California proposes additional 25% tax for flippers

California proposes additional 25% tax for flippers

Dan H.Pro Member
Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes

There is a bill proposed by Chris Ward district 78 called the California Housing Speculation Act that proposes charging a 25% additional tax (an income surtax) on the profit (above the regular tax collected on the profit) if a home is sold within 3 years of purchase.  The bill's author believes that the flippers are driving up the price of homes by purchasing them instead of the end buyer and selling them at a profit.

I am not a flipper, but I believe that flippers revitalize the properties while end buyers mostly do not. Without flippers, neighborhoods would get old. flippers and BRRRR investors play a large role in gentifying an area. It is my experience that neighborhoods like flippers and BRRRR investors. They typically know the property is run down and appreciate the improvement to the area that is accomplished by the rehab.

In addition, the rehab/revitalization of a property involves work and has risk.  People deserve to be compensated for their work and any risk that they take.

If the politicians go after flippers what is to say they will not go after BRRRR investors next or even turnkey rental property providers? BRRRR investors rehab properties to extract money but it also leads to higher rents than if we rented the unit in its old, run-down state. In addition, the property is owned by an investor instead of owner-occupied buyer.

To me it is an attack on property investors. If they attack any form of property investor, recognize your form could be the next to be attacked.

It is my view the bill is short-sighted (similar to rent control rules) and proposed to provide the optics of trying to address the problem of rising property values and lack of affordability.  I suspect Chris Ward has minimal understanding of Real Estate and is proposing this primarily to obtain votes.  I doubt he really would desire the consequences of reduced flippers.

8Reply
186 views

Most Popular Reply

Joe SplitrockPro Member
Moderator
Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
4y

I am not really convinced that this tax will even hurt flippers. One of two things will likely happen:

1. Flippers will demand lower acquisition price on distressed properties.

2. Flippers will demand higher sales price on rehabbed properties.

So if this doesn't hurt flippers, it hurts sellers or buyers. Just like increasing taxes on corporations doesn't hurt corporations. It hurts share holders or raises prices for customers. I think people who propose these taxes have good intent, but don't fundamentally understand how business or the economy works. They believe taxing a flipper will drive flippers out of business or make more houses available to owner occupied. 

@Seth Young people can make a lot of money on fix and flip's in California, because of the high selling prices. You may rehab in middle America and pay $80K, then sell for $250K. In California you may pay $800K and sell for $1.5M. Even if the margin is lower in California, it is lower margin on a higher basis, so total profit dollars are much higher. Even with all the problems CA has, their housing market is exceptional. 

See this reply in the discussion

33 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Peter MckernanBusiness Member
    Residential Real Estate Agent · Irvine, CA · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    I agree with a lot of the above, the owner occupied and all owners will get hurt. The forced appreciation of the housing in the area, the example I have for you on this one is that there is a property listed in an area of Airbnbs (I marketed it as a perfect Airbnb property to STR or vacation rental later down the road, live in, or do STR right away). The neighbors put up signs all around the house in every window shot that you look out that state "neighbors are suppose to live here, this is not for short term rentals." That scared away a lot of people and also goes to show that this pushes their value of their home/equity down instead of up if they are just getting normal homeowners. This would happen with flippers stopping their business in CA, it would drop a lot of the comps, home values (not all of them) a good amount of them and the appreciation would not be as grand as it would if they stayed around and continued their pursuit of the real estate hustle.

    The McKernan Group4.957 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · El Paso, TX · Member since 2018 · 82 posts · 49 votes
    4y

    I'm not a CA resident but get taxed on RE investments in CA and while I agree the medium state income tax may be low, it doesn't take much to exceed the median income in CA due to the high population. What I have noticed is that CA is very good at nickel and diming you to death and taxing income that is exempt at the federal level such as Opportunity Zones. This bill is typical of how CA tries to get another nickel out of a small subset somewhere. While the profits in CA are high, so is the headache....

  • Real Estate Agent · Anaheim, CA · Member since 2020 · 9 posts · 15 votes
    4y

    From the California Association of Realtors website:

    "C.A.R. is actively working to defeat two bills that will further harm property owners and exacerbate the state’s housing crisis: AB 1771 (Ward) and AB 2050 (Lee).

    C.A.R. strongly opposes to AB 1771 (Ward) which would unfairly penalize property owners with up to a 25 percent tax if a property is sold before seven years from its original date of purchase. C.A.R. has worked to put together a broad coalition in opposition to the bill including almost all sectors of the real estate industry.

