Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
General Landlording & Rental Properties
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated over 1 year ago, 08/21/2023

User Stats

14
Posts
2
Votes
Maria Mccarthy
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Hollywood, FL
2
Votes |
14
Posts

Security deposit claim

Maria Mccarthy
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Hollywood, FL
Posted

We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

Thank you in advance!

User Stats

1,489
Posts
1,023
Votes
Alex Deacon
  • Investor
  • Pittsburgh, PA
1,023
Votes |
1,489
Posts
Alex Deacon
  • Investor
  • Pittsburgh, PA
Replied

@Maria Mccarthy get a detailed estimate together of what you had to do to mitigate the smell and clean the apartment. Send it to the tenant and take that amount from her deposit. Its up to her if she wants to dispute it and take you to the Magistrate level court. 

User Stats

14
Posts
2
Votes
Maria Mccarthy
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Hollywood, FL
2
Votes |
14
Posts
Maria Mccarthy
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Hollywood, FL
Replied
Quote from @Alex Deacon:

@Maria Mccarthy get a detailed estimate together of what you had to do to mitigate the smell and clean the apartment. Send it to the tenant and take that amount from her deposit. Its up to her if she wants to dispute it and take you to the Magistrate level court. 

Thank you!
BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

17,100
Posts
14,635
Votes
Chris Seveney
Lender
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Virginia
14,635
Votes |
17,100
Posts
Chris Seveney
Lender
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Virginia
ModeratorReplied
Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

Thank you in advance!


 I would send a letter outlining we have been trying to reach you but you did not provide any type of forwarding address. Due to you having a pet which was against the terms of the lease, the pet caused significant damage to the carpets and the unit which caused them to be replaced. The costs outlined below were X. The amount of deposit on the lease was Y. Please remit to us the remaining balance of Z at your earliest convenience. If payment is not recieved by (DATE), we may turn the balance over to collections.

  • Chris Seveney
business profile image
7e investments
5.0 stars
15 Reviews

User Stats

8,351
Posts
4,355
Votes
Colleen F.
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Narragansett, RI
4,355
Votes |
8,351
Posts
Colleen F.
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Narragansett, RI
Replied

@Maria Mccarthy  Always send a letter detailing costs even if you have to send it to the property address and leave it unopened. I would send that letter now to whatever address she provided.  If we miss the deadline in RI they can win by default even if they did damage, doesn't matter if they provided a forwarding address. If your states starts counting days after you get a forwarding address then you could be fine. Either way I would send the deduction letter.

User Stats

14,335
Posts
11,019
Votes
Theresa Harris
Pro Member
#3 Real Estate Horror Stories Contributor
11,019
Votes |
14,335
Posts
Theresa Harris
Pro Member
#3 Real Estate Horror Stories Contributor
Replied

Hindsight is great, but you should have sent her a registered letter detailing the break down to her last known address. If she had mail forwarded, she'd get it at her new address; if not, you'd get it back.  With the latter, you keep it unopened as proof that you sent it.

Give her the itemized bill and state damage was from an unauthorized pet and litter box that was not cleaned.

Also others had had good luck using an ozone machine to remove smells.  The house can't be occupied when it is running, but they aren't that expensive.

  • Theresa Harris
  • User Stats

    2,090
    Posts
    1,019
    Votes
    Peter Mckernan
    Agent
    Pro Member
    #4 Rehabbing & House Flipping Contributor
    • Residential Real Estate Agent
    • Irvine, CA
    1,019
    Votes |
    2,090
    Posts
    Peter Mckernan
    Agent
    Pro Member
    #4 Rehabbing & House Flipping Contributor
    • Residential Real Estate Agent
    • Irvine, CA
    Replied
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

    She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

    How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

    Thank you in advance!


     You'll have all items you paid for put together, receipts/invoices, labor charges, and anything else. I would also write up a letter too that states what happened and how the condition of the property was left so that you have it on file and she does if she tries to take you to small claims court. 

