Advice on best approach to sell a group of multifamily.

Advice on best approach to sell a group of multifamily.

Member since 2023 · 22 posts · 9 votes

I have 6 duplexes (12 doors) that I want to sell. They are clustered in a small neighborhood (a 2-block cul-de-sac street with two 1-block side cul-de-sac streets), duplexes are all same age, 2 repeating floor plans, very close in size, all require some degree of repair/renovation. The duplexes are all on the main street. The 6 duplexes comprise more than half of all the properties on that street, so we've been able to control, to a degree, the feel and look of the neighborhood (quiet, clean), set the rent rate for other rentals in the neighborhood, and negotiate maintenance and repairs by the number and proximity of properties. Other than two owner-occupied sfh, all other properties in the neighborhood are also rental duplexes.

The neighborhood is in a central area in Austin about 10 mins from downtown; until 5 years ago it was mainly warehouses and non-retail commercial. Since then, major employers have come in, there are new condos, townhouses and a smallish sfh neighborhood, new convenience stores, a handful of trendy restaurants and a new community college annex. No HOA and no restrictions on short-term rentals. At least 2 duplexes in the neighborhood are currently STRs/Midterm, charging around $3,900/ mon, and fully-renovated duplexes rent for $37,500/year/duplex. Property taxes are lower than similar properties in the area.

I understand the value all the above and I know that an investor would do well to buy all 6 properties to take full advantage of the "economy of scale" opportunity, type of property, convenience of proximity and growing location. Of course, I would like to simplify my life and sell them as a group but i also want to get the best $$ for them. There is current duplex listed (not mine) at mid $500s and recently sold duplexes in the high $400s in neighborhood/area.

One realtor proposed selling the properties "auction style" whereby offers are received for 2 days and then sold to highest bidder, but holding a reserve price. Im not convinced. I'd love to hear other ideas and your advice, please.

2Reply
426 views

Most Popular Reply

Jordan MoorheadBusiness Member
Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2015 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
3mo

Selling them as a package is probably not your best option. I don't want to be too dramatic but don't take advice from anyone who hasn't done this before and isn't operating in the current Austin market. Don't sell them auction style either.

We're down 20-25% from the peak. Most everything that's sold doesn't cashflow with long term rents and frankly hasn't for many years. Investors generally want to at least break even while they hold for upside and someone buying a portfolio will be wanting to rent these long term which won't work at the market values because unfortunately rents are also depressed right now.

What's going to net you the most @Greta Clav is selling each of them individually, ideally with one unit of each duplex either vacant or MTM so an owner occupant buyer can buy them. They'll be able to get in there with a low down payment and get creative with STR, MTR or roommates to make the numbers work.

Otherwise if you just want to press the easy button I represent the largest duplex buyer in Austin. He pays cash, closes in a week and makes it really easy. He doesn't pay the highest price but it sure is easy. He has faith in the long term potential of Austin as I do and is buying as many as he can to hold long term.

Austin is in a rough spot right now with prices down, rents down, interest rates high and high property taxes to boot but my bet is that within 5-10 years we're going to be in a really good spot. We have an enormous amount of development and business moving this way because we let people build! Unfortunately we let them build so much that they oversupplied the housing market, but it will be back.

See this reply in the discussion

12 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Joseph CacciapagliaBusiness Member
    Lender · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3mo

    I'm in San Antonio, not Austin, so our markets are probably a little bit different. If I were selling multiple duplexes here, and I didn't need them all sold immediately, I would list them 1 at a time, and only when one unit was vacant in the duplex currently being listed. Right now the highest paying buyers are house hackers. There is a pretty decent spread in FHA and conventional investor rates, so they're able to outbid most investors today.

    My team recently listed a duplex with a vacant unit that sold within days, but has a similar price/quality one that has been sitting on the market for a while that's fully occupied. Almost all the inquiries we receive ask when one of the units will be available for a buyer/occupant.

    I've worked on a lot of portfolio sales of residential properties over the years, and I've always been disappointed when comparing the outcome to selling off properties individually. The universe of buyers who can pick up all 6 at once is just so much smaller than that of owner occupants. If you have the time, one by one would be how I'd do it. You can also cherry pick the first one, so you can set a strong comp for the rest.

    Joseph Cacciapaglia powered by Morty
  • Member since 2023 · 22 posts · 9 votes
    3mo

    Thank you for your insight, Joseph. I am not in a big hurry, I would just like to have them all sold before the end of this year. I've considered the one by one strategy you mention, and glad to hear this may be a better option. I had not considered "house hackers" and in anticipation of putting the properties on the market, I have them all vacant. The advice was that new landlords don't want to inherit tenants. How do you see the interest from house hackers on vacant duplexes? Also, do house hackers typically look for rent ready, fixer-uppers, full renovation....or would that be mainly investors?

