Is BUYING in a GOOD SCHOOL DISTRICT even that important anymore?

Is BUYING in a GOOD SCHOOL DISTRICT even that important anymore?

Shiloh LundahlPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes

The reason for this post is because I often read other investors post about looking for a property in an area where they have good schools. We did that. We bought a home in Burbank, California, a very expensive suburb of LA, because the school system was rated really high compared to the other schools in nearby cities. But after a year of my wife checking our kids out of school early to take them to acting auditions, she got fed up with the annoyance of the school system (not to mention the socialistic and extreme liberal political climate of the schools in LA). So she pulled them out of school and started to homeschool them. So it really didn’t matter as much whether we lived by a good school or not at that point and we could have purchased a cheaper property that was bigger and nicer for a lot less by going just a little farther outside of Burbank.

I am starting to see a lot of alternative schooling options now-a-days, especially in Arizona where I also live and invest. Here are some alternative schooling options. You can:

  • Go to your neighborhood school
  • Get an exception to go to another school outside of your area (this happens all the time by the way)
  • Go to a charter school
  • Go to a Montessori school
  • Go to a private school
  • Go to an academy 
  • Do online school
  • Do home school
  • Do a mix of online and home school
  • Do a co-op school

And I’m sure there are others I’m not familiar with. So if in your listing for the property you are renting or selling you state the excellent alternative schools in the area, does it really matter which school district you buy in if the boundaries are a lot less ridged than they used to be?

What are your thoughts?

12Reply
379 views

Most Popular Reply

New to Real Estate · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 37 votes
7y

It absolutely still matters, and no less than before. The number one factor for any parents when buying a home is area schools. Yes there are alternatives, but most who are searching for the alternatives are those who cannot be in their desirable school district. 

See this reply in the discussion

84 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Morgan PorterBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Richmond, VA · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 19 votes
    7y

    @Shiloh Lundahl School districts are now and will always be a big variable in overall property values. Don’t overlook it due to your bias. If a majority of buyers care and your property is in a bad district then you automatically loose a majority of potential buyers.

  • Developer · Dallas, TX · Member since 2015 · 84 posts · 79 votes
    7y

    @Shiloh Lundahl

    Yea schools matter but the socioeconomic situation of the parents will trump any desires for upgraded schools.

    Think of it this way, does having an all electric vehicle matter? Sure it does. Who wouldn't like to never have to buy gas again? But can everyone afford one? No. Just like in Maslow's hierarchy of needs, our basic immediate need for adequate shelter will trump our long term desire for our kids to go to better schools. Better schools only matter as much as the parents ability to shoulder that extra expense will allow it to be.

    The number one factor is budget first and foremost. And the hard truth is alot of people will still send their kids to sub par schools if that's what their pockets dictate. So I see flips in some sketchy neighborhoods (not war zone just sketchy) and they still sell. Either to folks who want what they perceive as an updated home in the neighborhoods they can afford, or to other investors who will buy turnkey rentals in those neighborhoods. There's still money to be made in rehabbing homes in those neighborhoods. You just buy and sell at lower pricepoints but the margins are the same.

    I don't think it matters as much as people's need to provide clean housing to their family does. If they have extra for more, great. But otherwise it's just seen as a luxury that low to low-medium income people will be glad to forgo and they make up the largest sector of potential homebuyers by the sheer number of people who meet that demographic.

  • Rental Property Investor · ME · Member since 2018 · 179 posts · 59 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Mark Creason:

    I have several points to make.  I have a 13 year old and we live in a Texas town that has a reputation for good schools.  The school district has access to all kinds of great programs that home schooling and online schools will most likely not offer.  @Jay Hinrichs Prosper HS offers a flight school.  I know you fly.  How many schools offer something like this?  Prosper also has a hockey and Lacrosse team.  I believe Prosper won the state Lacrosse championship beating out some of those high priced private schools.  A well funded public school has resources that most private schools do not have access to.

    I grew up in Chicago.  I went to Gordon Tech HS which was a private Catholic school.  Chicago in the 1980s had a really bad public school system.  My parents look back and now admit that they should have moved to the suburbs.  I lived closer to Maine South which has a great reputation.  If we had moved about 3 blocks further west, I would have gone there.  Now Chicago has changed.  The public schools have gotten better.  Gordon which is now called De Paul College Prep has seen enrollment go from around 2500 boys (We were all boys at the time) to about 500 co-ed student.  Tuition is currently $12,159 per school year.  Most renters are not in a position to pay that kind of money.