    • Peter Mckernan
    business profile image
    The McKernan Group
    5.0 stars
    32 Reviews

    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied
    Thank you! 

    Quote from @Peter Mckernan:
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

    She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

    How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

    Thank you in advance!


     You'll have all items you paid for put together, receipts/invoices, labor charges, and anything else. I would also write up a letter too that states what happened and how the condition of the property was left so that you have it on file and she does if she tries to take you to small claims court. 


    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied
    lol.  I argued with my husband about that but he disagreed.  I recall doing that with another tenant.  We didn’t try the ozone but it’s a converted house to a duplex (before my time).  So the first floor tenant would have been there.  I’ll keep it in mind.  In Michigan I believe they use a depreciated value, so may call an attorney just to be prepared.  

    Quote from @Theresa Harris:

    Hindsight is great, but you should have sent her a registered letter detailing the break down to her last known address. If she had mail forwarded, she'd get it at her new address; if not, you'd get it back.  With the latter, you keep it unopened as proof that you sent it.

    Give her the itemized bill and state damage was from an unauthorized pet and litter box that was not cleaned.

    Also others had had good luck using an ozone machine to remove smells.  The house can't be occupied when it is running, but they aren't that expensive.


    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied
    Thanks! Some good advice. 

    Quote from @Peter Mckernan:
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

    She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

    How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

    Thank you in advance!


     You'll have all items you paid for put together, receipts/invoices, labor charges, and anything else. I would also write up a letter too that states what happened and how the condition of the property was left so that you have it on file and she does if she tries to take you to small claims court. 


    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied
    I like your response.  Will use that as a base with the other comments

    Quote from @Chris Seveney:
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

    She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

    How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

    Thank you in advance!


     I would send a letter outlining we have been trying to reach you but you did not provide any type of forwarding address. Due to you having a pet which was against the terms of the lease, the pet caused significant damage to the carpets and the unit which caused them to be replaced. The costs outlined below were X. The amount of deposit on the lease was Y. Please remit to us the remaining balance of Z at your earliest convenience. If payment is not recieved by (DATE), we may turn the balance over to collections.


    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied
    lol. You are tough.  We all could probably use your docs.  However it seems that nowadays courts side with tenants.  However your approach has merit.  

    And to think we were swayed by our property manager to give this woman a break.   Her credit wasn’t too good.  

    Quote from @Chris Seveney:
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

    She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

    How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

    Thank you in advance!


     I would send a letter outlining we have been trying to reach you but you did not provide any type of forwarding address. Due to you having a pet which was against the terms of the lease, the pet caused significant damage to the carpets and the unit which caused them to be replaced. The costs outlined below were X. The amount of deposit on the lease was Y. Please remit to us the remaining balance of Z at your earliest convenience. If payment is not recieved by (DATE), we may turn the balance over to collections.


    User Stats

    4,008
    Posts
    2,361
    Votes
    Michael Smythe
    Property Manager
    • Property Manager
    • Metro Detroit
    2,361
    Votes |
    4,008
    Posts
    Michael Smythe
    Property Manager
    • Property Manager
    • Metro Detroit
    Replied

    @Maria Mccarthy in Michigan, a landlord is released from giving a tenant a breakdown of charges against their security deposit if the tenant fails to abide by Michigan statute and give their forwarding address within 4 days.

    So, you legally don't owe the tenant an explanation or response.

    If you want to take the tenant to small claims court for the damages that exceeded the security deposit, you will need their current address to have them served.

    So, you might play a game with the tenant and tell them you need their current address to "move forward" regarding their security deposit and damages (do not mention amounts!).

    Once you have their current address, start the small claims case.

    Highly recommend you invest some time in learning Michigan landlord-tenant statutes or hire a PMC. Here's an easy to follow handbook published by the Michigan legislature:

    https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Publications/tenantlandlord.p...

