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    4mo

    @Abby Gruendemann

    hi Abby.  you've done a lot right so i don't have much advice for you.  i'd recommend looking at lots of properties before you put an offer in, and not letting anyone rush you.

    hope that helps

  • Matthew Irish-JonesBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4mo

    How good do you believe your realtor is?  They are a key aspect in getting value.  If they know that to look for they can help you decide where value is.  If it's your cousin who does it part time you are on your own.  A good realtor has seen thousands and thousands of homes and knows instinctively what a good deal looks like.

    Don't but a project.  You will be shocked at how difficult construction is and how much it costs you simply to have the proper tools to complete a project.

    Buying a house hack that needs low skill upgrades is best, Painting, landscaping, carpets, cleaning, and other small updates go a long way.

    Most people can learn how to or already know how to do those types of sweat equity items.

    House hack is #1 best strategy for new investors, good luck!

    Irish Jones Realty4.948 Reviews
    View Page
    • Member since 2023 · 9 posts · 8 votes
      4mo

      @Matthew Irish-Jones I think I have a great realtor, I've had mutiple friends and family recommend her (some who also bought multifamily) and have had a great experience working with her professionally and seeing how she operates (she was one of my clients when I did real estate photography in the past).

      I do think I could probably lean on my realtor a little more, just based on some of the other comments I'm seeing on this post. For example, someone mentioned asking my realtor about lawn care... I wouldn't have thought of that. I think a hard part of this journey for me will be asking for help and trying to not do it all on my own. If you have any other thoughts of what I should ask my realtor through this process or what areas I should really rely on her for that would be appreciated! 

      Thank you for the other tips you mentioned!

    • Matthew Irish-JonesBusiness Member
      Real Estate Agent · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
      4mo

      @Abby Gruendemann ask your realtor for a pro forma on the property.  If they are investor focused they should be able to show you a rough estimate of a P+L which should include rental comps - operating expenses.

      Irish Jones Realty4.948 Reviews
      View Page
  • Investor · Get yourself trained before doing something inadvisable. · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4mo
    Quote from @Abby Gruendemann:

    I'm looking for some advice on what to have in order before buying my first house hack. I've been waiting for the moment where I'm ready to buy for so long, but now I'm feeling unprepared. I'm 23, steady job, single income, and plan to buy a duplex and house hack. I've already been approved by my lender for a conventional 5% down loan and have about $20K set aside for downpayment and closing costs and $10K in an emergency fund (hoping this is enough). I plan to invest local to where I am now, Fox Valley/Green Bay/Appleton WI area. 

    Does anyone have advice on what to have in order before really beginning to look and make an offer? I already have a realtor and my next steps are to find a property management company, but I don't really know what to expect for expenses like lawn care or other initial costs. Do I need to set up a separate business bank account or credit card for this purchase, where does the rent money go? What should I be keeping in mind for when taxes come around? What type of insurance should I be thinking about if I'm owner occupying? What else am I forgetting?

    I feel like I might be getting caught up in analysis paralysis right now, so any advice from people who have house hacked before would be greatly appreciated!

    Since I  don't have you financial picture, I just want to say most people underestimate costs for maintaining a house. Have ample reserves.
  • Member since 2023 · 9 posts · 8 votes
    4mo

    @Matthew Irish-Jones This is a great thought, thank you I will definitely do that!

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4mo

    @Abby Gruendemann, From a tax side, house hacking has a few specifics worth knowing before you buy, not after. Since you'll be owner-occupying one unit and renting the other, you'll split expenses between personal and rental use, generally based on square footage or number of units, mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, and repairs all get allocated that way, only the rental portion is deductible, the personal portion isn't. Depreciation works the same way, you only depreciate the rental unit's share of the property, not the whole building, since your own unit isn't a rental.

    Yes, open a separate business bank account for the rent income and property expenses even at this small scale, mixing it with personal spending makes it much harder to substantiate deductions later and is one of the most common things new landlords regret not doing from day one. Keep every receipt tied to the property, lawn care, repairs, anything, categorized from the start rather than reconstructed at tax time.

    One more thing worth knowing for later, specific to a duplex: since this is a two-unit property rather than a single-family home, the Section 121 exclusion at sale will only apply to your owner-occupied unit's portion of the gain, the rental unit is treated as a separate, non-qualifying property for 121 purposes in a true multi-unit setup, so that gain would be fully taxable (plus depreciation recapture) rather than excluded. Worth keeping that distinction in mind for your exit strategy years down the road, that's actually one advantage a single-family house hack has over a duplex, on an SFH, the entire home can qualify for 121 at sale even if part of it was rented, with only the depreciation recapture portion taxed. Happy to connect!

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • Rental Property Investor · Oconomowoc, WI · Member since 2016 · 996 posts · 432 votes
    3mo

    It's easy to get caught up in analysis paralysis at this stage, but at least it's on your radar so you're more likely to recognize it.

    When interviewing PMs, you want to keep in mind a few things.  1) Be sure you ask for a COMPLETE fee schedule prior to signing.  Only the items listed on the form are the items that can be charged. If they don't have a list, it's concerning.  However, they may just say all fees in the PM agreement, but then you have to be sure you don't have sneaky language that permits fees other than those in the contract.  2) Do not assume that PMs know state laws.  As a former PM I find it shocking how many are not as familiar with state statutes as you would think.  It's a good idea to kind of test their knowledge in a passive way.  "Do you guys issue 3-day notices when rent is late?" (Answer should be no, we issue 5-day notices.) 3) Be sure the property manager is someone you have a good rapport with.  I like to say it should be someone you could see yourself having a beer or coffee with. If it's easy for you to talk to them, the better the relationship will be. 

    There's a local group in Green Bay that is for buy-and-hold investors.  They provide education and solid networking of peole who are active in the industry. Different than a REAI.  

  • Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 287 posts · 47 votes
    2w

    Feeling unprepared right before a big purchase is really common, and being approved with savings set aside already says a lot about how careful you've been. Many people also keep a little cushion past closing costs for the first surprise repair, which can make the nerves settle down.

    Randy, Bunklow

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.