What is the best approach to deal with my debt?

What is the best approach to deal with my debt?

Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes

Like a lot of young people have done my wife and I have managed to place a lot of debt on top of ourselves, some of it good some of it bad. My wife is a teacher making 35000 a year. She is a 10 month employee so her paychecks come to 2800ish a month. I am active duty enlisted Air Force, e4 making 3200ish a month. Both of those are after taxes and include both off us putting about 200 a month into a retirement. I just graduated college and am focused on reducing debt and improving our financial situation.

The good:

We own two houses. One that we rent out and make about 550 a month cash flow past fixed expenses. The second we live in now and are going to move out after we have fulfilled the year va requirement for residency. I expect to make about 350 a month past fixed expenses on this one. We hit the year mark in February so I have already marketed the property and am generating interest to support this assumption. Both homes are on a va loan with interest rates less than 4.2%.

We have 6500 cash saved.

We both have 700 plus credit scores and have no negative history.

The bad:

My wife has 45000 in student loans. We have it set on income driven repayment on the 10 year plan where it is forgiven for public service since she is a teacher. Right now the payments are 0 and they qualify as payments. We are about a year into the 10 year plan.

I have 15000 in student loans from before I joined the military. They are not in repayment yet, I just graduated this month but they will be in a few months. I should be able to do the same 10 year plan. At some point though we will be required to make larger payments once her income is used because they use past taxes and she wasn’t working on those yet.

We have two car loans. One is 16000 and the payment is 307. The interest is 4%. Yes it’s a 6 year loan, yes I know that is to long. The car is probably worth 13-14000.

The other is 30,000, yes we were young and bought a brand new car and fully understand this was a bad decision. It’s payment is 470 yes it’s on 6 years too... and the car is probably only worth 21,000. Yes I know that’s bad.

We have about 6000 in credit card debt.

We have a 10,000 dollar personal loan that’s has a payment of 305 and will be paid off in June of 2020.

We make enough to make all payments and is we just continued as normal everything would pay itself off. I feel bad about

0Reply
101 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2013 · 451 posts · 369 votes
7y

You really need to check out Dave Ramsey, because you have every type of debt you possibly can and are living WAY above your means, even if you think you aren't. You should really tackle this debt before you get deeper into real estate, because if we hit a recession, which we probably will in a year or two, and a few things go wrong like you lose a tenant or two due to job loss, and your property values tank 20-30% ... you'll basically be on the verge of bankruptcy. How many months of vacancy to you withstand right now?

See this reply in the discussion

25 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    the post got to long.

    and we would be like the average middle class family. That is not my aspiration. I want to scale with rentals and plan to keep acquiring properties as time goes on. I am contemplating taking the time I was spending on school and getting a part time job to generate some extra income. I am also contemplating selling the smaller payment car and buying a junker. My wife isn’t so fond of either idea. She doesn’t want me to get a second job because of time. My job is steady In The air force 730-430 so I could maintain a set schedule normally for a part time job. She doesn’t want to sell the car because she thinks a junker might end up costing more per month if it breaks down etc.

    I don’t like the idea of selling the property we have equity in because it is a perfect rental and it’s located in the growing middle TN area and I think it will continue to climb in value and rent rates.

    We have curbed extra spending for the most part that led to the credit cards and personal loan. Also those are from before she worked because she was a full time student. So it was tough sticking to just my income at the time. That has now changed though and we are not creating more debt. Just trying to figure out the smartest way to expedite the process.

    I would appreciate honest opinions and options of how to enhance my situation while keeping a family balance because we also have two young children. Let me know if you need more specific information about something.

  • Real Estate Agent · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2013 · 451 posts · 369 votes
    7y

    You really need to check out Dave Ramsey, because you have every type of debt you possibly can and are living WAY above your means, even if you think you aren't. You should really tackle this debt before you get deeper into real estate, because if we hit a recession, which we probably will in a year or two, and a few things go wrong like you lose a tenant or two due to job loss, and your property values tank 20-30% ... you'll basically be on the verge of bankruptcy. How many months of vacancy to you withstand right now?

