Investor · Redmond, King County · Member since 2026 · 42 posts · 12 votes
Hi everyone,
I currently self manage my rentals. The management portion is not that bad but finding maintenance is very challenging. I have used property managers in the past and their maintenance people cost a lot.
Finding local maintenance personnel has been very challenging.
What have you done to find reliable maintenance that is not very expensive?
Hi Chris, what helped most from a distance was splitting it in two instead of looking for one person who does everything.
A handyman for the small stuff. Ask the counter at the local hardware store (the smaller one, not the big chain) who comes in every morning buying parts. Those are the working handymen. Other landlords in that town's landlord group are the next best source.
Licensed trades for plumbing, electrical and heating and cooling, picked before you need them. Give each one a small paid job first, like a faucet, a filter change or a smoke detector swap, and watch how they show up, answer and invoice.
Make your jobs easy to say yes to. Send each one in writing with the tenant's photos, the address, how to get in, and an amount they can go up to without calling you. Then pay the day the invoice arrives. A remote owner who sends clear jobs and pays fast moves up a contractor's list.
Let the tenant be your eyes. A photo or a short video before you book anyone saves a lot of trip charges, and a fair share of the time it turns out to be a breaker, a reset or a filter.
Give vendors a way in that doesn't need you or a key handoff, like a lockbox or a code for that visit.
Cheap and reliable usually comes from being a good customer to one or two people, not from shopping every job.
Hi Chris, what helped most from a distance was splitting it in two instead of looking for one person who does everything.
A handyman for the small stuff. Ask the counter at the local hardware store (the smaller one, not the big chain) who comes in every morning buying parts. Those are the working handymen. Other landlords in that town's landlord group are the next best source.
Licensed trades for plumbing, electrical and heating and cooling, picked before you need them. Give each one a small paid job first, like a faucet, a filter change or a smoke detector swap, and watch how they show up, answer and invoice.
Make your jobs easy to say yes to. Send each one in writing with the tenant's photos, the address, how to get in, and an amount they can go up to without calling you. Then pay the day the invoice arrives. A remote owner who sends clear jobs and pays fast moves up a contractor's list.
Let the tenant be your eyes. A photo or a short video before you book anyone saves a lot of trip charges, and a fair share of the time it turns out to be a breaker, a reset or a filter.
Give vendors a way in that doesn't need you or a key handoff, like a lockbox or a code for that visit.
Cheap and reliable usually comes from being a good customer to one or two people, not from shopping every job.
The management part is the easy half from out of state. The hard half is having someone local you trust before anything breaks. I build that bench in advance: a handyman, a plumber, an electrician, and an HVAC tech, each with a backup. The best way I have found them is through other local landlords and small contractors who already work on rentals, not the big dispatch companies. I test each one with a small paid job first and I ask for photos before and after, plus an itemized invoice. Once someone proves reliable, I keep their rates and response times in one list so I am not starting from zero at 9 pm on a Friday. I also give tenants a clear written process for what counts as urgent and what can wait until morning, so the call I get is the one that actually needs a fast response.
@Chris Nordstrom You're not alone, this is the hardest part of self-managing. What's worked for me:
Ask around. Staff at local supply houses, other landlords and your real estate agent know who's reliable. Local landlord groups are great for referrals too.
Test new people on a small job first. See if they show up on time, communicate well and clean up. Once you find a good one, pay promptly and send steady work. They'll usually prioritize you and give a better rate.
Batch non-urgent repairs into one visit, and learn the easy fixes yourself (flappers, faucets, disposals). Use licensed, insured pros for electrical, major plumbing and HVAC.
Keep a backup for each trade so you're never stuck. Good luck!
Hi Chris, the others covered where to find people, so here are a few things that cut the cost once you have them. Ask tenants to send a photo or short video before you dispatch anyone. A lot of "the sink is broken" calls turn out to be a clog, a tripped breaker or a dirty filter, and you save a trip fee. Put the small tenant-fixable stuff in the lease (bulbs, filters, batteries, disposal reset) so it never becomes a paid call.
For the vendors you do use, ask for a flat rate on common jobs instead of hourly, and bundle non-urgent repairs into one visit. Preventive work pays too: a yearly filter, gutter and water heater check is far cheaper than an emergency call at the wrong hour.
Keep a backup for each trade so one busy handyman never leaves a tenant waiting. Happy to connect and compare notes.
I keep it simple, and I start before there is a problem. On my Memphis rehabs I fix the roof, HVAC, plumbing, and electrical first, so most of the maintenance calls that eat a budget never happen. Then I use one local handyman for the small stuff and a licensed trade for plumbing, electrical, and HVAC, picked before I need them. Every job goes in writing, with a photo from the tenant first, and a photo after the work is done. No one gets paid on a phone call alone. The rent has to cover it. I buy under $100K, ARV $180K to $265K, Section 8 rent $1,395 to $1,950 for 3 bedrooms or more, and I check the 1% rule and DSCR at 70 to 80% LTV. If the rent does not leave room for a handyman and a trade call, the deal does not work.
I've had better luck treating the vendor search like building a small bench before an emergency, rather than shopping each work order. I ask local landlords, agents, and the neighborhood hardware store for names, then try one small paid job and see whether they return calls, keep the appointment, explain options, and send a clear invoice. I don't assume the cheapest quote stays cheapest once a second trip or tenant disruption is counted. For each trade I keep a primary and backup, a written scope, photos before and after, and a not-to-exceed amount for routine items. I also ask the tenant for photos first, so we can describe the issue accurately and avoid dispatching someone for a reset or clogged filter. A simple log of vendor, task, cost, response time, and warranty makes next time easier. Once someone has earned trust, paying promptly and giving complete access details helps keep the relationship. Happy to compare notes by message.
