i live in the 5th most expensive market in the country and Ive never had a gain over $500k. This will not affect most people who invest in residential real estate. It would primarily affect those in commercial.
@Jonathan Stone, No commentary here. But the numbers speak pretty loudly - All it takes to influence tax policy is... lawyers. Greatest number of lawyers/10,000 residents - https://lawschooltuitionbubble...
@Jay Hinrichs I was actually going to say the same thing here. There are plenty of politicians on both sides that take advantage of many of the benefits of real estate. I can't see this actually happening.
@Kenton LeVay one great benefit of taking advantage of the 1031, is that at the end of your time, if you have children to take over the business, when you pass on their basis is stepped up to current market value. So technically, you may never pay gains taxes if they were to sell after you die. There was some discussion of getting rid of that as well.
If loss of 1031 is paired with loss of stepped up basis I think you will see lots of people impacted because that reaches back to any prior 1031 gain. I don't think it will pass but I think both those items will lead to retention of assets. Aside from tightening the market this will result in people who maybe shouldn't be landlords holding on to an income stream rather then paying taxes on the gain.
I would bet that the effect on the real estate market would be exactly ZERO. This is like the car companies whining about catalytic converters being made mandatory or any industry group bemoaning any change to regulation. None of the doomsday scenarios ever happen. People adjust to the new normal and move on. Just look at the post Covid world.
I have not read the proposal but when they say $500k in profit I assume they mean all the 1031s together.
Example
I buy a property for $200k and sell it for $500k. I am good because the profit is $300k. Now I roll all the proceeds from the sale into a $1m building. That building is worth $1.5m now when I go to do my second 1031 exchange. So my profit from the second transaction is $500k Making my total profit from both 1031s $800k.
I don’t know why anyone would think it is a good idea to get rid of the 1031. It allows investors to continue to leverage their money. For the community it gives an incentive for property owners to sell their property. That puts tons of money in the local economy. It also helps improve the area when the new buyer renovates the building.
In addition, an investor that has achieved over $500k of appreciation likely does a good job investing and therefore is likely to continue to grow the investment. Allowing them to make the best investment to grow the investment further results in additional gains to tax (not including resetting the basis at death).
@Jaime Mack this bill may not pass in its current form but some of his tax and spend policies will in one form or another. We still have 18 months till the midterms.
1031 were created because large assets owners wouldn't sell their properties because of the tax implications. Why give up the cashflow of a $10 million asset when between depreciation and appreciation you'll be taxed $3 million on 7.5 for example and be left with cashflow on a $7 million asset.
Also remember that the $500k exclusion is unlikely to be indexed to inflation.
As to people adjusting to the new normal, it is correct but that doesn't mean that'll have zero effect on real estate.
Covid effects are already present. Suburb housing prices are up, dense urban prices are down, large office and retail are down, industrial is hot.
Eliminating 1031 will reduce real estate returns and some money will be moved to other asset classes. Less asset turnover will hurt the economy due to reduced capital improvements. Overall a net negative for landlords tenants and the government.
@Anish Tolia I'm not sure you can say it will have zero impact. Another proposal is to increase the capital gains tax to nearly 40%. With the removal of the 1031 and raising gains taxes to 40%, I think it could have a pretty significant impact.
Another proposal that keeps coming as well, paying taxes on unrealized gains. Never going to happen, but it's been brought up a few times by this administration.
@Anish Tolia I'm not sure you can say it will have zero impact. Another proposal is to increase the capital gains tax to nearly 40%. With the removal of the 1031 and raising gains taxes to 40%, I think it could have a pretty significant impact.
Another proposal that keeps coming as well, paying taxes on unrealized gains. Never going to happen, but it's been brought up a few times by this administration.
Back before Regan and the Neocons and Clinton and the "moderate" democrats, marginal tax rates were already well above 50% (as high as 94% in the 50s and 60s). These periods were the golden years of economic growth. Capital gains taxes have also been taxed as high as 40% in the past as well. Before the nonsense of trickle down economics was sold lock stock and barrel, it was expected that the wealthy would pay higher taxes and the economy did just fine. There is no data at all to suggest that high taxes are detrimental to growth. The caveat is that the tax revenue should be spent on projects that stimulate growth (like infrastructure) and not wasted on more useless bombs and corporate welfare.
Not sure how long 1031 has been around but stepped up basis has been around since the 70s. It benefits the intergenerational transfer of small businesses and family homes. Not sure there is a benefit to change that, to fund what? I am a little concerned that none of the changes talk about simplification of tax code or simplifying this complex social safety net that is now being called infrastructure.
This is actually the 100th Anniversary of the 1031 Exchange! It all started in 1921. We just completed a webinar discussing the American Families Plan with a focus on the 1031 Exchange.
