Neighbor painted “my” trees, wants court

Neighbor painted “my” trees, wants court

Contractor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2018 · 432 posts · 221 votes

Hi BP,

So it’s time to put up a fence for our soon to be completed flip. My wife wanted to start working on it, but there’s a bunch of nasty bush/ trees blockin the property line and the existing fence only runs half way down the 75’ lot. I figured I’d do some branch clearing, pull a sting line and put a fence. Almost all the pathetic overgrown trees are growing from our supposed side of the existing fence, and leaning slightly to the neighbors side. Got the chain saw out and cut one little tree and heard the neighbor (live in landscaper not owner) yell and tell me to stop. I asked if they intended to redefine the existing fence line and he said not to touch another branch. Since in my mind the trees are mine, I told him ok, but thought I could smooth the discussion out with a string line for when the real home owner got home, so I cut one 2” branch that was in the way. He came out yelling etc and said I better not touch any more. He had said he was going to run the string line that day, but I figured it would be better I did, buy a branch was in the way of following the top of the fence. It’s very overgrown and was hard to find a way through with a string line. So I apologize and say I thought I was helping him out by running the string line since he’s handicapped and not given much time to live (approx 40yrs old). He is a live in landscaper, though married to another woman, he’s moved in with his new love and thy argue they’ll be there forever, so I better get a survey if I want to touch the trees. Earlier that day he said he might get kicked out and was already sleeping upstairs. When I cut the branch he calls friend and says “oh no, I’m not going to have a place to sleep this winter” to further dramatize. Homeowner gets off work and I see an opportunity to smooth this over since I don’t care about the trees or where the property line is. I just want fence and sale. He gets his phone out and starts saying I’ve been cutting branches on their side and that I’m going to be sued if I touch another branch. He also gave me his lawyers number and said I had caused his health to be upset or whatever. Now this whole time I’m not being tough or anything, just trying to smooth things over and communicate I’m not going to touch any branches at the moment. So now I’m stuck with having to get a survey which they tell me is going to cost $900. Called a couple places and that’s pretty accurate. Feeling the tension on my poor pregnant wife, I call a surveyor and schedule immediately and text the neighbor live in landscaper that I’m sorry if I’ve offended and that it’s scheduled asap . He responds with a legal response threatening court and with his lawyers #. Up until this point he’s always been friendly, though they moved into this house only 2 months ago. Now it seems they are living for the dispute and I’m concerned he’s trying to hook me into court somehow. Today, my wife texts me and says they’re out there doing something at the property line (4 days later). He came on our perceived side of the fence and painted big blue paint on all the trees on our side. (I’m guessing it’s not permanent). I go out and ask why he would do something so offensive and he responds because I cut branches and he doesn’t want to talk anymore. By the way, the homeowner has told him she doesn’t want to talk to me, even though I’ve never really met her. One more complicating factor is that the property in back cuts over 5’ so the lines aren’t straight, but according to the deed the measurements show me the trees are mine. Surveyor is supposed to show next week. I thought about calling the cops since he kind of graffiti’d on our trees, but I don’t know for sure if they’re ours and I wonder if these guys know something I don’t about the property line. The logical thing is to wait for the surveyor and then make the fence accordingly. If the paint is permanent and the trees are mine, what should I do? I’d like to file a police report, but I’m concerned this guy is looking for a way to take our $. What kind of things should I watch out for with a sue happy guy like this? Are most people like this full of hot air?

1Reply
330 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Malvern, PA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 939 votes
7y

You could tell him you have no need to talk with his attorney, but he can have his attorney call you if he needs to do so.  It's a psychological counter to his game, but also compels him to spend his own $$$ if he is serious.  Otherwise, he's just trying to scare you.

File a police report about the painted trees now.  That will promptly establish the evidence.  You can explain to the officer you believe they are on your property and have a survey happening imminently.  You may also want to add a harassment complaint to reduce the stress.  In PA, the police can issue a "do not contact" order to the other party that is supposed to keep them from even talking with you.  Violations can land them in front of a judge facing a criminal charge.

