Contractors rate your property "High Risk" anonymously. Even for documenting the job

Contractors rate your property "High Risk" anonymously. Even for documenting the job

Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes

I came across an app called KARN tonight. It flips the usual review: contractors rate the homeowner and the property, by address. Owners get tags like "High Risk", "Scope Creep" and "Difficult Client", and the reviews are anonymous.

One review stuck with me. A kitchen backsplash job in San Francisco, rated 2 out of 5. The contractor's complaints: the owner inspected every tile, kept adding small things, mom wanted one thing, dad another, and they "wanted the whole thing documented".

This is exactly the situation we deal with on every renovation in Switzerland. The scope grew because nobody wrote it down before the first tile went on. And documenting the job isn't a red flag, it protects both sides. We photograph and sign off every stage before the next one starts, and every addition is its own line. When it's all written down, there's nothing left to argue about.

So two questions:

1. Has anyone here used KARN or a similar app?

2. Is there something like this for rating workers and crews?

0Reply
583 views

Most Popular Reply

Andy SabischPro Member
Investor · Jackson, MS · Member since 2021 · 664 posts · 563 votes
1w

We have seen the application but the fact that reviews are left anonymously to us is a red flag. A contractor that underbid a job can leave feedback that can hurt you in a later job with a different contractor and since it is anonymous, you can't leave feedback to rebut the comments. While the concept is needed it does leave questions on how it will be used.

See this reply in the discussion

17 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 291 posts · 80 votes
    1w

    Hi @Vladimirs Veiss,

    I haven't used KARN, but I agree with you completely: documenting the job isn't a red flag. It's what keeps both sides honest.

    That backsplash review reads like a missing scope, not a difficult client. When mom wants one thing, dad wants another and nobody wrote down who signs off, the contractor ends up in the middle of a family decision.

    What you do in Switzerland is the fix. I'd add one thing before the first tile goes on: name one person on the owner's side who approves changes, and put that name on the scope. It ends the "mom said, dad said" problem before it starts.

    On your second question, the most useful rating for a crew is often the owner's own file: dated photos, the original scope, and every change and how it was handled. A crew that's happy to work that way tells you most of what you need to know.

    All the best,
    Lee

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      1w

      @Lee Futcher one approver on the owner's side, yes. We go one step further: the change gets approved before anyone continues, with a photo and the price right in front of them. Mom and dad can argue all evening, the crew just doesn't move until one of them signs.

      And I like your point about the file. A crew that's happy to be photographed at every stage usually has nothing to hide.

      Your AI Squad works with landlords every day - can it handle that part too, getting a change approved before the crew moves on?

    • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 291 posts · 80 votes
      1w

      Hi @Vladimirs Veiss,

      Stopping the crew until one person signs is the cleanest version of it I've seen. Nobody argues with a photo and a price.

      Yes, that step is a great fit for automation. The change gets logged with the photo and the price, the approver gets one message to say yes or no, and the crew only gets the go ahead once it's signed. Everything lands in the job file on its own, so the record builds itself.

      The human part stays the same. Someone still has to make the call, it just stops getting lost in a text thread.

      Cheers,
      Lee

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      1w

      @Lee Futcher Exactly, Lee! Fully agree. One clear approval, everything documented, and no confusion for the crew. Simple, transparent, and effective. Thanks for sharing your perspective!

  • Andy SabischPro Member
    Investor · Jackson, MS · Member since 2021 · 664 posts · 563 votes
    1w

    We have seen the application but the fact that reviews are left anonymously to us is a red flag. A contractor that underbid a job can leave feedback that can hurt you in a later job with a different contractor and since it is anonymous, you can't leave feedback to rebut the comments. While the concept is needed it does leave questions on how it will be used.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      1w

      @Andy Sabisch that's the part that bothers me too. One side writes, the other can't answer, and nobody sees what was actually agreed.

      A review only means something when the record is behind it: the scope, the photos of each stage, who signed what. Then it's not one person's story anymore, it's what happened on the job.

      With 11 doors, how do you check a new contractor today before giving him the first job: other investors, references, or a small test job?

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    1w

    I have not used KARN, and I would not trust an anonymous rating either way. A review only means something when the record is behind it: the scope in writing, photos at each stage, who approved what, and what was paid when. That is how I run my Memphis rehabs. I write the scope before work starts, pay on milestones, and photograph every stage. If the scope grows, work stops until one person approves the change and the price in writing. I buy single-family under $100K, ARV $180K to $265K, and I do not let a contractor or an app decide my rehab for me. For a new crew, I start with a small test job, check references from other investors, and see if they show up, communicate, and clean up. A crew that is happy to be photographed usually has nothing to hide.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      1w

      @James Jones , I completely agree with you. Your approach is exactly how renovation projects should be managed: clear scope, documented progress, milestone-based payments, and written approval for every change. This is also the philosophy behind what we're building.

      I'm curious, have you ever tried using a digital platform to automate some of this process, particularly renovation cost estimation and budget tracking?

      If you have an upcoming rehab project, we'd be happy to run a test estimate for you using our platform and compare the results with your own numbers. No obligations, just a practical way to see how accurately our approach works on a real project.

      Would that be of interest to you?

  • Josh HandlerPro Member
    Contractor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2026 · 78 posts · 87 votes
    2d

    Answering from the other chair. I'm a general contractor, and James above is my business partner, so count us as one opinion rather than two.

