What Kind of Returns Are you ACTUALLY Seeing?

What Kind of Returns Are you ACTUALLY Seeing?

Michael BlankPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Atlanta GA · Member since 2013 · 85 posts · 82 votes

So I've been looking for deals in the Washington DC, Baltimore and Richmond VA area, and I've spoken with a half a dozen other investors nationwide, and the theme seems to be the same:

NO ONE SEEMS TO BE FINDING ANY DEALS.

I have two questions:

1. My first question is, what kind of returns are you looking for in your deals? 

I'm syndicating my deals, so I will have investors involved. I am looking for deals with IRR's between 12% and 15% for the investors. (The 12% IRR for investors assumes they own 70% of the building and get no preferred rate of return, and the exit is in 5 years. To compare apples to apples, the IRR would be about 16% if I were to own the building 100% myself). I could theoretically achieve that kind of return by buying an 8 cap on actual financials as long as there is enough upside to achieve those returns.

But I'm just not getting into those kind of deals. I am being out bid by crazy money, I don't know where it's from and why they'll put up with lower returns.

For example, I'm negotiating a 46 unit (B- property) right now: the seller is asking for $2.1M, I'm offering $1.7M, the seller agreed to $2M and they're totally set on that number and won't consider holding a second. I can't pay any more than $1.8M to make my returns.

A 24 unit, C-Type Property in Baltimore, asking price is $1.2M, there are two offers at $1.0M but the bank is not budging from their asking price, my max price is $900K. At $1.2M the cap rate is 7.8% with a projected IRR of 6% (!!). Who is willing to pay that? On the other hand, at $900K, the IRR for the investors is 13% with a cap rate of just over 9% going in.

2. If you're doing deals, what kind of returns are you projecting for those deals?

I'd like to hear from people who are actually doing deals, and what kind of IRR you're projecting for those deals, and any info about these deals you're willing to share.

Thanks!

0Reply
111 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2014 · 158 posts · 100 votes
12y

@Giovanni Isaksen and @Michael Blank, I'm a commercial realtor down here in south florida specializing in Multifamily and income properties. I also wholesale a good number of the same property types. In general, if a property gets listed on MLS , LoopNet, CoStar etc then my experience is that it has already made the rounds amongst a lot of serious investors who have passed it up due to being overpriced. Most listed deals aren't really deals! You are correct, the foreign money coming into the USA is looking for a safe place to go, so they are not as concerned with high IRR, or cap rate. They're trying to preserve capital. As this thread demonstrates, we're in a seller's market in the Multifamily sector - it's tough to find the good buys, but selling them is easy.

My personal tips for finding the best Multifamily properties:

1. Direct mail - get to the sellers before they list

2. Build relationships with brokers who specialize in Multifamily, and then make it easy to do business with you

3. Drive the neighborhoods and call for rent signs

4. MOST IMPORTANT: Follow-up religiously with potential sellers. Most of my listings/wholesale deals are only realized after 6+ phone calls with the sellers, frequently months after first contact, so don't give up (that's what everyone else does!)

See this reply in the discussion

34 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2009 · 566 posts · 274 votes
    12y

    @Michael Blank 

    I feel you!  We are hitting that point in our cycle in a lot of markets (a lot of markets already hit it).  As the market builds confidence investors (some not all) are willing to accept a lower rate of return especially with the low cost of debt.  I think being deeply networked in the investment community is extremely important.  Buying listed deals especially foreclosures has become extremely difficult (too many eyes on the deal).  Like you mentioned you can only lower your parameters so much.  The deal needs to make sense.  Speculating on rent growth can put you in a bad situation especially with leverage.  

    We are starting to get to a point where new development in multi-families will make sense.  You're not going to get a high cap rate off the bat however if probably built (size, location & building) it can provide a strong durability of income stream.  

