Hi from Lee, here to learn and to share what's worked on lead follow up

Hi from Lee, here to learn and to share what's worked on lead follow up

Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes

Hi everyone, I'm Lee.

I've spent the last 13 years helping business owners with marketing and sales, and my wife and I run three businesses of our own.

The biggest lesson we learned the hard way: most leads aren't lost to price or competition. They're lost because nobody answered fast enough, or nobody followed up after the first try.

I joined to learn how investors here handle that side of the business: seller leads, tenant inquiries, guest messages, and the follow up that falls through the cracks when you're busy.

What's the one part of your follow up you wish ran without you?

1Reply
1,048 views

Most Popular Reply

Diana KhanPro Member
Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 823 posts · 296 votes
2w
Quote from @Lee Futcher:

Hi everyone, I'm Lee.

I've spent the last 13 years helping business owners with marketing and sales, and my wife and I run three businesses of our own.

The biggest lesson we learned the hard way: most leads aren't lost to price or competition. They're lost because nobody answered fast enough, or nobody followed up after the first try.

I joined to learn how investors here handle that side of the business: seller leads, tenant inquiries, guest messages, and the follow up that falls through the cracks when you're busy.

What's the one part of your follow up you wish ran without you?

Hi @Lee Futcher! I'd say keeping track of follow ups after the first conversation. It's easy for messages to get buried when several things are happening at once. Having a system that reminds you who needs a response and when to reach out again would be helpful.

I'm a real estate attorney and broker based in Maryland, and I work with clients on contracts, property transactions, and other legal matters. Good communication is a big part of that work, especially when clients are waiting for updates or have questions.

I appreciate you sharing this, @Lee Futcher. Following up sounds simple, but it can make a big difference. Happy to connect!

See this reply in the discussion

15 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Diana KhanPro Member
    Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 823 posts · 296 votes
    2w
    Quote from @Lee Futcher:

    Hi everyone, I'm Lee.

    I've spent the last 13 years helping business owners with marketing and sales, and my wife and I run three businesses of our own.

    The biggest lesson we learned the hard way: most leads aren't lost to price or competition. They're lost because nobody answered fast enough, or nobody followed up after the first try.

    I joined to learn how investors here handle that side of the business: seller leads, tenant inquiries, guest messages, and the follow up that falls through the cracks when you're busy.

    What's the one part of your follow up you wish ran without you?

    Hi @Lee Futcher! I'd say keeping track of follow ups after the first conversation. It's easy for messages to get buried when several things are happening at once. Having a system that reminds you who needs a response and when to reach out again would be helpful.

    I'm a real estate attorney and broker based in Maryland, and I work with clients on contracts, property transactions, and other legal matters. Good communication is a big part of that work, especially when clients are waiting for updates or have questions.

    I appreciate you sharing this, @Lee Futcher. Following up sounds simple, but it can make a big difference. Happy to connect!

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    2w

    Thanks, @Diana Khan! You nailed it. The first conversation is usually the easy part. It's everything after that slips when a few deals are moving at once.

    In your world I'd guess it's worse, since clients go quiet until they suddenly need an update right now. Do you have a way of keeping track today, or is it mostly your inbox and memory? I'm always curious how busy attorneys handle it.

    Happy to connect too, I'll send you a request.

  • Brad SeidBusiness Member
    Lender · Licensed in 28 States · Member since 2026 · 206 posts · 72 votes
    2w

    @Lee Futcher Welcome to BiggerPockets, Lee! Great point about the importance of timely follow-ups. Consistent communication can make a huge difference in closing deals. I work on the lending side, helping investors explore financing options. Would love to connect and see how we can support each other and help more investors succeed!

    • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
      2w

      Thanks for the welcome. In lending, speed isn't a nice-to-have. It's the deal. Borrowers shop two or three lenders at once, and the first real answer usually wins. Licensed in 28 states, how do you keep that first reply fast when someone reaches out at 9pm on a Sunday?

  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 976 posts · 356 votes
    2w

    @Lee Futcher welcome, Lee. For me it's the longer-term follow-up, the people who aren't ready for six months or a year. Answering fast is easier to build a habit around. Remembering to check back in at the right time, with something actually useful to say, is the part that slips when things get busy. Looking forward to seeing what you share.

    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme549 Reviews
    • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
      2w

      That's the expensive one. The fast reply wins today's deal. The six-month check-in wins next year's. Most teams run the second one on memory, and memory loses every time. What brings your agents back to a lead today: a date, a market change, or whoever happens to remember?

  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 976 posts · 356 votes
    2w

    @Lee Futcher a mix, and every year we try to make it less about memory. A date in the system does most of the work. The follow-ups that actually land are tied to something real, like a property coming up where they were looking. A check-in with nothing to say doesn't do much.

    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme549 Reviews
    • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
      Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
      2w

      couple comments on this subject based on my decades and in different enterprises.