    • Michael Smythe
    business profile image
    Logical Property Management
    0.0 star
    0 Reviews
    1-800 Accountant logo
    1-800 Accountant
    |
    Sponsored
    Unlock Year-End Real Estate Tax Savings: Buy your accounting services now and deduct them on your 2024 taxes. Flat rate, never hourly.

    User Stats

    27,448
    Posts
    40,393
    Votes
    Nathan Gesner
    Property Manager
    Agent
    Pro Member
    • Real Estate Broker
    • Cody, WY
    40,393
    Votes |
    27,448
    Posts
    Nathan Gesner
    Property Manager
    Agent
    Pro Member
    • Real Estate Broker
    • Cody, WY
    ModeratorReplied
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    1. You should inspect your properties at least once a year, even with the best Tenant in place. If you have C-class or D-class properties, inspect more often.

    2. I don't understand why this is a question. The deposit can be used for cleaning and repairs. She obviously caused damage greater than the deposit so there should be no question in your mind. In fact, you should be sending her a bill for the renovations required by her unauthorized cat.

    Consider hiring a property manager or at least start reading some books and the law to learn how to protect yourself better.

    • Nathan Gesner
    business profile image
    The DIY Landlord
    4.7 stars
    151 Reviews

    User Stats

    6,413
    Posts
    3,671
    Votes
    Bob Stevens
    • Real Estate Consultant
    • Cleveland
    3,671
    Votes |
    6,413
    Posts
    Bob Stevens
    • Real Estate Consultant
    • Cleveland
    Replied
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

    She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

    How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

    Thank you in advance!


     She gets nothing, end of story. Unless you had 1ks and 1ks and 1ks of SD, tell her to move on, 

    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied

    Thank you!  Yes I am familiar with the landlord / tenant notice requirement but I find sometimes the courts handle things differently.

    We did speak to the attorney and he said not to send anything as she did not follow through on the 4 day notice.  

    We are not seeking recovery beyond the security deposit and are ready to move on.  

    At some point I hope to transfer to PMC but not yet.  They do handle the rental now, etc., but not the actual day to day management.  

    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied
    Thanks. 

    Quote from @Bob Stevens:
    Quote from @Maria Mccarthy:

    We have a tenant that leased for one year.  She had a no pet clause yet unbeknownst to us brought a cat in.  There were uncleaned litter box during an inspection.  We had a a broker present too.  The smell was terrible.  When she moved out , we sent notice of non renewal that week, she cleaned with significant pine sol smell.  Two independent people plus the new tenant said the smell was significant despite our efforts.  We had to tear out the carpet and padding, deep clean and laid out vinyl.  The smell remained for awhile even after that hence one reason we didn’t reinstall carpet.  

    She did not provide notification of forwarding address as required by the lease AND the state of Michigan.  4 days yo be specific.   Yet  over 2 month later she’s asking for a status.  

    How would you handle?   Thanks in advance.  We spent significantly more than the amount of deposit. 

    Thank you in advance!


     She gets nothing, end of story. Unless you had 1ks and 1ks and 1ks of SD, tell her to move on, 


    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied

    We do read the landlord/tenant rules. We have owned properties for 20+ years. Michigan  not as long. 10 years.  I find over the years landlord seem to have less rights, but it’s state, city specific.   And tenants seem more entitled than ever before.  Maybe we’ve been lucky but we haven’t had too much problem.  Thanks. 

    User Stats

    14
    Posts
    2
    Votes
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    2
    Votes |
    14
    Posts
    Maria Mccarthy
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Hollywood, FL
    Replied
    Thanks!  The attorney actually said don’t send because she didn’t provide the proper notice.  If she sends in writing we will probably respond. We’ve had the costs already set for some time.  

    Quote from @Alex Deacon:

    @Maria Mccarthy get a detailed estimate together of what you had to do to mitigate the smell and clean the apartment. Send it to the tenant and take that amount from her deposit. Its up to her if she wants to dispute it and take you to the Magistrate level court.