Kissamee STR - 1st time Canadian Investor

Kissamee STR - 1st time Canadian Investor

Member since 2022 · 5 posts · 1 vote

Hi All, Happy New Year! 

My name is Ryan Cotterill, and my wife and i have been looking for investement opportunities in recent within the Kissimee area. We have rented STR's ourselves in both Davenport, and Kissimee previously, and loved the experience. I have searched the forums and gained valuble information from local investors, agents, etc. This maybe a reiterated question, but through the search, a lot has changed in 5 months, and i am just hoping to keep current.

A few questions that would help gain some knowledge within this particular area from experienced investors:


1. Looking at the trending market, housing prices look to be at a higher value 2021/22. Im sure the pandemic has also been one of the variables in the rise to bringing life somewhat back to normal. 


2. Zillow.com - looked at homes within 25 minutes of Disney, for booking status - how many bedrooms do you generally look over for high rate of turn overs? 3 bed? 4 bed? 5bed? When we rented in the area, we had 3 families that wanted to stay in 1 home, so we rented a 8 bed, this would be out of our price range, but also we are considering buying for our own family joys also. 

3. I see many self managing their properties themselves. Are your homes part of an association with fees where lawn maintenance and basic outside care is taken? Do any of you have homes in a more residential area where you hire people for these services and what costs are associated with it?

4. Being a 1st timer, how has this year and futures look for the STR industry in that area? Any 1st time buyers that recently bought properties have a good ROI? Bookings consistant, etc?

Thanks all, enjoy your day!

1Reply
33 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Plymouth, MN · Member since 2020 · 157 posts · 102 votes
4y

@Ryan Cotterill

I'll help with your item 3. Self managing.

My wife and I have 5 str homes. We are in Minnesota and self manage our properties including one SFH in Naples, FL and in future one in the Orlando area.

Things are humming along very well. The house in Naples we have a regular pool maintenance company, yard maintenance, handy man we can call on, and very good cleaning company. And everything we could setup for remote monitoring- locks, ring, wifi, water shutoff, water leak sensors, noise monitor...

Pool - 100/month and yard - 100/month both in Naples, FL.

I typically stay away from HOAs like they are the bubonic plaque....but we may get a house with a HOA in Orlando/Kissimmee area for the amenities....pool/gym/etc....

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Tyler GibsonBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Orlando, FL · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Ryan Cotterill:

    Hi All, Happy New Year! 

    My name is Ryan Cotterill, and my wife and i have been looking for investement opportunities in recent within the Kissimee area. We have rented STR's ourselves in both Davenport, and Kissimee previously, and loved the experience. I have searched the forums and gained valuble information from local investors, agents, etc. This maybe a reiterated question, but through the search, a lot has changed in 5 months, and i am just hoping to keep current.

    A few questions that would help gain some knowledge within this particular area from experienced investors:


    1. Looking at the trending market, housing prices look to be at a higher value 2021/22. Im sure the pandemic has also been one of the variables in the rise to bringing life somewhat back to normal. 


    2. Zillow.com - looked at homes within 25 minutes of Disney, for booking status - how many bedrooms do you generally look over for high rate of turn overs? 3 bed? 4 bed? 5bed? When we rented in the area, we had 3 families that wanted to stay in 1 home, so we rented a 8 bed, this would be out of our price range, but also we are considering buying for our own family joys also. 

    3. I see many self managing their properties themselves. Are your homes part of an association with fees where lawn maintenance and basic outside care is taken? Do any of you have homes in a more residential area where you hire people for these services and what costs are associated with it?

    4. Being a 1st timer, how has this year and futures look for the STR industry in that area? Any 1st time buyers that recently bought properties have a good ROI? Bookings consistant, etc?

    Thanks all, enjoy your day!

    I probably won't answer these questions in the correct order but I'll give it a go. Prices have gone up as demand has gone up. There is still plenty of demand in the market. Larger single family homes were highly sought after this past summer due to many reasons. The short-term rental industry here is very strong. The revenue generated for the counties helps to ensure that they don't restrict it and many of the communities have HOAs that explicitly allow it. In terms of communities that cover lawn maintenance and other things yes they are out there. You will pay a premium in the HOA cost but it may be worth it in the end for you. I suggest you look at buying minimum four bedroom property but buy as big as you can. 6 7 and 8 bedroom properties will get you a premium return. The goal is not to have your property full all the time. The goal should be to charge a premium to have your property rented 75% of the time. The more people are in your property the more damage they will do to it. So you don't want to have it full 100% of the time. If you do have a full 100% of the time you probably have your prices too low. Still a lot of opportunity but interest rates are going to continue to rise and so will prices so if you're going to buy Best buy now. I'd be happy to answer any other questions you might have.

