@Mindy Jensen I totally agree that someone under 18 should be free to learn. I wouldn't block them from the site, but I am just not sure BP has safe guards in place to protect minors on this forum. I don't think it is a good idea for minors to be private messaging random adults or meeting up with them. My recommendation is to require a birth date when registering and disable private messaging on any minor. Anything that is being discussed with minors should be in the public forum.
The second issue I see is giving advice to minors. There is something such as reckless advice. It is one thing if an adult receives bad advice, but it is totally different when minor is involved. For example, telling children not to go to college. A child doesn't know how to process that, because they believe a successful person is telling them that. That may not be the case. I know someone used the example of Rich Dad, but that is totally different. That is someone that your parents know and is a real person in real life. Random people on the internet cannot be trusted in the same manner.
It would be best to block minors from posting, so they would have read only access. If you do allow posts, then admin should be reading every post and deleting any inappropriate advice. The standard for inappropriate to minors is higher than it is to adults. A 14 year old does not have the same reasoning skills as an 18 year old. Laws have clearly established that as fact. There is a reason someone under the age of 18 can't sign a contract.
My third recommendation is to add a "Report Abuse" link at the bottom of every page. This isn't just to report abuse involving minors but also to report scammers and trolls.
These recommendations are to protect BP as much as it is to protect users.
How about too old? Senile old men? :)
Tulips Hysteria all over again - we are at the top of a market with a flattening yield curve. Not too many tools to use for the next recession. My two cents, don't talk to kids on the internet if you value your freedom, your time and money. They need to go to Big Brother or daycare. Unless they are emancipated and married they can't sign a contract.
But what if you start getting 10 year olds on here? Is that ok? Are you fine with getting some of those questions. If you don't put an age limit on it, that will eventually happen.
If you're concerned about somehow taking away their ability to learn, let them have access to view the forums and articles but just not be able to post. That would make the most sense to me.
Keeps the forums from getting unnecessary noise yet still allows young people the ability to learn from others.
@Mike H., That's a great idea. And adults ask all the same questions anyway.
Just imagine though the quality of the young person with the perserverance to sit on the side reading and learning for years and that they'll do when their voice is unleashed. That's an awesome thought!
Don't sell your children short folks. Use this to get involved with them. They'll amaze you with their ability and capacity.
As a practical matter even the existing age limit is unenforceable . How are the moderators to know the actual age of the person creating a profile ?
As a practical matter even the existing age limit is unenforceable . How are the moderators to know the actual age of the person creating a profile ?
Well when someone titles their post "14 years old looking to build capital" it becomes pretty obvious. Of course a child can lie about their age, but that is not an excuse to have no policy at all. Moderators have to trust what someone declares until they have reason to not trust it.
I think it's great to have those under 18 on the site if they're serious and respectful (that's where moderators come in). My own boys are 16 and 19 and very interested in building a RE portfolio. I love that they are focused on a future instead of just playing video games. BP is a great resource for our whole family. My two cents.
Federal law requires BP to remove anyone under an adult age from the website if they learn they are under age, like a user claiming they are in a thread or in a private chat.. otherwise they could land themselves in a big time lawsuit that they will lose. For example Children's Online Privacy Protection Rule ("COPPA"), required anyone under the age of 13 has to have their parents in on the process. BP has give their parents a 2nd account to monitor the other account so they block access, see chats, etc. BP also has to get IDs, watch chats logs themselves, etc... Why you think Facebook banned anyone under the age of 18. It's a real PITA to develop into your backend.
To all,
I never mentioned that anyone should be banned for being a certain age. Maybe the title was a little misleading, some understood like @Joe Splitrock & other members.
The idea of having age Limits or age requirements was so BP can better manage minors accounts on BP. As I stated I don't believe Minors should be looking for Mentors on BP or any Internet forums, there are places where Mentors can be found for minors I mentioned these places on original Post. Like it or not by reading their posts these young members are looking for Mentorship and Guidance, this should not be the place for that. I'm all for having everyone access to all research materials in BP, Blogs and even being able to read forums but minors shouldn't post in forums is my opinion. A minor can be taken advantage of looking for mentorship, thats the point I was trying to make.
I wasn't expecting a response from Mindy & Scott.. I most sound like an old Landlord that doesn't like Kids. I'm only in my late 30's, I don't think I'm that old :)
Maybe if I gave you a little insight about myself you will better understand where I'm coming from.