      1. for real estate sales ANSWER THE PHONE I think most agents or deal makers are making a huge mistake letting everything go to VM and telling people to text them for quicker response.. Real world folks will just call the next agent if you dont answer happens all the time I know thats what I do. :)

      2. When I was in the land and Timber business IE buying Timber land and Timber rights. My partner had one rule if the trees are still standing its still a lead he was genius on doing what I call Oregon porch time with these owners.. I was used to one sit closes in my day.. Steve would show up with cooler full of either smoked or fresh salmon he caught on his property on the Oregon coast or Elk Jerky or back strap.. The bigger patch of timber the nicer the gifts were and the real big deals got to go fishing on his private stretch of the Trask river.. But the demographic of a NW timber owner is 60 to 100 years old NO debt owed the land and timber through generations and they just cant make a quick decision IE it takes them months or years.. So Steve ( basically through memory ) would check back in with his gifts every 6 months or so. Whereas if it was me if it was a NO I was on to the next one.. Today I guess folks use a CRM of some sort to track leads. Although to be fair I built the data base of 10k properties from the Or CA border to Tacoma up the I 5 corridor and that was the list we marketed with mainly telemarkting.. Letters ONLY if we could not get them on the phone. SEt up the appointment make the presentation then stick with them until the timber was gone. Many times our client would pass the property on and the kids would call they were not interested in the land or timber they wanted the Green backs.. with stepped up basis many of them found themselves turning that forest into big time money low 7 figures in many cases.. We also showed long time owner how to do a 1031 with the standing timber alone they did not have to sell the land.. STanding timber can be sold via DEED IE a Timber deed and then tax treatment like any other real estate. that was a tougher sell to our demographic as they just had a hard time with the concept and most had no CPA they just used a book keeper that had no clue about Timber deeds and such

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    2w

    That's it right there. A new listing where they were looking is a reason to call. "Just checking in" is a reason to ignore you.

    The hard part is nobody can watch every listing for every past lead by hand. That's the piece worth putting on autopilot, so your agents only pick up the phone when there's something real to say.

    How big is the past-lead list your team is sitting on right now? @Matthew Morrow

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    2w

    Hi Jay,

    52 years. That’s a career most people only talk about.

    Shame about the lodge at Stoney. Some places just don’t come back the same.

    What I do: I use AI to give people their freedom back and unlock extraordinary business growth. My wife and I automated three of our own businesses up to 95 percent, and it gave us our life back. Now I help other owners do the same, mostly agents, lenders and landlords buried in follow-up and admin.

    Cheers,
    Lee

    @Jay Hinrichs

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    2w

    Hi Jay,

    "Oregon porch time" is the best phrase I've read on here. Steve had it figured out. Smoked salmon every six months beats any drip campaign ever written.

    And you're right about the phone. Most deals still go to whoever picks up.

    The part that stuck with me is the kids calling years later. That's follow-up paying off a generation down the road.

    Cheers,
    Lee

  • Lender · FL · Member since 2024 · 500 posts · 128 votes
    2w

    Welcome to the forum, Lee! You hit the nail on the head, speed to lead is everything in this industry.

    From the lending side, the one part of the follow-up I always wish ran flawlessly on autopilot is collecting trailing documents from borrowers after they find a deal. Investors are out there hustling to get a property under contract, and getting them to pause and send over a missing LLC operating agreement usually takes three manual follow-ups!

    Glad to have a systems expert in the mix. Looking forward to your insights!

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    1w

    Hi Stevan,

    Thanks for the warm welcome. Trailing documents are a perfect example of the kind of follow-up that drains a week. The borrower isn't ignoring you, they're just busy chasing the deal, and the operating agreement drops to the bottom of their list.

    What tends to work is making the ask as small and specific as possible: one message that names the exact document, explains why it's holding up the file, and gives one simple way to send it. Then a short, friendly reminder two days later if it hasn't arrived, and a call only if that one doesn't land.

    Most of the time it's not about chasing harder. It's about making the next step easy enough to do from a phone between property visits.

    Looking forward to swapping notes,
    Lee

  • Real Estate Agent · Detroit, MI · Member since 2016 · 149 posts · 70 votes
    1w

    Welcome, Lee — that lesson is the whole business on the seller side. We work a few hundred seller contacts a day by call and text, and the first conversation is rarely where the deal is. The pattern I see: speed wins the first touch, but the appointments come from touches three through eight, and from the 'not now' sellers everyone else drops. The part I wish ran without me is exactly the long tail — the seller who said check back in six months, and having that check-back actually happen with the last conversation attached, not a generic drip. What made the difference for us was qualifying the first real conversation properly: a seller who needs speed and an as-is sale gets a cash-offer appointment, a seller who needs top price and time gets a listing conversation — and after that the follow-up almost writes itself, because you know what you're following up about.

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    1w

    Hi Anthony,

    Thanks for the welcome, and for laying this out so clearly. I think you described the long tail perfectly. Speed gets you the first conversation, but the deals come from the sellers who said "not now" and actually heard back at the right time.

    I also really like your point about qualifying that first conversation properly. When you know whether a seller needs speed or top price, every follow-up after that has a real reason behind it, instead of being another generic check-in.

    What I've seen work well is saving one short note after every real conversation: what the seller needs, their timeline, and the reason to call back. Then the six-month check-back can open with that note, something like "You mentioned wanting to wait until the school year ended," and the seller feels remembered instead of marketed to.

    Best,
    Lee

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.