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    7y

    Time to take a serious look at adjusting your personal life style. You can not get ahead until you catch up and that will require a total rethink on your daily choices. Not a easy transition unless you are both committed to change. Your family balance will be impacted if you are serious about change.

    To begin both of you should be looking to change careers to increase your income. She can probably do better than teaching and the fact that you have graduated college will likely open doors outside of the military if you can get out.

    You have made bad decisions and now need to make the tough decisions you know are necessary. The big question is whether you are actually serious enough to do it.

    Credit cards, personal loans, vehicles and real estate. You are walking a tight rope without a safety net.

  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    @Gregory Hiban

    I agree and that’s why we are looking at our situation. Everything built up faster than we realized. I have enough to with stand 4 months of vacancy I am working to get that to 6 months. The property that has 550 cash flow also has about 35-40000 in equity and I have contemplated selling it to clean most of our slate. But don’t like the idea of loosing that property. Do I need to loose the property? Or try refinancing and pulling cash out to clean slate and keep rental but obviously with less cash flow?

  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    @Thomas S.

    I am working on commissioning and that would up my income quite a bit but it is a slow process. She wants to teach and isn’t interested in looking at other careers, we’ve talked about it before. I could always try to rehash that though. I am stuck in my enlistment until July of 2022 so it’s either commission or wait until then. That’s why I’m looking at part time jobs that I could do.

    Do you have any other specific ideas as far as getting a job or selling the cheaper car?

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Saint Paul, MN · Member since 2018 · 85 posts · 65 votes
    7y

    @Christopher Hall

    You have already taken a huge first step by acknowledging you have a problem with debt and taking steps to learn how to move forward. So congratulations there!

    I'm a SSgt in the Air National Guard (2W171!) so I can speak to some of the resources available to those who wear the uniform. Military OneSource has some great resources here: Link. I would also recommend asking around base, my base has a financial counselor who meets for free with our members on drill weekends. I would assume an active duty base would have the same!

    The BP money podcast is a great way to hear some inspiring stories and get some ideas if you're feeling discouraged. Dave Ramsey has helped a lot of people, so I'd recommend checking his stuff out as well. I don't want to give you an specific strategy advice as I am not a financial counselor myself, but reducing your cost of living and, if by any way possible, getting rid of those payments would help you out a bunch.

    Best of luck to you!

  • Rental Property Investor · Chubbuck, ID · Member since 2018 · 532 posts · 466 votes
    7y

    I would sell a car maybe both, live cheap, and snowball the debt. Sacrifice is the key. You are one emergency into financial ruin. you might stop your retirement for a year while take care of the debt. You might put the student loans on forbearance for now so you have more cash to pay some of the other debts off faster. I might consider selling a property as well since you have equity. You can pick another one up later with less risk on your balance sheet. You probably should get a second job if you don’t sell a property. It is only for a little while, not forever. I wouldn’t wait the 10 years for the loan forgiveness; you will pay your principal amount in interest anyway and the law might change by then. If you want to get ahead in life and become financially independent you must sacrifice now. Also make sure your wife understands what the risk you have from the consumer debt and get her on board. Finally you need to pay more attention to your finances and budget with your wife based on your comment that it just built up so fast without realizing it. Good luck and if you put in the effort you will be in good shape in a year or two.

  • Rental Property Investor · Chubbuck, ID · Member since 2018 · 532 posts · 466 votes
    7y

    Also I forgot to thank you for your service to our country!

  • Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2015 · 625 posts · 601 votes
    7y
    @Christopher Hall I would get my wife off income based repayment. That program is encouraging her to make as little as she can lol. She needs to earn. She is a teacher so there are opportunities to coach and tutor as well as summer school or even a job in a different industry for the months she has off. You guys are a team and if she is working to not make money and you are working to make more to pay your debts your going in the opposite direction. 10 years is a LONG time to try and make as little as possible.
  • Rental Property Investor · Maryville, TN · Member since 2018 · 80 posts · 53 votes
    7y

    @Christopher Hall I don't think you should get rid of the house that's cash flowing $550/month. That's a great chunk of change for net cash flow per month. I agree with the others, the Dave Ramsey Method of snowballing towards debt payments would be great in your situation. Are there any short term side hustles either of you two could pick up between now and the time you're able to get a renter in your current house? Maybe consider looking into a duplex as the next purchase so you can have a tenant in one side and you provide a place for yourselves to live, as well... if another property isn't on the horizon for 1-2 years... consider a very small apartment or even moving into a mobile home/RV for that time, rents are typically much lower and if you don't have a lot of stuff, it allows for simplified living.

    Good luck, keep us all posted as you continue!

  • Rental Property Investor · Northern, CA · Member since 2012 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    7y

    Personally, I wouldn't sell the rental.  Why would sell the only thing in this equation that's MAKING you money, just to pay off the things that are COSTING you money??  If you did that, my guess is you'd end up right back in debt within a year because you're not addressing the underlying problem (poor money management & living beyond your means). 

    The first thing you should do is change your spending habits and get those under control so you don't end up back in the same position.  That means making a budget and sticking to it.  The credit card debt is a clear indicator that you were living beyond your means and spending more than you make, so that needs to stop immediately because that is an expensive type of debt to carry and a huge waste of money.   Like @Gregory Hiban pointed out, listening to Dave Ramsey or possibly even going to his Financial Peace training may help in this area because it's the exact type of thing he talks about.

    Second, the car situation is a problem because you own two cars that you can't afford and it's going to be hard to get out of them (and one that you probably can't get out of at this point).  You don't say how much of the 6 year loan you have left on the cheaper car and to me that is relevant.  If the car is almost paid off and you only have a year or so left on the loan, I'd say keep the car and stick it out until it's paid off.  However, if you have a significant amount of time left (4+ years), I'd sell this car and buy a cheaper one with cash so that you don't have the monthly payment.  It doesn't have to be a "junker".  You can find an older Honda or something similar that's reliable and that you can afford with no car payment, and then use the extra money that you were paying on this car's monthly payment to pay down some of your other debt.

    Unfortunately you're in a bad position with the more expensive car because you can't afford to keep it but you also can't afford to sell it since you're so far upside down on the loan right now.

    But I'd do whatever I could to start chipping away at some of that other debt.  Maybe start with the smaller credit card debt, and then once that's paid off move on to the personal loan and pay that off.  It'll feel like a long, slow process but the sooner you start the better.  You didn't get into this position overnight and you won't get out of it overnight either.  Just focus on one goal at a time (like paying off the credit card debt) so it doesn't seem overwhelming, and make sure your wife is onboard because it'll definitely take both of you working on it together.

    Good luck.

  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    @Kyle J.

    We are about a year and a half into both car loans. I think we will sell the cheaper one and get as cheap of a reliable car we can. I agree that we are stuck in the more expensive car. I feel like we are near the point where we decide how our lives are going to be either fix it or we tune into the middle class consumer that always has debt. We are trying to be on the same team but there is always the conflicting opinions on how to do it. I have been looking at part time jobs to do but haven’t fully decided what would be best and be flexible with me being military.

  • Developer · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 902 votes
    7y

    I wouldn't sell any houses, it's not like getting that chunk of change today is do or die for you financially and you'll have a foreclosure or repo on your hands without the sale. Houses are expensive to purchase and cash flowing rentals are hard to find, so hang onto it. Definitely have water heater/new roof/vacancy money set aside for it though. 

    As far as your wife, I'd never advocate that you try and make her work more, change jobs, etc. If she's happy in her job and doesn't want to change jobs or get a part time job, so be it. Marriage is hard enough without trying to force something like that on your partner. 