When my kids were younger I was a head coach for my son for 3seasons, & 1 as an Assistant Coach and for my Daughter I was a head coach for 1 year. Oh Boy, coaching Pre-Teen girls was an experience.. In my brief not so Glorious Coaching Career I developed a great appreciation and respect for Teachers and people involve in Youth Athletic, referees, Coaches, assistant you name it. I also learned Mentoring Youth should only be left for certain individuals, it takes a certain person to be able to Mentor our Youth.
Fast forward to 2017, now my daughter is a Freshman in College and riding the NYC subway everyday to go to school to Dad's horror. Unfortunately as @Shiloh Lundahl reminded me I don't even have 4 Properties in my Portfolio so I'm no Rich Dad just a newbie (No hard feelings Shiloh, I see your Post as being Positive gives me more of a reason to kick *** in 2018 in NC, NC better be ready an Investor from the Bronx has more motivation now) . So I need my day job and can't drive my daughter to school everyday so she can avoid the Unique People she encounters in our Wonderful Transit System. I have a great relationship w my daughter, she tells me everything (or just about everything) and feels me in with her encounters on Subway, they are rare but they do happen. I won't go into details lets just say if I could take her to school with a baseball bat I would.. Yes I know now I sound like the crazy overprotective dad so be it...
With her experience I now see there are a lot of creeps everywhere, maybe I'm seeing the World a little differently now.
BP is becoming "bigger", a wise Uncle once said with Great Power Comes Great Responsibility. Unfortunately the bigger BP gets, the more trollers, the more scam artists and more Undesirable members will be joining our community, I wish that wasn't the case.
After writing my original post I came to a realization, I sound just like my Parents O.M.G the day finally came they warned me it would :)!!!
@Joe Splitrock on this thread are we talking about underage smoking, drinking, voting, getting credit cards, or signing contracts or are we talking about kids participating in forum discussions where the focus is learning about investing in real estate? I thought we were talking about real estate.
Joe, I want you to know that I agree with you. I don’t think that we should sell cigarettes to children (or anyone else for that matter I think that it is a nasty habit). I also don’t think that children under age should have voting rights. I think that they should study the candidates and understand the issues before making decisions on who they’re going to vote for. I also understand the importance of fully understanding a contract before someone enters into one. So I can accept having a legal age requirement in order to enter into a legal contract (although many individuals who do enter into contracts do not fully understand even though they are adults). As far as credit cards go, since when did the age raise from 18 to 21 to get a credit card?
Anyhow, the point remains that there shouldn’t be an age restriction on learning or gaining knowledge from others including adults even when you are a kid. This is my opinion.
@Account Closed , I have 100% respect for you in wanting to protect children from being taken advantage of. No one wants that.
This is a great community, but it is an online community and fake accounts will exist, along with criminals, despite our efforts to the contrary. This is a fact of life with virtually any major social network, and anyone with an email address can sign up for BiggerPockets. I think we do a great job here at moderating our forums, but that is no excuse to fail to use common sense and watch over your children's online behavior with strangers over the internet. Parents should not allow minors to join the community if they are unwilling to accept the responsibility of engaging in appropriate online behaviors and taking appropriate cautions, just as they would in joining any other online community such as facebook, linkedin, or reddit.
I believe other online communities in our industry (the social network industry) have age requirements of 13 or 14. I have no idea if that's the right age for allowing people to join social networks, just as I have no idea if the age to give teens the ability to drive a missile (car) down the street at high speeds is 16, or if a 19 year-old has the worldview to vote for the men and women who will lead the country. I'm sure all of these ages are or were up for debate at some level. But 13/14 seems to be the norm in our industry, and I believe that privacy policy was written by our excellent legal counsel. At some point, I guess this is a rite of passage - accessing the internet's online communities and the freedom and responsibility that comes with that access.
I'm a 27-year-old man, I'm over 200 lbs and I play rugby in my spare time, and I do not meet strangers I meet on BiggerPockets or elsewhere online in places that are not public for my own safety. I believe that this is a staple precaution for any adult networking, and I don't understand why a minor would EVER meet someone they met online without their parents, really for any reason.
