Separate LLC vs One LLC

Separate LLC vs One LLC

Riverview, FL · Member since 2016 · 53 posts · 18 votes

Trying to find an article about putting each rental property into a separate LLCs or putting a group of rental properties into one LLC.

Just looking for pros/cons of each approach.  I've heard there are differing opinions from a legal and tax side.

I know this has probably been discussed ad nauseum so a link to a forum discussion or a formal article/blog post.

Thanks

0Reply
305 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
8y

IN my mind this all boils down to what kind of assets you have … if your just have vanilla rentals and your not a slumlord what is your risk.. and insurance is far more important than how you hold title.

most people have never been in litigation .. so for some reason they just think hey your sued and going to end up in court.. it is extremely rare for anyone to end up in court.. there just is not that amount of liability renting out little pink houses to renters.. 

but irrevocable trusts I believe offer protection and same with charitable remainder trusts.. but just having LLC no matter where its formed.. the opposing council will sue you personally that I can flat guarantee.. they wont say HEY this guy is smart he has multiple entities so we cant sue him or her.. NO he will sue all the entities and you and usually our wife personally.. then you will spend thousands in motions in liminee and still probably not win since its going to be apparent those are your assets..

Not to mention as @Ned Carey  the cost of maintaining all these correctly becomes a drag on your cash flow.  Where this all makes sense is when you have multi members.. 

When we build our housing subdivisions we cant put all 30 houses in separate LLCs  we have one.... but what we do have is we pay 30k for a 10 year 1 million dollar liability policy so if we get sued we have the first million in legal fees for someone to go through before they get to our regular policy and then there is our general business umbrella for another monsters amount that is very cheap and you don't need to do anything but pay the fees annually.. 

See this reply in the discussion

50 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Costin I.:

    @Matthew Olszak can you please find the case and share the details of it with the rest of us? 

    But I'm willing to bet such case doesn't exist and your attorney has a direct interest in establishing individual LLC's (since his bottom line is impacted by the existence of Series-LLC).

    I'll ask for the case number. Maybe I misheard/misunderstood him. Here's some reading in the meantime: http://www.wallerlaw.com/portalresource/lookup/wos...

    What I gathered from their opinion is that we still don't know how a series LLC bankruptcy will play out. I've read several other articles stating the same. Why go from "unprotected" to "maybe protected" when "protected" is only a small amount more cost? And really if cost/fees are a factor in this decision for someone, its not likely that person has a high enough net worth to warrant these protections.

    BTW - this came from a top real estate attorney and cpa firm with extensive experience in asset protection for high net worth individuals - he's not going to recommend something overkill or inappropriate just to make an extra $300 bucks. I'm not an attorney, nor am I involved in a case like that, so I'm not trying to argue an opinion on how it will play out, simply tossing out what I've heard for someone else more-experienced to add to/discuss.

  • Rental Property Investor · Round Rock, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 971 votes
    8y

    @Matthew Olszak Thanks, I'll read that article. And I'll wait for the actual case details too - I have a Series-LLC and I'm very interested in it.

    Yes, there isn't much case law for the Series-LLC. But the Series-LLC are not a novel concept, the first one was formally introduced in the state of Delaware in 1996 - one can make the case the lack of cases is a testament to the strength of the Series-LLC.

    I doubt a top real estate attorney with extensive experience in asset protection for high net worth individuals will charge you only $300 for an LLC. It will be closer to 1K and above and is not only one time, but every time you'll need an LLC. So if I'm (hoping to) selling you a product and hope to do it repeatedly but I stand to lose you as a customer after the first sell of a similar competitor product, would you expect a glamorous review of that competitor product?

    I had similar doubts and faced the same misinformation before I made my decision to form a Series-LLC. I discussed with a constitutional law professor that contributed to the formation of Series-LLC Texas law - simply put, an attorney denigrating Series-LLC simply doesn't know what he's talking. The only caveat I'm aware is not all states have them and therefore, the impact on multi-state activities.

  • Investor · Rochester, NY · Member since 2017 · 206 posts · 175 votes
    8y

    I've always thought that multiple LLC's per property aren't necessary until those properties build enough equity, once that happens quick claim those properties into their own LLC's.