  • Investor · Plymouth, MN · Member since 2020 · 157 posts · 102 votes
    4y

    @Ryan Cotterill

    I'll help with your item 3. Self managing.

    My wife and I have 5 str homes. We are in Minnesota and self manage our properties including one SFH in Naples, FL and in future one in the Orlando area.

    Things are humming along very well. The house in Naples we have a regular pool maintenance company, yard maintenance, handy man we can call on, and very good cleaning company. And everything we could setup for remote monitoring- locks, ring, wifi, water shutoff, water leak sensors, noise monitor...

    Pool - 100/month and yard - 100/month both in Naples, FL.

    I typically stay away from HOAs like they are the bubonic plaque....but we may get a house with a HOA in Orlando/Kissimmee area for the amenities....pool/gym/etc....

  • Shawn McCormickPro Member
    Realtor · Central Florida-Orlando · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 894 votes
    4y

    @Ryan Cotterill to help answer some of your questions, let me see if I can help. 

    Yes, housing prices have gone up considerably. We just got numbers for November of 2021 and inventory is down 45.4% over a year ago, median price is up 20%, volue of sales is up over 30%...so it is very active and prices are continuing to rise. With the new Fannie Mae rules going into effect, this will curb some of the investors buying and allow homeowners more of a chance, but I don't see prices coming down.

    For looking on Zillow, I think 25 miles out from Disney is way too far. First off, you can't airbnb in Orange County (for the most part), so you have to stick to Lake, Osceola and Polk and I would stick to 10 miles out if you want a high performing unit. More than that and the traffic is a nightmare! I see that the bigger homes are likely out of your budget, my advice is always buy as big as you can afford, you can always rent it out as a 'smaller' unit in non peak times, but there are simply less of the bigger units and you won't be competing on nightly rates with smaller units that want to rate cut their competitors.

    For self managing, there is a big learning curve. Unless you have the time to learn everything and have contacts for all the trades and apps and software you will need, I think it is best to hire a PM until you get a grasp on how it all works and let them build your reviews and presence.

    Hope this helps, Good luck!

  • Member since 2022 · 5 posts · 1 vote
    4y

    Thanks all for your input. I work within property management in Canada, automation would not be an issue. Reputable contractors and contacts for each trade would be a networking curve.
    Some 4 beds are within our budget, taken into consideration the dollar exchange. 
    What is everyone’s experience for bookings after purchase, house Reno’s/paint/lipstick, and then gaining traction?

  • Shawn McCormickPro Member
    Realtor · Central Florida-Orlando · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 894 votes
    4y

    @Ryan Cotterill the majority of these home come fully furnished and with future bookings in place, so really a turn key opportunity. You don't have to keep the bookings and may do better if you rebook, that is up to you. You don't get the previous owners reviews, so building your home's reputation to get on page one is going to take time and should be considered.

    Trades and contractors of all types are extremely overloaded with work and finding someone to do a honey-do list is quite difficult from OOS. Cleaners, handymen etc can pick and choose what jobs they take as there are so many to choose and they are (unfortunately) unreliable. How do you handle that from OOS? If you are using a good Realtor or PM, they should be able to connect you with contacts to do those types of fixes based on your calendar of bookings.

  • Property Manager · Orlando Kissimmee, Daytona Beach & Cocoa Beach · Member since 2016 · 331 posts · 166 votes
    4y

    Hi Ryan. 

    2. Zillow.com - looked at homes within 25 minutes of Disney, for booking status - how many bedrooms do you generally look over for high rate of turn overs? 3 bed? 4 bed? 5bed? When we rented in the area, we had 3 families that wanted to stay in 1 home, so we rented a 8 bed, this would be out of our price range, but also we are considering buying for our own family joys also.  I do believe that 4 bedrooms are ideal. Large homes require too much maintenance. Plus, yes you can fit 16-20 people in there, but you still are dealing with a single family house and not a hotel!. 

    3. I see many self managing their properties themselves. Are your homes part of an association with fees where lawn maintenance and basic outside care is taken? Do any of you have homes in a more residential area where you hire people for these services and what costs are associated with it?  Absolutely yes. My own vacation home is located in Eagle Pointe community with $40 HOA, and we just use a lawn service for $60 monthly. There are so many vendors in Kissimmee! 

  • Property Manager · Orlando Kissimmee, Daytona Beach & Cocoa Beach · Member since 2016 · 331 posts · 166 votes
    4y

    ...removed as duplicated :)

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.