Advice on Specific Performance for Breach of Real Estate Contract

Advice on Specific Performance for Breach of Real Estate Contract

Member since 2019 · 37 posts · 16 votes

In October 2024, I began searching for a property in Colorado but couldn't find anything suitable on the MLS. Exploring alternative options, I inquired about a property that was listed for rent. I reached out to the agent representing the property to see if the owner might consider selling. The owner was open to the idea and outlined their terms and conditions.

After several weeks of negotiations, we reached an agreement, and the seller signed a binding contract. However, about eight days later, the seller informed me that they had "changed their mind" and no longer wanted to sell.

In the weeks that followed, the seller failed to provide the required documents, including HOA disclosures, the seller's disclosure, and other essential paperwork, all of which were due within specific timelines per the contract. This failure constitutes a breach of the agreement.

This property is truly unique and perfectly suited to my needs. I’ve sent the seller a demand letter, but instead of honoring the contract, they offered me money to walk away. I don’t want compensation; I want the property. Has anyone pursued legal action for specific performance in a similar situation? Any advice or insights into the process would be greatly appreciated.

0Reply
261 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
1y
Quote from @Ryan S.:
Quote from @Steve K.:

Did you use the state-approved contract/ a contract that addresses the remedy for breach of contract and specific performance? 

Thanks for your insight. That makes sense. This is a very frustrating situation. I really want this property for so many reasons and don't just want to just walk away.

Yes. I used a Colorado state-approved contract. The contract states the below: 

20.2.1. Specific Performance, Damages or Both. Buyer may elect to treat this Contract as canceled, in which case all Earnest Money received hereunder will be returned to Buyer and Buyer may recover such damages as may be proper. Alternatively, in addition to the per diem in § 17 (Possession) for failure of Seller to timely deliver possession of the Property after Closing occurs, Buyer may elect to treat this Contract as being in full force and effect and Buyer has the right to specific performance or damages, or both.

22. MEDIATION. If a dispute arises relating to this Contract (whether prior to or after Closing) and is not resolved, the parties must first proceed, in good faith, to mediation. Mediation is a process in which the parties meet with an impartial person who helps to resolve the dispute informally and confidentially. Mediators cannot impose binding decisions. Before any mediated settlement is binding, the parties to the dispute must agree to the settlement, in writing. The parties will jointly appoint an acceptable mediator and will share equally in the cost of such mediation. The obligation to mediate, unless otherwise agreed, will terminate if the entire dispute is not resolved within thirty days of the date written notice requesting mediation is delivered by one party to the other at that party’s last known address (physical or electronic as provided in § 26). Nothing in this Section prohibits either party from filing a lawsuit and recording a lis pendens affecting the Property, before or after the date of written notice requesting mediation. This Section will not alter any date in this Contract, unless otherwise agreed.








so you wont sue at this point you will go to mediation. 

U asked if anyone had done a specific performance.. And yes I have done one in 50 years in the industry.
Facts:

1. purchase contract and gave 50k up front to bring tax's current.
2. it was all cash no contingencies.
3. seller just goes dark no response to anything.
4. We put 100% of the purchase price per the contract into escrow 2 days before closing.
5. Close date comes and goes and still not a word from the seller.
6. I am now out 50k and have a few hundred grand sitting in escrow.
7. not willing to just walk from 50k if there was not this 50k I would have just moved on.
8. We sue
9. We win as seller is a no show in court
10. Judge still gives seller another 90 days to file appeal or whatever.
11. that time runs now title company wont insure until we give another 60 days.
12. judge signs order and the 60 days the title company starts to run.
13. We finally close with title insurance.
14. seller is holed up  its a massive hoarder situation as bad as I have ever seen.
15. another 6 months to get eviction.

so about 30 months later we finally take possession and bull doze house and built three new homes.  250k in out for 30 months  another 30k in legal fees..

Now this is with an uncontested legal action.. I suspect if someone contests could be longer.

I also think once you go to mediation this will get worked out pretty quick mediators if you get a good one do a nice job putting these deals together..
See this reply in the discussion

45 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Tom GimerBusiness Member
    DMV · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y

    You can't take an element from state X such as "uniqueness" and try to apply it in state Y where that appears not to even be part of the analysis.

    Let's see how this turns out.

    Gimer Law518 Reviews
  • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Tom Gimer:

    You can't take an element from state X such as "uniqueness" and try to apply it in state Y where that appears not to even be part of the analysis.

    Let's see how this turns out.


     Tom so you wouldn't be as concerned about that element? I defer to your expertise here. 

