Crypto has better growth and passive income over real estate?

Crypto has better growth and passive income over real estate?

Rental Property Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2017 · 51 posts · 33 votes

Honest question, why lockup your money in real estate when over the past decade crypto (bitcoin) has better returns and you can now earn passive income and are much more liquid than buying a home? I am moving more and more of my money into crypto and selling homes to accumulate crypto assets, I can make 8.6% interest on a digital dollar that is paid monthly, doesn’t fluctuate and compounds. I also make 6% on Bitcoin and my interest is paid in bitcoin. I don’t have to deal with repairs and the other stresses of managing a property. I would love peoples thoughts on this.

5Reply
366 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
5y

You can't leverage bitcoin, you can't improve it and you have no control over it. Can't BRRR it either. REI is a lot of work, takes a long time, it's messy - so I can see the appel of something that is quick and easy!

To me in many ways crypto reminds me to my first stock investing days back in 1999, it's great until it's not.

See this reply in the discussion

114 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Robins, IA · Member since 2015 · 45 posts · 18 votes
    5y

    My thoughts. I am open to learning. Bitcoin was designed to be used as a payment system. If using it like that, the govt wants their due taxes and really makes it a large headache come tax time since you currently have to track the daily price of bitcoin and account for gains and losses in your taxes. Without some sort of regulation negating this headache it will be too burdensome to catch on as a payment system in a major way.

    Other use is as a store of value. This could work but will need a functioning internet and electricity to use as such. I prefer bullets and tools to use them. They are Actually useful in a dire situation.

    Anything else is speculation. I do also have some speculation in my portfolio so I’m not completely disregarding it.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Kevin H.:

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Hi Joe, I’m not part of any affiliate group, nor am I shilling specific cryptos as Bitcoin is way to main stream for me to move the needle. I will give you numbers though and pardon me if my math is wrong, as it should be close though if it is. First off you’re right blockfi isn’t fdic backed, I feel like the risk is worth it as I have done my own research and am comfortable with the risk. Let’s go into my scenario. I invested into btc in may of 2020, we’ll say after I bought, I put it into blockfi and haven’t sold. This is what my returns are:

    Blockfi pays a 6% APY, monthly payout that is able to be compounded and my interest is paid out in BTC:

    May 1st 2020 - purchase price: 1 BTC = $87771.57

    June 1st 2020 - BTC price $9564.95: 1.005 BTC, .BTC interest = $47.82 and my total holdings = $9612.77

    July 1st 2020 - BTC price $9153.95: 1.01 BTC, BTC interest = 45.77 and my total holdings = $9245.72

    Aug 1st - BTC = $11354.16: 1.015 BTC, BTC interest = $56.77 and total holdings = 11582.95

    Sept 1st - BTC = $11964.21: 1.02 BTC, BTC interest = $59.82 and total holdings = $12205.29

    Oct 1st - BTC = $10626.6: 1.025 BTC, BTC interest = 53.13 and holdings = $10894.93

    Nov 1st - BTC = 13662.97: 1.03 BTC, BTC interest = $68.81 and holdings = $14181.05

    Dec 1st - BTC = $29391.78: 1.035 BTC, BTC interest = $146.96 and holdings = $30436.05

    Jan 1st - BTC = $33543.77: 1.04 BTC, btc interest = $167.72 and holdings = $34909.24

    Feb 1st - Btc = $45159.5: 1.045 btc, btc interest = $225.8 and holdings = $47232.8

    Interest alone I’ve made $872.6 for 10 months, I accumulated.045 more btc which is now worth $2032.18 and my initial investment is up 438%. Again I’m not saying I am done with rei, I just feel at the moment if I $100k today and was looking to invest it, real estate has too many risk and is less attractive (excessive government printing, unemployment, high housing prices, eviction moratorium’s, etc) I personally feel it would be hard for me to yield a nice return on my money and don’t want to deal with the headaches. As stated, I can put that 100k and earn 8.6% compounded yield and can borrow on it. Yes I miss out on the appreciation of the home and tax benefits, but at the moment bitcoins roi is way better than what real estate could do for me.

    OK, first, REI has far less risk than this...mainly because you have enough control to be able to input risk controls with REI, but with this you don't.

    OK second, and this is going to be fun. Take the same $10k you invested here and multiply it by 10 to equal that $100k starting point. Now multiply your interest return by that same 10 then extrapolate it out to cover a full 12 months, and you would get a projected interest return of around $10k. That would be the same type of return as cash flow from REI.