The reduction or elimination of 1031 Exchanges would have a tremendous impact not just on the real estate market but the economy on a whole. You can visit the following websites to get more information and to register your opinion with your local congressional representative: www.1031taxreform.com or www.ipa.com/1031s/ (both are industry trade groups that are part of the coalition fighting the changes).
Hi @Account Closed,
Yes, you can combine the 1031 Exchange and the 121 Exclusion. There are a number of planning opportunities.
Exeter 1031 Exchange Services, LLC and Exeter Trust Company4.826 Reviews
@Account Closed, It can be a very elegant solution. And it may become another very powerful tool if certain laws change.
Qualification for the 121 exemption is based on have you lived in the property you are selling for 2 out of the 5 years immediately prior to sale. You do not have to be living in it when it sells. So an opportunity that has always existed is to move out of your primary and convert it to investment for up to 3 more years. When you sell you still have lived in it for 2 out of the 5 prior to sale. So you get the 121 exemption and only have to recapture the depreciation for that short time.
Qualification for a 1031 exchange is based on the use of the property when you sell. You must have purchased the property with the intent of holding for productive investment use. And that is how it must be when you sell.
But conversion of a primary into investment as long as done within the timelines will allow you to take advantage of both. Or if there is more than the allowed 121 exemption gain you can convert to rental for a year or so and then sell and take the maximum 121 exemption allowed and 1031 the rest!!
And conversion of an investment into primary will allow you to continue to defer the tax as long as you live in it. and when you do sell you will still get a partial 121 exemption as long as you meet the 2/5 timelines and have owned the property for at least 5 years (an additional requirement when converting a house that was the subject of a 1031.
@Russell Brazil From what I understand the issue is that it would force large multifamily investors into smaller real estate deals. This would lower supply and increase barrier to entry for new investors as well as first time home buyers
@Russell Brazil From what I understand the issue is that it would force large multifamily investors into smaller real estate deals. This would lower supply and increase barrier to entry for new investors as well as first time home buyers
Currently many small investors are complaining that people doing 1031s are beating them out on deals since the 1031 people are all overpaying for properties to avoid the taxes. It cuts both ways.
1031's are anti-free market. They distort the free market.
@Russell Brazil, I would agree with you except for the fact that 1031s represent less than 10% of all real estate transactions. So I would say that those complaining about 1031 buyers driving up costs just to satisfy an exchange might be in a few special markets or situations. Or they're the frugal ones keeping gains locked and taxes deferred so they can afford to buy in this market.
Nationwide I'd say it looks more like 1031 transactions are mirroring the rest of the market not distorting. Their numbers aren't significant enough for that as a % of all transactions.
i live in the 5th most expensive market in the country and Ive never had a gain over $500k. This will not affect most people who invest in residential real estate. It would primarily affect those in commercial.
I was talking to one syndicator of MF and his thought was it could preclude those in 1031 from paying stupid prices for MF was his comment or I suspect current syndications were proformas were an exit at a very low cap rate to achieve the proforma return ???
Lets just go with a flat tax like Steve Forbes wanted .. thats the best.. LOL 10% to everyone .. even playing field.
A flat tax system would at least be more fair than the current bell curve we currently have. And I benefit from that bell curve paying drastically lower rates than the middle of that curve.
Herman Cain and his 9-9-9 plan baby! lol As much as a flat tax would simplify things and as fun as it would be to talk about, I'm sure we all know that we've gone way too far down our current path for any hope of change. Any hope of coming back to a place where we'd actually be able to implement something like this is nothing more than fairy dust. Think Bernie's plan was unrealistic? The 9-9-9 plan puts it to shame. As an investment accountant, I see first-hand just how HUGE the tax industry is. Corporate and investment taxation accountants are some of the highest paid in the industry. It would be impossible to eliminate these industries to make way for the flat tax... probably just as difficult as eliminating private for-profit medical insurers to make way for true universal health care.
Not sure how long 1031 has been around but stepped up basis has been around since the 70s. It benefits the intergenerational transfer of small businesses and family homes. Not sure there is a benefit to change that, to fund what? I am a little concerned that none of the changes talk about simplification of tax code or simplifying this complex social safety net that is now being called infrastructure.
I dont think that the correlation is causation and of course economic growth is driven by many factors. The post WWII environment was hugely favorable to the US for many reasons. The takeaway is that the taxes did not in any way HAMPER the economic growth. And what they did prevent was the ridiculous wealth gap we now see and enabled huge investments in infrastructure (like the entire interstate, railroads, electrification, telecommunications etc etc) that we still rely on today.
For all the whining about changes in tax policy for real estate or capital gains, there is no historical evidence to suggest it will dramatically change the trajectory of the market.
I will be affected personally like many other investors here and of course Id like to keep more money in my pocket. But I dont believe all this Chicken Little crap about the end of the world as we know it.