Real Estate Agent 路 Memphis, TN 路 Member since 2015 路 1k+ posts 路 1k+ votes
Can we talk about all the Artificial Intelligence responses we are getting on every post in the forum section? Agents, wholesalers, Turn Key providers in the Memphis market are all using auto response that they have connected to AI. One particular person is using it 15+ times per day on every single topic.
Anyone else see this in their specific city forums?
Does BP care?
Do buyers want to talk to a real property source or a robot?
Its been discussed at great length here on the forum. These AI sock puppets have throughly diluted the forum to a point that most of the OG's are gone. Some mods like J.D., Chris & others have been doing their best to combat them but lets face it....they're overwhelming. Since TCG now owns the majority stake in BP I beleive they'd like the forum to be more of a sales platform than an organic forum with us mere mortals. I do give credit to these spam bots though that they're getting beter at making their obtuse rhetorical question posts sound a little more genuine. To note now that REI investing has gone back to normal (cheap leverage being gone, inflation affecting prices) itll be difficult for this forum to ever be what it once was.
@Dean Harris I've seen this in my city forums as well.
I've even seen AI responses that quote some of my own previous forum posts. Curious to know if there is a way for BP to distinguish actual posts vs. AI-generated
Its been discussed at great length here on the forum. These AI sock puppets have throughly diluted the forum to a point that most of the OG's are gone. Some mods like J.D., Chris & others have been doing their best to combat them but lets face it....they're overwhelming. Since TCG now owns the majority stake in BP I beleive they'd like the forum to be more of a sales platform than an organic forum with us mere mortals. I do give credit to these spam bots though that they're getting beter at making their obtuse rhetorical question posts sound a little more genuine. To note now that REI investing has gone back to normal (cheap leverage being gone, inflation affecting prices) itll be difficult for this forum to ever be what it once was.
These AI aided posts all follow the same formats, patterns and ques. It seems like the joint is really hustling to bring in newbs here. They're more likely to bite on the AI or purchase from a checkered "nationwide" turn key provider here that certainly spends a lot to market to newbs and hawk suspect deals.
Nothing against newbs, but after 25 years in the game, you can only respond to so many posts from people maybe looking at properties for the first time. Where did everyone go who has experience?
These AI aided posts all follow the same formats, patterns and ques. It seems like the joint is really hustling to bring in newbs here. They're more likely to bite on the AI or purchase from a checkered "nationwide" turn key provider here that certainly spends a lot to market to newbs and hawk suspect deals.
Nothing against newbs, but after 25 years in the game, you can only respond to so many posts from people maybe looking at properties for the first time. Where did everyone go who has experience?
We probably all got old and jaded at the same time 馃槀
Make sure to flag the post. It makes it easier for us. I was just reading one where somebody wanted to get a portfolio loan on three rentals in Cleveland. Every single post was almost identical, which started off with "Congrats on getting XYZ and this," and then goes into a brief explanation where they end up writing a short novel to never even answer the question that was asked. Yes, it continues to get worse. Unfortunately, there's only so much we can do.
Make sure to flag the post. It makes it easier for us. I was just reading one where somebody wanted to get a portfolio loan on three rentals in Cleveland. Every single post was almost identical, which started off with "Congrats on getting XYZ and this," and then goes into a brief explanation where they end up writing a short novel to never even answer the question that was asked. Yes, it continues to get worse. Unfortunately, there's only so much we can do.
Echo this. Other users help a lot because it will bring names and styles to our attention. The AI has become ridiculously good; a year ago it was easy to knock these guys out. It is a lot harder now - the posts are getting good at introducing subtlety and inflection that mimics humans pretty good. I fully expect at some point it will just be near impossible to distinguish but until then we'll keep doing our best.
Yes, it's turning the forum into a spam fest. These forums have been a huge help for me as an investor when I was just starting out back in 2018 as well as for my Realtor business doing authentic real posts. I still have many friends to this day I met through BP meetups pre covid, let's keep it that way as a great resource! Should be an easy filter to add that elimates at least the worst of the culprits. I saw one user who even had fake other users responding entirely with AI.
I joined in 2018 and feel old in the forums which is crazy. 100% agree with the above. I don't like the mixed in posts (ads) for the podcast. If I want to listen to the podcast I'll open my Spotify and do so. Speaking of the podcast it's heavy on ads as well sometimes to the determent of the listener.
I am reluctant to remove posts from Memphis people even when it is obvious that they are AI because I am viewed as someone who has something to sell. I don't want to get accused of removing posts that might conflict even though I don't sell here and no longer advertise on BP.
I'm approaching 20 years being on BP and unfortunately, I rarely log on anymore and like I said, I no longer advertise. There are a lot of reasons behind that, but one is that the forums just don't attract the conversationalists or good back and forth at the same rate it used to. Spam AI bots are a major reason. I opened BP on Sunday night, and my entire front page of searched topics was one person in Memphis.
