Investor · Freeville, NY · Member since 2014 · 131 posts · 37 votes
I know your supposed to keep working and keep chugging forward but after 3 years of hearing "NO" from banks I am feeling really frustrated. How do you keep motivated to continue when continually getting denied. :(
Sounds like your asking for a banking product that does not exist.. at least for someone starting out.
I have lunch with my commercial banker at least once a month. and the banks are not looking for real estate loans per se.. they only bank VERY experienced cashed up borrowers that they know well.. they simply are not looking for new clients. This for fix and flip loans or construction loans.
if you want to buy rentals.. the post above gave you the guidelines and you use a national lender for those.. I see many many folks get that financing every week.. VERY easy as long as you Actually qualify..
if you do not hit all those metrics IE credit score.. DTI income and LTV then there is plenty of money out there if you do not meet all of those at all times then your not bankable until you do.
Interesting situation. There's no reason that the future of sustainability should not attract a lot of republicans. Right now, though, they are few and far between in this line of thought and investment strategy. I'm a liberal, tree-hugging, green investor, but I appreciate that the increase that we so DESPERATELY need in sustainability has to come from everyone. There are republicans in business starting to notice that you can make a lot in this sector. Don't market green measures as saving the planet, market them as ways to do good business. Save costs. Because you know that they do.
I was involved in a project with the business school at our university. Getting more businesses on board is a challenge. (Like banks) But it has to happen.
First, I want to say there are some completely fascinating elements to this story. It's a lot to ask, but I would be interested in a case-study type blog post. I'd leave nothing out - politics, sustainability, banks, construction, finance, and marketing.
Second, I am representing a buyer who is trying to pick up a very nice cash producing quad in an unincorporated area outside of Houston and being treated similarly by the banks. There is nothing unusual about this property, lots of upside, just no good comps in the area to support a value so the banks view it as too risky. They just told us that the week we were scheduled to close. I can see you running into this issue. It has been extremely frustrating for all parties.
James Klafehn Have you thought about crowdfunding through a site like FundRise? I would certainly invest in this project as an individual! Always keep your politics under wraps when working with investors, though. I, too, would be extremely reluctant to invest in a green project spearheaded by a Republican. I'm an Eisenhower Republican, but that gets confused with Trump Republicans and Romney Republicans, whose first name is mud these days.
I have Amy. I dont know if it would work though. I agree that its something that many people would support but I also think there would be a lot of people insulted because a "greedy landlord" was trying to grow his business.
I think @Jay Hinrichs has the right answer - you have done something that's outside the lines, and no one wants to be in the position of holding that project should it come to pass that you default. Projects that don't conform to norms usually require private money, and there's usually a lot of private money invested in anything before it becomes mainstream enough to be funded by regulated financial institutions.
Your experience in landlording doesn't really matter here. Your experience building and operating other successful solar, sustainable pet-friendly communities is what matters. Banks don't want to know that you have done this once and made money. They want to know that if they had to absorb it, can someone else run it and make money? If they are going to fund it, they want to know if the model can be duplicated.
In order to find bank money, you have to see your project from the banker's point of view and figure out how to counteract their objections. On one-off projects, there are going to be a lot of objections, and you have to be honest and admit that a lot of those objections are reasonable and legitimate.
I think @Jay Hinrichs has the right answer - you have done something that's outside the lines, and no one wants to be in the position of holding that project should it come to pass that you default. Projects that don't conform to norms usually require private money, and there's usually a lot of private money invested in anything before it becomes mainstream enough to be funded by regulated financial institutions.
Your experience in landlording doesn't really matter here. Your experience building and operating other successful solar, sustainable pet-friendly communities is what matters. Banks don't want to know that you have done this once and made money. They want to know that if they had to absorb it, can someone else run it and make money? If they are going to fund it, they want to know if the model can be duplicated.
In order to find bank money, you have to see your project from the banker's point of view and figure out how to counteract their objections. On one-off projects, there are going to be a lot of objections, and you have to be honest and admit that a lot of those objections are reasonable and legitimate.
I'm sorry but that doesn't make any sense to me. Its an apartment community. Nothing different than what every other people own except I have a zero vacancy rate. It doesn't matter that there is a dog park and a passive solar duplex. It is 2 duplexes and anyone could manage it just like they do their own duplex. Its only special to the tenants who are in love with the idea. I dont think I asking for anything out of the ordinary from banks. They finance 2 and 4 unit houses all the time. My application for a HELOC on my owner occupied property is no different than if you had done it. My property just happens to have two houses on it. If anything they should be happy. If one burns down I still have another one haha.
I keep hearing people say, find a private lender. I have been trying to find one for 4 years now. If any of you know of a private lender who A. hasn't lent out all of their funds B. will do business in Central NY, let me know. Because so far Ive contacted 30+ people and haven't found anyone who can.
Also, I keep hearing that this is "outside of the box" from you guys. But look at any apartment complex, if it has multiple buildings the owners dont put each individual building on a separate parcel. No, its all one property. Granted they probably start with one huge loan and multiple investors but I havent found that yet. So I started with one.
I think @Jay Hinrichs has the right answer - you have done something that's outside the lines, and no one wants to be in the position of holding that project should it come to pass that you default. Projects that don't conform to norms usually require private money, and there's usually a lot of private money invested in anything before it becomes mainstream enough to be funded by regulated financial institutions.
