Hi ,
I just list my house for short term
four young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks. the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest. few days in they asked to add 4 more people.
hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?
is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people? send someone to visit the house?
also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as booking.com VRBO etc?
thanks !
Itay
Hey @Itay Heled
Trashed Airbnb homes makes for good click bait news, but it's not the norm.
In twelve years with investment properties in Colorado -- including LTRs, MTRs, and STRs -- we've had exactly one "trashed" home ... and that was from a long-term tenant, not a short-term rental guest. Similar story for all our vacation rental investor clients.
Set strong rules and expectations, vet guests as best you can, have robust insurance and carry on.
Hi ,
I just list my house for short term
four young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks. the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest. few days in they asked to add 4 more people.
hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?
is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people? send someone to visit the house?
also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as booking.com VRBO etc?
thanks !
Itay
Just have the correct STR insurance and don't sweat it
Hi ,
I just list my house for short term
four young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks. the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest. few days in they asked to add 4 more people.
hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?
is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people? send someone to visit the house?
also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as booking.com VRBO etc?
thanks !
Itay
Just have the correct STR insurance and don't sweat it
can you explain please what STR insurance is actually covering what is the cost and what is the deductible to get a sense?
Hi ,
I just list my house for short term
four young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks. the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest. few days in they asked to add 4 more people.
hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?
is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people? send someone to visit the house?
also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as booking.com VRBO etc?
thanks !
Itay
Just have the correct STR insurance and don't sweat it
can you explain please what STR insurance is actually covering what is the cost and what is the deductible to get a sense?
It varies. You'll need to get several quotes to get prices specific to you property.
Hi ,
I just list my house for short term
four young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks. the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest. few days in they asked to add 4 more people.
hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?
is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people? send someone to visit the house?
also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as booking.com VRBO etc?
thanks !
Itay
Just have the correct STR insurance and don't sweat it
Hi ,
I just list my house for short term
four young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks. the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest. few days in they asked to add 4 more people.
hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?
is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people? send someone to visit the house?
also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as booking.com VRBO etc?
thanks !
Itay
Just have the correct STR insurance and don't sweat it
You need a STR insurance policy or at least a STR rider from your current policy
Hello Italy,
Unfortunately there will always be risk when doing short term rentals, and things will inevitably get ruined or broken at some point. Expect that and plan for it! Airbnb does have an insurance policy in case a guest does trash a house but I will note that they are very much partial to guests and will normally not side with the host in a dispute unless you have really good evidence. There are a few things that you can do to help protect your listing, this is not exactly an exhaustive list but just a few things:
- You can install a ring doorbell so that you have video evidence of who is coming in and out of the house. If the guests throw a party against your rules you will be able to show a bunch of people entering the house who weren't supposed to be there.
- You can require that guests have uploaded proof of ID to airbnb in your settings. This prevents people from making a new account to throw a party, trash a house, get a bad review from the host, then just make a new account so that it doesn't matter.
- You can require a refundable deposit/place a hold on their card just in case. I don't do this and I wouldn't necessarily recommend it but you can.
- Have a smart lock. It is really helpful to have a log of when guests were going in and out of the house. This has helped me with airbnb disputes before
- Tell your cleaners to let you know if anything is broken or trashed and to take thorough pictures before touching anything.
- I believe the other OTAs also have host insurance but not as robust as airbnb.
- Send a message during the guest's stay checking in and ask how their stay is going. This gives them a chance to tell you if anything is wrong with the unit and if they do not reply or say that everything is going well, it will help you if they break stuff and/or try to get a refund later.
- Honestly, I haven't had that much issue with people breaking things, I have had more people trying to fraudulently get a refund though.
- Set aside a % of each host payout you get for future repairs replacing furnishings, expect it to happen, and then you will be prepared when it does.
Feel free to reach out if you have more questions!
Hi Itay
I can understand your nerves! As a PM I have managed over 200 STR's in total and currently around 65 units. As mentioned above there is always some risk - but to be honest I have had worse lucky with LTR's. STR's at least your cleaners are getting in a few times a month allowing windows to keep up with maintenance tasks. With LTR's usually if the tenant is quiet and pays on time you may go months or even years without seeing the property's condition. In 9 years and over 30,000 reservations we have only had damages under $1,000 maybe around 20 times and over $1,000 3 times.
That said, do make sure you have an STR compliant insurance policy. This, usually, will not cover small damages and items, but the property as a whole and used for large claims. If you are renting exclusively on Airbnb, there is AirCover, which will cover you if the guest trashes the house or causes damage. Make sure you document everything and you can submit right through Airbnb's Resolution Center.
