Hello from San Francisco! Is the Bay Area right for me?

Hello from San Francisco! Is the Bay Area right for me?

San Francisco, CA · Member since 2015 · 3 posts · 3 votes

Hi everyone, 

I'm hugely impressed with the quality of information I've found here so far, so I wanted to say hi and introduce myself. My name is Max, and I'm a San Francisco native. I'm in my late 20's and a Mechanical Engineer at Apple. 

I'm here for 2 reasons: 1) I bought my primary residence in San Francisco in late 2014 and I caught the "bug" of real estate - I just can't stop looking at properties! I find it hugely entertaining. 2) All of the successful folks I've known in life have owned several rental properties, and really enjoyed the rental incomes as a retirement cashflow later in their lives. 

So, I'm interested in learning more about purchasing rental properties. 

I have a little over $325k in the stock market right now and I'd like to diversify my overall investments by moving a hefty portion of this into a rental property downpayment. My struggle is this: Ideally I would like to buy my first rental property within driving distance so that I can manage it myself - but as we all know, the Bay Area is quite expensive. Is the Bay Area really only a good deal if you're looking to make money on raising property values? Is it not a good cash flow environment? Would I gain a better cash return if I look in other markets, possibly out of state? 

Or, if investing in a place in the Bay Area is possible for someone with my amount of free cash, what sorts of properties / areas do you recommend looking in? 

Another question is: If I look in a cheaper out-of-state market where I would have enough for all-cash (or at least much more than 20% down), is this even an option you would recommend? It seems to me that with interest rates so low, I'd be a fool to put more than 20% down on a place no matter where it is. Am I missing something? Why DO people make all-cash offers? Related to this question is - would it be a better overall investment to pay down my current mortgage in big chunks over the next few years so that I can own my home outright within the next ~7years, and THEN start looking at rental properties?  (I realize that this is more of a question for a financial advisor, but just curious if anyone else has been in the same boat!)

I realize these questions are a bit broad, and I'll look forward to narrowing my focus (and my questions) as I learn more. 

Thanks!

-Max

2Reply
542 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Broker · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 51 posts · 48 votes
11y
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

@Max Maloney

I generate 12%+ Cash on Cash and 20%+ Internal Rates of Return on every out-of-state investment.  Investing locally means you will likely loose money for several years, before you're able to raise rents sufficiently to cash flow.

My belief is that investing for appreciation is speculation.  You cannot predict appreciation.

Jon - You do realize that IRR calculations/forecasts are heavily weighted to the exit price? Therefore you're blatantly contradicting yourself saying that you get 20%+ IRRs, but you think investing appreciation is speculation and you can't predict appreciation.

I find it very hard to believe that you can find a stabilized out of state property (like one Max would hypothetically be investing in) that can generate a 20%+ IRR. The only way you're going to get to a 20%+ IRR, is through value add short term investing or unrealistic assumptions. Any one can throw out claims like you have above, but I'd be very interested to see your financial models and assumptions to see how realistic they really are.

Additionally, you need to realize that no matter how high prices currently are in the Bay Area, they have only just now reached pre-recession levels. There's plenty of room for the Bay Area to continue this upward trend because of land scarcity, much more difficult lending practices than 2005, job growth, income growth, and pent-up demand from the Millennial generation. Many out of state markets have had a huge run up in recent years and have now greatly surpassed their pre-recession levels and that throws up a big red flag for me. 

Additionally, there are plenty of properties locally that can cash flow day 1. I purchased an A+ located $1M SFR this year, that generates a 9% cash-on-cash return in the East Bay. Real estate is an industry built upon inefficiency, all it takes is a little digging and work to find a truly good deal.

Over the past 20 years (which includes 10 years of the worst market in recent history), SF home prices have increased 3.5x and SJ homes have increased 4x. Rather than simply saying appreciation is speculation, I challenge you to show me any market in the US that has experienced appreciation anywhere close to that. Additionally, although there's no rental data going back that far in history, I also guarantee that rents have experienced similar (or quite possibly more) exponential growth. 

