How I check supply before I offer on a small storage facility

How I check supply before I offer on a small storage facility

Kevin RapportPro Member
Real Estate Coach · Sacramento Area · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 39 votes

A lot of the storage deals I see get priced out carefully and never get a real supply check.

Here's how I run it.

About 7 square feet of storage per person is my benchmark. That's my rule of thumb, not a universal law. Markets differ. A seasonal town is going to look different than a small year-round town. But if a market is way over that number, I'm usually fighting for every tenant, and the lease-up I just modeled starts to look optimistic.

Quick example with round, made-up numbers:

Say a town of 4,000 people already has 40,000 square feet of storage, and I'm looking at another 15,000-square-foot facility. That's 55,000 square feet against 4,000 people, or about 14 square feet per person. I don't need a fancy report to know that town is heavy. I'd want a very good reason to believe I can fill empty units, or I'd walk.

The number is only the start. Then I call the other operators and ask what's actually available. How many units are empty. Whether they've been running specials. How long a 10x10 has been sitting. An offering memo can say the market is tight. A five-minute phone call often says otherwise.

I also look at what's coming. A project that's already permitted can change the math before I close. Current vacancy is the present. New supply is the future.

This doesn't replace pricing the deal. It tells me whether the upside I underwrote is actually there. A cheap facility in an overbuilt market is still a cheap facility in an overbuilt market.

For those of you looking at small facilities right now, what's your supply test?

Do you use a square-feet-per-person number, or do you go straight to calling the other operators?

1Reply
434 views

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • G. Brian DavisPro Member
    Investor · Hatboro, PA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 908 votes
    2d

    I like using the square-feet-per-person number as a starting point, but I wouldn’t rely on it by itself. I’d want to know what the existing facilities are actually experiencing occupancy, rents, specials and how long units are sitting vacant. I’d also call the competition. An offering memorandum can tell you the market is undersupplied, but a few conversations with local operators can tell you whether that’s actually true. And I’d check what new supply is coming before assuming my lease-up projections are realistic. The spreadsheet tells you what could happen. The market tells you what’s actually happening.

    • Kevin RapportPro Member
      OP
      Real Estate Coach · Sacramento Area · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 39 votes
      1d

      Brian, agree completely. The 7 square feet per person number is a filter, not a verdict. It tells me whether a town is worth a phone call, not whether to buy.

      The calls are where the truth comes out. If a "tight" market has competitors running move-in specials and 10x10s that have sat for months, the OM is selling a story the street isn't buying.

      And you're right on new supply. A permitted project down the road doesn't show up in today's occupancy, but it shows up in your lease-up after you close.

      When you call competitors, do you call as a renter or tell them you're an operator?

  • Michael K GallagherBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2d

    I appreciate the SF per person number but I'm curious what data or inputs when into getting to that 7sf/pp benchmark. I don't have any experience in the asset just genuinely curious what when into that being the benchmark.

    • Kevin RapportPro Member
      OP
      Real Estate Coach · Sacramento Area · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 39 votes
      1d

      Michael, fair question. It's not my number. It's roughly the national average of storage square feet per person that gets cited across the industry, so it's a way to compare one town against "normal."

      That's also why I only use it as a filter. A national average blends big metros, college towns, and rural markets that behave very differently. A town can be over 7 and still be healthy if demand is strong, or under 7 and still be soft.

      So it tells me which towns deserve a closer look. The phone calls to the other operators tell me whether the deal works.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 632 posts · 180 votes
    1d

    Your phone call to the other operators is the most valuable step here, and most buyers skip it because the memo already looks finished. Supply hits the financing as hard as it hits the price. If the plan is short-term money now and a permanent loan after lease-up, that refi is usually sized on collected income, not projected, and most lenders want several months of it seasoned at the new occupancy before they count it. In a town at 14 square feet per person, a lease-up that runs six months long means six more months of bridge interest, plus a refi that prices off the specials you ran to fill units. So ask those operators two things: what's empty, and how long it took them to fill their last 10x10s. The price gets you in. The lease-up pace gets you out.

    • Kevin RapportPro Member
      OP
      Real Estate Coach · Sacramento Area · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 39 votes
      1d

      Noah, great add, and it's the part most people miss. Supply doesn't just hit the price, it hits the exit.

      "How long did your last 10x10s take to fill?" is a better question than "what's empty?" Vacancy is a snapshot. Lease-up pace is what actually decides when the refi happens and what it's sized on.

      And the point about specials is a good one. If I have to run discounts to fill units, that's the income the lender sees, not the rent I put in my model.

      How many months of seasoning are you seeing lenders want on small storage right now?

  • Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 1 vote
    1d

    Good framework. I'd add a few things from the operating side. I run Storage IQC, a management company for independent facilities, so I often see these deals after closing.

    • Call as a customer, not a buyer. Ask for a 10x10, what the move-in special is, and what the rate goes to after it ends. The gap between the online rate and what you'd really pay shows how hard they're fighting for tenants.

    • Break it down by unit type. A market can have too much 10x10 non-climate and still be short on climate-controlled units or parking. Square feet per person blends all of that together.

    • Use the real trade area, not the town line. Rural renters drive in from a distance, and one big facility on the edge of town can pull from everyone.

    • Look at how the competition is run. Check their Google listings, reviews, online rental and how fast they answer the phone. A heavy market can still be winnable if the nearby sites are poorly run. It's much harder against operators with full online move-in.

    • For new supply, check the county planning agendas, not just the city's.

    For me, the supply number tells you whether to dig deeper. The competitor calls and the unit-mix check tell you whether to buy.

    • Kevin RapportPro Member
      OP
      Real Estate Coach · Sacramento Area · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 39 votes
      1d

      Ron, this is the operator-side stuff a spreadsheet never shows. You also answered the question I asked Brian: call as a customer. Ask for a 10x10, the move-in special, and what the rate goes to after. That gap tells you more than the occupancy number in the OM.

      The unit-mix point is the one I'd underline. A town can be heavy on non-climate 10x10s and still be short on climate-controlled units or parking. Square feet per person blends all of that together.

      Same with the trade area. Rural renters drive past the town line, so one big facility on the edge of town can change the whole picture.

      When you take over a facility after closing, what's the first thing you usually find that the buyer missed?

  • Denise SuppleeBusiness Member
    Realtor · Willow Grove, PA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 667 votes
    22h

    I like the idea of actually checking the competition instead of just relying on what's in the offering materials. That's something I pay attention to as a passive investor. I want to understand how the operator came up with the demand and lease-up assumptions and what they did to verify them. Sometimes a few phone calls to other operators can tell you a lot more than a pretty market report.

    Spark Rental Co-Investing Club585 Reviews
  • Kevin RapportPro Member
    OP
    Real Estate Coach · Sacramento Area · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 39 votes
    19h

    Absolutely! And there have been plenty of times when an under supplied market on paper turned out to be a market with little to no demand. Without assessing the competition you'd never know. And demand is the single most important factor when evaluating a storage facility.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.