DSCR lender issue help!

DSCR lender issue help!

Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes

Hello BP family. Seasoned inventor here with a problem I never encountered before with DSCR lender. My current rental property was previously on the market for a short time after flipping it, as initially I hard a hard time selling it due to weather, timing and rates here in Delaware. Now the DSCR lender ordered an appraisal which came back favorable, however they will not use the appraised value, instead the lesser list price which is significantly lower than the appraised value, (I deliberately had it listed lower to attack buyers). The lesser list price throws off all the numbers, leaving me without a cash-out refinance, something I need to be able to brrrr.

My question is does anyone know of a lender that will use the appraised value only. If not I have to wait 6-12 months before the lender will use a new appraised value at that time, and I will loose time and money to BRRRR. 

“The lender will use the lesser of the appraised value or list price if the property was recently on the market.”


Any help would be appreciated!! Property is in Delaware. Seasoning isn’t an issue. Thank you in advance.

0Reply
543 views

Most Popular Reply

AJ ExnerPro Member
Lender · Springfield, MO · Member since 2023 · 664 posts · 320 votes
10mo

Hey Jay,

How much time has elapsed from taking it off market to now? I know a few that might want 30 days but would be fine at that point. 

See this reply in the discussion

23 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • AJ ExnerPro Member
    Lender · Springfield, MO · Member since 2023 · 664 posts · 320 votes
    10mo

    Hey Jay,

    How much time has elapsed from taking it off market to now? I know a few that might want 30 days but would be fine at that point. 

    • Jake YuskaitisBusiness Member
      Lender · New Jersey, USA · Member since 2022 · 254 posts · 68 votes
      10mo
      Quote from @AJ Exner:

      Hey Jay,

      How much time has elapsed from taking it off market to now? I know a few that might want 30 days but would be fine at that point. 


       this is the right question

    • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
      9mo
      Quote from @AJ Exner:

      Hey Jay,

      How much time has elapsed from taking it off market to now? I know a few that might want 30 days but would be fine at that point. 


  • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
    10mo

    It was just taken off the market. This is the first time after completing a flip I put the home on the market, then changed directions to doing a DSCR. This house and market and timing etc.,had this direction go off course.

  • Brittany MinocchiBusiness Member
    Lender · Massillon, OH · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 486 votes
    10mo

    This is something that'll be lender specific, but you should have some options. I know of a couple that'll allow it, but not positive of the minimum length of time it has to be off market and/or whether they require a prepay. Sometimes they'll want at least a ~3 year prepay to dissuade you from listing it again and paying it off too early. 

    Brittany Minocchi - Barrett Financial Group, LLC520 Reviews
    View Page
  • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
    10mo

    Thank you for your input. Any information is useful. Does that lender ordinarily require 5/3 PPP anyway? In Delaware I noticed a few already ask for that. Thank you again !

    • Brittany MinocchiBusiness Member
      Lender · Massillon, OH · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 486 votes
      10mo
      Quote from @Jay Smith:

      Thank you for your input. Any information is useful. Does that lender ordinarily require 5/3 PPP anyway? In Delaware I noticed a few already ask for that. Thank you again !


      Not sure if this was for me or not, but figured I'd reply just in case - most lenders will price a DSCR out with a 5-year PPP as a default, just not states like OH and PA if they don't allow them. So I wouldn't say they necessarily require a PPP, but if you want to (or have to) buy it out, it gets expensive. Higher rate, points, or both. Just depends on what the borrower is looking for. That PPP will trigger if you refinance, sell, or make extra principal payments in some cases. So if you know you'll be selling, will want to refinance, etc then it may make sense to take a higher rate or points to buy it down or out completely. From my experience, most people stick with 3-5 years. 

      Brittany Minocchi - Barrett Financial Group, LLC520 Reviews
      View Page
  • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
    10mo

    Thank you for that. One lender told me they didn't have to add PPP, then the terms changed to include it. Lots of surprises with DSCR depending on the lender, but thank you as I do more flips than I do holds. Very lender specific!

  • Lender · Member since 2021 · 500 posts · 131 votes
    10mo
    Quote from @Jay Smith:

    Hello BP family. Seasoned inventor here with a problem I never encountered before with DSCR lender. My current rental property was previously on the market for a short time after flipping it, as initially I hard a hard time selling it due to weather, timing and rates here in Delaware. Now the DSCR lender ordered an appraisal which came back favorable, however they will not use the appraised value, instead the lesser list price which is significantly lower than the appraised value, (I deliberately had it listed lower to attack buyers). The lesser list price throws off all the numbers, leaving me without a cash-out refinance, something I need to be able to brrrr.

    My question is does anyone know of a lender that will use the appraised value only. If not I have to wait 6-12 months before the lender will use a new appraised value at that time, and I will loose time and money to BRRRR. 

    “The lender will use the lesser of the appraised value or list price if the property was recently on the market.”


    Any help would be appreciated!! Property is in Delaware. Seasoning isn’t an issue. Thank you in advance.

    Brittany and AJ gave great advice. Finding the right lender is the important part. Many lenders have begun to cap at lowest list price within a set timeframe. It always makes situations like yours tricky! Bummer that the current lender did not check on the front end, always a good thing to share when you’re getting future quotes. 