    You would end up after 1 full year of (if I'm reading this correctly) of about $45k in value, starting from $10k...or $450k starting from $100k.

    OK. Now, I can take that same $100k, and by RE at 20cents on the dollar (20% down), which means my PV starts out $500k, and my CF would be around $6k/$100k DP per year....that's starting our at $30k/year in CF. So, if after 1 year my REI appreciated only 5% in value, my holdings would be worth $525k..which is an increase of $25K.

    Let's compare:  Both starting at $100k in cash.

    .                                                     Coins               REI
    Cash at start                                  $100k              $100k
    STarting Value of Investment          $100k              $500k
    Cash Flow/Interest 1st year           $  10K              $25k
    Note:  this means it takes 10 years to recover your cost, but I can do it in 4, so from year 5 - 10 (6 yrs) my CF is pure profit equal to $150k, but you haven't actually made a profit yet since you're still recovering your cash/cost until year 10.
    Apprec/increase value 1 yr            $472k              $525k
    ...and after that, with the reinvestment of the cash income, REI leaves BC in the dust.

  • Erie, PA · Member since 2018 · 413 posts · 348 votes
    5y

    How do you know if someone does crossfit? They will tell you

    How do you know if someone is a vegan?  They will tell you

    How do you know if someone invests in bitcoin?  They will tell you

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Kevin H.:

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Hi Joe, I’m not part of any affiliate group, nor am I shilling specific cryptos as Bitcoin is way to main stream for me to move the needle. I will give you numbers though and pardon me if my math is wrong, as it should be close though if it is. First off you’re right blockfi isn’t fdic backed, I feel like the risk is worth it as I have done my own research and am comfortable with the risk. Let’s go into my scenario. I invested into btc in may of 2020, we’ll say after I bought, I put it into blockfi and haven’t sold. This is what my returns are:

    Blockfi pays a 6% APY, monthly payout that is able to be compounded and my interest is paid out in BTC:

    May 1st 2020 - purchase price: 1 BTC = $87771.57

    June 1st 2020 - BTC price $9564.95: 1.005 BTC, .BTC interest = $47.82 and my total holdings = $9612.77

    July 1st 2020 - BTC price $9153.95: 1.01 BTC, BTC interest = 45.77 and my total holdings = $9245.72

    Aug 1st - BTC = $11354.16: 1.015 BTC, BTC interest = $56.77 and total holdings = 11582.95

    Sept 1st - BTC = $11964.21: 1.02 BTC, BTC interest = $59.82 and total holdings = $12205.29

    Oct 1st - BTC = $10626.6: 1.025 BTC, BTC interest = 53.13 and holdings = $10894.93

    Nov 1st - BTC = 13662.97: 1.03 BTC, BTC interest = $68.81 and holdings = $14181.05

    Dec 1st - BTC = $29391.78: 1.035 BTC, BTC interest = $146.96 and holdings = $30436.05

    Jan 1st - BTC = $33543.77: 1.04 BTC, btc interest = $167.72 and holdings = $34909.24

    Feb 1st - Btc = $45159.5: 1.045 btc, btc interest = $225.8 and holdings = $47232.8

    Interest alone I’ve made $872.6 for 10 months, I accumulated.045 more btc which is now worth $2032.18 and my initial investment is up 438%. Again I’m not saying I am done with rei, I just feel at the moment if I $100k today and was looking to invest it, real estate has too many risk and is less attractive (excessive government printing, unemployment, high housing prices, eviction moratorium’s, etc) I personally feel it would be hard for me to yield a nice return on my money and don’t want to deal with the headaches. As stated, I can put that 100k and earn 8.6% compounded yield and can borrow on it. Yes I miss out on the appreciation of the home and tax benefits, but at the moment bitcoins roi is way better than what real estate could do for me.

    OK, first, REI has far less risk than this...mainly because you have enough control to be able to input risk controls with REI, but with this you don't.

    OK second, and this is going to be fun. Take the same $10k you invested here and multiply it by 10 to equal that $100k starting point. Now multiply your interest return by that same 10 then extrapolate it out to cover a full 12 months, and you would get a projected interest return of around $10k. That would be the same type of return as cash flow from REI.

    You would end up after 1 full year of (if I'm reading this correctly) of about $45k in value, starting from $10k...or $450k starting from $100k.

    OK. Now, I can take that same $100k, and by RE at 20cents on the dollar (20% down), which means my PV starts out $500k, and my CF would be around $6k/$100k DP per year....that's starting our at $30k/year in CF. So, if after 1 year my REI appreciated only 5% in value, my holdings would be worth $525k..which is an increase of $25K.