    Financially, you're definitely a bit tight but it's not insurmountable and you're young. Many people never learn these lessons or don't learn them till much later in life and have dug themselves a hole so deep they can't see out of it. Pat yourself on the back, you're on the right path! Also, becoming an officer is a great move to increase your pay, very smart. I'm a military brat, my dad was 21 years in the USN, retired as an E-8. I saw the young guys on base get married, have kids, spend way more than they made, and never have a pot to piss in. Credit cards are a huge trap too. Hell my parents did all of those things and it wasn't until my dad retired and got a good paying job with the FHA and was drawing his military pension that they were even living comfortably. As far as I can remember they were paycheck to paycheck his entire military career. I'm very impressed that you're making these changes so young!

    Track your spending and try cutting as much fat as possible like starbucks, booze, work lunches out, dinners out, lower cell phone, plans, get rid of cable, etc. and pay down all your debt. Don't even think about further REI until you have your own finances in order. That's a house of cards waiting to crumble unless you can do some wholesaling here and there. My advice would be to get a second job but if it's going to cause marital strife, I wouldn't do it. Perhaps you can put a budget together and show your wife the hole you're in and explain how a year of part time work/side hustle would pay off?

    I don't disagree with your wife about clunker cars but you don't need the latest greatest either. I always hated having older cars in my younger years that broke down often. Too much stress! A few year old Honda Civic with 40k miles on it, purchased outright or with very cheap, low interest payments, would be a smart move. Run those payments out and get rid of those cars and, next go round, get cheap and reliable transportation. 

    Hope this helps and I commend you for even posting and asking for help. You're going to do well! 

  • Rental Property Investor · VT · Member since 2017 · 233 posts · 147 votes
    7y

    @Christopher Hall

    I didn't read the other responses, but I set up a profile of your debts in an example payoff plan.

    It shows your debts, and then the monthly payment for that debt.

    "Total Payments" is what you're able to pay every month towards debt (I did 3200 + 2333.33 (10 month salary over 12 months)) which was 5533.33 per month. I didn't include your 550 cash flow from the rental in this, as I assume that is what you would live on (might be too little, but I don't know) ---- adjust the numbers for how they would actually work for you (it's undebtit.com). You'd have to add if you have a mortgage if you do.

    Keep your savings as an emergency fund, and if/when you rent the 2nd place - add that to it and pay it off faster.

    Using this pay down method, you would pay off ALL of your debts (including the ENTIRE 45k loan that can be forgiven in 9 years) in 2 years.

    Don't need to sell the cars, don't need a second job, literally just don't blow your money and concentrate on debt payoff. You do need to follow a budget and not spend money you don't need to. You're not even close to being in trouble. Read "The Complete Money Makeover" by Dave Ramsey where he explains the "snowball debt  payoff method" -- or at least google it. That is what this chart is showing. 

    Cheers.

  • Member since 2018 · 17 posts · 8 votes
    7y

    I am sorry you're having to deal with financial stress. I am 17 years into the Air Force - happy to help a fellow Airman. You need to call your Airman and Family Readiness center (AFRC) and make an appointment with the financial advisor. It is completely free and a great benefit to have. Bring all of your financials with you and just down with an expert. They can help you create an individualized plan that will suite you and your wife's needs and goals. I would not recommend making a big choice like selling or keeping your property without sitting down with a pro. Additionally, and this is just my personal opinion, if you want to commission as an officer DO IT! There will always be a reason to talk yourself out of it...but you will not regret it. Try and try again. If your passed over...reapply, ask for advise to help your odds of acceptance...just don't give up. The quality of life that you can provide yourself and your family will be far better. Just my 2 cents. Good luck and let us know what the advisor says...I'm curious :)

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    7y

    Thoughts:

    1. Greetings fellow military man. I did my time years ago and got out at the end of my enlistment. 

    2. If you stay in you will be transferred. How will that work into your wife's profession as a teacher?

    3. How many miles are on the cars? At a certain point, you've already ate the depreciation and are only selling like for like. Cars are a losing proposition from day one so from a financial point of view the best you can do is the cheapest, most economical car you can get in terms of cost per mile (ownership+repairs+maintenance). *MOST* of the time, unless you have something that's a maintenance or operations nightmare (i.e. you're driving a 10 MPG Hummer), the cheapest thing you can do with cars is keep the ones you have until the wheels fall off. Lots of times people will make knee-jerk reactions to debt - "Sell everything!" - but you may just find yourself in a junker that costs you just as much to operate. So you need to consider that carefully. What kind of cars are they, what year, how many miles, what do you owe on which?