Consider filing a small claims lawsuit against the neighbor to clean or remove the trees if they are on your side.  My guess is it would be harder to sell a completely renovated home with blue painted trees.  It sounds like a settlement would be unlikely given the attitudes, but a judgement may eventually help you if there are assets you can access.

They have no case if the trees are on your property.  Get the survey as others wrote, put up the fence, file a police report to address the painted trees and move on in life.  The stress isn't worth it.

See this reply in the discussion

94 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Central, FL · Member since 2016 · 950 posts · 821 votes
    7y

    For the painted trees if you truly believe they are on your side, I would file a police report about it.  That way once the survey comes back you have it recorded with the police so you can then press charges and have proof for small claims court.  

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Nick Goodwin that’s what everyone is saying about hiring a fence company.. sounds like probably what I should do, but it’s so easy for me to build it, that I might just do it really quick.

    If you are fine dealing with what you know will inevitably happen, then do it.  I'd suggest having a couple of friends over to help, so it is even faster.  He might be less inclined to come out if there is a group of people. 

  • Specialist · New York City, NY · Member since 2019 · 34 posts · 111 votes
    7y

    As @Erik Baumer is saying, how do you know she doesn't want to talk to you?

    If he isn't the owner, it's very logical that he won't allow you to talk to the actual owner and will say she doesn't want to talk to you...

    It sounds like this guy is one of those who just need an ax to grind and an insecure ego with a need to assert himself as someone important...

    This guy can't sue you for something he is claiming you did to his property because it's simply not his property. The owner is the one who would have to initiate legal action if she has a problem with your actions.

    I would circumvent him and go straight to the owner. Until you actually speak to the owner, you don't really know if a lawsuit is a actually a real possibility. Maybe she doesn't even know what's going on in the first place.

    You shouldn't even be discussing it with him and tell him so because he isn't the owner.

    Just go behind his back and get through to the principal here first so we know were things actually stand here

  • Rental Property Investor · Amityville, NY · Member since 2018 · 351 posts · 441 votes
    7y

    @wy exactly

    @Jonathan Greer in my area its pretty clear to see where the property line is. If you have good idea of where it is just start cutting everything that is on your side.

    Go to the town and see if they have a survey on file so you dont have to order a new one.

    Not sure what the repercussions are of cutting some overgrown bushes down on the wrong s side but once it's done its done.

    People like this need to be confronted and put in their place.

  • Contractor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2018 · 432 posts · 221 votes
    7y

    @Eric C. I was mindful to have the survey done first, which I’m waiting for, then file a police report when I know exactly what’s up.

  • Contractor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2018 · 432 posts · 221 votes
    7y

    @Wy Kay very good points. Well, the owner was outside and shouted something off one day to the tune of “I’ve been gracious!” But she was in their yard as he was telling me she won’t talk to me when I came out to respectfully and considerately discuss the fence. Most homeowners can ask their neighbors if they want to pitch in! Good point on how he can’t sue for a property that’s not his. He’s trying to lay the case that I’ve caused him physical harm, since he’s undergone surgeries and only given a short period to live or something. Who would spend the last days of their life as a live in landscape boyfriend, fighting over bushes and fences. Some people need these little battles to feel alive and feel purpose

  • Contractor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2018 · 432 posts · 221 votes
    7y

    @Erik Baumer I did get the deed description which had measurements. I pulled them from the intersection street and it looks like all trees are mine according to that, yet the other neighbor looks like they set all their fence lines back 5’ which I think is what’s making it look like we have too much on our side. I’d almost rather not own the trees so I can just slap a fence in front of them, but that’s not very marketable if I do that and the trees are our responsibility. How would one trim them if they’re on the other side of the fence?

  • Multifamily Syndicator · Houston, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    WOW... Whoever thought that trees were this important and could cause such a big legal issue! 