    I have chosen to send my kid to public schools but have also chosen to live in good school districts.  Just my "two cents".

     Most my tenants dont have kids. Nor care about quality schools. Love of death and Abortion has contributed to this.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jeremy A.:
    Originally posted by @Mark Creason:

    I have several points to make.  I have a 13 year old and we live in a Texas town that has a reputation for good schools.  The school district has access to all kinds of great programs that home schooling and online schools will most likely not offer.  @Jay Hinrichs Prosper HS offers a flight school.  I know you fly.  How many schools offer something like this?  Prosper also has a hockey and Lacrosse team.  I believe Prosper won the state Lacrosse championship beating out some of those high priced private schools.  A well funded public school has resources that most private schools do not have access to.

    I grew up in Chicago.  I went to Gordon Tech HS which was a private Catholic school.  Chicago in the 1980s had a really bad public school system.  My parents look back and now admit that they should have moved to the suburbs.  I lived closer to Maine South which has a great reputation.  If we had moved about 3 blocks further west, I would have gone there.  Now Chicago has changed.  The public schools have gotten better.  Gordon which is now called De Paul College Prep has seen enrollment go from around 2500 boys (We were all boys at the time) to about 500 co-ed student.  Tuition is currently $12,159 per school year.  Most renters are not in a position to pay that kind of money.

    I have chosen to send my kid to public schools but have also chosen to live in good school districts.  Just my "two cents".

     Most my tenants dont have kids. Nor care about quality schools. Love of death and Abortion has contributed to this.

    rentals don't matter as much since basically if its in a rental dominated area values are only as strong as rents or what an investor will pay for a given cash flow.. the upside value in SFR is owner occ.. that's were the big money is made in those assets not as rentals.

    so for that to happen you need good to great schools.. those that can afford high end homes it matters.. 

  • New York, NY · Member since 2019 · 60 posts · 82 votes
    7y

    @Shiloh Lundahl

    I personally know families that are still paying for million dollar homes in queens ny because of “better” schools.

    I say, yes.

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Shiloh Lundahl:

    The reason for this post is because I often read other investors post about looking for a property in an area where they have good schools. We did that. We bought a home in Burbank, California, a very expensive suburb of LA, because the school system was rated really high compared to the other schools in nearby cities. But after a year of my wife checking our kids out of school early to take them to acting auditions, she got fed up with the annoyance of the school system (not to mention the socialistic and extreme liberal political climate of the schools in LA). So she pulled them out of school and started to homeschool them. So it really didn’t matter as much whether we lived by a good school or not at that point and we could have purchased a cheaper property that was bigger and nicer for a lot less by going just a little farther outside of Burbank.

    I am starting to see a lot of alternative schooling options now-a-days, especially in Arizona where I also live and invest. Here are some alternative schooling options. You can:

    • Go to your neighborhood school
    • Get an exception to go to another school outside of your area (this happens all the time by the way)
    • Go to a charter school
    • Go to a Montessori school
    • Go to a private school
    • Go to an academy 
    • Do online school
    • Do home school
    • Do a mix of online and home school
    • Do a co-op school

    And I’m sure there are others I’m not familiar with. So if in your listing for the property you are renting or selling you state the excellent alternative schools in the area, does it really matter which school district you buy in if the boundaries are a lot less ridged than they used to be?

    What are your thoughts?

     #1 rule in real estate; location, location, location.

  • Rental Property Investor · Wayzata · Member since 2019 · 80 posts · 24 votes
    7y

    Good schools are everything. In California where I lived and currently where I reside, it dictates everything, especially home prices. 

    @Shiloh Lundahl

    I get what the OP is trying to get at -- parents are becoming more empowered in their choices but at the root of those choices is finding the best schools for their kids and the family, what works the best and what schools are most aligned with their family's values. Saying it's not a factor is not helping yourself when analyzing areas. However, it depends on who the potential market is -- young parents with pre-school kids or seniors? Maybe not as much a factor but people think about it and look at it in terms of resale value too.

    Perception is also part of this. There are ratings that go into it and online ratings that aren't always accurate but it doesn't matter because the perception alone (of desirable schools) can drive up home values.

    Also, teachers are very important. Hey, be nice to your kids teacher today! Send them a Starbucks gift card. Most people don't know it but teachers spend something like $800-$1200 a year out of their own pocket for supplies. There are more options and it behooves the investor to at least know a bit about schools in the area, what the perception/reputation is and options. A good place to start is online rankings.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.