As far as guest screening goes, there are some services out there but especially at scale it is cumbersome and costly. We do check guest reviews as well as having guests sign an agreement outlining damage procedures, partying, etc. Usually this is enough to scare people off if they know they are rowdy. For example most of our larger, pool homes attract things like bachelor/ette parties. They book and once they see the agreement (also posted in listing) they become a bit nervous that they may be removed from the property with no refund if we get noise complaints. We let them cancel with full refund. Steps like these weed out 99+% of potential trouble, at least in our experience.
I have owned vacation rentals since 2005 and had many thousands of guests. I don't recall when I have had anything trashed.
A) do not rent to people that only have one review. B) do not rent to anybody on a last-minute basis make it be at least 3 days in advance, C) never rent for only one night, that will be a partier for sure. D) sets your age limit higher, I use 30 years old.
just call your regular insurance company and ask them if they insure short-term rentals. I use State Farm and they were super reasonable, but make sure you tell them exactly what you're using it for.
A) do not rent to people that only have one review. B) do not rent to anybody on a last-minute basis make it be at least 3 days in advance, C) never rent for only one night, that will be a partier for sure. D) sets your age limit higher, I use 30 years old.
just call your regular insurance company and ask them if they insure short-term rentals. I use State Farm and they were super reasonable, but make sure you tell them exactly what you're using it for.
A) do not rent to people that only have one review. B) do not rent to anybody on a last-minute basis make it be at least 3 days in advance, C) never rent for only one night, that will be a partier for sure. D) sets your age limit higher, I use 30 years old.
just call your regular insurance company and ask them if they insure short-term rentals. I use State Farm and they were super reasonable, but make sure you tell them exactly what you're using it for.
Just make sure that you specifically say that you are "using the house as a Vacation Rental, like VRBO or AirBnB". Don't say that you just have a 'rental property'.
Hey @Itay Heled
Trashed Airbnb homes makes for good click bait news, but it's not the norm.
In twelve years with investment properties in Colorado -- including LTRs, MTRs, and STRs -- we've had exactly one "trashed" home ... and that was from a long-term tenant, not a short-term rental guest. Similar story for all our vacation rental investor clients.
Set strong rules and expectations, vet guests as best you can, have robust insurance and carry on.
thanks James,
what is your vet process for Airbnb guests? other than look at their reviews what else
are you doing?
Hey @Itay Heled, just to be sure, you are insured with a correct policy for short term rentals right?
If not, stop renting right now and get that squared away asap. Not having the right policy will mean no coverage if there is a serious incident.
AirBNB does provide the Aircover (which is not insurance) that might help cover any damage. It can be a pain to get things covered and you need plenty of proof of damage.
We don't rent our house for less than 3 days, I don't allow autobooking and chat with each and every guest to get a feel for them. I don't rent to anyone under 25.
@Andrew Steffens
As some of you may remember, I am in the process of starting an STR and have two bookings for the summer already which I am excited about! But also a bit nervous because of the exact concern/question brought up by the OP here.
I have to say that the overwhelming positive responses here are encouraging and reassuring and offering some relief relative to what seems to be very few bad experiences from those who have had managed STRs for a while.
Appreciate everyone’s comments on this topic!
Thanks
Short-term rentals come with risks, but proper screening can help protect your property! While Airbnb provides some verification, it’s limited, and you don’t always know who’s actually staying in your home. If you're accepting bookings from VRBO, Booking.com, or direct reservations, screening guests yourself is even more important.
✅ ID Verification – Confirms each guest’s identity, not just the person making the booking. This helps prevent fraud and unauthorized stays.
✅ Judgments & Liens Search – Since these no longer appear on credit reports, a separate check can uncover unpaid debts or past legal issues.
✅ Criminal Background Check – A nationwide search can flag any major concerns before handing over the keys.
✅ Eviction History – If a guest has a history of past evictions, that’s a huge red flag for potential property damage.
✅ Verified Income Data – If offering mid-term stays, checking bank deposit history can help confirm financial responsibility.
For last-minute guests or those with little rental history, it’s reasonable to request verification for additional occupants.
The best way to minimize risk is to treat guest screening just as seriously as long-term tenant screening. A little extra diligence upfront can prevent major headaches later!
Hey there Itay - It’s totally normal to feel worried, especially with a larger group and minimal guest history. One way to protect yourself is to ask for the names and IDs of all guests, even if Airbnb doesn’t offer full background checks. For added security, you can use noise monitoring devices like Minut or send someone for a quick check-in, especially during longer stays.