  • Real Estate Agent · Virginia Beach, VA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    Just thought I'd add that even with surveys, there are disputes over property lines quite frequently, and surveyors can come up with different lines.  Our city does not record surveys, so no way to see previous ones unless the former owner provides a copy.  We had a survey done during settlement, and it was 2' less on one side then the survey left at the home by the previous owners (wish I'd had a copy of that to give to the surveyor).  I'm not a lawyer, no legal advice, but it's my understanding that once you have your survey done (and ask them to add extra markers so it's very clear where your land lies on that side), follow local fence codes, obtain permit if required, and plan to have materials ready to go and build fence same day (or weekend while city offices are closed) as you cut trees so neighbor has less chance to interfere.  Once it's built, I believe you have more rights to keep it, at least in our area, as neighbor would have to jump through many more hoops to try to force you to remove it, unless you didn't follow city requirements. 

  • Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 13 votes
    7y

    @Jonathan Greer I'd agree that you should have as little face to face time with these guys as possible. Let the surveyors do their thing before taking any additional steps. Any encounters you do have with them, take as detailed notes afterward as you can about what you said (which should be minimal) and what they said.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 112 posts · 38 votes
    7y

    @Jonathan Greer

    Omg! What an Total idiot I don't know if you're from out in LA I didn't read that but that sounds like something in LA but yeah if that tree ends up being on your side I would definitely file a graffiti report I had a woman throw a drink on my car because I couldn't get through a drive thru a bank window quick enough for her and I called the cops and they made her pay me for detailing my car or I could press charges so I would definitely report it that's vandalism To me it sounds like they're looking for pay day on your bank account I'm sorry my heart goes out to you guys I know what that feels like But like to hear the ending of this how it turns out

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 112 posts · 38 votes
    7y

    @Heath M.

    Just remember how people start out don't always end up the same personality I've seen it with tenants

  • Accountant · Santa Barbara, CA · Member since 2016 · 213 posts · 66 votes
    7y

    @Jonathan Greer in all honesty, they're just being asses. They made the mistake of threatening lawsuits (showing that they consider this to be the scary safty to heyyyyy what you want) just sue them and they'll back off. Might even settle

  • Specialist · Member since 2019 · 137 posts · 125 votes
    7y

    @Account Closed  I'm sorry you have to deal with this but my advice is to minimize & end all talk with the non-owner and physically be there when the survey takes place and take pictures/video of all the markers, etc.  I would also file a police report after I had crystal clear clarification from the survey results if they do anything further.  

    I understand you don't want to go to court but vexatious litigants are a problem for real estate investors.  According to the National Survey of Court Data (I have this if you want to read it) while 25% of Americans are sued in their lifetime, for real estate investors it rises to the astonishing rate of having a 95% change in the next 20 years.   This is not to scare you, but just let you know that paperwork and how you go about handling your real estate investment business is crucial for you to minimize your risk of exposure.  Document everything, keep a concise timeline and once the survey comes in I'd think about sending a certified letter to the owner of the property with the survey map, pictures & information in it that is drafted by an attorney that any interference on their part with your reasonable and lawful use of your land will not actionable on your part.  I'd also discuss with the attorney including an offer to allow the offending neighbor to buy the tree line that covers all your costs and is reasonable with what you'll be losing in terms of real estate with a hard deadline (but based on their behavior, I might not want to even give them that option, plus you may not want to do that at all as it might not be worth it.)

    I agree with your gut feeling that they are the type of people looking for a fight and trying to figure out if they can make some money off of you.   Sadly, this is not uncommon so just make sure to document everything and every interaction.   Hope this helps and good luck!  

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 112 posts · 38 votes
    7y

    @Ola Dantis

    Whenever you deal with humans look out anything is possible

  • Contractor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2018 · 432 posts · 221 votes
    7y

    @Ola Dantis I’ve got to find a way to post a photo of these trees on my Mobil. They’re so ugly and scragley!

  • Contractor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2018 · 432 posts · 221 votes
    7y

    @Lynn M. Great point. The survey company I hired actually did the surveys on the properties to the left and right and behind us 20 yrs or so ago. That should strengthen the position. Big fan of the weekend idea!