  • Investor · Savannah, GA · Member since 2016 · 79 posts · 62 votes
    8y
    @Alan Davidson IMO it is much easier accounting wise to have one property per LLC, as long as the cost to maintain/renew each LLC is low (as it is in my state).
  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Kevin Ngo:
    Another question should be asked is the tax benefit of one per LLC vs. multiple in one LLC?

    No tax benefit. The IRS doesn't care about LLCs. Any properties you own are properties you own. Money they make is money you make. Can be in 1 LLC, 0 LLCs or 10000 LLCs.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Ned Carey:

    @Alan Davidson There is a cost to running and maintaining each LLC. This will in part depend on the state you are in. Some states the annual fees are very inexpensive some like CA I believe is $1,000 a year. MD is $300 a year. In addition to these costs you have the cost of accounting and separate tax returns, separate bank accounts and the time spent to keep everything else separate.

    In Texas at least, there is no extra fee if it's 1 or 100 LLCs.   I have about 50 and I don't use separate bank accounts, or have to do separate taxes (they all roll into my name), or any separate accounting.  My property management software keeps track of income/expense by property and that's what my tax guy uses.    People tend to think LLCs are much more than they are. 

  • Attorney · Nashville, TN · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    @Costin I.

    I don't have a dog in the Series-LLC debate but a lot of what you wrote goes way overboard:

    • No lawyer would argue that "lack of caselaw" is a "testament to the strength" of Series LLC. It's just a newer form of entity and many jurisdictions still haven't figured out what to do with it. Also, note that 1996 is very early from legal standards. For example, take a look at the history of plain-old LLCs. The IRS didn't really figure out what to do about it until the 90s.
    • Part of why many lawyers still recommend traditional LLCs over Series LLC has to do with the fact that the legal world is extremely risk-averse. That's especially true if the benefits for the risk are low. Let's say you're representing a large-scale investor. Everything that this investor purchase is $10+ million for the purchase price. The investor couldn't care less about incorporation costs since it's irrelevant --- even if the lawyers charged $10k per formation, it would be less than 0.1% of the deal size. In such a scenario, do you go with the tried-and-true option or do you go with something new? Most lawyers go with the tried-and-true option because they think the risk of trying something new is not worth it --- both for them and the client.
    • Following the above two points, you should note that most caselaw comes from institutional clients. For example, there are many "great" unanswered questions in Landlord-Tenant laws in Pennsylvania. This is not because it doesn't get litigated --- it's because most parties involved in these disputes don't have the means (or financial interest) in appealing the matter to the appellate courts. So until the "big boys" start using Series LLCs, it will likely not generate any meaningful caselaw for a while. 

    Again, I have no dog in this fight since Pennsylvania doesn't allow its formation yet. But Series LLCs are not some magical device. 

    Disclaimer: While I’m an attorney licensed to practice in PA, I’m not your attorney. What I wrote above does not create an attorney/client relationship between us. I wrote the above for informational purposes. Do not rely on it for legal advice. Always consult with your attorney before you rely on the above information.

  • Member since 2018 · 509 posts · 211 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Cody L.:
    Originally posted by @Ned Carey:

    @Alan Davidson There is a cost to running and maintaining each LLC. This will in part depend on the state you are in. Some states the annual fees are very inexpensive some like CA I believe is $1,000 a year. MD is $300 a year. In addition to these costs you have the cost of accounting and separate tax returns, separate bank accounts and the time spent to keep everything else separate.

    In Texas at least, there is no extra fee if it's 1 or 100 LLCs.   I have about 50 and I don't use separate bank accounts, or have to do separate taxes (they all roll into my name), or any separate accounting.  My property management software keeps track of income/expense by property and that's what my tax guy uses.    People tend to think LLCs are much more than they are. 

     Doesn't 50 llcs require 50 bank accounts? 

    Seems you have 1 llc. 

  • Member since 2018 · 509 posts · 211 votes
    8y

    My guy told me to put all personal actts unto an Llc. 

    Me personally is Broke. 

    My Llc is worth 2,ooo,ooo and untouchable. 

    My stocks n bonds don't drive drunk-they will never be sued. 

    Lots of paperwork though. 