  • Member since 2019 · 37 posts · 16 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Tom Gimer:

    You can't take an element from state X such as "uniqueness" and try to apply it in state Y where that appears not to even be part of the analysis.

    Let's see how this turns out.

    Sorry, I don’t understand. May you please elaborate. 
  • Tom GimerBusiness Member
    DMV · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Steve K.:
    Quote from @Tom Gimer:

    You can't take an element from state X such as "uniqueness" and try to apply it in state Y where that appears not to even be part of the analysis.

    Let's see how this turns out.


     Tom so you wouldn't be as concerned about that element? I defer to your expertise here. 

    Does the contract include a monetary damages provision? Don’t know, haven’t read it. But given that it expressly includes a specific performance provision I would not be ignoring it… and neither would a judge or mediator.

    Real estate is unique by nature. People should stop applying sale of goods theories to it.  

    Gimer Law518 Reviews
  • Member since 2019 · 37 posts · 16 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Tom Gimer:
    Quote from @Steve K.:
    Quote from @Tom Gimer:

    You can't take an element from state X such as "uniqueness" and try to apply it in state Y where that appears not to even be part of the analysis.

    Let's see how this turns out.


     Tom so you wouldn't be as concerned about that element? I defer to your expertise here. 

    Does the contract include a monetary damages provision? Don’t know, haven’t read it. But given that it expressly includes a specific performance provision I would not be ignoring it… and neither would a judge or mediator.

    Real estate is unique by nature. People should stop applying sale of goods theories to it.  


    Got it. Contract says Buyer may elect to treat this Contract as being in full force and effect and Buyer has the right to specific performance or damages, or both.

  • Kristi KandelPro Member
    Developer · Fort Myers Beach, FL · Member since 2018 · 383 posts · 195 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Steve K.:

    I definitely see what you’re saying about the seller backing out being a violation of your good faith agreement, and what is the point of a contract if the seller can just change their mind… However in my experience most people do end up settling for monetary damages incurred rather than trying to force the sale.

    I have seen two cases where it went the distance and the buyers successfully sued for specific performance. The first was a $10M historic property in Downtown Denver that was truly unique due to its location and age. There are no other properties like it. The buyer had performed at closing, delivered funds to the title company, signed closing docs and everything. Seller decided to back out at the last moment for some arbitrary reason and just didn’t show up to closing to sign the docs. Closing funds were held in escrow, buyer decided to sue for SP. Eventually after about 3.5 years the buyer did prevail. I’m not sure who paid legal fees but they must have been significant.

     The second case was a commercial property (an 8 unit multifamily in a complex of 6 individual 8 unit buildings), owned by a group of investors. A developer had already worked out deals with the owners of the other 5 buildings and finally got the 6th and final building under contract. Some of the owners had wanted to sell and others didn’t. I believe the owners with the majority ownership share forced the others to sell, but they weren’t cooperating. They all had their own lawyers of course and it was a mess that took 3 years but eventually the buyer (the developer) did prevail. I think the key in that case was that the property was the last one needed in a large development of a group of blighted small MF buildings that were to be torn down and redeveloped. The building was vacant and completely rundown with the windows all smashed out by the end of the lawsuit. The owners were essentially slumlords. The buyers had invested a lot into the deal (~$100M) and purchasing the property was critical to complete their development.

    In almost every case involving vanilla SFH's that I've been privy to, buyer and seller have settled during mediation for monetary damages. In a few cases the buyer has moved forward trying to sue for specific performance but eventually gave up after about a year and around $30k spent on legal fees.

    The gamble is that the outcome hinges upon the courts discretion and it's rare to see specific performance unless buyer can demonstrate that monetary damages aren't enough to make them whole. As an investor looking to purchase an STR in a ski town, I'm not sure I'd feel that confident in a court deciding in my favor, personally. Seller might claim that the contract wasn't fair and equitable to begin with, or use stalling tactics, or they might say they need to move into the property because they are getting divorced/ lost their job/ need to move their ailing mother into the property, etc. and anything along those lines might make a judge more sympathetic to them than an investor buyer looking to turn the property into an STR.

    I’m also not quite convinced that the property is unique enough to justify specific performance because it is typically only enforced when there is a lack of other remedies such as monetary damages. For example the property being historical or a critical part of a large development plan. You could probably just go buy a different investment property and achieve the same returns. So that will be a tricky element to this IMO. 

    But I get where you’re coming from, it’s super lame when a seller backs out. Keep us posted on what your lawyer says if you can, let us know how it goes, and good luck. 

