Questions From a Rental Investor Newbie

Questions From a Rental Investor Newbie

Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes

Hello Bigger Pockets. This is my first post. I recently lost my job here in the Bay Area in CA. And I am at the very beginning of my exploration into passive income by investing in rentals. 

I have a house that I inherited in this location that Zillow estimates at about 1.3 million. It's in a location, Silicone Valley, that could bid up. It also has Prop 13 which means I only have to save about $40 per month for property tax. Bummer losing that. We currently make $2900 net rent from it since we have a management company.

We like Austin TX for the schools though, and hopefully friendlier culture. And we think we could buy, possibly, 4 houses there at about 300k and live in one and rent the others. 

I bought the Bigger Pockets books and will read them up. But my goal is to learn about real estate investing so I can make living income somewhere in a less ridiculously expensive place with good schools.

So, are there specific people I can call that specialize in what I am trying to do for consultation? I don't want to screw this up. I'd love to be able to snowball this too. 

What are some things to keep in mind with a goal of being a rental investor in a specific situation as mine?

1Reply
143 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
7y

Why would you sell that Silicon Valley property? It sounds like it's infinitely profitable (since you inherited it and you're netting $3000/month), and it's likely only going to keep gaining in both rents and value, all while your property tax doesn't move.

Can a crew of Austin properties cash flow that well and have that much appreciation potential??

See this reply in the discussion

48 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y

    Yeah I am basically learning that there is a give and take between appreciation and cashflow. The thing is, while I haven't been there yet, I've heard great things about living in Austin, but the most important thing to me is schools. So if I could find deals and rehab and rent and get a somewhat workable cash on cash, we could make it work. I'm not looking to be making bank on that part initially, just looking to get by and be happy and grow from there.

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y

    What I get right now for the 1.3M house after Prop 13 and management fees is $2900mo about 2.7 percent. All research I've done, people I have asked has told me that's not that great. If we sold the house spent 275k on a house with a decent school, I'm trying to see if I could get enough cashflow from the 1M with maybe a rehab and rent plan to just limit savings/capital burn and just be able to live frugally in the meantime. I'm not looking for get rich quick.

  • Jaron WallingPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7y

    @Seth Tipton What are your other living expenses? Car loans, student loans, credit cards, etc? If you have any of those I would seriously consider paying them off first. Regardless of what you do with the 1M property it's important to make good lifestyle/ spending choices first. Finding a replacement property is a nice idea if the timing is right.

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 304 posts · 462 votes
    7y

    From my perspective, California is not a good place to invest in real estate; niether is New York or Illinois. All three of those states have serious financial issues and taxes are only going to go higher which does not bode well for price appreciation in the future. Texas is a good state as is Florida and the Carolinas. I would definitely sell in California ASAP and get out of the state. 

    As far as purchasing anything, you need to assess your own skills before deciding on a course of action. Do you own your own home now and are you capable of managing the home on your own? If you have no experience, I would start small. Buy a duplex or a triplex and if your circumstances allow, live in one of the units and rent out the rest. You will learn first hand what it takes to manage property and tenants. 

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Dennis Cosgrave:

    From my perspective, California is not a good place to invest in real estate; niether is New York or Illinois. All three of those states have serious financial issues and taxes are only going to go higher which does not bode well for price appreciation in the future. Texas is a good state as is Florida and the Carolinas. I would definitely sell in California ASAP and get out of the state. 

    As far as purchasing anything, you need to assess your own skills before deciding on a course of action. Do you own your own home now and are you capable of managing the home on your own? If you have no experience, I would start small. Buy a duplex or a triplex and if your circumstances allow, live in one of the units and rent out the rest. You will learn first hand what it takes to manage property and tenants. 

     The thing I like about California is Prop 13. As the value of the home rises, the property tax remains stable. The concern I have had about Texas is the high tax percentage and how that must constantly be balanced with raising rent to keep cashflow consistent (unless maybe there is another way I haven't thought about.) What do people do when they own a home and the value goes up 300 percent but not their wages? Seems like an impending crisis is coming there. In CA, they were facing the same problem which is why they passed prop 13 in the first place. When it comes to property taxes, they actually don't go higher at least for now unless they modify it.

    The difficult choice I have is that I have a prop 13 on the house in CA from my grandmother keeping the tax at 40 dollars a month. That's a unicorn and we are lucky and selling that is a much more difficult choice because we would never get that again.

    From what you are saying, we should get out of that immediately? Dennis, do you believe that the Silicon Valley and California is on it's way to an impending crash/decline making it worth it to sell a property like that? Most other investors on this thread have encouraged us to keep it.