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Eric Adobo:

     Doesn't 50 llcs require 50 bank accounts?  Seems you have 1 llc. 

    If I had 1 LLC I wouldn't say I had 50. I have exactly 1 operating back account. If I had a bank account for each property/LLC my life would be a nighmare. How I would I do payroll when may managers work over multiple properties? How would I buy my Home Depot stuff when we go and buy 10 HVAC units for stock for multiple properties? What bank account would my combined water bill come to?

    Just because you have several LLCs doesn't mean you have to have several bank accounts.   But wtf do I know  :)

  • Attorney · Austin, TX · Member since 2014 · 890 posts · 759 votes
    8y

    Overall, some solid advice.  A few points that I'm not sure where they got it from.

    • Insurance is your 1st line of defense, then entity.
    • Entities will not protect from gross negligence and require care/feeding (respecting the formalities).
    • Entities are state creatures, tax structures are federal creatures. Each state has its own laws.
    • Mostly determined by your tolerance for risk (10 small rentals v. a single 150-unit).
    • Segregate character of income (rental income from dealer income, etc).
    • Segregate by character of risk (landlord premise liability v. construction personal injury).
    • Segregate by participants (spouses v. unrelated 3rd party).
  • Member since 2018 · 509 posts · 211 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Cody L.:
    Originally posted by @Eric Adobo:

     Doesn't 50 llcs require 50 bank accounts?  Seems you have 1 llc. 

    If I had 1 LLC I wouldn't say I had 50. I have exactly 1 operating back account. If I had a bank account for each property/LLC my life would be a nighmare. How I would I do payroll when may managers work over multiple properties? How would I buy my Home Depot stuff when we go and buy 10 HVAC units for stock for multiple properties? What bank account would my combined water bill come to?

    Just because you have several LLCs doesn't mean you have to have several bank accounts.   But wtf do I know  :)

     Intermingling is a bad word in the world of Llc. 

    Your 1st Llc is connected to number 50 by use of using same bank account. 

    🌲 fall on boy in Llc.  number 1.boy can get assets in Llc 🔢 50.

    I'm asking. I don't know. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Round Rock, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 971 votes
    8y

    Thanks @Chris K. for bringing another perspective to the discussion.

    I agree with you on most points, I didn't claim the Series-LLC are magical, I just took issue with "a lawyer told me" mention (after all, "Q: How can you tell when a lawyer is lying? A: His lips are moving", j/k). And I would argue for small investors it makes a difference if the LLC costs you $300 vs $10K, and if it costs you every time you need one.

    Ultimately, there is no absolute answer and unique tool/strategy in anything real estate, including the various types of LLCs. You need to learn how and when to use all the tools available to you (financing, insurance, management, etc.) and to understand how they fit together in your toolbox, as none will give you everything (e.g, insurance is required and it will cover you for many situations, but not always; asset protection (LLC) is litigation insurance and complements regular insurance, by minimizing the target and making it unappealing).

    My main point - be wary of any professional who has an interest in selling you a specific product and not giving you options/information. Most of the time they will give advice that makes the most profit at the least risk for them, not for you.

  • Ronald RohdePro Member
    Attorney · Dallas, TX · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Leon Li:
    @Alan Davidson

    If it's out of state rental the LLC must be created in that state. If you buy everywhere that narrows your choices. Like mentioned above it's based on your risk tolerant. If you have 500k of equity among 4 houses and you put them in 1 LLC 1 law suit and it's all gone.

    Also theres huge benefit in term of taxes, the more LLC you have the more you spend the more expenses you right off.

    Theres also a better and common way to protecting your asset by having a parent LLC from Wyoming or Nevada owning all of your LLC, reason for that is those 2 states have tougher laws to penatrate during a lawsuit, but dont quote me on it.

    That's not precisely true, you may need to file a foreign certificate, but you don't need to form a local entity.

    Lots of good advice in this thread, lots of bad advice too. Good luck for anyone trying to build real estate instead of becoming a legal expert! 