Are you telling me that you'd rather buy something turnkey in the Midwest that will most likely increase in price 2x over the next 30 years and maybe see rents increase 2x, rather than property in the Bay Area that will not only make you a multi-millionaire in 30 years or sooner when the loan's fully paid off, but will also be spitting off more rental cash flow than you know what to do with? Also what do you think is going to happen when turnkey investors eventually start exiting the popular out of state markets en masse?

The majority of out of state investing is shortsighted and built upon unrealistic assumptions and inflated numbers. Invest in solid property that pencils out, in a market with strong fundamentals, lock a loan in for 30 years and you'll kill it in the long run. 

See this reply in the discussion

193 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    @Account Closed

    Also FYI the condos are now worth a bit more than I paid for them while the properties in Austin have almost doubled in value.

    So, if you're buying for appreciation, I would suggest learning about market cycles because of you get your timing wrong, you'll be in for a long wait until a full market ca les had occurred and you build equity.

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    "market cycle"

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Account Closed

    I own some condos in San Bruno that I paid $350k for each in 2006.  At that time, they rented for $1,200.

    I also acquired a single family rental in Dallas for $90k that rented for $1,200.  Which is better for cash flow generation?

    $350,000 : $1,200 vs. $90,000 : $1,200

     For what, one month?  That is the problem with you touting RTP for one period in time.  It means nothing.  Now the San Bruno rents probably increased a minimum of 7% annually over that time so you'd be collecting over $2,200 a month.  Dallas at 3%?  only $1,565.   That's almost $16,600 a year more.  Plus compare the Texas tax increase to the Prop 13 tax in 2015!  

    But NOW you are being very evasive about my original comment to your statement about RTP ratios.  I appreciate your continued participation but please answer that question.  

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Account Closed

    Also FYI the condos are now worth a bit more than I paid for them while the properties in Austin have almost doubled in value.

    So, if you're buying for appreciation, I would suggest learning about market cycles because of you get your timing wrong, you'll be in for a long wait until a full market ca les had occurred and you build equity.

     You are the one that needs to understand market cycles if you bought in 2006 and the value is just a little more than what you paid.  I've bought in everyone of the last five market cycles and have doubled the value on each property in about 2 years on every one but the last and I'm up almost $300,000 on that but I have 3 more years to get the doubling.  

    And I am an out of state investor.  I just happen to invest in the more profitable states like Hawaii and CA.  

  • Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2015 · 84 posts · 8 votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Max Maloney

    With $325k, I could invest out of state in 9 properties and generate $3,600 per month, $43,000 per year in cash flow.  In addition, the appreciation would likely be more than 10% per year.

     i like it.

  • Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2015 · 84 posts · 8 votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    Max,

    Welcome to Biggerpockets. Congrats on generating so much interests on your thread.  I guess anyone with half a brain can tell who's right and who's blowing smoke.  :-) 

    My business partner was a mechanical engineer who hit it big with a start up company in 2000 and retired at the age of 29.  All sort of financial advisors said they would invest and take care of his money.  At 29 years of age with 8 figures in the bank, he gave some money to these fools. They managed to lose a couple millions of his money. He did one thing right by buying a couple of properties in Palo Alto.  They have appreciated in millions.  I guess you can say he made back the money that the financial advisors managed to lose for him.  LOL!!!

    You're doing quite well for a young man. Like anything in life, the happy time will end. You just don't know when. Try to save and invest the money wisely so the 2nd half of your life will be much more comfortable than the 1st half. I suggest you set some goals and try to get there in the shortest amount of time with the least amount of risk.  Time is the most precious commodity in this world, and money can buy you time. Can I say FREEEEEEEEDOM?

    I wish you the best of luck.

     Did they put him in coconut trees in Bolivia?

  • Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2015 · 84 posts · 8 votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Account Closed

    Also FYI the condos are now worth a bit more than I paid for them while the properties in Austin have almost doubled in value.

    So, if you're buying for appreciation, I would suggest learning about market cycles because of you get your timing wrong, you'll be in for a long wait until a full market ca les had occurred and you build equity.

     You are the one that needs to understand market cycles if you bought in 2006 and the value is just a little more than what you paid.  I've bought in everyone of the last five market cycles and have doubled the value on each property in about 2 years on every one but the last and I'm up almost $300,000 on that but I have 3 more years to get the doubling.  

    And I am an out of state investor.  I just happen to invest in the more profitable states like Hawaii and CA.  

     You think Kapiolani Terrace studios can hit  $300,000?  Its at $259,000 now. in say 2 years.

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

     You think Kapiolani Terrace studios can hit  $300,000?  Its at $259,000 now. in say 2 years.

    http://www.oahure.com/SearchMLS.php?PropertyType=C...

    Everything in escrow or pending. Just over $600sf and reasonable maintenance fee.  I'm not familiar with the building.  I concentrate on the Gold Coast, Diamond Head and around the International Market Place.  No doubt those will increase in value as Waikiki gentrifies even more  Affordable and PARKING!  

    http://honolulu.craigslist.org/oah/apa/5132598581....

    $1200 rents.  I can see demand for these units increasing over the next few years.

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    @Account Closed

    Yes I that. And Bob you're completely incorrect about rent growth. Rent growth in north Dallas (Richardson, Rowlett, etc.) has trumped rent growth in San Bruno. If you had experience investing in these markets you would know that.

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    @Account Closed

    Yes, per month.

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    For all the naive San Franciscans on this post that think prices only appreciate.  If you're not familiar with Dr.Glenn Mueller, google him.  He is the foremost expert in the U.S. on market cycles.

  • Gordon CuffePro Member
    Investor · Roseville, CA · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 587 votes
    11y

    This thread is quite a hot topic and I like all the opinions. You could just do the math on properties in your market and then compare them to a market in Sacramento then out of state and decide. When looking out of state you should not even think about appreciation. So you would invest there for true net income on the money invested.

     You can compare that with a house around Sacramento that you could buy at 220k with a 44k down payment that would have a piti payment of $1200.0 per month that would rent for $1400.0 per month. You could also look for a great deal and get that same house for 180k and put 20k into it so at least you have another 20k of equity built into it even after your down payment. As the Bay area goes up in value so does Sacamento. The numbers just are not as big. Just remember that we have seen quite a big run up in values the last three years so the odds of that happening the next three years are very very low. California has big increases in values for a few years then a number of years of zero to negative appreciation.

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Account Closed

    Yes I that. And Bob you're completely incorrect about rent growth. Rent growth in north Dallas (Richardson, Rowlett, etc.) has trumped rent growth in San Bruno. If you had experience investing in these markets you would know that.

     Jon I don't invest in every little town in Northern CA or Texas.  Can you give me a source for your rent growth numbers in the two locations you mentioned and over what period of time?  Can you also discuss the RTP ratio and how it has any meaningful relationship to profitability?

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    11y

    @Account Closed

    as you know I am pretty familiar with both sides of this debate.. and Not sure many have owned more out of state SFR rentals than myself... But one thing we must consider and no one is talking about... if there is a price constriction in the bay area there can be a price constriction in ANY of the other cash flow markets.

    My first foray into HML in Detroit the homes were appraising at 120 to 140k in 2002.. we loaned 60% on HML... those homes dropped in some cases to worthless in 10 years. and then as investors came back on the scene maybe get back to 20 to 50k.. now I know your point is going to be that's Detroit Jobs etc.

    I also was loaning in Atlanta one of the largest economies in the US... same numbers 120 to 160k nice homes 5 to 20 years old.. when they cratered they got down to 20 to 40k.. I bought 54 of them at the bottom.. some were new construction I bought for 40k each never lived in. they have of course come back up about 100%..