    • Joseph CacciapagliaBusiness Member
      Lender · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Greta Clav:

      Thank you for your insight, Joseph. I am not in a big hurry, I would just like to have them all sold before the end of this year. I've considered the one by one strategy you mention, and glad to hear this may be a better option. I had not considered "house hackers" and in anticipation of putting the properties on the market, I have them all vacant. The advice was that new landlords don't want to inherit tenants. How do you see the interest from house hackers on vacant duplexes? Also, do house hackers typically look for rent ready, fixer-uppers, full renovation....or would that be mainly investors?


      They're primarily looking for their side to be move in ready, and I've found that most prefer to have a tenant in place on the other side. This gives them the widest options on the financing side, and makes it easiest to use rent to help them qualify for the loan, if necessary. When I'm selling single family homes, I prefer them to be vacant, but I believe half full duplexes are the ideal. If I saw 6 vacant duplexes on one street, it might make me a little worried as a buyer.

      Joseph Cacciapaglia powered by Morty
    • Member since 2023 · 22 posts · 9 votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Joseph Cacciapaglia:
      Quote from @Greta Clav:

      Thank you for your insight, Joseph. I am not in a big hurry, I would just like to have them all sold before the end of this year. I've considered the one by one strategy you mention, and glad to hear this may be a better option. I had not considered "house hackers" and in anticipation of putting the properties on the market, I have them all vacant. The advice was that new landlords don't want to inherit tenants. How do you see the interest from house hackers on vacant duplexes? Also, do house hackers typically look for rent ready, fixer-uppers, full renovation....or would that be mainly investors?


      They're primarily looking for their side to be move in ready, and I've found that most prefer to have a tenant in place on the other side. This gives them the widest options on the financing side, and makes it easiest to use rent to help them qualify for the loan, if necessary. When I'm selling single family homes, I prefer them to be vacant, but I believe half full duplexes are the ideal. If I saw 6 vacant duplexes on one street, it might make me a little worried as a buyer.


       I intentionally moved tenants out in prepping to put the properties on the market. At this point, it would not make sense to get new tenants, which may not be appealing to house hackers but may be ideal for an investor that wants to make changes right away rather than waiting for long-term lease to end. 

  • Lender · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2026 · 55 posts · 17 votes
    3mo

    This is an interesting portfolio. I’m not sure I’d jump straight to the auction approach either.

    One thing I’d want to understand first is whether selling all six together actually produces the highest total value. The operational efficiencies you described are absolutely valuable to an investor, but a buyer taking down the entire portfolio may also expect a bulk discount.

    I’d be curious to compare three scenarios: selling individually, selling the six as one portfolio, and potentially offering them in smaller packages while giving buyers the option to bid on the entire portfolio.

    I'd also put together a very clear package showing current rents, market rents after renovation, renovation needs by property, taxes, insurance, historical expenses, and the potential STR/MTR opportunity. The fact that you control more than half the street and the properties are clustered together is a pretty unique part of the story.

    Before deciding on the sales method, I’d want to see which strategy produces the best net result—not necessarily just the highest offer on any one property.

    Very curious what you ultimately decide to do with these.

    • Member since 2023 · 22 posts · 9 votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Claudia Rodriguez:

      This is an interesting portfolio. I’m not sure I’d jump straight to the auction approach either.

      One thing I’d want to understand first is whether selling all six together actually produces the highest total value. The operational efficiencies you described are absolutely valuable to an investor, but a buyer taking down the entire portfolio may also expect a bulk discount.

      I’d be curious to compare three scenarios: selling individually, selling the six as one portfolio, and potentially offering them in smaller packages while giving buyers the option to bid on the entire portfolio.

      I'd also put together a very clear package showing current rents, market rents after renovation, renovation needs by property, taxes, insurance, historical expenses, and the potential STR/MTR opportunity. The fact that you control more than half the street and the properties are clustered together is a pretty unique part of the story.

      Before deciding on the sales method, I’d want to see which strategy produces the best net result—not necessarily just the highest offer on any one property.

      Very curious what you ultimately decide to do with these.

      Thank you, Claudia. Yes, exactly, I am ultimately looking for best overall result, which to me, includes the element of time-saving in selling them all together or in smaller groupings, even if i don't get the net $$ that I might if sold individually. Another strategy proposed to me was to list the best one first and allow its sale to set the comp for the rest of them which would be offered as a package. 
  • G. Brian DavisPro Member
    Investor · Hatboro, PA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 905 votes
    3mo

    I'd probably try selling them as a package first. There aren't many opportunities to buy 12 doors all in one place, and for the right investor, that's worth something. It's a lot easier to manage than having the same number of units scattered across a city.I'd also think about who your buyer is. Someone looking to add one duplex probably isn't your buyer, but an investor trying to grow a portfolio might see a lot more value in buying all six together. I'd at least see what kind of interest you get before deciding to split them up.