  • Rental Property Investor · Bothell, WA · Member since 2018 · 76 posts · 37 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Ronald Rohde:
    Originally posted by @Leon Li:
    @Alan Davidson

    If it's out of state rental the LLC must be created in that state. If you buy everywhere that narrows your choices. Like mentioned above it's based on your risk tolerant. If you have 500k of equity among 4 houses and you put them in 1 LLC 1 law suit and it's all gone.

    Also theres huge benefit in term of taxes, the more LLC you have the more you spend the more expenses you right off.

    Theres also a better and common way to protecting your asset by having a parent LLC from Wyoming or Nevada owning all of your LLC, reason for that is those 2 states have tougher laws to penatrate during a lawsuit, but dont quote me on it.

    That's not precisely true, you may need to file a foreign certificate, but you don't need to form a local entity.

    Lots of good advice in this thread, lots of bad advice too. Good luck for anyone trying to build real estate instead of becoming a legal expert! 

    You are right, I should of worded differently and my opinion does not replace legal counsel. In my personal experience my lender has told me multiple times that this can not be done, I wanted an out of state property to my WA LLC. I was told most title companies will not allow you to transfer title into an LLC that is not qualified or formed in the state where the property is located. Confirmed the same information with my attorney as well.

  • Attorney · Nashville, TN · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    @Costin I.

    Understood. I would just point out a few items:

    • Assuming all the details stay the same, most attorneys won't charge the same amount for the same kind of work. I was using the $10k figure to stress a different point. But in most cases, an attorney would be able to create the same entity for around $500 or less including filing fees (that's what I and most other attorneys I know do for simple LLCs). 
    • If you change the nature of the operating agreement because you are adding additional parties, that changes the equation. But that's true whether you use Series LLCs or not.
    • I find this point interesting: I actually find a lot of "distasteful" pitches for Series LLCs. The pitch goes along the lines of "Yes, you have to pay more up front but thinking of the cost savings in the future" (or something along those lines). Some attorneys try to drag people from a different jurisdiction to set it up the underlying LLC in their jurisdiction. For example, an attorney licensed in Delaware may try to convince a client that intends to invest in Pennsylvania that they should open a Delaware Series LLCs for x, y, and z. In some cases, it's a legit strategy. In other cases, I personally find them to be a little scummy.

    Disclaimer: While I’m an attorney licensed to practice in PA, I’m not your attorney. What I wrote above does not create an attorney/client relationship between us. I wrote the above for informational purposes. Do not rely on it for legal advice. Always consult with your attorney before you rely on the above information.

  • Member since 2018 · 509 posts · 211 votes
    8y

     OOS llcS need to register in a foreign state to do business. Can do.

  • Ronald RohdePro Member
    Attorney · Dallas, TX · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Leon Li:
    Originally posted by @Ronald Rohde:
    Originally posted by @Leon Li:
    @Alan Davidson

    If it's out of state rental the LLC must be created in that state. If you buy everywhere that narrows your choices. Like mentioned above it's based on your risk tolerant. If you have 500k of equity among 4 houses and you put them in 1 LLC 1 law suit and it's all gone.

    Also theres huge benefit in term of taxes, the more LLC you have the more you spend the more expenses you right off.

    Theres also a better and common way to protecting your asset by having a parent LLC from Wyoming or Nevada owning all of your LLC, reason for that is those 2 states have tougher laws to penatrate during a lawsuit, but dont quote me on it.

    That's not precisely true, you may need to file a foreign certificate, but you don't need to form a local entity.

    Lots of good advice in this thread, lots of bad advice too. Good luck for anyone trying to build real estate instead of becoming a legal expert! 

    You are right, I should of worded differently and my opinion does not replace legal counsel. In my personal experience my lender has told me multiple times that this can not be done, I wanted an out of state property to my WA LLC. I was told most title companies will not allow you to transfer title into an LLC that is not qualified or formed in the state where the property is located. Confirmed the same information with my attorney as well.

     No problem, glad you got your advice sorted. All these threads are just a starting point anyway.

  • Investor · Dublin, CA · Member since 2016 · 344 posts · 228 votes
    8y

    @Kevin Ngo and @Alan Davidson Single LLC or Multi-LLC is decided by how much risk you can tolerate?