    4. I would keep the rental properties. They make money. One path to wealth is to keep things that make money until they stop making money.

    5. I would skip the part time job. It won't make jack for money and you have two small children and a wife with a full time job. You will both be on burnout in short order and burnout leads to divorce. Concentrate on seriously scaling back your living costs and focus on how you can make more money in your primary profession. Perhaps your wife can scale up and make more money as a teacher. Or you get commissioned. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    @Jennifer Thompson

    I have met with the financial advisor and she is not fond of real estate. She thinks it is risky in most cases. I don’t think that we are necessarily in trouble. I just don’t feel like we are progressing any more. Also I simply don’t like th debt. She did recommend the snowball method that seems to be the most popular debt pay off method and I can see why. The other limiting factor is that we have two children and child care is not cheap. Nearly 1050 a month. I’m just looking for other opinions on our situation from an outside prospective because the internet isn’t emotionally invested in my finances but can still spark some ideas.

  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    @JD Martin

    It is a 2015 VW Tiguan 47000 miles. 16000 left on loan.

    2017 Dodge Journey 22000 miles, 29000 left on loan.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Christopher Hall:

    @Jennifer Thompson

    I have met with the financial advisor and she is not fond of real estate. She thinks it is risky in most cases. I don’t think that we are necessarily in trouble. I just don’t feel like we are progressing any more. Also I simply don’t like th debt. She did recommend the snowball method that seems to be the most popular debt pay off method and I can see why. The other limiting factor is that we have two children and child care is not cheap. Nearly 1050 a month. I’m just looking for other opinions on our situation from an outside prospective because the internet isn’t emotionally invested in my finances but can still spark some ideas.

     Not fond of real estate?

    I would probably ask to see the financial advisor's balance sheet before I took any of her advice. Virtually all wealthy people I know have some real estate as part of their portfolio no matter how they make their money. 

    Child care: does your base do 24/7 shifts? Is it possible for you to switch shifts? That alone is a way of getting a "part-time job" by simply eliminating the child care costs. Yes, you will see less of your wife and you won't be on the exact same schedule any more, but your kids will see more of their parents. 

    On the cars: well, you're a little stuck there. The 29k loan is the one worth 21k I assume. So you'll have to absorb 8 grand plus the shell-out for the new vehicle. Is it possible to sell that car and car-share in the other? 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    @JD Martin

    I am medical so night ops isn’t an option. Ride sharing would be very difficult given that we both work in opposite directions.

    You are correct that the larger loan is the one worth 21000.

  • Member since 2018 · 17 posts · 8 votes
    7y

    Honestly, only you can decide what level of risk you're prepared to handle. I personally wouldn't let go of property that is bringing in that level of income. As it pays down it will be an even greater asset but that's assuming the market won't tank in the area...but that's a risk only you can choose. Your debt doesn't seem that crushing...even though it may feel like a lot you can certainly manage it with a good strategy and some frugality. Just get strict on yourselves...really strict and you'll pay it down and maybe even have some income producing assets on the flip side. I know childcare is costly, we have 3 little ones and it certainly eats a chunk of income. Hang in there and try the snowball approach. If it still feels like a struggle after a year, maybe then consider selling the property...but hold on to it and see if you can get things settled another way first.