    So yes we have cash flow markets but cash flow markets can go down.. the rents in Detroit and Atlanta never changed.. the only thing that changed was returns for those that were gutsy enough to invest in 09 2010. there cash flow was and is great at those numbers.

    So one can put historic appreciation on any market but its not reality .. it may rise it could very well fall. Especially if you buying in newer neighborhoods and saturating them with renters.. that will kill values all on its on.. the only value with be an investor backing into a cash flow number.. Whereas in CA or BAy Area if you have a home as a rental you WILL sell it to an Onwer occ no problem.. not the same out east... You get predominance of rentals and your property is for ever a rental..  And if you know that then fine its your call. But to think these will appreciate at all is really speculative and frankly based on my getting into this business in 2000 not reality or even remotely.. Austin Excluded.. Dallas has had some run ups.. but a lot of that is Herd mentality by investors..

    If you took the CA investor completely out of the market.. the prices in many of the mid west markets would be much lower than they already are.. As the local investors back into value ONLY on rent income.. and Most do not live anywhere near their rentals.

    Were as If you live in SF you live right down the street from your rental.. or In Palo Alto or Cupertino or where have you.. there is no rental stigma

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    @Jay Hinrichs

    Thanks for joining the discussion.

    I don't invest in Detroit or Michigan for that matter.

    Like I said, I am not apposed to investing locally. In fact today I'm touring some small multifamily and redevelopment projects I might get involved with.

    That said, in invest in the locations I do based on a thorough analysis of population and job growth forecasts, teen analysis (wealth moving from high to low tax states, primarily middle class, price/rent ratios, market cycles and a consideration of various other items (ex. masterplans).

    Yes, you are right. You cannot predict appreciation, but based on my experience over the last ten years, I can predict cash flow at a much higher accuracy rate.

    You're also right, cash flow can go down, but in Austin as well as the other markets I'm in that are experiencing tremendous job and population growth...hence demand for rentals... It's unlikely.

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    @Jay Hinrichs

    I invest in neighborhoods only that are 80% owner occupied, so it's doubtful they'll become "forever a rental". If I see that negative trend occurring, I sell.

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    For those of you who have no experience investing out of state, consider the town of Frisco in North Dallas. It's population has grown over 400% in the last two years (google it).  I know Craig Hall who owns Hall Office Park in Frisco. Coincidentally he also flips wineries in Napa/Sonoma.

    Do you know where all the people who lost jobs as a result of the recession and tech boom moved?

    They moved to TX.  The resulting middle class wealth migration to places like TX is dramatic.  

    And that trend is not short term. It is long-term.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    11y

    @Account Closed

    I believe Oregon is the number one in migration state from CA... at least if it is not its number 2.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    11y

    @Account Closed

      its good to have these lively discussions I think folks that are not as keen as you are can learn something from both camps..

    We have been doing pretty good in Sac these days doing flips for retail.  Same with Dallas and Houston  Portland though is just so competitive you talk about a place that is tough.. its not like bay area stuff does not get bid up by 100k but it goes in a matter of hours and you better have your money lined up these deals close in 3 to 7 business days if you want to be competitive. 

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    As others have posted in this board, there are decent returns that can be generated in every market, but when you're investing for appreciation be careful to not be caught on the wrong side of the curve. Otherwise, you'll have no return until the market improves and you can sell or refi and pull cash out.

    There are infinite strategies in real estate and I'm  convince decent returns can be generated in every market, however I'm a conservative investor and though I own investments locally, I've chosen not to invest a large amount of my capital in old properties purely for appreciation which may or may not be realized. i generate 12%+ of my return from cash flow alone and do this in all markets and all cycles...which protects me from down markets.

    I'm done posting on this topic.

    Feel free to reach out to me if you have specific questions.  I'm happy to share what I know.

