Do you keep all your rentals in one market or spread them out?

Do you keep all your rentals in one market or spread them out?

Garrett BrownPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Houston, TX · Member since 2024 · 520 posts · 567 votes

Everything I own is within about 2 hours of my house, all in Texas. Love it until insurance renewals hit and everything goes up at once.

I know investors with 12 doors on one street and guys with rentals in 5 states they’ve barely seen. Neither is wrong, but I'm curious what the temperature is from the crowd on spacing out rentals.

How many markets are you in and would you do it again? Best answers go in Thursday’s BiggerPockets Investor Brief newsletter.

6Reply
1,174 views

Most Popular Reply

JD MartinBusiness Member
Moderator
Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
1d

All of my properties are less than 20 minutes from my house. I'm not beholden to any contractors or property managers, and all of my tenants know they might just bump into me at the supermarket or the dog park. There's no real substitution for geography.

Skyline Properties
View Page
See this reply in the discussion

16 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2020 · 94 posts · 45 votes
    1d

    4-States and 5 markets.

  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1d

    3 states 4 markets but only because I expanded by adding 2 beach properties. For almost 30 years 1 state 2-3 markets 90 minute drive. I like keeping my eyes on things.

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 210 posts · 82 votes
    1d

    I'm still early in this and everything I own is in San Antonio, close enough to drive to. I like being able to see a place myself and know the streets around it. Spreading out sounds good on paper but I would be leaning on other people for the stuff I can still do myself here. For now one market feels right and I am still learning what I don't know about it.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 262 posts · 135 votes
    1d

    Garrett, several years ago I owned long-term rentals in Orlando, and I sold them before I moved to California. When I did move, I turned my primary residence into a rental and put a property manager in place, because I didn't want to be a long-distance landlord. I found the PM through the local REIA, and having someone I trusted on the ground is what made owning from across the country work.

    Today I'm in two markets and exploring a third. In the third one I plan to buy first and hold off on co-hosting there for a while.

    For STR and MTR, going into a new market means being smart about who you bring on. The right cleaners, handyman and vendors make everything run more smoothly, because turns, maintenance and guest issues happen on a schedule you don't control. Once that team is in place, I can self-manage my own units and co-host other owners' homes nearby, and every added property makes that team more efficient. That's the economy of scale I'm after.

    So would I do it again? Yes, but market by market: build the team and go deep in one area before adding the next, instead of scattering single properties across states.

    Disclosure: I co-host STRs for other owners.

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 71 votes
    1d

    All of ours are in one town, close enough to reach every house in the same afternoon, and for renting by the room I would do it the same way again.

    Rooms turn over more often than whole houses, so the work is a lot of small visits: a bedroom clean between residents, a set-day clean of the shared kitchen and baths, a new door code, a showing. When the houses sit a short drive apart, one cleaner can do several houses on the same day and one handyman can fix three small things in one trip. Spread those same houses across states and every small visit turns into its own trip or its own vendor.

    The cost is the one you named. Everything renews, gets reassessed and gets hit by the same storm at the same time. The answer to that is a bigger reserve for repairs and insurance, not necessarily another state.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    1d

    All of my properties are less than 20 minutes from my house. I'm not beholden to any contractors or property managers, and all of my tenants know they might just bump into me at the supermarket or the dog park. There's no real substitution for geography.

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 550 posts · 165 votes
    1d

    Spread them, but by risk rather than by distance. Keeping everything within two hours is the right call for running them well, and you've already found the catch. Every door renews against the same insurance market, the same property tax rules and the same storms, so one bad year hits all of them together. A second Texas city fixes nothing on that list.

    It shows up in the financing too. DSCR is rent over the full payment, insurance included, so a statewide premium jump drops the ratio on every property at once, often right when you'd want to refinance one. A second market in a state with a different insurance picture means one renewal season can't squeeze the whole portfolio. The close ones you can manage yourself, the far ones you hire for.

  • Ryan BrownPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2022 · 133 posts · 45 votes
    1d

    Garrett, I'm all in one market, Louisville, and I'd do it the same way again. Honestly, I don't think I'm big enough to need more than one market. If you have 1,000 units, spreading across states makes sense. At that size, one bad insurance year, a tax reassessment or a local economy slowing down can hit a big share of your portfolio at once, and you have the staff and systems to run properties in several places. For most of us with a handful of doors, splitting across markets doesn't really diversify anything. You end up with one or two properties in each place, and you don't know any of those markets well.

    The advantage of staying in one market is knowledge, and it keeps adding up. Over time you learn which streets rent quickly and which ones sit, which neighborhoods appraise well, which contractors show up, what turnover really costs and what a fair price looks like before the listing photos go up. That's how you find the deals that actually work, especially now, when the margins are thin. Someone who shows up from out of state and buys off a spreadsheet is competing against people who already know all of that.

    Your insurance point is fair. When renewals all go up at once, it hurts. But a bad renewal year in one market is something you can plan for with reserves and by shopping your policies. Paying too much, or buying the wrong block, in a market you don't understand is much harder to fix.

    So my vote is to go deep before you go wide. Learn one market well, build a team you trust and let each property make the next one easier. If you outgrow the market someday, that's a good problem to have, and you'll go into the next one knowing exactly what you need to look for.