    Some options that will still do it though with a good appraisal and CDA to back the value!
  • Stacy RaskinBusiness Member
    Lender · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 533 votes
    10mo

    Many DSCR lenders will have minimum time periods that the listing will have to be be off the market regarding what value will be used-whether list price or appraised price for a cash out refinance. Prepayment penalties will vary- most states allow anywhere from 1 to 5 years (so a one year prepay, two year prepay, etc). As the prepayment window shortens, it will have more of an impact on the rate. DSCR loans aren't regulated in the same way as owner occupy conventional loans so possible to have surprises on anything and everything all the way up to closing the loan. It's important to work with a DSCR broker or lender that has a good reputation or you have worked with personally to avoid a DSCR lender doing one thing after saying another. If working with a mortgage broker that specializes in DSCR loans, it will help to connect you with more DSCR program options as different DSCR lender programs are not all identical. Happy to connect to discuss further.

  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    10mo

    @Jay Smith  I am not going to answer your question directly, but I do want to offer something else to consider. You mentioned that the home did not sell due to weather, timing, and interest rates. Are you confident that is the reason? What feedback did you receive from showings. 

    It is worth asking whether the market response was influenced by the condition or quality of the rehab itself. A few hundred dollar BRRR appraisal does not come close to the level of scrutiny a real buyer applies, and as a result there is often a meaningful gap between what a property appraises for and what it will actually sell for in an arm's length transaction.

    Many investors follow a different sequence than you did, where they refinance first and list later, only to discover that the appraised paper equity was never real. In your case, you may simply be receiving that market feedback earlier in the process. If that is even a possibility, it is worth asking whether taking on additional debt is truly in your best interest.  

    @Jay Smith

  • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
    10mo

    Thank you Stuart for your response. We actually didn’t get alot of showings because the weather has been very cold etc. The end strategy was to sell it immediately after the flip was completed, but then decided to rent it out instead. The few showings we have the feedback we did have was positive about the quality of the flip, one buyer’s feedback was that they weren’t ready to buy and just started their search, the other wanted a garage and we don’t have one. Nonetheless I’m left to figure this out as I will be keeping this as a long term rental. Thank you again 

  • Lender · Charleston, SC · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10mo

    If it was recently listed and is now being taken off market to rent, the vast majority of lenders are going to use the lower of appraised value vs recent listing price for several months after delisting, typically 3-6. Some lenders will not close a cashout refi at all until its been off market for 6 months. Too much risk right now between fraud and property values declining. Basically, lenders are very skeptical of the argument "no one would buy it at $X, but it's really worth more than $X so now I want to keep it."

    As for the PPP, you have the option to not have a PPP, but the lender is just going to frontload the PPP with points instead. The default for these loans is typically a 3-5 year PPP, as these mimic CRE loans with yield maintenance. It sounds like you are looking for more of a bridge loan to finance temporarily until you can relist in the future.

  • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
    10mo

    Thank you for your insight. This was a learning  experience for the future..

  • Erik EstradaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10mo
    Quote from @Jay Smith:

    Hello BP family. Seasoned inventor here with a problem I never encountered before with DSCR lender. My current rental property was previously on the market for a short time after flipping it, as initially I hard a hard time selling it due to weather, timing and rates here in Delaware. Now the DSCR lender ordered an appraisal which came back favorable, however they will not use the appraised value, instead the lesser list price which is significantly lower than the appraised value, (I deliberately had it listed lower to attack buyers). The lesser list price throws off all the numbers, leaving me without a cash-out refinance, something I need to be able to brrrr.

    My question is does anyone know of a lender that will use the appraised value only. If not I have to wait 6-12 months before the lender will use a new appraised value at that time, and I will loose time and money to BRRRR. 

    “The lender will use the lesser of the appraised value or list price if the property was recently on the market.”


    Any help would be appreciated!! Property is in Delaware. Seasoning isn’t an issue. Thank you in advance.


    This is something your loan officer could have easily caught by looking up the property and checking the listing history. Most DSCR lenders will go based on the lower of the two. There are lenders that will use only the appraised value or have a 90 day seasoning period to use the higher of the two, but you might be limited on the rate and terms.

    LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
  • Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2021 · 497 posts · 127 votes
    10mo

    Quick question — how long was the property listed, and was it fully renovated at the time it hit the MLS? I help investors navigate DSCR guidelines, and those two details can make a big difference in whether appraised value can be used.

  • Lender · Boston, MA · Member since 2021 · 125 posts · 64 votes
    10mo

    What's interesting is there are a handful of lenders who will just deny the loan if it's listed and the appraisal comes in over list.  Kiavi is one of them. 

  • Jake YuskaitisBusiness Member
    Lender · New Jersey, USA · Member since 2022 · 254 posts · 68 votes
    10mo

    yeah this is very common. think of the prior listing as another appraisal. 

  • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
    9mo

    Thank you AJ for your immediate assistance and guidance through this process. You and your team made it happen for me! 

  • Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2017 · 100 posts · 57 votes
    9mo

    Unfortunate set of circumstances. DSCR can feel like the wild west sometimes because different companies can offer different rules and guidelines. I say that when comparing these to your typical Fannie/Freddie loans which for the most part are more consistent (overlays do exist of course)

    Typically DSCR underwriters will flag this process because the original intent was to flip the house. Due to whatever circumstances, that was not the outcome. The market with real money spoke and the lender is not going to reward upside now based on an appraisal.

    In this case, the paper appraisal became worthless in their view.

  • Member since 2019 · 27 posts · 6 votes
    9mo

    Thank you for your reply. I was able to move forward with another lender who successfully completed the deal and accepted the appraisal. The experience was exceptional across the board—strong customer service, competitive rates, and full transparency. Most importantly, the final terms matched exactly what was originally quoted.DM me if you want there contacts.

  • Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2017 · 100 posts · 57 votes
    9mo

    Glad it worked out

  • Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 1 vote
    3d


    Thanks for sharing. Do you mind telling what did you do next?
    Were you able to get another lender? How much delay did it create?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.