    • Member since 2023 · 22 posts · 9 votes
      3mo
      Quote from @G. Brian Davis:

      I'd probably try selling them as a package first. There aren't many opportunities to buy 12 doors all in one place, and for the right investor, that's worth something. It's a lot easier to manage than having the same number of units scattered across a city.I'd also think about who your buyer is. Someone looking to add one duplex probably isn't your buyer, but an investor trying to grow a portfolio might see a lot more value in buying all six together. I'd at least see what kind of interest you get before deciding to split them up.

      Yes, exactly, my thought! This is a unique opportunity that does not come up very often with many upsides for the right investor. 
  • Jordan MoorheadBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2015 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3mo

    Selling them as a package is probably not your best option. I don't want to be too dramatic but don't take advice from anyone who hasn't done this before and isn't operating in the current Austin market. Don't sell them auction style either.

    We're down 20-25% from the peak. Most everything that's sold doesn't cashflow with long term rents and frankly hasn't for many years. Investors generally want to at least break even while they hold for upside and someone buying a portfolio will be wanting to rent these long term which won't work at the market values because unfortunately rents are also depressed right now.

    What's going to net you the most @Greta Clav is selling each of them individually, ideally with one unit of each duplex either vacant or MTM so an owner occupant buyer can buy them. They'll be able to get in there with a low down payment and get creative with STR, MTR or roommates to make the numbers work.

    Otherwise if you just want to press the easy button I represent the largest duplex buyer in Austin. He pays cash, closes in a week and makes it really easy. He doesn't pay the highest price but it sure is easy. He has faith in the long term potential of Austin as I do and is buying as many as he can to hold long term.

    Austin is in a rough spot right now with prices down, rents down, interest rates high and high property taxes to boot but my bet is that within 5-10 years we're going to be in a really good spot. We have an enormous amount of development and business moving this way because we let people build! Unfortunately we let them build so much that they oversupplied the housing market, but it will be back.

    • Member since 2023 · 22 posts · 9 votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Jordan Moorhead:

      Selling them as a package is probably not your best option. I don't want to be too dramatic but don't take advice from anyone who hasn't done this before and isn't operating in the current Austin market. Don't sell them auction style either.

      We're down 20-25% from the peak. Most everything that's sold doesn't cashflow with long term rents and frankly hasn't for many years. Investors generally want to at least break even while they hold for upside and someone buying a portfolio will be wanting to rent these long term which won't work at the market values because unfortunately rents are also depressed right now.

      What's going to net you the most @Greta Clav is selling each of them individually, ideally with one unit of each duplex either vacant or MTM so an owner occupant buyer can buy them. They'll be able to get in there with a low down payment and get creative with STR, MTR or roommates to make the numbers work.

      Otherwise if you just want to press the easy button I represent the largest duplex buyer in Austin. He pays cash, closes in a week and makes it really easy. He doesn't pay the highest price but it sure is easy. He has faith in the long term potential of Austin as I do and is buying as many as he can to hold long term.

      Austin is in a rough spot right now with prices down, rents down, interest rates high and high property taxes to boot but my bet is that within 5-10 years we're going to be in a really good spot. We have an enormous amount of development and business moving this way because we let people build! Unfortunately we let them build so much that they oversupplied the housing market, but it will be back.


       Thank you, Jordan. 

  • Real Estate Investor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2016 · 447 posts · 147 votes
    3mo

    @Greta Clav

    As a wholesaler, I would take this approach before committing to either sale. Figure out if you want 100% market rate or would you be ok with 70-75% or somewhere in-between. I believe joseph is correct, If you want as close to 100% market rate as you as possible, sell 1 by 1. That way you gain the comp to support your price along the way. But If you want to move all 6 and have some time on your hands You could probably looking for buyers on the county records to see who has the most property in your area cyberbackground check them and see if they would like to buy all of them.  

    • Member since 2023 · 22 posts · 9 votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Jamie Parker:

      @Greta Clav

      As a wholesaler, I would take this approach before committing to either sale. Figure out if you want 100% market rate or would you be ok with 70-75% or somewhere in-between. I believe joseph is correct, If you want as close to 100% market rate as you as possible, sell 1 by 1. That way you gain the comp to support your price along the way. But If you want to move all 6 and have some time on your hands You could probably looking for buyers on the county records to see who has the most property in your area cyberbackground check them and see if they would like to buy all of them.  

      I had not thought about that route to look up possible buyers. Thank you!
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.