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 767 votes
    1d

    One market, deep. I buy in the same 9 ZIP codes in Memphis on repeat — 38109, 38111, 38112, 38114, 38116, 38117, 38118, 38122, 38128 — and I've closed 236 properties there.

    Going deep is how you know the numbers before the listing photos go up: what a 3BR+ rents for ($1,395-$1,950 Section 8), what a rehab really costs, which streets rent fast and which ones sit, and what ARV $180K-$265K looks like on a single-family under $100K. That knowledge is deal flow.

    Spreading thin means you pay a new-market tax on every deal — new contractors, new property manager, new inspection standards — and you still don't know the block. Stay in one market until the deals there stop working, then add the next one the same way, deep. Yes, I'd do it again the same way.

  • Pakistan · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    1d

    Great question, Garrett! Keeping everything close makes property management much easier, but scaling across multiple markets definitely helps manage local risks like rising insurance costs in Texas.

    For investors looking to expand or find off-market deals in new markets, having clean, verified data makes all the difference. Always good to see different perspectives here!

  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 696 votes
    1d

    One piece that doesn't come up when people compare markets is the paperwork. Each state you own in generally means its own return, since rental income is usually taxed where the property sits. Four states can mean four nonresident returns, plus your home state, and your preparer's fee goes up with each one. It's not a reason to stay local, but it belongs in the numbers.

    Garrett's insurance point is where concentration really hurts, and a reserve helps. Say you have 10 doors at about $1,800 a year each, so $18,000 total. A 20% jump at renewal is $3,600 more. Setting aside $300 a month for that gap means a bad renewal is a transfer, not a surprise.

    Harrison's answer about bigger reserves is the same idea. I'd keep a separate ledger per property no matter how many markets you're in, so when one market's premiums or taxes jump you can see exactly which doors it hit.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
  • Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1d

    @Garrett Brown We've bought properties in 9 states and I don't even know how many markets. I think that it is an individual thing, no right answer, no wrong answer. when I co-authored the Bigger Pockets book "Real Estate Rewind"; I wrote that for me at least to do it all over again, I would buy less properties. I know that goes against More is Better. It makes a difference on how big do you want to get? In one town of 1,300 houses, I bought 117 properties from 116 different owners. It was a fun experience, but in 2022 I decided to sell my last property there. This year we also sold our last properties in two more states. I liked both states and we used outside management as well as personal management for those properties. One of the states we have been in since 1986; the other state we were in a much shorter time.

  • Investor · San Francisco · Member since 2026 · 70 posts · 33 votes
    16h

    I keep all five of my single-family rentals in one area, and I would do it the same way again. Self-managing is the reason. When the houses are close together, one set of contractors, one set of handymen, and one mental map of the neighborhoods covers everything, and a drive-by costs me twenty minutes instead of a weekend. Spreading out only pays if you are comfortable handing each market to a different property manager, and then you are really running a manager business, not a rental business. The tradeoff is real. One market means one local downturn hits every door at once. For me that risk is worth it, because knowing the streets and the rents cold is what lets me buy right and keep the houses full. If you self-manage, stay close. If you hire out everything, diversify.

  • Lender · McKinney, TX · Member since 2026 · 23 posts · 10 votes
    5h

    Garrett, one Texas-specific lever on the "everything renews at once" problem: protest the appraisal district values on every door each spring. Rentals don't get the homestead cap, so assessed values can climb faster than on your own house, and a protest (yourself or through a flat-fee service) is often the cheapest way to soften a bad tax year across a concentrated portfolio. On insurance, check whether your policies carry a percentage wind/hail deductible, because 1-2% of dwelling coverage on several houses after one storm adds up fast, and it's worth sizing reserves to that rather than just the premium. On financing, being in one market matters less than how the loans are structured. A blanket loan across all the doors is convenient, but it ties them together when you want to sell or refinance one, so separate loans per property keep more flexibility. Full disclosure, I'm a lender. For a self-managed portfolio, staying within two hours sounds right to me.

  • Douglas LarsonPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Salt Lake City UT San Diego CA Daytona Beach, FL · Member since 2008 · 411 posts · 338 votes
    2h

    I have 11 doors. 6 are in Utah where I currently live. I can drive to each one in 30 min or less. 2 are in NE Florida, about 2 blocks to the beach. I have a brother in that area and a good handyman. I love to visit and surf each year. 3 of my doors are in San Diego about 3 miles to the beach. Good tenants and great rents. I love to visit a few times per year. I have tried several management companies over the 25 years I have been a landlord. All of them dropped the ball badly at some point so I self manage all.

  • Vicki X.Pro Member
    Investor · Member since 2022 · 188 posts · 155 votes
    1h

    Lots of good comments above already.

    I agree that with a great team (a Realtor with investor mindset and experience, reliable handyman and plumber, and cleaner), you can comfortably invest in and manage properties outside your home market while still achieving strong returns.

    However, focusing on a smaller area (within a two-hour drive) allows one to develop deeper local expertise and respond more quickly, potentially generating higher returns while better managing risks.

    We currently own properties across two states and five counties. I think this level of geographic diversification works fine, as long as the properties are solid investments with strong ROIs. If I were to look for opportunities in another States, I'd be very picky.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.