Frustrated with this market - sanity check

Frustrated with this market - sanity check

Shane WendelPro Member
Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 0 votes

Hello all - first time poster. I've got one LTR in Milwaukee and looking to purchase an STR in the Sevierville, TN area for tax advantages and investment diversification.

I'm posting here because I'm incredibly frustrated with this market - the asking prices for homes - even those that have sat on the market for hundreds of days - seem quite unrealistic. Rental rates and ANRs are not keeping up with the inflated home prices that sellers are trying to get.

Current DSCR loan rates are at 8% with a 5 year PPP. Most of revenue projects from the properties I've looked at don't even get close to getting to a 1.25 DSCR ratio. It's like these sellers and realtors don't know how the financing for this market works.

This is a prime example of what I'm talking about- https://www.homes.com/property/2733-pine-crest-ln-sevierville-tn/jtjncdmr2yb8p/

This realtor is advertising on Facebook at 2026 annual GROSS revenue of $67K. By my calculations that only supports a total after closing costs purchase price of $660K. That would be with ZERO profit or accounting for any OPEX.

What a I missing here? Is every seller just waiting for a unicorn cash buyer or someone who can put down a huge down payment to offset the financing market? Or do I just have to be patient here and wait for the market to get worse and these sellers to get more realistic?

0Reply
213 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
8h

you are probably under estimating how many folks have cash or put more than minimum down to reach the DSCR level they need.. its more of a unicorn these days that a minimum down maximum loan investor is able to operate as you noted.. raise your down payment to meet the requirements is all that is needed.

Nothing is written that says the only good investment is one with minimum down and max leverage that is actually the most risky way to invest leaves you with very little outs if you needed to sell.

See this reply in the discussion

13 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9h

    I'm fairly new to STR, bought to rebalance a heavy TSM index fund portfolio and for personal use so was looking more at appreciation. Not sure STR is a reasonable investment if looking for cash flow in many markets now. Unless you have other objectives I would wait for a unicorn or buyers market if you aren't willing to look in other areas.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 316 posts · 162 votes
    8h

    @Shane Wendel you're not missing much on the math. A lot of sellers in tourist markets are pricing off what a cash buyer or a personal-use buyer will pay, not what works at a 1.25 DSCR.

    A few things I'd check on any "grossed $67K" claim before running it:

    1. Ask for actuals, not projections. When I was underwriting apartments, a lot of the sales packages highlighted projections instead of actuals, and the gap between the two was usually where the deal fell apart. Same thing here: ask for the PMS reports or platform payout history for the trailing 12 months. A full-year 2026 figure quoted in November is partly forward bookings or an estimate.

    2. Look at what's in the income. If cleaning is listed as an income source, look for a matching cleaning expense. That should be there unless the owner is doing the cleaning themselves, and if they are, you'll be paying someone to do it.

    3. Check it against the market yourself. I use PriceLabs for pricing, and its market data is a quick way to see what comparable listings are actually booking and at what occupancy. If a listing claims far more than its comps, there's usually a reason.

    4. Look at the current listing's reviews and calendar. The review count over the last year tells you roughly how many stays it really had.

    Then run it on net, not gross: cleaning, supplies, utilities, internet, insurance, taxes, maintenance, platform fees, and management or your own time. You already found it doesn't work on gross at that price, and expenses only widen the gap.

    Tourist areas can be a challenge. We see it here in Orlando: highly seasonal, with big swings between peak and slow months. They still work, but the numbers have to work, and that means underwriting the slow months too, not just the peak ones. Homes sitting for hundreds of days tell you which side will eventually have to move, so making offers on the stale listings, based on numbers you've verified, costs you nothing.

    (I co-host STRs for other owners, so I'm a little biased, but I see a lot of these "projected revenue" numbers from the owner side.)