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 304 posts · 462 votes
    7y

    Even though you are only paying $40 a month in property taxes, how much are you paying in state income tax on your rental income. I suspect it is a lot more than $40 per month. I believe that California has seen its best days. There is little upside potential and a lot of diwnside risk. Given that the value is $1.4 million, the capital gains on a sale will trigger significant taxes. If possible you might want to try a 1031 exchange which would defer those taxes. 

  • Developer · Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y

    Seth,

    It sounds like you have no choice but to sell your CA home and move on. Yes you lose out on the future appreciation but with no job and other factors, you need to do what you need to do. 

    Cashflow now when times are desperate is more important than appreciation in the future. You can't eat money in the future.

    So you're right on the money: just sell the house and use the proceeds and buy cashflowing properties. You can invest where you want to move to - and you can start with single family homes or (my personal preference)  buy a 4-plex. Live in one unit and rent out the other 3 units. 

    Just buy 1 property and conserve the cash. Meanwhile, look for a job.

    Once you have a job, you can refinance, pull some money out and buy more properties.

    Why buy only 1 property? You don't know enough to buy multiple properties at this point. You don't have the management skills nor know the right PM to hire. You are moving to a new area. Although buying a rental is not rocket science, you need to know the "ins" and "outs" first.

    For the rest of your cashflow needs, you can get that from a job.

    Makes sense?

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Dennis Cosgrave:

    Even though you are only paying $40 a month in property taxes, how much are you paying in state income tax on your rental income. I suspect it is a lot more than $40 per month. I believe that California has seen its best days. There is little upside potential and a lot of diwnside risk. Given that the value is $1.4 million, the capital gains on a sale will trigger significant taxes. If possible you might want to try a 1031 exchange which would defer those taxes. 

     Dennis, I looked into that and that is a good idea if we decide to keep the house. Also, I should mention that I inherited the house and according to CA law cap gains appreciation starts at the time of the decedent's passing. In my case, about 4 years ago it was 950k and now 1.3M. They give a 500k deductible for married ppl on top of that. One of the plans we had been considering is moving into the house and after 2 years that wipes out the cap gains tax I believe.

    But when you say CA best days are behind it, I see where you are coming from. But, in my case, I put nothing into the house as an "investment" so any growth would be positive from that perspective, even if growth may slow down.

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Michael Ealy:

    Seth,

    It sounds like you have no choice but to sell your CA home and move on. Yes you lose out on the future appreciation but with no job and other factors, you need to do what you need to do. 

    Cashflow now when times are desperate is more important than appreciation in the future. You can't eat money in the future.

    So you're right on the money: just sell the house and use the proceeds and buy cashflowing properties. You can invest where you want to move to - and you can start with single family homes or (my personal preference)  buy a 4-plex. Live in one unit and rent out the other 3 units. 

    Just buy 1 property and conserve the cash. Meanwhile, look for a job.

    Once you have a job, you can refinance, pull some money out and buy more properties.

    Why buy only 1 property? You don't know enough to buy multiple properties at this point. You don't have the management skills nor know the right PM to hire. You are moving to a new area. Although buying a rental is not rocket science, you need to know the "ins" and "outs" first.

    For the rest of your cashflow needs, you can get that from a job.

    Makes sense?

     Thanks for the advice and yes it does make sense. As we learn more, a clearer and more realistic picture is emerging it it looks alot like what you describe. However, it's not off the table for us to move into the house. We wouldn't have rent at least. Just one of several possible plans we are considering. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 304 posts · 462 votes
    7y

    Your personal exemption of $500k only applies to your personal residence, not to income property so yes, you will have about $50k in taxes to pay. If you decided to move into the house, it would constitute a change in use which would still trigger capital gains taxes so given your circumstances that is not a solution either. 

    I am not talking about a slow down in growth. I am talking about a decline in property values. As the looney left in Sacramento continue to raise taxes to pay for the benefits to all the “undocumented” iimmigrants (i am trying to be politcally correct) the state will become less and less affordable and more people will leave the state. You mentioned that your parents in law are leaving in January. How many other people do you know who are leaving? I am sure there are more. Eventually enough people will leave where the supply of housing exceeds demand which means prices WILL DROP. That is basic economics. It will reach a point where the only people left are the super rich and the takers. All the taxpayers will be gone and what will property be worth then? I am not trying to sound alarmist but that is the path that California is on.  The objective now should be preserving capital, never mind any gains. 

