What do you use to keep fix-and-flips, rentals and land deals in one place?

Question

I'm trying to see how other investors keep track of a mixed portfolio. Some of mine are rehabs with budgets and draws, some are long-term rentals with tenants and leases, and some are land I'm holding or developing. Most software I've looked at handles only one of those well.

What do you use for each type, and does any of it talk to the others? A spreadsheet is a fine answer. I'd like to hear what actually works.

Sundeep Babbar · Answer

One thing I'd add since you have flips in the mix: flip costs usually aren't expenses as you go, they pile up as that project's cost until it sells, while the rentals run a normal monthly P&L. So whatever app you land on, check that it can hold a running cost total per flip separate from rental income and expenses, otherwise the year-end numbers get blended. Worth confirming the treatment with your CPA since flips and rentals often get taxed differently.

Rachel Mazzanti · Answer

The master sheet is fine for a snapshot. But I'd run one set of books per entity, not per strategy. That's what saves you later. Flips need job costing, line by line, draws as liabilities until the work's done. Rentals just need a tag per property so the P&L pulls clean. Land, don't forget it, just log taxes and carrying costs as they hit. My company keeps the detail in the accounting system and the sheet simple. One row per property, money in, money out, next date that matters. The sheet tells you where you are. The books answer the lender and the CPA.

Addy Chupa · Answer

Eric, one thing I'd add to the master sheet idea: give every deal the same return column, so the three types can be compared against each other, not just listed side by side.

The trap with a mixed portfolio is that each type gets judged by its own yardstick. Flips get judged on profit, rentals on monthly cash flow, land on what you think it'll sell for. That makes it hard to tell where your next dollar should go.

What works for me is two numbers per row:

1. Cash in today: down payment, rehab money, closing costs and carrying costs paid so far, minus any cash you've pulled back out (a refi or a partial sale).

2. Annualized return on that cash: for a flip, expected profit divided by cash in, divided by the months held, times 12. For a rental, the last 12 months of cash flow divided by cash in. For land, minus the yearly carrying cost divided by cash in, until it sells.

Example numbers: a flip that makes $30,000 on $100,000 of cash over 8 months is 30% / 8 x 12 = 45% a year. A rental with $60,000 in and $4,800 a year of cash flow is 8%. A lot with $40,000 in and $2,400 a year in taxes and insurance is minus 6% until something happens with it.

None of that says sell the land or stop buying rentals, since appreciation, principal paydown and tax benefits aren't in those numbers. But it shows what each bucket costs you in cash while you wait, which is the question a mixed portfolio usually needs answered.

Noah Wright · Answer

Eric, sorting this out before the portfolio gets bigger will save you a lot of cleanup later. One angle nobody's raised is to set up each tracker in the shape the next lender will ask to see it. On the rehabs, keep your budget on the same line items as the scope of work the lender approved, so every draw request lines up item for item and moving savings into contingency is easy to show. On the rentals, keep a current rent roll with the signed leases attached, since most DSCR lenders size a refi off the rent. On the land, log taxes, insurance and other carrying costs as they come in, so you always know what holding it really costs. The tracker runs the deal, the paper trail gets you the next loan.

Lee Futcher · Answer

Hi Eric,

Honest answer: no, I don't have one app I'd point you to for all three, and judging by the replies here, nobody else does either. Five investors, five setups, and almost every one ends with a sheet sitting on top.

If you're thinking about building it, ask a handful of these investors for a screenshot of the columns they actually keep. The columns people add on their own are your real feature list, and the ones they never fill in tell you what to leave out.

Cheers,Lee

Dan Worth · Answer

Eric, I'd second the one-row-per-property master sheet and add a column for the next dated bill that costs you money if it's missed, like a tax bill, insurance renewal or draw deadline. Taxes on land are the easiest to forget, since there's no tenant or contractor around to remind you, and in a lot of counties an unpaid bill quietly turns into a lien. A separate tab per rehab for receipts and draws also lets your CPA pull the cost basis at year end without digging.

Ashish Acharya · Answer

Eric, with flips, rentals, and land all in the same portfolio, I think the important part is having one place to see everything without treating everything the same.

I'd keep the master view simple, but make sure each property/project is separately tracked underneath it. From the tax side, a flip, a long-term rental, and land you're holding or developing can have very different treatment for income, expenses, basis, and timing.

That becomes especially important with rehab costs and land carrying costs. If everything gets lumped together, it can be difficult to tell what's actually profitable and even harder to clean up at tax time.

I'd build the system around the way your CPA will ultimately need the information, not just around what makes the portfolio easiest to look at.

Happy to connect!

Eric Kleinsasser · Answer

Hey Ashish, Thank you for your response. I agree with you. I've just had RE investors tell me that they can't find an one app that does multi asset tracking and management across several types of Real Estate investing.

If you come across anything like that feel free to shoot me a DM.

Eric Kleinsasser · Answer

Yeah, I'm wondering more about if there is an app you use for this...?

Clever Mukori · Answer

Eric, one reason to keep the three buckets clearly separated, even under one master sheet, is that your CPA will likely treat them differently at tax time. Flip profit, rental income and land held for investment usually end up in different places on the return, and holding costs on raw land have their own rules, so ask your CPA early whether to expense or capitalize them. What makes that easy is a separate bank account per bucket (or per entity), plus a property ID on every transaction, so the master sheet can be built from the bank data instead of retyped. If a dollar ever moves between buckets, record it as a transfer, not as an expense, or the returns on each bucket get muddy fast.

What do you use to keep fix-and-flips, rentals and land deals in one place?

What do you use to keep fix-and-flips, rentals and land deals in one place?

Most Popular Reply

17 Replies