    Yes, contractors rate clients. We do it constantly and we do it before we bid, which is more consequential than doing it afterward, because the rating shows up as a number you never see rather than as a review you can read. A client somebody didn't want would get a price with a cushion in it, or a schedule that never quite opens up. That part of the system has always existed. Writing it down just makes it visible.

    But I'd read that San Francisco review differently than the contractor who wrote it. "Wanted the whole thing documented" is not what made that job unprofitable, and I'd be suspicious of any contractor who says it is. A written scope and a signed stage protect the contractor more than the owner, because they're the only defense against exactly the scope creep he's complaining about in the same sentence. If documentation threatens your number, that usually means the number was built on the scope staying vague.

    What actually makes an owner expensive is something else, and it's worth naming precisely because owners can fix it: DECISION LATENCY. Inspecting every tile is fine. Inspecting every tile and then taking four days to decide is what costs real money, because a crew is perishable. A tile setter's Tuesday cannot be put in a drawer and used in March. When a job stalls waiting on an answer, I either stand people down and pay for nothing, or I move them to another job and then pay again to remobilize onto yours. That's the money. So the contractor in that review has probably mislabeled a latency problem as a documentation problem, which is a shame, because the owner could have fixed the first one and can't fix the second one by being less careful.

    The actual red flag in that review is one line and he didn't seem to notice it: mom wanted one thing, dad another. No single decision maker is the best predictor of a difficult job I know of, better than budget or scope or property age. And it's fixable contractually rather than interpersonally: name ONE person in the contract who can approve a change, give them a dollar authority, and state that an instruction from anyone else on site isn't an instruction. Every contractor reading this has had a job where two owners gave contradictory direction and both remembered being agreed with.

    Andy's objection is the right one and I'd add a structural piece. The rating attaches to an ADDRESS, and addresses outlive owners. A difficult seller in 2024 generates a permanent tag that gets inherited by whoever buys in 2027, who has no way to clear it and was never a party to it. Meanwhile the person actually being rated has moved and is unaffected. Any reputation system keyed to property rather than to a party fails that way, before you even get to anonymity and to the absence of any proof that the two parties ever transacted.

    On your second question, rating crews. The honest answer is that the system already exists, it's just oral and it's closed to you. Suppliers know who pays. Subs know who holds money. Inspectors know whose work gets corrected. That network is more accurate than any public rating will be, and an owner has no access to it, which is the real problem anybody building in this space is actually trying to solve. The closest substitute an owner can run alone is records rather than opinions, because records can't be anonymous or retaliatory.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      1d

      @Josh Handler, good day. In Switzerland we see the same thing: a tiler's day lost to a late answer is the most expensive line nobody puts in the offer.

      What helps is when every open question carries the date the crew needs the answer. The owner sees the deadline up front, and the crew isn't left waiting.

      On your Memphis jobs, how long do you give an owner to answer before you move the crew?

  • Jonathan KlemmBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Contractor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1d

    Hey @Vladimirs Veiss - Thank you for sharing this, and I like that you're photographing at every stage. We use a similar custom tool for our company here in Chicago that we built to share progress with clients. It's an update on the work performed that week along with pictures and videos.

    I haven't used KARN, so I can't speak to how it works in practice but I'd be a little cautious with anonymous reviews in either direction, since there's no way to see the full story.

    If the contract just says "install tile" and nothing else, everyone has a different picture in their head and that's where the fights start.

    On rating workers and crews, I don't know of a good one. Honestly, if you have a great network then they can refer a sub for the job you need, so referrals from other investors and GCs you trust have worked better for me than any app.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      22h

      @Jonathan Klemm, good day. A weekly update shows the client what happened. In Switzerland we saw the biggest relief one step earlier: each stage gets its items, quantities and price written down before work starts, and the photos close exactly that list.

      The owner knows what he pays for and on which day, the next trade knows when the room is free, and a change becomes a new line the owner signs, not a talk at the end.

      In your tool, does the client sign off each weekly update, or is it for information only?

    • Jonathan KlemmBusiness Member
      Moderator
      Contractor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
      22h

      Hey @Vladimirs Veiss - That is a great idea to have the client do a sign off. Right now, the client can comment, ask questions, seek clarification so I really want it to be a a two-way street. I will look into ways of incorporating that...maybe even a thumbs up emoji to show they are all good with the update.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      8h

      @Jonathan Klemm, a thumbs up works well because it costs the client one second.

      If it sits next to the items of that week's update, a later question about what was agreed is answered by the record itself.

      On your jobs, do clients usually react within a day or two, or do they hold it for the weekly call?

    • Jonathan KlemmBusiness Member
      Moderator
      Contractor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
      15m

      Hey @Vladimirs Veiss - It depends on the client. Some are very responsive and some are more relaxed but in general, our clients tend to lean towards those that are more comfortable with tech and like having a system for updates where they can browse photos, etc.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
      9m

      @Jonathan Klemm, thank you. For the clients who prefer a call, the same weekly items sent as a short list afterwards keep the call and the record in one place.

      After a call like that, who writes down what was agreed - you or the client?

  • Flipper/Rehabber · CA · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3h

    Because of this thread I checked it out. Looks pretty toothless to me. I dont care about the anonymity, its their revenue stream of charging contractors thats a no go for me. To wit; I highly doubt that SF review is by a legitimate licensed contractor, it reeks of side job bs. Also a house cleaner reviewer....yeah no.

    As mentioned above our supply house salespeople are great at sharing info on flaky customers, shoppers etc. DMing each other on contractors forums also.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.