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y

    Yes I do know of some others who left. If we didn't have the house we would probably have to leave too and we are definitely considering it. I don't know if it is as simple as the picture I always hear that everyone is leaving. I read an article from the San Diego Union Tribune which stated that while 5 million left to Texas, Nevada and Oregon, 4 million moved in from New York and New Jersey. So it is a net loss but not exactly a hemorrhaging. Also, if prices do deflate, it could attract even more from those places to move in while the prices are nice. Not sure if I am allowed to post the article but it is an interesting read.

    https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/opinion/the-conversation/sd-california-losing-low-income-people-gaining-wealthy-people-per-report-20180221-htmlstory.html

  • Real Estate Agent · Princeton, NJ · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    @Seth Tipton - Sorry you lost your job. Silicon Valley has gazillions of jobs. What’s the probability you can get another one relatively soon? Can’t you collect unemployment for a while? You talk about Austin like it’s some dream. Most of the housing prices there have been bid up. Your next house should be where your next job is or your spouses job. The great thing about Palo Alto etc. is a high concentration of very high paying jobs and smart people and a lot of NIMBY anti development activism. Job growth without housing growth just means the house prices will continue to go up. Texas is notorious for few zoning regulations and better houses continue to be built. Job growth with housing growth (or property tax growth) means little or limited appreciation.

    If I were you, I would try to get another job in Silicon Valley, and I would "owner occupy" Airbnb or rent out rooms long term to working professionals to help pay bills. I was just reading an article about a place called podshare which charges $1200/mo for a bunk bed in the Bay Area and there were like 6 bunks to a medium size like 12x12 bedroom. Be creative. You can afford to stay in California, collect appreciation on the house and get enough money to pay all your bills. After you get a new job, why not get a 30 year mortgage at all time low interest rates like 4% and pull out like $1000000 in equity tax free? (Assuming it's paid off and you can get 75% LTV). If you sell, you'll pay hefty taxes on your capital gain.

  • Commercial Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2015 · 102 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    If you are in the Bay Area, Sacramento area is a great place to look around before moving out of state.  Many areas have good schools and decent ‘burbs’ to raise the kids (Folsom, El Dorado Hills, Roseville, Rocklin).   And it is growing, in almost all areas.  Jobs are coming into the area too.   Commercial retail is fire hot right now.  Landlords have no problem filling vacancies.   Maybe consider doing a 1031 - your money goes a lot further here than in the Bay Area.  Yes, the kindergarten kids under the dome are in charge here but they haven’t completely destroyed everything, yet (but they seem to be trying very hard...).

  • Investor · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2014 · 942 posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    @Seth Tipton I feel you need to take a step back before you even consider selling and moving. The issue you should address first is the fact that it will be extremely difficult for you to get a loan to buy a house anywhere without a W2. Even if you have a large pile of cash in a savings account, DTI is still a thing. I cannot imagine that you are considering selling your place in the BA to buy all cash in Austin. Even if you were to do that and bought multiple rentals in a a different market, lenders will not take your rental income into consideration for a several months to several years. You could inadvertantly put yourself in a really tight financing hole.

    Your main concern seems to be the school district, but you did not elaborate on the ages of your children. If they are still very young the schools will not be as important, you just need a longer term plan to get to good schools for 8th grade and up. Make up the difference in the younger years by spending "homework" time at the kitchen table with them and augment with Kumon or other outside tutoring options.

    Don't even consider killing the "goose that lays the golden eggs". Things like taxes and school districts are real concerns, but if you cannot get a loan or don't have other sources of funding you will not be able to expand into REI.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · College Station, TX · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 969 votes
    7y

    @Seth Tipton. Several quandaries you are facing.  

    1. At present you have an Investment Property. Best way to sell an Investment Property is to do a 1031 Exchange. With this approach you can escape capital gains taxes on all the gain you have realized in the property. On the other side of the 1031 you have to reinvest ALL of the proceeds in some type of "similar" property within 6 months or you pay taxes on the gain. Another short straw is you only have 45 Days from Closing the Sale to IDENTIFY the property(s) you intend to use as replacement. 45-Days sounds like a lot of time - but the clock can tick away quickly. 

    2. The other option is to move back into the property and convert it to personal use. No idea what this does to your $40 / Month taxes. However, when you sell the property you'll pay Cap gains on the amount above $500K. 

    3. Moving to Austin.  Long time Austin Resident & Broker / Agent in Austin. Moved away in 2015, going to somewhat semi-retired status, increasingly weird (People's Republic Of Austin) Politics, High Taxes, Traffic, etc, etc., etc.  I still manage a few properties in Austin and am a Member of the Austin REALTOR Board, so still knowledgeable about Austin. 

    Schools seem to be very important to you: Best School Districts in the Austin area are Eanes (Westlake), Lake Travis, & Round Rock. Eanes - average price range probably $800K, Lake Travis - average price range probably $450K, Round Rock - average price range probably approaching $350K. Certainly, you can find more economical housing in all three areas. There are some good school tracks within the Austin ISD, you just need to educate yourself.

    Lots of decisions to be made, reach out if you want to discuss. 

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y

    Thank you for the great feedback everyone. I am taking it all in.