     @Steve K. awesome response. That covered pretty much everything! 

  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Tom Gimer:
    Quote from @Steve K.:
    Quote from @Tom Gimer:

    You can't take an element from state X such as "uniqueness" and try to apply it in state Y where that appears not to even be part of the analysis.

    Let's see how this turns out.


     Tom so you wouldn't be as concerned about that element? I defer to your expertise here. 

    Does the contract include a monetary damages provision? Don’t know, haven’t read it. But given that it expressly includes a specific performance provision I would not be ignoring it… and neither would a judge or mediator.

    Real estate is unique by nature. People should stop applying sale of goods theories to it.  


     My thought exactly.

  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    1y

    In my experience, a suit for specific enforcement of a real estate purchase contract is not particularly complex or fact intensive that would lead to extensive time needed for discovery.  Assuming the contract is valid, enforceable, and the buyer can prove (s)he was ready, willing and able to close, a summary judgment might be awarded granting the request.

    While every litigant has a right to appeal an adverse judgment, not every request for the appeals court to hear the matter will be granted.  They appellant must show the trial court made an error, either of law or procedure; an insufficiency of evidence; or an abuse of discretion.  If one of those can't be shown, the request for appeal may be denied or the court may hear the appeal and return a per curium affirmed (PCA) based simply on the briefs, both of which will shorten the length of time to conclusion.

    I looked at the CO promulgated real estate contract, and it has a provision that the prevailing party will be awarded their costs and expenses including attorney's fees, so the parties better be sure of the strength of their positions.

    If it were me, I'd probably push for mediation as soon as possible.  I've found that a good mediator will identify strengths and weakness for both parties and help them resolve their differences.  I would also ask my attorney about the advisability recording a copy of the contract or an affidavit of interest as I think it's possible the seller may have found someone willing to pay more for the property and I'd want a third party to be aware of my contract interest in the property.

    Lastly, I'd make sure the attorney I hired specializes in real property law, particularly in the county where the property lies.

  • Attorney · Northbrook, IL · Member since 2017 · 719 posts · 549 votes
    1y
    I don't know the laws in your area, but tread carefully assuming a judge will award specific performance when money damages are available.
  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Bob Floss II:
    I don't know the laws in your area, but tread carefully assuming a judge will award specific performance when money damages are available.

    Can you point me to a reported decision where a court ordered money damages in lieu of specific performance when real property was the subject of the dispute?

  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Bob Floss II:
    I don't know the laws in your area, but tread carefully assuming a judge will award specific performance when money damages are available.

     This has been my experience: 

    "As to the remedy plaintiffs seek, the case law reveals that "the equitable remedy of specific performance is routinely awarded in contract actions involving real property, on the premise that each parcel of real property is unique" (EMF Gen. Contr. Corp. v Bisbee, supra at 52). Although certain defenses do exist including, insofar as is relevant here, unreasonable hardship, " 'the court's discretion to grant or deny specific performance of a contract for the sale of realty is not unlimited; unless the court finds that granting a decree of specific performance would be a drastic or harsh remedy, or work injustice, the court must direct specific performance' " (id., quoting 91 NY Jur 2d, Real Property Sales and Exchanges § 204). Moreover, "[v]olitional unwillingness, as distinguished from good faith inability, to meet contractual obligations furnishes neither a ground for cancellation of the contract nor a defense against its specific performance" (Meisels v 1295 Union Equities Corp., 306 AD2d 144, 145 [2003]).  

    Richard D. Alba v Jean-claude Kaufmann :: 2006 :: New York Appellate Division, Third Department Decisions :: New York Case Law :: New York Law :: US Law :: Justia



  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Peter Walther:
    Quote from @Bob Floss II:
    I don't know the laws in your area, but tread carefully assuming a judge will award specific performance when money damages are available.

     This has been my experience: 

    "As to the remedy plaintiffs seek, the case law reveals that "the equitable remedy of specific performance is routinely awarded in contract actions involving real property, on the premise that each parcel of real property is unique" (EMF Gen. Contr. Corp. v Bisbee, supra at 52). Although certain defenses do exist including, insofar as is relevant here, unreasonable hardship, " 'the court's discretion to grant or deny specific performance of a contract for the sale of realty is not unlimited; unless the court finds that granting a decree of specific performance would be a drastic or harsh remedy, or work injustice, the court must direct specific performance' " (id., quoting 91 NY Jur 2d, Real Property Sales and Exchanges § 204). Moreover, "[v]olitional unwillingness, as distinguished from good faith inability, to meet contractual obligations furnishes neither a ground for cancellation of the contract nor a defense against its specific performance" (Meisels v 1295 Union Equities Corp., 306 AD2d 144, 145 [2003]).  