  • Investor · Riverside, CA · Member since 2014 · 239 posts · 177 votes
    7y

    @Jonathan Greer might be my mild anger issues but I’d be throwing every legal issue back at him with every inch of my would until the go crawling back licking their wounds. Buuut... the logical part of my says wait for the survey, and once you have it, put some earphones in and get to cutting everything in site you want cut. Why the earphone? To drown out all the crying and complaining you’ll hear from them. Tough Sh@t, they’re your trees.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Todd F.:

    @Jonathan Greer might be my mild anger issues but I’d be throwing every legal issue back at him with every inch of my would until the go crawling back licking their wounds. Buuut... the logical part of my says wait for the survey, and once you have it, put some earphones in and get to cutting everything in site you want cut. Why the earphone? To drown out all the crying and complaining you’ll hear from them. Tough Sh@t, they’re your trees. 

    having spent a decade in the timber business were standing Timber = Big $  normal SOP is to run cut lines  IE survey lines.. now not formal record of survey and if a tree was a line tree or questionable you might leave that one..  but in a residential setting. its as easy as surveying and placing your corners or usually finding the old corners identifying them then run a string line between the two points.. anything on your side of the string line you cut.. AS for painting your tree's I suspect that is a small claims court matter and you can see what the trier of fact would say about it or rule in your favor  I suppose they would and maybe since damages would be hard to ascertain maybe they give you max amount ??  in the old days in Timber country they used Blaze lines  these were hatchet chops into the base of the trees alternating left right and towards the center line.. Many many millions of acres of timber has been harvested with nothing more than blaze lines. 

    However if your proven to have cut over the line.. well established case law for 100 plus years its Treble damages.. value of the stumpage X 3 

  • Investor · Canton, GA · Member since 2014 · 728 posts · 501 votes
    7y

    You might see if the surveyor will just run the line in question. No need for a full survey. You could save you a few bucks.

  • John UnderwoodPro Member
    Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    7y

    Sound like you just need the surveyor to locate 2 corners. Maybe give you a discount?

    I'm looking forward to hearing more about how this story progresses.

    Once you have the property line marked you might want to have the police come by before you start cutting to "keep the peace"

    $900 is pricey they last one I did only cost $300.

    If you know approximately where the corners are, you should be able to find the metal markers with a metal detector if you could borrow or rent one.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @John Underwood:

    Sound like you just need the surveyor to locate 2 corners. Maybe give you a discount?

    I'm looking forward to hearing more about how this story progresses.

    Once you have the property line marked you might want to have the police come by before you start cutting to "keep the peace"

    $900 is pricey they last one I did only cost $300.

    If you know approximately where the corners are, you should be able to find the metal markers with a metal detector if you could borrow or rent one.

    good advice most properties the old pin and be found with a metal detector and a shovel..  

  • Investor · Clairemont, CA · Member since 2011 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @John Underwood:

    Sound like you just need the surveyor to locate 2 corners. Maybe give you a discount?

    I'm looking forward to hearing more about how this story progresses.

    Once you have the property line marked you might want to have the police come by before you start cutting to "keep the peace"

    $900 is pricey they last one I did only cost $300.

    If you know approximately where the corners are, you should be able to find the metal markers with a metal detector if you could borrow or rent one.

    This is a very regional thing as far as cost and level of detail ect. In FL where I invest and am from I get a survey for $350-$500 depending on the size ect. In CA where I do land use planning we use an outside surveyor but they run $2,000-$7,500+ depending on complexity. And no that's not a typo here in CA that's what it costs due to the 'type' of survey performed. And that wouldn't necessarily include re-setting monuments or line stakes ect.

  • Financial Advisor · Elmira, NY · Member since 2015 · 132 posts · 67 votes
    7y

    Family member had a similar situation about a decade ago - only they were never going to do the fence themselves, and it was the neighbor who was trimming trees up to the property line.  My relatives had to call the cops & go to court to get an injunction to get the neighbor to not interfere with the already-permitted fence construction.  Cops were happy to help, one of them had gone to high school with the difficult neighbor and had seen the movie before so to speak...

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2018 · 36 posts · 32 votes
    7y

    @Jonathan Greer

    Let us know what happens with the survey.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.