    Jim, about the Austin taxes one thing I am wondering is how are locals dealing with the skyrocketing home values? In CA, if your home goes up in value prop 13 protects you from getting taxed out of your home. In Austin, without some kind of protection, I'm trying to figure out what people do. Do the investors simply raise the rent? Do home owner residents without much income apply for a tax break or are they just forced to move? 

  • Real Estate Broker · Austin, TX · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    @Seth Tipton What I do and many other investors do is protest taxes and raise rents. Its a common well worn path to the county appraisal district office to protest taxes and its very effective. There is a small industry here with small companies representing investors and home owners to protest the taxes. Landlords raise the rent. Home owners can file for homestead exemption which effectively lowers taxes. There are other exemptions too. A senior citizen can file for exemption. There are loopholes. You will need to educate yourself on it. 

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Aaron Gordy:

    @Seth Tipton What I do and many other investors do is protest taxes and raise rents. Its a common well worn path to the county appraisal district office to protest taxes and its very effective. There is a small industry here with small companies representing investors and home owners to protest the taxes. Landlords raise the rent. Home owners can file for homestead exemption which effectively lowers taxes. There are other exemptions too. A senior citizen can file for exemption. There are loopholes. You will need to educate yourself on it. 

     So you can protest when the only reason for the increase is a new appraisal? What can the government do other than lower the tax percentage? Would they actually do that?

  • Real Estate Broker · Austin, TX · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    You can protest your tax based upon a faulty appraisal valuation. You have to understand that the type of appraisal performed by the local government is far different than what folks normally think an appraisal is all about. Once you wrap your head around the nuances of the appraisal process you will see that the process is flawed. Therefore, protesting becomes possible. Its not feasible for most folks to spend the time to gather data to build the case to protest the taxes over say a $500 increase in property taxes so they hire someone to do it for them. These companies will charge a percentage of the amount saved. It all works. The percentage is not lowered or increased for this purpose. The taxable value is lowered. The State Government recently forced the local governments including Austin to go to the voters in order to increase the taxable percentage over a certain amount. 1/3 of the metro area protest their taxes btw. Here are the exemptions that one can file which lowers taxes too. 

    https://www.traviscad.org/forms/forms-exemptions/

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Aaron Gordy:

    You can protest your tax based upon a faulty appraisal valuation. You have to understand that the type of appraisal performed by the local government is far different than what folks normally think an appraisal is all about. Once you wrap your head around the nuances of the appraisal process you will see that the process is flawed. Therefore, protesting becomes possible. Its not feasible for most folks to spend the time to gather data to build the case to protest the taxes over say a $500 increase in property taxes so they hire someone to do it for them. These companies will charge a percentage of the amount saved. It all works. The percentage is not lowered or increased for this purpose. The taxable value is lowered. The State Government recently forced the local governments including Austin to go to the voters in order to increase the taxable percentage over a certain amount. 1/3 of the metro area protest their taxes btw. Here are the exemptions that one can file which lowers taxes too. 

    https://www.traviscad.org/forms/forms-exemptions/

     Ah I see what you mean. That's interesting though. As an investor, or even as just a resident, I'd be arguing against raising the value of my own asset. Are the government appraisals different than the market values?

  • Real Estate Broker · Austin, TX · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    Yeah the process creates an incentive to say that their properties are total dumps and close to condemnation. 

  • Member since 2019 · 24 posts · 7 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Aaron Gordy:

    Yeah the process creates an incentive to say that their properties are total dumps and close to condemnation. 

     LOL this would make for a great Monty Python bit. "Yes this is Italian marble but it's the worst one I could find!"

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · College Station, TX · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 969 votes
    7y

    @Seth Tipton. @Aaron Gordy has illuminated some of the issues with taxes. Tax Appraisal are (mandated by state law) to be valued at 100% of Market Value. 

    But what is Market Value. Generally, I would say the Appraisal Districts do a reasonable job of keeping up with market conditions. However, their basis is mass data - not individual addresses. You'll typically find the majority are with a reasonable stroke of accurate, but some are exorbitantly high and occasionally you'll find one low. 

    As an Investor / Homeowner you need to have an idea of what market value is or "a friend in the business"  you can rely on to provide you with timely accurate data. It's not difficult to protest, just involves some research and an hour or so of your time. 

    You can look up any property you might be interested in via the county appraisal district. For Example in Travis County (Austin area) go to www.TravisCAD.org and click on the Property Search Button. For Williamson County (Round Rock) it's www.WCAD.org .

    As a Homeowner (NOT Investor) you can file for and obtain a "Homestead Exemption" for your personal residence. The exemption will reduce your tax bill by about 8%. Not a huge sum, but every little bit helps. 

    Let me know what other questions you might have, and what I can do to assist. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.