Make sure your house rules are super clear — no parties, noise limits, and a strict guest count. Also, consider short-term rental insurance for extra coverage, especially for bookings outside Airbnb. Keeping open communication with guests while reinforcing expectations goes a long way in preventing issues. Let me know if you’d like more details on any of this!
I agree that short-term rentals usually include some degree of risk and that occasionally, items break or damage themselves. However, being proactive with guest screening, clear communication, and using proper insurance can help reduce those risks.
We make sure our properties are covered by the right insurance, which is important for all platforms. We screen all guests and don’t accept anyone under 25 or one-night bookings. We also check reviews to make sure they’re reliable. Clear communication is key, so we always explain house rules upfront to set expectations.
You are getting quite varied feedback, and this will likely only add to the confusion. I do not screen guests. I have instant book turned on for both VRBO and Airbnb and do not do much for direct bookings either. I've even rented to people with few to no reviews and with less than 5 stars without incident. I currently have 2 guests staying in 2 different properties, one has 4.5* and the other has 4. The one with 4 even had a review from a host that said they would never recommend or rent to this guest again. I spoke with the guest and felt comfortable. There are always two sides to each story. I figure, hotels don't screen and no level of screening I can do will eliminate any real risk.
The only (small) damage I've had is from children, generally unwatched by parents in my humble opinion, staining and breaking things, which have been covered by Airbnb / VRBO - and that was only twice, and nominal damage. (5 years doing STRs). Otherwise, I had significant damage followed by a legal suit with a LTR. As others have said, the risk of serious in STR is not nonexistent but not what some folks make it out to be.
What I do to help mitigate risk:
1. I have properties more on the luxury side so the nightly rate almost eliminates riskier people - they just aren't willing to pay higher rates and trash the place. Not sure if your property can sustain higher rates or not..
2. I have a 7 night minimum (also a 29 night maximum) and very rarely allow 5 night stays to fill gaps and then, only in high season with very high rates.
3. I don't allow a ton of guests (I even eliminated sofa beds). I allow 2 people per bedroom with 2 king beds (further pushing my guests without kids). I know many try to get as many people as possible for occupancy and higher rates, when I allowed 2 on a sofa bed, I had more damage. My rates and occupancy have not suffered, I'd maybe argue that they are better, and my ideal guest has changed (two couples, retirees, older families). And those that still arrive with families have been stellar.
4. As others have said, YOU MUST HAVE A STR INSURANCE POLICY. This is for liability more than anything else. I wouldn't just worry about your property being trashed but your livelihood.
5. This last point isn't so much about mitigating risk but a suggestion as a STR host. Treat people the way you would like to be treated and you will be on your way to success. Don't assume and micromanage everything about your short term rental or you will see it in your reviews. I cringe when I hear stories of people watching their doorbell camera, backyard cams etc., and generally being invasive with their questions. This is the hospitality business, if you can't let go a bit, it may not be right for you.
Hi Itay, as an STR host and co-host in Metro Atlanta, I understand your concerns. Protecting your property comes down to smart screening, clear house rules, STR insurance, and monitoring tools. Require ID verification, avoid last-minute/one-night bookings, and use smart locks, Ring cameras, and noise monitors to deter parties. Airbnb’s AirCover helps, but STR insurance is a must, especially for VRBO/Booking.com. Setting higher minimum stays and strategic pricing also attracts responsible guests. Wishing you a smooth hosting experience!
Hi Itay, as an STR host and co-host in Metro Atlanta, I understand your concerns. Protecting your property comes down to smart screening, clear house rules, STR insurance, and monitoring tools. Require ID verification, avoid last-minute/one-night bookings, and use smart locks, Ring cameras, and noise monitors to deter parties. Airbnb’s AirCover helps, but STR insurance is a must, especially for VRBO/Booking.com. Setting higher minimum stays and strategic pricing also attracts responsible guests. Wishing you a smooth hosting experience!
Hi Anja and thanks for your your reply,
who are you asking for ID?
what exactly you mean by "smart screening"?
on VRBO reservation I have there is zero information other than the name . I was told i can add a deposit from a VRBO guests
I have dozens of STR's. I have been doing it since the 90's before airbnb and VRBO.
I have actually never had anyone trash it. Now there is rarely a dish not done.
Once someone broke a AC and paid for it, Once someone had a dog that was not suppose to air bnb made them replace our couch. $1000.
I would not worry much about it. It might happen. No likely.