Worth it to allow pets?

Worth it to allow pets?

Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 29 posts · 10 votes

I'm setting up a new rental (large SFR with backyard) in Cozy and can't decide if I should allow pets or not. My current tenants don't have pets, so it didn't come up previously, but with the new listing I'm leaning towards allowing cats and not dogs (or small dogs, but that doesn't seem to be an option). I can also choose to not specify and have that conversation with whoever applies I guess, but is it better to set expectations up front? I'd ideally not like to deal with them, but also don't want to limit my renter pool too much.

What have you seen success/issues with?

2Reply
373 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 5k+ votes
7y

Around 62% of households have a pet. Saying no to pets reduces your renter pool by 2/3. 

Anyone who wants a pet can have one. All the tenant needs to do is say that the pet is an Emotional Support Animal and you are out of luck and basically have to accept the animal.

Charge a pet fee if you like, but many people will get around this by claiming ESA. Best bet is to allow pets, price a pet into the rent regardless of whether the renter has one, and get a large enough deposit to cover damages. 

See this reply in the discussion

63 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 29 posts · 10 votes
    7y

    @Luciano A. great advice about making the pet deposit refundable!

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 29 posts · 10 votes
    7y

    @Sarah Sheaffer yeah, after reading what everyone has said it seems like it's not worth cutting out that many potential tenants. Just have to be hyper-vigilant when screening!

  • Rental Property Investor · New York City · Member since 2019 · 703 posts · 538 votes
    7y

    I am a owner of 2 dogs and love animals but its my primary property and my rentals are a different story.

    I have two 2 family houses in NYC and i have a no pet policy.  I don't need to be worried about a dog biting someone, or having a good tenant leave because of barking or having a fear of dogs, someone complaining of allergies, chewing the sheetrock and wood finishes.   I don't need the headache. 

    "Sorry Mr. Smith i love dogs too but i don't allow them for insurance reasons".

  • Jordan MoorheadBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2015 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore I had an extremely difficult time putting limitations on dogs. Austin is a dog city and people have dogs of all cities. I'll never not allow them after trying to not allow them. My place sat and didn't rent when I said "no dogs". People want a fenced in yard for their dog. Cater to them and charge for it!

  • Great Falls, MT · Member since 2017 · 97 posts · 172 votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore

    I had a strong reaction when you said, “Allow cats, but not dogs.”

    Really, cats are the worst. I mean I LOVE cats myself, but they can destroy a rental. Think urine smell soaked into solid oak original hardwood! Yup....one cat destroyed, arguably, the most durable floor out there!

    This is my criteria, and I have never had a dog do much damage.

    ONE dog (you will get a million sob stories of why 3 dogs will be fine, so brace for it and hold strong).

    3+ years old. First, older dogs don’t cause nearly as many issues. AND who gets a puppy while searching for a new rental? Irresponsible and impulsive people is who!

    I purposely have homeowner insurance that has breed restrictions. Insurance companies make their living running stats to reduce risk. If they think a certain breed is more risky; I am going to adhere to that thinking too. And I require vet records stating the breed to avoid the “lab mix” lie.

    Must have bite coverage on rental insurance policy.

    Must have all shot records.

    Charge pet rent and deposit.

    It’s worked very well for me. I had one border collie who scratched a bedroom door to get out. No other issues in many years and multiple properties.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Corby Goade:

    This is market specific. In my market, approx 66% of the population has dogs. If you say "no pets" you are likely to have either higher vacancy or people who lie on their applications and move in with a pet anyhow. We use petscreening.com, charge higher pet fees and work closely with our tenants to ensure that their dogs are well behaved and not causing problems with the property. It's very rare that we have any pet related damage, and generally when we do, our tenants notify us, we have it repaired and the tenants pay for the repairs outside of their deposit. 

    I hate to sound like a broken record, but it comes back to tenant screening. If you are properly screening and a great candidate has a pet, it's likely that it won't be a problem. A renter with a 750 credit score who makes $150k a year isn't likely to have a pitbull who is going to tear up your yard or eat your drywall. Responsible, quality tenants are responsible with their pets, too. 

     I couldn't have said it better myself. It always comes back to tenant screening. Things fit together, like a puzzle. Responsible people with steady work and well behaved kids and pets rarely have 550 credit scores, and people with 800 credit scores and steady jobs rarely have dogs that destroy the property and crap all over the house. 

    I look at everything when someone comes to see the house. What does their car look like? I don't mean is it older or newer - I mean is it filthy? Is it covered with junk everywhere inside? Food wrappers? That's how they're going to keep your house, and that's how they're going to keep their pets. Are they dressed like slobs? Do they stink? Is their hair unwashed? Are they morbidly obese? Do they smoke? Do they vape? Do they smell like marijuana? Do they smell like alcohol? You know who I want renting my house? Ward Cleaver. Is this prejudicial? Maybe, but I don't care. I don't want to rent to smokers. Or slobs. Or drunks. Or irresponsible pet owners. Luckily, smokers, vapers, drunks, potheads, slobs, dirtbags, and irresponsible pet owners are not protected classes. 

