whats your take?

Question

Looking for some real-world insight from people actively in the lending and investor space.

My primary background is in commercial equipment finance, and I’ve been exploring the idea of eventually expanding into the real estate side as well — specifically:

• DSCR loans

• fix-and-flip financing

• bridge/hard money products

Easy to see a ton of overlap between the two industries:

• relationship-driven business

• brokers/connectors win

• speed matters

• structuring matters

• clients value certainty over just rate

***But is the demand still there? I see offers everywhere!***

That said, I’m trying to better understand the actual demand and economics from people already doing it.

A few questions for those active in hard money/private lending:

• Is demand still strong right now?

• What products are seeing the most traction?

• Are DSCR loans becoming more competitive/margin compressed?

• What does a realistic broker pipeline look like if you’re only planning to do a handful of deals per year initially?

• What do brokers realistically expect to make per funded loan on average?

Not looking for anybody to give away trade secrets — just trying to understand the business model from operators already in the trenches before deciding how deep to go into this side of the industry.

Would genuinely appreciate any insight from lenders, brokers, investors, or flippers actively working in the space.

Mike Klarman · Answer

Steve, fellow Philly boy here.  So I figure I'd drop in and answer your questions.

• Is demand still strong right now?

Demand for loan products?  That's always there.  When rates are low and inventory high, it's in more demand than when rates are high and inventory low and then it's a dry industry.

• What products are seeing the most traction?

It is Bridge and DSCR, that is your bread and butter.  If you get a nice Ground Up biz going, great, those are the hardest programs.  DSCR loans tend to yield more commission than bridge all things considered.

• Are DSCR loans becoming more competitive/margin compressed?

No.  Like you said, I am not giving up my outs or my trade secrets but DSCR loans can be very lucrative.  I am focusing on high net worth individuals who want to buy upper tier STR homes.  The commission on those are sweet, but I offer to go over and above for the client and help them make sense of the income info on AIR DNA and the comps and try to make sure they get in a good spot.  But the commission on these can be 6k - 9k.  I've made 15k on one of these before.  You do 5 of these a year and it really makes a difference.  10 per year and it is a living.

• What does a realistic broker pipeline look like if you’re only planning to do a handful of deals per year initially?

The life of a broker is not glamorous.  You essentially own your own business and it is up to you to bring the business in.  It is a flooded field and we are all selling the same products.  A good pipeline has loans in every stage at all times.  Some in the intake stage, some in processing, some in underwriting, some getting ready to close.  A handful of deals?  They better be big deals.  You standard fee will be 1 point.  So, if you close a bridge loan for 250k, you'll make 2,500.  Not a bad check, but you need about 50 of them, not a handful.  A handful of deals would be more like a commercial broker who is closing 10 million dollar deals, then maybe you need like 3 per year.

• What do brokers realistically expect to make per funded loan on average?

1 point.  I've seen brokers charge as much as 3 points.  I mean, it's all about what the client's threshold is and the kind of loan.  I had a loan recently that was in Philly.  It was a first time investor, who had the house bequeathed to her recently and she immediately wanted to refi the house - it was worth 600k.  So first, I needed a non seasoning refi lender and that same lender had to be able to finance in Philly - Philly is on the blackball list right now btw - and then the same lender had to do a first time investor.  So I charged the investor 3 points.  I told them upfront and I said it will be right there on the HUD.  They said I deserved it.  That was like a 10k check for me.  I do not chase the small bridge stuff anymore.  If it lands in my lap or someone needs to some guidance and asks for my help, I will.  But chasing the bridge loans is much like being an ambulance chasing lawyer.  If you can close 3 - 5 loans per month as a free agent broker, you are doing well.

James Driscoll · Answer

Good breakdown from the NJ specialist above — a lot of that rings true, and I want to add a lender's perspective since we sit on the other side of these deals every day.

On DSCR specifically: the margin compression question is worth unpacking. Margins have tightened at the commodity end — vanilla single-family, straightforward ratios, cookie-cutter borrowers. Where there's still real money, for both brokers and lenders, is in the more complex layering: short-term rental income analysis, non-warrantable property types, higher loan amounts, borrowers with multiple entities. That complexity creates value, and value is where pricing holds. The STR angle the NJ poster mentioned is real — but it also demands that whoever is structuring the deal actually understands how projected income gets underwritten, not just what a data platform spits out. Getting that wrong at origination kills deals at the finish line.

On pipeline math: the "handful of deals" framing is the part I'd push back on hardest. In 31 years in the mortgage business, the operators I've seen succeed — broker or LO — are the ones who build a process, not just a contact list. A pipeline with loans in every stage simultaneously isn't just good advice, it's survival math. The dry months don't hurt you if your intake never stops. Bridge loans at $250K are fine volume-builders, but they're not the foundation of a business unless you're closing them consistently and using each one to expand the referral network.

For anyone newer to DSCR origination: the underwriting discipline up front is everything. I've worked with investors where doing the deal analysis carefully before they even applied saved them from a property that would have bled cash. That kind of rigor is what turns a one-time client into a repeat borrower.

Hope this adds something useful to the thread — feel free to DM me if you want to dig into the underwriting side of any of this.

Jim Driscoll

Erik Estrada · Answer

Hey Steven,

Let me answer these based on my perspective:

• Is demand still strong right now?

Yes it is still pretty strong. As long as you can focus on a niche within the industry.

• What products are seeing the most traction?

Niche loan programs not readily available (Manufactured Home Refis, Multi-Family, lenient guidelines)

• Are DSCR loans becoming more competitive/margin compressed?

Yes If you focus on cookie cutter deals. You will make more on deals that require real expert knowledge and effort.

• What does a realistic broker pipeline look like if you’re only planning to do a handful of deals per year initially?

5-10 loans per months at least.

• What do brokers realistically expect to make per funded loan on average?

Min $3k up to $20k depending on the loan amount and how the loan is priced.

Joel Miller · Answer

As a private hard money lender, I can say that at least in our area of northwestern PA the demand is strong. I would connect with whatever area investor/landlord groups you can find and get involved. Network is key because you will be lending based on relationships. The more "underwriting" you put them through the less attractive you will be to them.

whats your take?

Most Popular Reply