Renting out current home and building a small Short term rental to move into!

Renting out current home and building a small Short term rental to move into!

New to Real Estate · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2024 · 1 post · 0 votes

Hey guys, 

My first post here, I have been saving up and researching a bunch to purchase my first property. I am rarely able to find relevant information, so I thought I would see what you guys think.


Im in Roseville,CA, Sacramento area. Currently own a house with a nice $1500/month low interest mortgage. The home is in a nice area so I want to hold on to it. I want to acquire my first investment property but not sure which direction to go.


I have been considering in buying out of state. I went to school in Notre Dame, IN and it seems like houses cash flow over there. 


I would love to invest closer to me, but there are not many deals I can find locally that would work, primarily looking for cashflow. I looked at a manufactured home on owned property, but that was priced too high for my comfort. Duplexes seem out of reach at the moment and they do not cash flow(at least with my calculations). Looked at some condos, but would hate to pay all the HOAs, that I feel I could use better. 

Finally, I have been looking at land in foothills, 45-60min from Sacramento. It seems like I could buy some land there. My idea is to find land with a view to build a very simple small house 600-800sqft to live in and rent out my current house, looks like I could get up to $2500 in rent for 3bed 1 bath house. While living in the smaller house I could improve the area around it like build a nice deck for a view, maybe a sauna, firepit etc.  Then once we build up some money hopefully buy another place and move, and turn the small house into a short term rental. 

The properties I am looking are in  $100k - 250k range.  Some are ready to build, some need to be developed. 


I can pull together roughly $50-60k in cash to invest. 

Am I over complicating my first investment? Or is it feasible and could work out for me ? 

I would appreciate any comments, ideas, advice and local connections as well ! 

Thank you!

0Reply
73 views

Most Popular Reply

Brian LarsonPro Member
Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2018 · 313 posts · 230 votes
1y

I would use extreme caution buying in this market right now, especially as someone new to investing.  It sounds like you have the ability to stock away money now.  I'd continue to do that.  Maybe get a roommate to lower your monthly expenses further.

BP has many success stories on the podcast and this forum but we haven't seen a downturn in the real estate market for over a decade so I suspect many people (including ones here are overleveraged).  Don't make that mistake.  People look like investing geniuses because they have serendipitously timed the market so even bad investments look good.

However, there are always deals to be had, even in a down-market, but I'd advise not being too hasty and waiting for a deal.

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brian LarsonPro Member
    Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2018 · 313 posts · 230 votes
    1y

    I would use extreme caution buying in this market right now, especially as someone new to investing.  It sounds like you have the ability to stock away money now.  I'd continue to do that.  Maybe get a roommate to lower your monthly expenses further.

    BP has many success stories on the podcast and this forum but we haven't seen a downturn in the real estate market for over a decade so I suspect many people (including ones here are overleveraged).  Don't make that mistake.  People look like investing geniuses because they have serendipitously timed the market so even bad investments look good.

    However, there are always deals to be had, even in a down-market, but I'd advise not being too hasty and waiting for a deal.

  • Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 556 posts · 427 votes
    1y

    Hey Ilya, I'm a local investor, real estate broker, and property manager -- we manage about 100 STR properties in addition to long term.

    Love the strategic thinking here. I think your greatest barrier is "analysis paralysis..." a very common affliction. There are limitless opportunities out there, and it can be quite overwhelming. 

    There's something to be said for investing in your backyard, where you have full control over the property and your service vendors. If something goes wrong in Indiana, it's gonna be a massive headache, whereas if something goes wrong nearby, you can go and resolve it quickly and efficiently. 

    Additionally, those cheaper midwestern markets tend to fluctuate and do not appreciate the same way that a "blue chip" market like NorCal will. This should be considered. 

    There are many multifamily opportunities in Sacramento and surrounding areas. In your shoes, I would buy a small duplex-fourplex, live in one unit, and rent the others. This would be a better long-term play as you pay down the equity and "hack" the property. Just my two cents. 

  • Barry MathisBusiness Member
    Roseville, CA · Member since 2024 · 24 posts · 11 votes
    1y

    Great ideas above - Noah is a Monster in STR - Have you considered offering Co Living spaces or rent by the room ? This is a trend that is being accelerated by the lack of affordable housing and can make profits soar, however it is not for the faint of heart. We are working with one of our investors now in this space.

  • Scott ScovilleBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2019 · 502 posts · 276 votes
    1y

    Hey IIya, welcome to BP. There are so many different strategies to choose from. I'm an investor and agent in Sacramento. With $50k-$60k, you could do a live in flip, or even purchase a duplex where you live in one side and rent out the other. Another option would be to purchase a seller finance property. Typically our seller finance properties require low down payments. Be happy to chat about different options if you are interested.

    Scoville Realty & Investments LLC
  • Ryan RomingerBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 340 posts · 144 votes
    1y

    Your plan is creative and could work, but building can be unpredictable—permits, utilities, and construction costs can eat into your budget and timeline.

    If cash flow is your main goal, buying in Notre Dame, IN, where you already have familiarity, might be a more straightforward first step. Renting out your current home for $2,500 is a solid move, but make sure you’re comfortable with the challenges of building before committing.

    You’re thinking long-term, which is great—just weigh the risks of new construction vs. a more turnkey investment!

    Intrigue Real Estate & Property Management4.6272 Reviews
  • Real Estate Agent · San Diego, CA · Member since 2023 · 189 posts · 88 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Ilya Golubevs:

    Hey guys, 

    My first post here, I have been saving up and researching a bunch to purchase my first property. I am rarely able to find relevant information, so I thought I would see what you guys think.


    Im in Roseville,CA, Sacramento area. Currently own a house with a nice $1500/month low interest mortgage. The home is in a nice area so I want to hold on to it. I want to acquire my first investment property but not sure which direction to go.


    I have been considering in buying out of state. I went to school in Notre Dame, IN and it seems like houses cash flow over there. 


    I would love to invest closer to me, but there are not many deals I can find locally that would work, primarily looking for cashflow. I looked at a manufactured home on owned property, but that was priced too high for my comfort. Duplexes seem out of reach at the moment and they do not cash flow(at least with my calculations). Looked at some condos, but would hate to pay all the HOAs, that I feel I could use better. 

    Finally, I have been looking at land in foothills, 45-60min from Sacramento. It seems like I could buy some land there. My idea is to find land with a view to build a very simple small house 600-800sqft to live in and rent out my current house, looks like I could get up to $2500 in rent for 3bed 1 bath house. While living in the smaller house I could improve the area around it like build a nice deck for a view, maybe a sauna, firepit etc.  Then once we build up some money hopefully buy another place and move, and turn the small house into a short term rental. 

    The properties I am looking are in  $100k - 250k range.  Some are ready to build, some need to be developed. 


    I can pull together roughly $50-60k in cash to invest. 

    Am I over complicating my first investment? Or is it feasible and could work out for me ? 

    I would appreciate any comments, ideas, advice and local connections as well ! 

    Thank you!


    Hey llya, I totally get this thinking. I own 2 cash flowing investment properties in Sacramento. One is in Roseville and the other is Natomas. I have a bit of a unique strategy for higher ROI renting by the room and working with sober living organizations. Even with the cash you have on hand, it is possible to get into a good cash flowing investment if you know where to look. Luckily I have a couple opportunities I can share with you and a unique strategy to help get what you want with the budget you have. I don't like to share my strategy publicly, I am able to do what I do because of the personal connections I have. Feel free to connect with me, I'd be happy to see how I can help.

  • Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 6 votes
    1y

    Closed on a planned STR in South Bend (go Irish). Out of state and just getting everything into place.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.