@Chris Clothier That one person is flooding the site all day with an auto generated response system through AI. That person cant string together 3 straight sentences in a real convo yet AI has it sounding over the top "official". I have been a paying agent on this site longer than any agent in the city (According to BP) and I am about to cancel it. The leads are no longer viable. They are diluted and the buyers are confused by half the crop they read...from AI! Hate to see OG's like yourself and some other not post here and come on the site as much due to AI
@Jaron Walling BiggerPockets was bought out by PE a few years ago and it has been an advertising free for all since then. Shame to see the quality go down like it has
@Henry Lazerow Lets keep making BP aware. If you are seeing it, I would imagine everyone is seeing it too.
@Chris Seveney I will 100% be flagging these posts from now on. Good suggestion. I hope everyone does!
@James Wise My post isn't about saying anything with my chest or creating a "tough guy" competition. Although, you can obviously see who the people/teams/companies I am referring to and so can everyone else. My post was to point out how bad the site has become overtaken by AI and people/teams/companies that use it consistently on every single topic that is posted. Are you enjoying the AI reading material?
@Chris Clothier That one person is flooding the site all day with an auto generated response system through AI. That person cant string together 3 straight sentences in a real convo yet AI has it sounding over the top "official". I have been a paying agent on this site longer than any agent in the city (According to BP) and I am about to cancel it. The leads are no longer viable. They are diluted and the buyers are confused by half the crop they read...from AI! Hate to see OG's like yourself and some other not post here and come on the site as much due to AI
@Jaron Walling BiggerPockets was bought out by PE a few years ago and it has been an advertising free for all since then. Shame to see the quality go down like it has
@Henry Lazerow Lets keep making BP aware. If you are seeing it, I would imagine everyone is seeing it too.
@Chris Seveney I will 100% be flagging these posts from now on. Good suggestion. I hope everyone does!
My biggest question is does BiggerPockets care?
Well, this ends up becoming a self-reinforcing doom loop. If real people like yourself quit posting and joining and participating, then eventually there won't be anything left except for bots. The answer is more, not less, participation.
@JD Martin "Doom Loop". Excellent description. However, keeping up with that automation with real content and replies is impossible. Maybe if we cut our allowable comments to 2-3 per day. I mean les be serious, nobody wants to hear from anyone more than 2-3 times per day.
No, it's killed the quality of lead gen that this site produces. BP has gone from one of my top 3 lead sources to not even cracking the top 10..... Call um out browski. Take them to task. Do not let the terminator win.
Im on a couple other forums (Contractors, Motorsports) & its largely self policed, fakes get called out & the mods axe em. They're much smaller than this forum though.
I think ultimately not feeding the schills & flagging them is really all we can do.
Like Chris mentioned it used to be conversational though. It wasn鈥檛 all kumbaya, ahh I remember the cap rate arguments in the old days lol.
I know we wont hear anything but I would be curious to get a response from BiggerPockets.
It seems I'm not the only one who has noticed and that was the point of the post. I wanted to see how many other investors out there noticed and then objected to this site being run by AI and automation.
I appreciate the replies and conversation. Lets see if we can report and squeeze it out so we can attempt to get back to sold conversation between actual investors in these forums.
We see this too, and I agree with the point you are raising. It's nearly impossible to not see it. Bots and accounts that post AI-written filler don鈥檛 belong here. The moderation team removes them when they find them. The best way to help us there is to report posts.
The hard part is where to draw the line. A lot of real members use AI to clean up a post, or to help get a thought out. Some aren鈥檛 confident writers. Some don鈥檛 have English as a first language. So there is a lot of nuance to this conversation. It's also just getting harder and harder to distinguish, so our automated efforts to date all seem to fall short.
I have to be careful not to tip our hand too much, but we are in the process of developing some internal signals to score posts on likelihood of it being AI or not. Results so far have been mixed, but it's a start - and congrats, your post scored a 1 out of 100. While it's early days, I have hopes this will eventually help us start to make some change that will make this a better place. We most certainly do care.
It's not just AI in of itself, its the schilling & AI enables it. Its used as a way to make the OP sound like an expert. Funny thing Ive learned in life is to be skeptical of "experts", an excellent writer isn't necessarily genuine in their advice, or worse, how they conduct business.
@Alan F. You are hitting the "nail on the head". This is exactly where my head is at with this. I know some of the guys personally using the AI for every post and every response and this is 100% accurate description
@Connor Reaumond I appreciate the response from BP. I certainly didn't think we would hear form you guys. I'm excited to see some potential governing on the AI posts. Scoring or grading the posts to help identify artificial intelligence in the posts is a great idea. Anything that can help get this website back to live conversations between actual investors is what would bring this site back. Thank you again