Your experience in landlording doesn't really matter here. Your experience building and operating other successful solar, sustainable pet-friendly communities is what matters. Banks don't want to know that you have done this once and made money. They want to know that if they had to absorb it, can someone else run it and make money? If they are going to fund it, they want to know if the model can be duplicated.
In order to find bank money, you have to see your project from the banker's point of view and figure out how to counteract their objections. On one-off projects, there are going to be a lot of objections, and you have to be honest and admit that a lot of those objections are reasonable and legitimate.
I'm sorry but that doesn't make any sense to me. Its an apartment community. Nothing different than what every other people own except I have a zero vacancy rate. It doesn't matter that there is a dog park and a passive solar duplex. It is 2 duplexes and anyone could manage it just like they do their own duplex. Its only special to the tenants who are in love with the idea. I dont think I asking for anything out of the ordinary from banks. They finance 2 and 4 unit houses all the time. My application for a HELOC on my owner occupied property is no different than if you had done it. My property just happens to have two houses on it. If anything they should be happy. If one burns down I still have another one haha.
I keep hearing people say, find a private lender. I have been trying to find one for 4 years now. If any of you know of a private lender who A. hasn't lent out all of their funds B. will do business in Central NY, let me know. Because so far Ive contacted 30+ people and haven't found anyone who can.
It doesn't really make any difference if it doesn't make any sense to you. From your original post:
"I spoke with another bank and even convinced the VP and the mortgage originator to come out, check out the property, look over my figures, review my building plans etc. They didnt believe in my concept and didnt think it would work. (I am building a sustainable, pet friendly housing community that includes passive solar duplexes) They didnt believe that the passive solar construction would work or that it was worth the investment even though its a tried and true method and has been around for decades."
I make a couple of assumptions from this paragraph:
1. Your costs of construction are higher than a typical duplex because of your added concepts;
2. Your project is unique enough to call it a concept.
From the bank's perspective, unless they are going to sell the duplexes, do you think they care if the tenant has to pay $100 or $150 electric bills? Does the bank see space for a dog park as more added value than expanding the number of duplexes that can be absorbed on that property? Does the bank see the local market able to absorb more units if/when they loan you money to build more units?
I get that working with banks can be aggravating. The idea that they just don't want to loan money, however, is laughable - loaning money is the only real way they make any money. Go down and talk to any loan originator, and if he/she tells you that he hasn't made any loans this year I guarantee he/she is about to be fired or the bank is about to be liquidated.
Just because they don't like your project doesn't mean that there isn't any money out there. If it were me, I would either reinvent the project in such a way that the banks liked it, or pursue a different funding avenue if I had enough belief in the concept. Banks fund the wrong kinds of projects all the time, mostly because they like familiarity. Banks are not good at shifting with the economy or public perception; they follow those shifts. Maybe your project is totally kick-***, and you'll be laughing at the banks who turned you down in a couple of years. Or maybe you live in a dying area and the bankers that declined you will be thanking themselves that they followed the norms.
this is why I always use HELOC for new deals. As you own more properties the more HELOC you have. Don't need to go thru why you need to borrow money again. It is just there for you to tap at anytime.
this is why I always use HELOC for new deals. As you own more properties the more HELOC you have. Don't need to go thru why you need to borrow money again. It is just there for you to tap at anytime.
Exactly, that is why I have been trying so hard to get a HELOC for the past 2 years.
The previous poster was posting about old applications. I havent applied for a construction loan in years.
I'm getting tired of it too. I know my credit sucks but I can't even get a heloc (on my already paid off home); and hard lenders say no credit but then they still want to run it only to still reject anyways :( ... suggestions? please! anyone...
Our commercial lender really, really cares about the dscr (annual noi / 1st year P&I). They require at least 1.25 to consider the deal. What is the DSCR for the deal?
@James Klafehn instead of financing that requires a DTI, research lenders who do not require DTI but a DSCR. These are mostly private lenders. Yes, the interest rate will be slightly higher. So, crunch the numbers to determine if the financing will work for you.
I would pay off the credit cards with a commercial mortgage if a HELOC or residential mortgage is not obtainable. Otherwise you could go into credit counseling and have the cards paid off within 5 years.
Have you tried getting a loan for the building but without the extras you wanted? That way you get the majority of the funds to build the building. The extra dog park and solar you could add on latter with your own funds or some other way.
I talked to an electrician once and he made it sound like for an extra 1k he could run the basic feed for the solar add on and cap it until the money for solar panels was available. That way you are not tearing up your newly built building to add new wires.
@James Klafehn, You gotta kiss a lot of frogs.... It's a stretch but reach out and talk to the folks at Babcock Ranch Florida. It's being billed as Americas first self sustaining solar city. Talk about out of the box thinking!!! They may know someone or be someone you could work with.
Find out exactly why all banks denied you and make change/improvement. If you credit is not good, go fix it. If the deal is not good enough, move to the next one. Banks want to lend money out, but to the right borrower and deals. Good luck.
Ithaca and their devout hatred of Republicans... I feel your pain.
I'm not sure if you can mention here specific names (in fact I think you can't), but I'm wondering who you've tried to work with already? I'm an agent here and I know of some great resources and maybe even a private investor or two. I'll send you a PM!