    Dogs vs. Cats: dogs any day of the week. Cat piss is vicious stuff. Cats also like to claw everything - it's in their nature. Size of dog is less important than maturity of the dog. I'd steer clear of puppies (any dog under 2). Bigger dogs tend not to be obnoxious barkers around the neighbors. Anyone who tells me their dog is an "outside dog" is automatically disqualified, because 95% of the time "outside dog" means almost completely neglected and a yard with torn up grass and dog crap everywhere. Dogs that are not fixed are disqualified, because that suggests an irresponsible pet owner. Dogs that don't have shots - at least all initial + rabies - are disqualified, because that suggests an owner who is either negligent or too poor to afford the vet visits. Generally anyone with more than 1 pet is disqualified. 

    In our advertisements, when it comes to pets, we note it is negotiable on a case by case basis. I don't want to say I accept pets because if I like the person and they qualify but their animal is obnoxious (we usually meet the animal, even if this sounds crazy) I'm not going to rent to them. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Rental Property Investor · Douglas County, MO · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @JD Martin:

    [...] (we usually meet the animal, even if this sounds crazy) [...] 

    That's not crazy, it's good business. The animal will be a resident in the home. I want to meet all the residents before signing a lease.

  • Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 512 posts · 301 votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore I think we go pretty easy personally. Small dogs we do a very minimal 125 fee 125 deposit. Medium or large 200/200 and 250/250. It can also vary with properties.

    The last time I was a tenant it was a 300$ non refundable fee and 200 for any additional dog plus a 35$ rental price raise.

    We don’t raise the rent for having pets.

    9 times out of 10 we don’t allow cats.

    I think cats get snuck in plenty because dogs are harder to hide in my opinion.

    Not sure if there is a right or wrong on pet fees/deposit.

    Like I said in my last post, there never really is a problem and They don’t do too much damage if the owners are responsible but still collect a fee because there will be extra clean up and

    small damages almost always.

    Many ways you can do this but I’m rather pro pet and pet friendly so i like to think my fees are fair/not too high

  • Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 512 posts · 301 votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore no tenants have ever reacted with dismay when presented with the pet fees.

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, GA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Erica Moore:

    @John Teachout I've paid a non-refundable fee at pretty much every apartment I've lived in, but never for a house. How have prospective tenants reacted to that?

     Surprisingly, it doesn't seem to be an issue. They just pay it as part of their pre move in fees. The monthly animal "rent" is something recent and we only have one tenant paying that. If someone had a problem with it, then likely we never heard from them after sending them our tenant profile (first step in the application process)

  • Real Estate Investor · Unionville, CT · Member since 2016 · 260 posts · 167 votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore I allow pets since I am a pet owner myself. I charge $25 a Month extra for it. It’s a good way to increase your earnings.

  • Western NC · Member since 2019 · 7 posts · 6 votes
    7y

    This may not be quite as relevant because I'm primarily with vacation rentals up to this point, but I've had a lot of experience with different dogs (no cats allowed) many times a year with each property.   It seems to me that larger dogs don't get bathed as often because it's more of a chore to do so, and they cause much larger messes of all types.  Even after only a week-long vacation, that "loveable well-behaved mutt that just lays around all day" can cause terrible odors and stains that are costly and hard to remove between renters.   Small dogs don't cause any kind of problem like that, and they're almost always kept clean.  We now only allow small dogs up to 25 lbs and we're strict with that limit.  All dogs must still be pre-approved by us.  We've had no problems at all since putting that policy in place, and our property manager has to see the dog at check-in so there's no chance of cheating.  Even with the restrictions I believe our rentals stay booked significantly more by comparison to the ones in our area that don't allow any pets.  We're now searching for a multifamily property to rent out long term and we'll probably adopt a similar policy for those units.

  • Keyonte SummersPro Member
    Harper Woods, MI · Member since 2017 · 384 posts · 311 votes
    7y

    I would but state in the lease a non-refundable deposit for having the dog and add A monthly fee for the pet.

  • Greenville, SC · Member since 2018 · 45 posts · 17 votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore I allow small pets and charge a pet rent per pet. I currently don’t have carpet in my rentals so hopefully it stays cleaner. I don’t think you can predict if something is going to get chewed up, but then the deposit should help cover damages?

  • David IvyPro Member
    Real Estate Broker · Austin, TX · Member since 2016 · 355 posts · 700 votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore

    If you don't allow dogs, you'll miss out on a very significant portion (majority?) of the Austin renter pool. The overwhelming number of lease inquiries I receive on my and my clients' properties are from people with dogs. As you said, Austin is very much a "dog city." So, if your goal is to expose your rental to the largest number of potential tenants and get it rented as quickly as possible, you'll want to allow at least one dog.

    You can set a weight limit (e.g., 50 lbs. or less). Be sure to call your insurance agent or review your insurance documents to see if there are any dog breed restrictions. Also, familiarize yourself with your responsibilities related to assistance and emotional support animals, which are not considered pets. Many renters have their pet designated as an emotional support animal. They can do that online for less than $100.