    Richard D. Alba v Jean-claude Kaufmann :: 2006 :: New York Appellate Division, Third Department Decisions :: New York Case Law :: New York Law :: US Law :: Justia




     This decision gives an excellent explanation of when specific performance might be denied.

    EMF Gen. Contr. Corp. v Bisbee (2004 NY Slip Op 02288)

  • Member since 2019 · 37 posts · 16 votes
    1y

    Thank you, everyone, for your advice! I wanted to provide an update on the status of my situation. I hired a litigator to review my position, and they concluded that we had a very strong case. The seller had attempted to buy me out of the deal but ultimately realized they had no legal grounds to back out. Thanks to my attorney’s efforts, the seller has backed down and has now agreed to proceed with the sale.

  • Shawn AckermanPro Member
    Real Estate Entrepreneur · Mid West, East Coast · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    @Ryan S. I am not sure about the RE laws in the market you are referring too however in the State of WI if there is a property a seller does not perform on contractually, before expiration we have our attorney draft a notice of interest into that property and file it with the county.  Whenever there is a search done on the property this notice will appear and need to be resolved prior to that sale.  I've done this a few times and it usually results in a monetary payout or the seller kills the next buyers deal.  I have yet to successfully close on a property that I've filed a notice on but i cements your presence. Now if a new buyer is ok with buying the property without a warranty deed then that is a different ball of wax. hope this helps man.

    All the best!

  • Attorney · Northbrook, IL · Member since 2017 · 719 posts · 549 votes
    1y

    @Shawn Ackerman @Ryan S. Sound advice. The title commitment has a section for insuring the seller has no other contracts on the property. If a seller tries to back out, you can record the contract on the property. It prevents the seller from trying to sell to a different buyer and the title company will catch it. 

  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Ryan S.:

    Thank you, everyone, for your advice! I wanted to provide an update on the status of my situation. I hired a litigator to review my position, and they concluded that we had a very strong case. The seller had attempted to buy me out of the deal but ultimately realized they had no legal grounds to back out. Thanks to my attorney’s efforts, the seller has backed down and has now agreed to proceed with the sale.


    Congratulations, I'm glad it's working out for you.  Did you find out why the seller wanted to back out?

  • Member since 2019 · 37 posts · 16 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Peter Walther:
    Quote from @Ryan S.:

    Thank you, everyone, for your advice! I wanted to provide an update on the status of my situation. I hired a litigator to review my position, and they concluded that we had a very strong case. The seller had attempted to buy me out of the deal but ultimately realized they had no legal grounds to back out. Thanks to my attorney’s efforts, the seller has backed down and has now agreed to proceed with the sale.


    Congratulations, I'm glad it's working out for you.  Did you find out why the seller wanted to back out?

    Sellers remorse.

  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Ryan S.:
    Quote from @Peter Walther:
    Quote from @Ryan S.:

    Thank you, everyone, for your advice! I wanted to provide an update on the status of my situation. I hired a litigator to review my position, and they concluded that we had a very strong case. The seller had attempted to buy me out of the deal but ultimately realized they had no legal grounds to back out. Thanks to my attorney’s efforts, the seller has backed down and has now agreed to proceed with the sale.


    Congratulations, I'm glad it's working out for you.  Did you find out why the seller wanted to back out?

    Sellers remorse.


     Err in haste, repent at leisure

  • Member since 2019 · 37 posts · 16 votes
    1y

    Just wanted to share the final outcome. I ended up having to retain legal counsel, and my attorney spoke directly with the seller’s attorney, making it clear that the seller had no legal way out and that I was prepared to sue for specific performance. Fortunately, the seller came to his senses and accepted that he was obligated to close. We officially closed on Friday.

    It was a nerve-wracking transaction, but I made it to the finish line. Thank you to everyone who offered advice and support along the way—much appreciated!

    • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Ryan S.:

      Just wanted to share the final outcome. I ended up having to retain legal counsel, and my attorney spoke directly with the seller’s attorney, making it clear that the seller had no legal way out and that I was prepared to sue for specific performance. Fortunately, the seller came to his senses and accepted that he was obligated to close. We officially closed on Friday.

      It was a nerve-wracking transaction, but I made it to the finish line. Thank you to everyone who offered advice and support along the way—much appreciated!

      Congratulations

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.