Again, I totally respect the thought of this thread. Just saying that I really don't think that BiggerPockets has a solution to this particular issue other than what Facebook, LinkedIn, and other larger, more well-capitalized businesses seem to be doing. I think it comes down to parental supervision, and diligence as a community to point out bad behavior as it appears. If you see an account of someone that is younger than 13, please let us know.
And, just throwing this out there, but I have a feeling that if we banned 14-year-olds from the site, or restricted their access, that they'd simply tell us they were 18+. Trying to block me as a 14-year-old from accessing the internet in the manner I wished was not a battle that anyone was going to win.
So bigger pockets is that new social network all the kids at school are talking about? Where you learn about self directed IRAs... sarcasm finished.
If you’re a kid and interested in this stuff, more power to you. You do get a lot of entertaining post but the content is what it is.
My 0.02 cents on advice:
Advice given by anyone is a subjective opinion. People are given advice everyday but it is up to the individual to filter the “good and bad” .
I'm not so sure there should be an age limit. I can tell you that when I was 14 I'd have loved if someone told me, "Hey kid. Wanna retire early?". I'm being partly facetious but I think you get my point.
"even for my 18 yo daughter I would feel uncomfortable for her meeting up someone from BP, maybe I’m old fashion"
As far as a safety concern for minors goes, there could be an age limit to attend BP meetups (or else have a guardian with them). Thought, statistically speaking, your children stand a far, far, far greater chance of being abducted or harmed by someone they already know than by strangers. I just dont think that real estate forums are the places where child predators come to look for victims.
You are simply fearful. This is understandable (and laudable, to an extent), but let's not call it anything other than what it is: fear.
@Joe Splitrock on this thread are we talking about underage smoking, drinking, voting, getting credit cards, or signing contracts or are we talking about kids participating in forum discussions where the focus is learning about investing in real estate? I thought we were talking about real estate.
Joe, I want you to know that I agree with you. I don’t think that we should sell cigarettes to children (or anyone else for that matter I think that it is a nasty habit). I also don’t think that children under age should have voting rights. I think that they should study the candidates and understand the issues before making decisions on who they’re going to vote for. I also understand the importance of fully understanding a contract before someone enters into one. So I can accept having a legal age requirement in order to enter into a legal contract (although many individuals who do enter into contracts do not fully understand even though they are adults). As far as credit cards go, since when did the age raise from 18 to 21 to get a credit card?
Anyhow, the point remains that there shouldn’t be an age restriction on learning or gaining knowledge from others including adults even when you are a kid. This is my opinion.
I don't think anyone is saying there should be an age restriction on learning or gaining knowledge. I just don't think anonymous adults should be giving advice directly to children. I also disagree with adults private messaging children they don't know. Maybe I am less trusting than you are. I read the advice people were giving the 14 year old in the other thread. I hope he has the maturity to understand the people giving advice could be unemployed losers living in their moms basement.
There should be an age limit. A few persons they are most likely adults trying to pull your leg.
Or get some GoFundMe $$$$.
I'm not so sure there should be an age limit. I can tell you that when I was 14 I'd have loved if someone told me, "Hey kid. Wanna retire early?". I'm being partly facetious but I think you get my point.
"even for my 18 yo daughter I would feel uncomfortable for her meeting up someone from BP, maybe I’m old fashion"
As far as a safety concern for minors goes, there could be an age limit to attend BP meetups (or else have a guardian with them). Thought, statistically speaking, your children stand a far, far, far greater chance of being abducted or harmed by someone they already know than by strangers. I just dont think that real estate forums are the places where child predators come to look for victims.
You are simply fearful. This is understandable (and laudable, to an extent), but let's not call it anything other than what it is: fear.
Statistically speaking most car accidents happen within 25 mile of your home. That is because the majority of driving is with 25 miles of your home. It isn't because the roads magically get safer at 26 miles away. Similarly, you are statistically more likely to be harmed by someone you know. That is only because the majority of our interaction is with people we already know. It isn't because strangers are safer.
Brett, if you want your kids private messaging and meeting up with strangers, that is your choice as a parent. It doesn't mean other parents are fearful if they want to put better safeguards in place for their children. It is called being responsible, not being fearful.
BP cannot police everything that is said on the site. Great & horrible advice is given out to people of all ages every day. If you over moderate you no longer have an open forum. It is up to the person receiving the info (or their parents?) to take it with a grain of salt. Lot's of info everywhere in the world. TV, NEWSPAPER, GOOGLE etc....Not all of it is good or objective.