    There is no tax benefit going either way. LLC is for asset protection and IRS doesn't consider it as an entity. For IRS, single member LLC is a disregarded entity and multi-member LLC is a partnership. If you want to have an IRS approved entity then you can file your LLC taxes as S-corp.

  • Attorney · NJ · Member since 2018 · 120 posts · 58 votes
    8y

    Whether to use a single llc or multiple llcs depends on your asset protection and business strategy.  An llc is not something to use instead of insurance but with insurance to protect you as an investor and, for some, to separate your personal from professional.  From a tax perspective there usually is no difference.

  • Investor · Medford, MA · Member since 2017 · 56 posts · 27 votes
    8y
    @Ashish Acharya Not only risk tolerance but how much it costs. Some states it's $50 bucks to start an llc, which then would make sense to have one or two properties per llc. While in Mass it is $500, which is insane, and forces you to have multiple properties in one llc so the cost is spread over more properties.
  • Jerry W.Pro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Thermopolis, WY · Member since 2012 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y

    @Cody L., in my experience the fact that you don't have 50 bank accounts to go with your 50 LLCs might be cause to pierce the veil as no formalities of separateness have been followed.  I would suggest consulting with a local attorney for second opinion as laws vary from state to state.  Co mingling money is very likely to allow the veil to be pierced.  Your address is listed as being in CA it was my understanding the CA charges you 800 for every entity you have in another state if you live in CA.

  • Realtor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2018 · 184 posts · 71 votes
    8y
    He spoke the truth right there with his main point.  Went through a company in Nevada to open my first LLC.  Then they filed a foreign LLC license in CA.  Quickly, I come to find that with each time we communicate, they simply are trying to get me to bite on more services.  I've figured them out and have figured out the process for filing LLCs, which is much cheaper than what they charge.  Once I broke it down to them and they realized I knew, they still tried to sell me on services.  Like $200 for their fancy shmancy binder with operating agreement (received for 1st LLC filed through them, which is super generic, not even custom tailored to my business, no one from the company consulted with me during drafting the OA).  Along with that were generic minutes documents, membership certificates, etc.  All things which someone who is motivated can draft up themselves (IMO), kept internally and regularly maintain/update documents as business grows.  The company definitely got sour as they kept realizing they couldn't sell me anything more. (They were suppose to be "Compliance Coaches" offering guidance with anything related to my LLC.  That was far from the truth.  It felt as if I was at war with them when trying to grasp information about my LLC and how I should go about my current deal).  They offered to create a Partnership Agreement for $1,500!  I bet anything it would have been generic just as their operating agreement.  As we know, agreements are terms and conditions between multiple parties.  So, one could simply draft up a partnership agreement themselves with resources to ensure it's proper.  The reality of my situation in particular, I don't need any document for my partner and I.  There are relationships which simply you don't need to.  They exist in the real world.   All the documents that these companies are selling are for internal use and to ensure there is proper recordings/documentations of minutes/minutes/decisions/financials/ etc of the business, Right?  Correct me if I am wrong.  So I don't understand the point of hiring these companies to do this for you, who frankly have no idea about you, your partner or the deal.  Same thing for an attorney.  They basically are mediators between multiple parties.  You would meet with the attorney, partners and talk about what will be on the partnership agreement.  Right?  Well, why pay the attorney in that case?  I can get together with my partner, discuss what we will put in the agreement and sign the damn thing.  If it's just two people and the two people are in full compliance with one another, I don't see what the big issue is that majority seem to make such a case to hire a attorney to draft up your partnership agreement or hire someone to draft an operating agreement??  Even in today's world, we have all the information available.  I spoke to a local attorney, he asked me, "Do you know what attorney's get paid to do?  We get paid to do research."  And that research is nothing but case laws.  So there it is, spend some time doing research to educate yourself, I know I always am and wanting to connect with like minded individuals. 

    Originally posted by @Costin I.:

    Thanks @Chris K. for bringing another perspective to the discussion.

    My main point - be wary of any professional who has an interest in selling you a specific product and not giving you options/information. Most of the time they will give advice that makes the most profit at the least risk for them, not for you.

  • Attorney · Wilsonville, OR · Member since 2017 · 504 posts · 411 votes
    7y

    @Alan Davidson Do both with the same structure with a Series LLC and Land Trust.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.