  • Investor · Round Rock, TX · Member since 2010 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    12y

    Who are you losing to? Are REITs buying product in your area? They have a lower cost of capital than you do so it is logical you are losing if you're trying to syndicate them and add a fee layer that others don't have. I stopped chasing apartments in Austin 4 or so years ago precisely for the reasons you're stating. Many experienced developers in Austin were having the same problem at the time and the market demanded to invest in other types of projects. Thus we moved to new development SFR projects instead.

  • Rental Property Investor · Phoenix/Lima, Arizona/OH · Member since 2012 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    12y

    I am sure as hell not getting anything.  My strike generally comes in 60%-70% of what things sell for.  I read your post @Michael Blank - relative to the IRR I don't know anyone who would think it's sexy to go in at anything less than 15% after the split. This means that deal IRR needs to be 19+...

    Who care about CAP Rate - we don't buy on CAP Rate...

    Good thread!

  • Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2014 · 332 posts · 288 votes
    12y

    We are still able to find 10% cash-on-cash returns on large multifamily in the Midwest.  Kansas City, Detroit suburbs, Tulsa, Omaha, etc. Much, much harder to do than a couple of years ago, but we are still buying at 6.5-7 cap rates and financing with Fannie/Freddie at 4.25% for 10 years with a couple/3 years of interest only. 

    Two years ago it was much easier to find deals than it is today.  We've had to stretch our "box" a bit, but with a lot of digging it can still be done.  

  • Homeowner · Elkridge, MD · Member since 2012 · 33 posts · 4 votes
    12y

    As a noob, what is IRR if I may ask?

  • Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2014 · 332 posts · 288 votes
    12y

    IRR = internal rate of return

    internal rate of return = discount rate that makes the net present value of all cash flows from a project equal to 0

    how it relates to real estate investing? think of cash-on-cash return as your yearly net cash flow and think of IRR as all your yearly net cash flows PLUS the profit you receive once you sell a project.

  • Residential Realtor · Leawood, KS · Member since 2014 · 47 posts · 13 votes
    12y

    The internal rate of return (IRR) is a rate of return used in capital budgeting to measure and compare the profitability of investments.The term internal refers to the fact that its calculation does not incorporate environmental factors (e.g., the interest rate or inflation).

  • Rental Property Investor · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2010 · 390 posts · 599 votes
    12y
    Great thread. As Ben Leybovich mentioned there is not much going. In fact I don't remember the last time I saw a deal that was marketed on actuals. Everything is a laughable cap on pro forma in complexs with inherent flaws (boilers, master metered, bad unit mix, def maintenance, etc etc. We purchased a 56 unit a few months back and it took it falling through w other buyers twice and a complex probate to finally motivate the seller. I purchased at around a 8% cap going in but the complex is class B with a lot of upside that we are already realizing. IRR is really a guesstimate using future variables and assumptions that do change. I'm looking at 15% cash on cash year 2 w conventional financing. 80% LTV 3.5% fixed 10 yrs 30 yr amortization. Not a homerun by any means but a great local and manageable buy and hold. Personally I don't think it's the time to buy large Multifamily.
  • Engineer · Richmond, VA · Member since 2014 · 14 posts · 6 votes
    12y

    @Michael Blank while I am by no means an accomplished real estate investor, I am a native of the Richmond, VA area.

    Richmond has always pushed to keep its buildings looking as historically accurate as possible.  In doing so, the city has created a lot of opportunities for historical tax credits.  This has encouraged a lot of affluent investors to invest in the Richmond area for the tax credits alone.  While I am speculating on your particular situation, I believe you may be seeing a lack of return due to the historical presence of cash buyers in the market seeking tax shelters and growing confidence in the real estate market as a whole; just some food for thought.