Anybody watch the coverage on the same event on FOX NEWS & CNBC wildly different point of view of the same source material. Who is right? Who is wrong? It depends whom you agree with.
A couple of post by some kids...or adults pretending to be kids.....and people want to overreact and start some age policy? Kind of overkill don't you think?
If some younger kid truly wants to learn about this stuff....when 99% of kids that age would avoid this stuff like the plaque....then more power to them.
They cant enter legal contracts so no matter what they will need an adult to truly get into REI.
Predators?...... they are involved in dozens of social forums etc that pose a million times higher risk than on a REI website.
Just like any troll on here.....if you get some kid that is basically screwing around and causing issues, then block them and move on.... otherwise let them post. As adults we have to obligation to base our answers and comments with regard to their age
@Account Closed , I have 100% respect for you in wanting to protect children from being taken advantage of. No one wants that.
This is a great community, but it is an online community and fake accounts will exist, along with criminals, despite our efforts to the contrary. This is a fact of life with virtually any major social network, and anyone with an email address can sign up for BiggerPockets. I think we do a great job here at moderating our forums, but that is no excuse to fail to use common sense and watch over your children's online behavior with strangers over the internet. Parents should not allow minors to join the community if they are unwilling to accept the responsibility of engaging in appropriate online behaviors and taking appropriate cautions, just as they would in joining any other online community such as facebook, linkedin, or reddit.
I believe other online communities in our industry (the social network industry) have age requirements of 13 or 14. I have no idea if that's the right age for allowing people to join social networks, just as I have no idea if the age to give teens the ability to drive a missile (car) down the street at high speeds is 16, or if a 19 year-old has the worldview to vote for the men and women who will lead the country. I'm sure all of these ages are or were up for debate at some level. But 13/14 seems to be the norm in our industry, and I believe that privacy policy was written by our excellent legal counsel. At some point, I guess this is a rite of passage - accessing the internet's online communities and the freedom and responsibility that comes with that access.
I'm a 27-year-old man, I'm over 200 lbs and I play rugby in my spare time, and I do not meet strangers I meet on BiggerPockets or elsewhere online in places that are not public for my own safety. I believe that this is a staple precaution for any adult networking, and I don't understand why a minor would EVER meet someone they met online without their parents, really for any reason.
Again, I totally respect the thought of this thread. Just saying that I really don't think that BiggerPockets has a solution to this particular issue other than what Facebook, LinkedIn, and other larger, more well-capitalized businesses seem to be doing. I think it comes down to parental supervision, and diligence as a community to point out bad behavior as it appears. If you see an account of someone that is younger than 13, please let us know.
And, just throwing this out there, but I have a feeling that if we banned 14-year-olds from the site, or restricted their access, that they'd simply tell us they were 18+. Trying to block me as a 14-year-old from accessing the internet in the manner I wished was not a battle that anyone was going to win.
@Michael Kantar Believe it or not our opinions are very similar. Somehow the point I was trying to make got lost in the noise. I agree w Scott its great how you and your parents are on same page. You may not know this, not only is Scott a Rugby Player (Who gets injured often :) ), he is also a pretty cool author. You might want to ask your parents to check out his book.
@Scott Trench I really appreciate your comments, coming from you that means a lot. I see that you took the time to actually read my posts & even took the time to read Michael's post. This is a great Community, I find it so interesting that someone from Sioux Falls, Idaho & a guy from NYC has so many similar opinions and I got a feeling we both have very different backgrounds. Yes I'm aware many didn't agree with my post, but I got a feeling they didn't take the time to read my original & Second post and just read the title & whoever posted last. That's on me I did a poor job on title, its only my 2nd Discussion I started if I decide to do it again I'll spend a little extra time to make sure my title is clear for no misinterpretations. (For those not caught up, my discussion was specifically about Minors looking for mentors in BP not a discussion about Younger members being able to be in BP or being banned)
I took some time to review BP Privacy Policy that you provided. Yeah it is clear, and the Privacy Policy is well made.
You're right there's no quick or easy solution, if there was one I would PM you and Mindy right away with an answer but I don't have it.
Keep on writing books Scott, I look forward to your next one..
Have a Happy Thanksgiving!!!