Chris, the replies on finding people are good. Since you mentioned PM maintenance costs, a disclosure: I'm a Realtor with Swiss Realty Group and assist at Swiss Property Management Group in Columbus. If you ever go back to a manager, a few questions explain most of the cost difference:
Do they add a markup or coordination fee on vendor invoices, and how much?
Can you use your own vendors, and what insurance do they require from them?
What dollar amount can they approve without calling you?
Do they send before and after photos with every invoice? If you keep self-managing, a short price list from each vendor for common jobs (service call, drain clearing, faucet, furnace tune-up) makes a high invoice easy to spot. Where are your rentals?
I currently self manage my rentals. The management portion is not that bad but finding maintenance is very challenging. I have used property managers in the past and their maintenance people cost a lot.
Finding local maintenance personnel has been very challenging.
What have you done to find reliable maintenance that is not very expensive?
Frankly, it's hard. Until you are big enough to constantly have work for trades and build relationships it's hard and every interaction is going to be a one-of. Which means you are going to pay more and get less on every other task. No way around that.
My recommendation is to hire the best PM you can find, they have those realtionships and the volume. I know you want the cheapest PM, but the $50 you save every month are going to come back and bite you (over and over and over)
There's a lot of great advice here on building the bench, so I'll add one piece that helps a lot on the cost side. Leo's point about the second trip is the one I'd build on.
From a distance, the expensive part usually isn't the hourly rate. It's the handyman who shows up, finds the faucet is a brand he didn't expect or the filter is a size he doesn't carry, and has to come back another day.
I'd keep a simple one page file for each property and send it with every job: photos of the water shutoff and breaker panel, filter sizes, appliance make and model numbers, paint colors, and how to get in for that visit. A vendor who arrives with the right part can usually fix it the first time, and that's where a lot of the savings come from.
It also makes you a much easier customer to work with, which counts for a lot when you need someone in a hurry.
Chris, a few ways to keep maintenance costs down without relying on one expensive vendor: build a short bench of two vendors per trade so you can compare quotes on anything non-urgent, and ask each for a flat rate on the jobs that repeat (filter changes, smoke detector swaps, lockouts, turnover touch-ups). Set a spending limit per job so small fixes don't wait on you, and require a photo before and after plus an itemized invoice every time. Ask your tenants for a photo or short video first, since many calls turn out to be a reset or a filter. Keep a simple log of each vendor's response time and price, and after a few jobs you'll see who deserves the regular work.
Hi Chris, the vendor-bench advice above is a good foundation. One extra system that helps from a distance is a short triage step before any vendor is called.
Experienced landlords often ask for three things with every report: a photo or short video, the exact location in the unit, and whether water, power, heat, or safety is affected. That information usually makes it clear whether the job is urgent, can wait for a scheduled visit, or may be a simple reset, a tripped breaker, or a filter that needs changing. It also gives the vendor enough detail to bring the right part and avoid a second trip.
It helps to write those categories down in advance, with a response time for each one, and share them in writing so expectations are clear. For example, a leak or loss of heat gets same-day attention, while a cosmetic repair can be grouped with other non-urgent work.
Finally, keep a dated log for each job: the report, photos, the vendor, the cost, and before-and-after photos. That record makes it easier to spot repeat problems, compare vendors, and keep maintenance records tidy for bookkeeping and tax preparation.
One cost question I'd add when interviewing those referrals: which neighborhoods do they already service, and can routine work fit into an existing route? A small job can be expensive simply because of travel and a minimum callout. Get the minimum, parts-pickup charges and any return-trip charges spelled out before booking. For non-urgent work, offering a flexible appointment window may help you find someone dependable within budget. Keep a separate arrangement for emergencies so a lower-cost routine visit doesn't become a delayed urgent repair.
It depends on where your properties are and the nature of the maintenance. If you don't know anything about the ground game there, then you are going to have to hire out using professionals if you want any kind of job you hope to trust. If you do know the ground game, or if you have rentals in an area with plentiful property managers, then you can likely do what I did with our short term rental - find a "caretaker". Essentially a PM that has some basic handyman skills that you pay a monthly fee, but they do very little of the back-end management. You still find your own tenants, collect rent, pay bills, etc. They show up to check to see if the place was vacated, tighten up the loose electric outlet, etc. My caretakers were skilled enough to change pool pumps, pool lighting, etc and I paid a very low & reasonable price for those things that were "beyond the ether" so to speak. If the door lock batteries went dead they changed them for me no cost (we provided a big box of batteries). ETC. So if you know the ground game, and have some contacts, you can probably find someone to act in the same fashion. Bonus - these people don't have to be licensed PMs, so you can cast your net broadly.
So, you want to find the cheapest handymen possible?
The terrible ones are on Craigslist!
The good ones are too busy and have no need to advertise - you can only find them via networking.
Even then, they are not above asking you for 50% upfront and then putting you as their lowest priority!
Good luck on warranty work
You should also require that they at least have liability insurance in case of an accident, as you'll get sued and using an unlicensed/uninsured handymen will often result in claim denial
What do you know about the federal contractor lead paint licensing requirement?
How will you confirm they've done everything they want payment for and the quality is satisfactory?