  • Real Estate Investor · Goshen, IN · Member since 2014 · 18 posts · 3 votes
    12y
    Our 12 unit in Indiana required 56k cash to close. We cleared 16k cash last year after all expenses including debt service, insurance, taxes, property mgmt, and repairs. Our loan in on a 15 yr repayment schedule. Our duplex and MHP are too new to have a full year actual income calculation, but things look quite similar. That said, I'm not finding many new prospects that compare.
  • Contractor · New York, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 12 votes
    12y

    We're hitting around 15% returns on a property I bought on Miami beach last year. An investor gave us 200k @ 5% interest only to park his money in the US for a share of the resale profits, so after paying him we're doing about $45k on 300k invested, and we're about to refinance out for $420k. Going to pay the investor $120k out of that and pocket the rest, which will bring down net cashflow to around $7000/year on $20k of remaining invested principal, so around 35% return on that?

    I am actually working on a new deal for $2m that should net me around 15% irr after renovating and repositioning. also have the ability to turn it into a "hotel" and almost double that irr.

  • Contractor · New York, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 12 votes
    12y

    IRR on property A is around 40% if everything keeps going smoothly.

  • Anthony GaydenPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Omaha, NE · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Serge S.:

    Great thread. As Ben Leybovich mentioned there is not much going. In fact I don't remember the last time I saw a deal that was marketed on actuals. Everything is a laughable cap on pro forma in complexs with inherent flaws (boilers, master metered, bad unit mix, def maintenance, etc etc.

     I have noticed the same in smaller multi-family as well. The buildings without the flaws are all extremely over priced. 

  • Investor · Bellingham, WA · Member since 2010 · 308 posts · 230 votes
    12y

    We're seeing two things at work in our markets, the first is that institutional buyers with a lower cost of capital are compressing cap rates even in markets they wouldn't touch a couple years ago and somehow other owners in those markets, even small ones think their properties are worth a premium cap rate.

    As a result our private equity and syndicators are looking at value add deals where there is a lot of work that needs to be done up front. We just took a run at one of the hairiest deals ever which I almost didn't show to my private equity client. Fannie was auctioning the note, owner was in bankruptcy and there was a Phase 2 on the property which was located in a market we wouldn't normally be looking in (smaller, not much growth). Ultimately the enviro issues/risks/costs were just unquantifiable so we passed.

    The other thing we see happening on the west coast and there's reportedly the same on the east is overseas flight money is paying up, in cash, for properties. These aren't investors in the true sense that they're looking for X return on their investment, they're really just getting their wealth out of their home market before the political winds change and in to ours which they consider more stable and where the rule of law is more entrenched. So we just keep digging and working our networks to find properties 'bad' enough to have the upside we need.

    If you think things are bad in the States though, have a look at Vancouver BC. I did a BP post on it here: http://www.biggerpockets.com/blogs/5055/blog_posts...

    The one upside is that if you're a long term holder and don't have investors who want their money back in 5 years you can buy things today that will work well over the next 20-30 years, especially if you can tie it up with long term fixed rate money.

  • Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2013 · 9 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Michael Blank, I'm 90% sure that this $1.2M 24-unit was the same deal I picked for my sample deal package (just getting started in multifamily, following advice from your podcast). $900k was the number I used too. If it is the same property then, apparently, it just went under contract. It chills me to think someone may have paid the asking price.

  • Michael BlankPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Atlanta GA · Member since 2013 · 85 posts · 82 votes
    12y

    @Sam Henry LOL! I'll have to ask the listing agent to see what it went for -;)

  • Michael BlankPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Atlanta GA · Member since 2013 · 85 posts · 82 votes
    12y

    @Giovanni Isaksen interesting about your comment about oversees money. I was approached by an oversees syndicator, and he was looking for a modest return in the US for his clients.

    Based on the feedback so far, it's tough all across the country to find good returns, and the only way to do is by finding value-add deals. Nothing new there I guess!

    For those of you syndicating the deals, what is the range of IRR (or returns in general) you feel you need to achieve for your investors to get deals done?

    I am getting a good response right around a 12% average annual return. Just note that these are friends & family and high net worth individuals, not sophisticated and/or institutional investors.

    How about you?