    Best of luck 

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    @Jay Hinrichs

    I spent time in Portland last year. It's an interesting market I do t know a lot about, but if you've got a good deal and are looking for equity partners, I've got investors who might have an interest investing in the Silicon Forest.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    11y

    @Account Closed

      PDX is red hot  its stand in line for deals and investors are not the problem its the deals.

    I only do new construction here in PDX.. its not as competitive.. everyone and their brother with a hammer wants to do rehabs.. but ground up that is a little easier for us to compete in.  breaking ground next week on a 27 lot sub... so I know I have at least 27 jobs for the next 12 months without having to hunt for deals  :)

    And a last point of the Texas west coast debate.. if Oregon was nearly as business friendly as Texas or a South Carolina for example this place would Literally explode. But those that know Oregon.. Know that those that run the state have the attitude we are Oregon everyone wants to live here and be us.. so if you want to come here you have to pay to play. 

    Instead of what Texas and SC do and that is roll out the red carpet for business. SC took the Boeing 787 plant from Washington and darn near snagged the whole company !!

    And guess were I am heavily invested ( within 3 to 5 miles of Boeing SC)

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    http://recenter.tamu.edu/pdf/1794.pdf

    @Amit M.

    Read the link above.  Fortunately smoking grass will likely be legalized soon in your neck of the woods :-)

     This does not support your assertion that Dallas has averaged 5% appreciation over the last 20 years. Report stops at 2004. Fail. 

    ----------

    Max- it absolutely maxes sense to look at 2-4 (value added is best) in the Bay Area as an investment. Plus given your job and down payment, you can either absorb a small negative or put a bit more done to compensate. You'd probably have a hard time getting something at a decent price in SF proper (unless you get lucky), but Daly city, Oakland, etc . Would be good markets to plant seeds in.  Depending on market cycle and overall economy, their values may fluctuate a bit more, but 5-10 years from now you'll very likely be cash flowing nicely and have a nice appreciation gain. Then you borrow against that gain (and/or the gain in your primary) and buy again. That's what I did. Worked like a charm :)

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 577 posts · 203 votes
    11y

    @Jay Hinrichs

    Makes sense. Good call.

    Lots of markets getting uncomfortably near peaks now, but I'll continue investing in deals that generate my return targets primarily through cash flow.

    TX is over. No longer doing deals here.

    The SouthEast is where I'm focusing. I still see lots of opportunity as the wealth migration continues moving from NYC south.

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y

    Dang Jon,  How ya making any money doing deals like these two from your website?  Your Austin property only appreciated LESS than $3,000 over 8 years!!!  PTR ratio .9%!!!  You can get that IN state plus a few hundred thousand dollars in appreciation.

    Hell property two you LOST about $19,000 in value in less than a year!!!!!

    PTR ratio?  Again .9%again!!!  

    So are you making your money in tax write offs?   LOL

    8433 Alum Rock Drive

    Austin, TX 78747

    3 Bed / 2 Bath
    Year Built: 2002
    House Size: 1,325 Sq Ft
    Lot Size: 6,900 Sq Ft

    SUMMARY

    • Bank REO acquired for $105,000 in 2007
    • Comparable properties were selling for $119,000+
    • Located in upscale neighborhood 10 miles south of downtown Austin
    • Renting for $1,095 per month
    • Current market value: $121,929*

    9724 E WT Harris Blvd.

    Charlotte, NC 28227

    6 Bed / 3.0 Bath
    Year Built: 2009
    House Size: 2,504 Sq Ft
    Lot Size: 16,117 Sq Ft

    SUMMARY

    • Purchased from an investor for $148,000 in 2015
    • Comparable properties were selling for $175,000+
    • Located in strong middle/upper middle class neighborhood in east Charlotte
    • Renting for $1,450 per month
    • Current market value: $156,000

    @Amit M.

    @Alex Vidal

    @Jay Hinrichs

    •  Put your checkbooks away.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.