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    8h

    you are probably under estimating how many folks have cash or put more than minimum down to reach the DSCR level they need.. its more of a unicorn these days that a minimum down maximum loan investor is able to operate as you noted.. raise your down payment to meet the requirements is all that is needed.

    Nothing is written that says the only good investment is one with minimum down and max leverage that is actually the most risky way to invest leaves you with very little outs if you needed to sell.

    • V.G JasonPro Member
      Investor · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
      1h
      Quote from @Jay Hinrichs:

      you are probably under estimating how many folks have cash or put more than minimum down to reach the DSCR level they need.. its more of a unicorn these days that a minimum down maximum loan investor is able to operate as you noted.. raise your down payment to meet the requirements is all that is needed.

      Nothing is written that says the only good investment is one with minimum down and max leverage that is actually the most risky way to invest leaves you with very little outs if you needed to sell.

      This is it. People are using a terribly old strategy(super high leverage) in an inverse environment--this benefits the debt holders.

      Logically speaking, you'd rather own the note at 8% then the property at 8%. 8% on a high income person is 12% (+/- 1%) in gross tax. The value in the house is land value, land location, immediate fixes.

      This will(over time) defeat the 8-12%.

      The DSCR/Cash flow will be a function of the leverage, and the leverage is saying don't do it at high amounts. The problem is 99% of people, like OP, follow the pack such as BP's terrible strategies the past 2-3 years and don't have the capital to put more down. And sellers are underwater if they list below. Liquidity is trapped & gone.

      This is why i say REI's are now top 3% of the economy, and at that 3% is hyper liquid &been stacking. A person making $400k year is not fit to invest in real estate's environment right unless they're chasing C-D quality. Now if they've been making it last 3-4 years and have $250k+ set aside, they now can grab a high quality investment property in B/C+ cities which may be local, their forte, or their 2nd destination. The 2% can buy that B/C+ year 1. That 1% they're buying it up in cash in B areas, the .5-1% all cash in lower A areas or higher B areas. Inside the .5% all cash in primo areas. Cause the math says buy cash not levered.

      Bottom line: most aren't fit to invest + they are not capable of listing below their price due to being underwater.
      End result: stale market in the $400k-$1.5MM price points

  • Investor · Member since 2023 · 150 posts · 83 votes
    7h

    You're not missing much. $67K is gross. With a manager, I'd expect 40-50% of that to go to cleaning, platform fees, utilities, supplies, insurance, taxes and management. Call it $36K NOI.

    At 8% on a 30-year, $36K of debt service supports a loan around $410K. With 25% down, that's roughly a $545K purchase just to break even. Most asks are well above that.

    Two things I'd do. Ask for 24 months of actual Airbnb/VRBO payout reports, not the agent's projection. And ask your lender exactly how they calculate STR DSCR, since many haircut gross or use AirDNA. Waiting is a valid strategy here. A seller on day 200 is usually more open to an offer than the list price suggests.

  • Lender · Salt Lake City, UT · Member since 2013 · 162 posts · 25 votes
    5h

    Honestly you're reading it right. Listing agent revenue numbers are usually best case, so I'd underwrite off trailing 12 month payouts or an AirDNA style number with a haircut, not what's on the Facebook ad. Also 1.25 isn't a hard line everywhere. A lot of STR DSCR programs will go down to 1.0, and a bigger down payment can make a tighter ratio work, so it's worth shopping the DSCR requirement as much as the rate. Sevierville gets seasonal and crowded, so I'd run the slow months too. How much are you planning to put down?

  • Andrew SteffensBusiness Member
    Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3h

    I am not an expert in Gatlinburg area but this does match up with others posts I have read there, and it is similar to my next door market of Orlando (I am in Tampa). A 10% or so gross yield will lead to a negative cash flow. You likely need around 15% for breakeven. I would advise you look in other markets - In Tampa for example 15% is pretty common and 18-20% gross yield is not uncommon. Good luck!