    Though anecdotal, my experience in the Austin area is that it's most common for small or individual landlords to charge a non-refundable pet fee up front (per pet) without charging any additional monthly pet rent.

  • Rental Property Investor · New Castle, DE · Member since 2016 · 376 posts · 158 votes
    7y

    I just read a post about a person not renewing a lease because the tenant let their animals use the bathroom in the property.  I'm not a pet person, so I don't want pets in my rental.  I've seen some pets use the bathroom where they live; chew and scratch moldings so it's a no go for me.  I don't want the hassle of irresponsible tenants and care free pets.

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 29 posts · 10 votes
    7y

    @Alissa Engel I've always had great cats and had no idea people felt this way - so glad I posted this! Doesn't look like I'll be allowing them after reading what everyone has to say. And puppies are out. 

    Really appreciate the insight!

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 29 posts · 10 votes
    7y

    @JD Martin it sounds like everything ultimately comes down to the tenant screening. I updated the listing as "case by case basis," so I'll be diligent about which pets, if any, I allow! 

    Thanks for the detail!

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 29 posts · 10 votes
    7y

    @David Ivy I definitely need to get with my insurance company and see what their restrictions are. How do you handle an emotional support animal? Same pets fees/rent/deposit as anyone else or are they exempt?

    Good to know about what else you've seen in Austin - want to make sure I'm competitive!

  • Jordan MoorheadBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2015 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y

    @Erica Moore check with an attorney that you don't violate fair housing law. "Case by case" sounds like it opens the door to discrimination.

  • Rental Property Investor · New York City · Member since 2019 · 703 posts · 538 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Alissa Engel:

    @Erica Moore

    I had a strong reaction when you said, “Allow cats, but not dogs.”

    Really, cats are the worst. I mean I LOVE cats myself, but they can destroy a rental. Think urine smell soaked into solid oak original hardwood! Yup....one cat destroyed, arguably, the most durable floor out there!

    This is my criteria, and I have never had a dog do much damage.

    ONE dog (you will get a million sob stories of why 3 dogs will be fine, so brace for it and hold strong).

    3+ years old. First, older dogs don’t cause nearly as many issues. AND who gets a puppy while searching for a new rental? Irresponsible and impulsive people is who!

    I purposely have homeowner insurance that has breed restrictions. Insurance companies make their living running stats to reduce risk. If they think a certain breed is more risky; I am going to adhere to that thinking too. And I require vet records stating the breed to avoid the “lab mix” lie.

    Must have bite coverage on rental insurance policy.

    Must have all shot records.

    Charge pet rent and deposit.

    It’s worked very well for me. I had one border collie who scratched a bedroom door to get out. No other issues in many years and multiple properties.

     Aren't cats/kittens fully trained in like 2 days to use a litter box. I don't allow pets but I've never been to a home where a cat urinates or poops wherever it pleases. Just change the litter before it smells and get it a scratching post with some toys.

  • Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2014 · 285 posts · 142 votes
    7y

    I invest in 2-4 unit plexes. In most cases, I'd allow for pets, but be very specific in the lease: 

    1) Breed restrictions: especially those that insurance companies won't allow - dobermans, pit bulls etc. 

    2) Have a photo of the pet on file. Stipulate that if renter gets new pet, landlord must be notified

    3) Set a 10-15 pound limit, and case-by-case basis

    4) I actually like cats - they keep the mice away!

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Erica Moore:

    @David Ivy I definitely need to get with my insurance company and see what their restrictions are. How do you handle an emotional support animal? Same pets fees/rent/deposit as anyone else or are they exempt?

    Good to know about what else you've seen in Austin - want to make sure I'm competitive!

    Your bio says you only have 2 houses. Check your local laws but the FHA doesn't apply to you if you are renting out the property yourself (i.e. not using professional property management to rent the property). And "emotional support animal" is not covered by the ADA. This is largely a lot of crap irresponsible tenants try to use to get over on landlords. Know your rights and the limits of the law :)

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Rental Property Investor · Central, FL · Member since 2016 · 950 posts · 821 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Trevor Cox:

    I think if you charge a pet deposit and a monthly fee that will cover (most) of the expenses of cleaning up, you should be okay. If you select a great tenant that meets all your requirements, hopefully they are responsible enough to take proper care of the pet and you will never need to use the deposit or fees and you're making more money. That might be wishful thinking though.

    The big thing is I don’t charge a pet deposit but a non refundable fee for a pet.  It is about having a buffer for your damages. Given if a dog destroys a home you most likely have a person who won’t pay you a dime pay your collected deposit.  

  • Columbus, OH · Member since 2018 · 29 posts · 20 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    The big thing is I don’t charge a pet deposit but a non refundable fee for a pet.  It is about having a buffer for your damages. Given if a dog destroys a home you most likely have a person who won’t pay you a dime pay your collected deposit.  

    Yes I should have said pet fee instead of a deposit. Do also charge a monthly fee for having a pet or do you rely on the up front fee to cover any damages? 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.