    AB 1771 also does nothing to ensure that first-time or other home buyers are guaranteed access to homes, nor does it create more housing opportunities. Rather, the bill will cause unintended consequences for the market by reducing the number of homes available for sale – further depressing California’s ownership housing supply.

    In a time of record surplus, the state should not punish property owners simply for deciding to move due to unforeseen life events. C.A.R. strongly opposes this bill as it drives yet another wedge into bridging the wealth gap by reducing the opportunities for wealth creation and housing security.

    C.A.R. also opposes AB 2050 (Lee), which is basically a reintroduction of AB 854 (Lee). Enacted by the Legislature in 1985, and sponsored by C.A.R., the Ellis Act prohibits local government agencies from forcing property owners to continue operating their private properties as rental businesses. C.A.R. successfully defeated AB 854 (Lee) with the help of its members who responded to a Red Alert on the bill. It looks like we will be forced to now take on AB 2050, which like AB 854, weakens the Ellis Act by, among other things, forcing property owners to stay in the rental business for at least 5 years before seeking to use the Ellis Act to go out of business."

  • General Contractor · Palm Desert, CA · Member since 2016 · 197 posts · 79 votes
    4y

    Rent control, which is really the goal here, is really the most effective way, next to bombing, to destroy cities.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Will Barnard:
    Quote from @Bruce D. Kowal:

    How does this increase the supply of "affordable" housing?  It's just another tax.


     It doesn't, in fact, it will hurt it even more! If investor flippers stop doing flipping because of the tax, run down and outdated homes will sit longer and longer, less inventory will be for sale since even homeowners will need to sit on their homes for 7 years to avoid the taxation. Please step up and vote against this bill!


    first time home buyers cant get loans on homes that dont pass  FHA VA appraisal inspections  one little issue there.
  • Dan H.Pro Member
    OP
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Will Barnard:

     Well this is not accurate at all. Taking the counties you listed (and correcting San Jose to "Santa Clara" as there is no such thing as San Jose county), and adding in Alameda County which is so close to San Francisco as well as adding Sacramento county (our state capital should be included in this list), you get 23M in population of the total 39M in the state, therefore, these counties comprise of almost 60% of the entire state. Not a "fairly small" % at all. I do agree that your argument to the other poster claiming that CA has a lower state income tax than the median in the country was certainly wrong. CA has the highest by far at 13.3% with only Hawaii and New Jersey having double digit rates. Many CA residents are or have moved on due to the high taxes and frustrating political environment. That said, the population is not at all in danger of losing out as the total net only lost a tiny % for the first time recently and was dubbed "the great exodus" by the media. Those of us smart enough to use a calculator can determine that the media was just blowing smoke for their own self interests, nothing more.


    By small percentage, I was referring to the size (area), not the population.  I thought the big state suggested this.  The largest county by area of the ones you listed (San Diego) comes in at #9.   San Francisco is the smallest county in the state (#58).  imperial with average home of $300k comes in at #10.  Fresno with average home price not much higher than $300k come in at #6. 

    I also was not trying to be all inclusive on the expensive counties (Santa Barbara, etc).

    There are many areas in CA where homes can be purchased for $300k, but they are not the areas that we listed as expensive areas (and as you pointed out where a large percent of the people live).  It is a big state (I am referring to the area) and many locations (a large percentage of the state by area) have homes that can be purchased for $300k. 

  • Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y

    Here's a summary of recent actions on AB 1771.  You can read everything in detail here on the AAPL Website.

    On 4/14/22 a legal team from the American Association of Private Lenders met with Assemblymember Christopher Ward, author of the bill. He agreed the bill is flawed, but believes, “some action is better than no action and got this idea from (unnamed) other countries.” (???) He also agreed that investors who “add value to a property … should not be treated as a party that simply buys and resells shortly thereafter (Iike Zillow and Opendoor).”

    On 4/25/22 The bill was heard by the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation. Their analysis concluded it, “would remove inventory by encouraging homeowners to rent … rather than rehab and sell.” Significantly in my view, they recognized that rehabbers “add significant value to the market by making needed renovations and improvements that homeowners are ill-equipped to do.”

    As written, the bill appears to be DOA, but it could be rewritten by Assemblymember Ward, who said he wants to salvage it.

  • Real Estate Agent · Central Coast, CA · Member since 2022 · 110 posts · 58 votes
    4y

    Thanks for the follow up @Jeff S.!!!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.