  • Shane WendelPro Member
    OP
    Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 0 votes
    3h

    Thanks for all the replies. Good to know I'm at least doing the math right and I'm not crazy.

    I've probably analyzed 100+ properties over the last few months using BNBCalc, PriceLabs, Reventure, and Rabbu, as well as having my lender look at them too and letting me know which ones will pass.

    One thing I didn't mention is that I'm specifically looking at this area because my wife and I plan to retire in the Smokies area in the next 5-7 years. The data tells me that it IS a buyer's market right now - and that this market is projected to have negative appreciation of around 7% at least through 2027. I guess maybe the sellers just haven't gotten the message, or are sitting on such low interest rates that they don't have to be in a hurry.

    I could certainly afford to deploy more cash - just didn't want to, but it looks like a 30-35% may be what is required. I'm also factoring in the bonus depreciation since my wife and I are both high W-2 earners. I guess I will just have to be more patient and this may be a 2027 purchase rather than a 2026.

    • Nicholas L.Pro Member
      Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
      3h

      @Shane Wendel

      i hear you on the frustration part - I think a lot of us feel that way on both LTRs and STRs. but, sellers would rather not sell, and in some cases continue to pay carrying costs on vacant properties, than get less than what their neighbor did. especially if the property is paid off.

      you should just make an offer at what works for you, thank them for their time if it's rejected, and move on to the next.

      i am not in the market for an STR but in 2025 i had to look at about 25 properties to buy one deal.

      and... i wouldn't wait for sellers to get more realistic - who knows what's going to happen. maybe it will get even worse.

      hope this helps!

  • Shane WendelPro Member
    OP
    Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 0 votes
    3h

    I don't currently own a primary home - we sold our Milwaukee home before the market turned here. We rent a condo and I just have a small single family that I'm partnered with my son for a "house hack" on.

    Anyone have any experience with doing a property like this using a conventional personal loan and just carrying a high PLUP, rather than closing in an LLC structure using an investment loan product?

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    2h

    I wouldn't be surprised if you're looking at people who bought either because they were already renting cabins personally and thought they'd save all that money and bring some in. They are under no pressure to sell as they're still using it personally but aren't making what they thought they would, the kids grew up and went to college, or they want to vacation somewhere else. The other seller could be someone "tricked" in to buying for the STR tax loophole. They never planned to make a killing renting it out. They wanted the 6 figure tax break. Problem is they can't sell without doing an exchange or paying those 6 figures back. So they have to get enough to buy something else.

    Everyone in the STR "business" forgets families used to own places like this that sat empty 9-10 months per year. Every dollar is a bonus. Maybe you should figure out where these sellers are buying next and leapfrog them.

    • V.G JasonPro Member
      Investor · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
      1h

      I think in most markets you're right. Especially in the super rich one's. A good example is right near you-- Phoenix STRs crashing, Scottsdale slightly thriving. The former is levered and needing help, the latter less to no leverage and the rich usually pile in here for privacy, exclusivity. It's probably the best micro market in a market where you can see true wealth disparity in an inconspicuous way.

      And @Collin Hays can correct me for the Smokies, but I think the under the $1M buyers are almost fully levered and anyone purchased 2022, or past, is underwater on their property and needing that revenue to sustain this venture. They just cannot afford to list much below where they are cause they are underwater.

      And (most of the) sellers aren't exchanging, they are tapping out. The really high price point one's like $2M+ are doing swaps. Sell Smokies, and leveling up to Tahoe if they're moving west, or Berkshire's if east etc.

  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 364 votes
    1h

    @Shane Wendel you're probably not missing anything. If the only way the deal works is a huge down payment or a buyer who ignores operating costs, the price is the problem, not your math. I'd underwrite it with a real insurance quote, real vacancy, and the actual loan terms you can get, and if it still can't cover itself, I'd wait. Seller-advertised gross revenue isn't a number I'd build around.

    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme4.950 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.