  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    We have sat down now and looked at our situation, I let her read this post and I think that helped to have outside opinions presenting options and showing the possibilities in worst case scenarios. We are looking into selling the cheaper car and buying something cheap 3-5000. I fully listed the house we are living in to see if we can move out sooner. I don’t think the mortgage companies will have fit if we move out a month early. We are going to look at the cheapest possible places like a 2 bed apartment we can get here for like 750 a month. That will help. Our current mortgage is 1117 and I can rent it out for 1400 give or take. That alone will be 6-700 more cash a month towards debt. We have sat down and looked at our budget and have both agreed to be very strict to what we have talked about.

  • Missoula, MT · Member since 2016 · 163 posts · 55 votes
    7y

    I think the OPs question has been more or less beaten to a pulp with good answers but I figured i would chim in with my personal journey of getting out of debt.

    3 years ago... 11,000 in credit card debt and another 3,800 in student debt that was quickly rising.

    Full time student working a part time job. I was making about 1,100 a month. My rent is 650 a month, utilities and other living expenses were totaling 435 on average.

    Do the math and that left me $15 a month to pay off those debts!

                What did i do?

    Drastic spending habits change and i took on extra earning opportunities at work.

    When i say drastic i mean drastic. I canceled my cable tv subscription. Started buying all my groceries at the cheapest possible place which was walmart. Absolutely no frivolous expenses like going drinking down town on satuday night or purchasing anything that wasnt absolutely necessary. So no lattes, eating out, driving up to go ski’ing - Nothing.

    I will say that my friends were not a fan of this. This pretty much ment i had to pass on almost everything fun related that my friends wanted me to come along on. I explained to them what i was trying to accomplish and i think for the most part they understood.

    Getting back to the how. For my pt job i demanded a pay raise and ended up getting promoted to supervisor as a part time employee.

    One interesting thing that i did for extra cash that im pretty proud of was my side hustle. Im not talking about moonlighting as an uber driver either. I sold beeswax on ebay. Its a little unorthodox but i was raking in an extra 1,400 a month!

    Moral of the story is cut back, explain to others what your doing then beg, hustle, demand, negotiate, and fight your way out of debt any way you can. Dont just sit on it and hope you catch a break.

  • Rental Property Investor · Knoxville, TN · Member since 2017 · 14 posts · 5 votes
    7y

    We are in almost an identical situation. Only out of college a few years, with student loans, car loan, credit card debt, and two mortgages. I have thought about selling the rental for the exact reason you mentioned, but for the exact reasons you mentioned we decided to keep it since it cashflows well. All this to say I completely understand where you are at. We are aggressively trying to eliminate every debt we have besides mortgage at the moment so that we can start getting aggressive with real estate in the next two years. Step one is to stop the bleeding. Before you buy anything ask yourself if that purchase will directly help you pay off your debt (for instance I just bought a part for my coffee maker to avoid me justifying buying coffee out) My husband and I have set a goal of no eating out besides one date night per month (cheaply, to keep the relationship alive) until the end of 2019. Step two everyone has already said is lower every monthly payment you can and snowball by focusing on the debt you hate the most-usually start with credit cards. Step three is make any extra money you can. It doesn't always have to be conventional either, uber, airbnb a spare room, build shelving, tutor, offer any service you have any skill at. If you can have that kind of discipline for two years you will be out of financial jail. Good luck I hope we both meet our goals! 

    PS I would also recommend listing the cars for sale at what you owe on them- if you were (no offense we've all been there) stupid enough to buy them for more than what their worth someone else might be as well. Good luck!

  • Rental Property Investor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 37 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    @Alison Nowotarski

    We have rented out our personal residence and moved into a cheaper rental house for the time being. It cost about 600 to move between truck rentals and fees for turning services and such on. I am making 233 a month from renting the personal residence out now and saving about 200 a month from lowering living expenses by moving into the smaller place. Only 1.5 months and I will be positive from the move and start snowballing with the money. We have talked about it a lot and I let me wife read this thread, I think it helped to get us on the same page hearing it from other people. I plan on keeping this thread updated with our progress as we get things paid down. I hope everyone had a great New Years!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.