  • Real Estate Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2014 · 158 posts · 100 votes
    12y

    @Giovanni Isaksen and @Michael Blank, I'm a commercial realtor down here in south florida specializing in Multifamily and income properties. I also wholesale a good number of the same property types. In general, if a property gets listed on MLS , LoopNet, CoStar etc then my experience is that it has already made the rounds amongst a lot of serious investors who have passed it up due to being overpriced. Most listed deals aren't really deals! You are correct, the foreign money coming into the USA is looking for a safe place to go, so they are not as concerned with high IRR, or cap rate. They're trying to preserve capital. As this thread demonstrates, we're in a seller's market in the Multifamily sector - it's tough to find the good buys, but selling them is easy.

    My personal tips for finding the best Multifamily properties:

    1. Direct mail - get to the sellers before they list

    2. Build relationships with brokers who specialize in Multifamily, and then make it easy to do business with you

    3. Drive the neighborhoods and call for rent signs

    4. MOST IMPORTANT: Follow-up religiously with potential sellers. Most of my listings/wholesale deals are only realized after 6+ phone calls with the sellers, frequently months after first contact, so don't give up (that's what everyone else does!)

  • Investor · Bellingham, WA · Member since 2010 · 308 posts · 230 votes
    12y

    @Chris Kennedy  great point on #4, persistence pays off.

    @Michael Blank  we're seeing the same low to mid double digit unlevered IRRs be attractive to our clients' investors too. The trick for the clients will be executing to those returns on their value add strategies.

  • Plano, TX · Member since 2013 · 226 posts · 156 votes
    12y

    We bought a 32 unit in the DFW area Feb of 2014 at about an 8 cap. Projection for investors was 10-12% cash on cash, with a 100% return after sale at 5 years. After 4 months of operation, and a better idea of where rents can go, we're looking at 13-16% cash on cash, and an IRR after 5 years of around 22%.

    Same thing here though, everything I'm interested in won't allow me to keep projections conservative if I want to compete. 

  • Wholesaler · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 44 posts · 3 votes
    11y

    There are still a few good value add deals in and around the Midwest including the Chicagoland market but I have to search harder to find them.  Along with some marketing I find I have to be more creative with my prospecting.

  • New York City, NY · Member since 2014 · 8 posts · 5 votes
    10y

    @Sebastian B - Curious how the Miami Beach properties are doing now. How does everyone feel about returns now as opposed to two years ago?

  • Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2016 · 127 posts · 25 votes
    10y

    Sid, Miami Beach returns are not that great. Prices are high. I am sure there are some exceptions, but difficult to find.

  • Real Estate Agent · Miami, FL · Member since 2016 · 3 posts · 0 votes
    10y

    I can agree to that. Unless you can do short term rentals.

  • Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2015 · 283 posts · 128 votes
    10y

    Lots of comments but I vote for all those that question IRR as your basis for comparison. We syndicate properties all the time and when I get an investor that asks about IRR, I ask them what number they want and will adjust my projections accordingly. I know that sounds arrogant but the issue is that for real estate, IRR is a moving target.

    A vacant piece of land that has an annual negative cashflow for taxes insurance, etc.. could have the same IRR as a fully occupied rental project with positive cash on cash returns. The two are very different investments with different capital requirements, holding strategies, most importantly, exit strategies.

    For IRR to be meaningful, the properties being compared should be very similar in almost all respect. Real estate is seldom a generic investment. Two people doing the same deal might have very different returns. I would focus on selling your investors on the merits of the deal. Risk/Reward analysis are far more helpful and if you apply a sensitivity analysis to your IRR projections, you might find out what is more important to your investors, cashflow vs appreciation and the risk of each, which should help you determine a target for raising capital. I usually tell an investor that says he/she wants a 20% return that they must be willing to accept a risk that there is a 20% chance of losing money. I know that that is not a direct relationship but if you think that getting 1% on a CD means that there is a 1% chance you might lose, it put the whole risk/reward equation in perspective.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.