    Let's compare:  Both starting at $100k in cash.

    .                                                     Coins               REI
    Cash at start                                  $100k              $100k
    STarting Value of Investment          $100k              $500k
    Cash Flow/Interest 1st year           $  10K              $25k
    Note:  this means it takes 10 years to recover your cost, but I can do it in 4, so from year 5 - 10 (6 yrs) my CF is pure profit equal to $150k, but you haven't actually made a profit yet since you're still recovering your cash/cost until year 10.
    Apprec/increase value 1 yr            $472k              $525k
    ...and after that, with the reinvestment of the cash income, REI leaves BC in the dust.

     Joe you do realize btc has returned over 80,000% over the last 7 years? 

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Matt R.:
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Kevin H.:

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Hi Joe, I’m not part of any affiliate group, nor am I shilling specific cryptos as Bitcoin is way to main stream for me to move the needle. I will give you numbers though and pardon me if my math is wrong, as it should be close though if it is. First off you’re right blockfi isn’t fdic backed, I feel like the risk is worth it as I have done my own research and am comfortable with the risk. Let’s go into my scenario. I invested into btc in may of 2020, we’ll say after I bought, I put it into blockfi and haven’t sold. This is what my returns are:

    Blockfi pays a 6% APY, monthly payout that is able to be compounded and my interest is paid out in BTC:

    May 1st 2020 - purchase price: 1 BTC = $87771.57

    June 1st 2020 - BTC price $9564.95: 1.005 BTC, .BTC interest = $47.82 and my total holdings = $9612.77

    July 1st 2020 - BTC price $9153.95: 1.01 BTC, BTC interest = 45.77 and my total holdings = $9245.72

    Aug 1st - BTC = $11354.16: 1.015 BTC, BTC interest = $56.77 and total holdings = 11582.95

    Sept 1st - BTC = $11964.21: 1.02 BTC, BTC interest = $59.82 and total holdings = $12205.29

    Oct 1st - BTC = $10626.6: 1.025 BTC, BTC interest = 53.13 and holdings = $10894.93

    Nov 1st - BTC = 13662.97: 1.03 BTC, BTC interest = $68.81 and holdings = $14181.05

    Dec 1st - BTC = $29391.78: 1.035 BTC, BTC interest = $146.96 and holdings = $30436.05

    Jan 1st - BTC = $33543.77: 1.04 BTC, btc interest = $167.72 and holdings = $34909.24

    Feb 1st - Btc = $45159.5: 1.045 btc, btc interest = $225.8 and holdings = $47232.8

    Interest alone I’ve made $872.6 for 10 months, I accumulated.045 more btc which is now worth $2032.18 and my initial investment is up 438%. Again I’m not saying I am done with rei, I just feel at the moment if I $100k today and was looking to invest it, real estate has too many risk and is less attractive (excessive government printing, unemployment, high housing prices, eviction moratorium’s, etc) I personally feel it would be hard for me to yield a nice return on my money and don’t want to deal with the headaches. As stated, I can put that 100k and earn 8.6% compounded yield and can borrow on it. Yes I miss out on the appreciation of the home and tax benefits, but at the moment bitcoins roi is way better than what real estate could do for me.

    OK, first, REI has far less risk than this...mainly because you have enough control to be able to input risk controls with REI, but with this you don't.

    OK second, and this is going to be fun. Take the same $10k you invested here and multiply it by 10 to equal that $100k starting point. Now multiply your interest return by that same 10 then extrapolate it out to cover a full 12 months, and you would get a projected interest return of around $10k. That would be the same type of return as cash flow from REI.

    You would end up after 1 full year of (if I'm reading this correctly) of about $45k in value, starting from $10k...or $450k starting from $100k.

    OK. Now, I can take that same $100k, and by RE at 20cents on the dollar (20% down), which means my PV starts out $500k, and my CF would be around $6k/$100k DP per year....that's starting our at $30k/year in CF. So, if after 1 year my REI appreciated only 5% in value, my holdings would be worth $525k..which is an increase of $25K.

    Let's compare:  Both starting at $100k in cash.

    .                                                     Coins               REI
    Cash at start                                  $100k              $100k
    STarting Value of Investment          $100k              $500k
    Cash Flow/Interest 1st year           $  10K              $25k
    Note:  this means it takes 10 years to recover your cost, but I can do it in 4, so from year 5 - 10 (6 yrs) my CF is pure profit equal to $150k, but you haven't actually made a profit yet since you're still recovering your cash/cost until year 10.
    Apprec/increase value 1 yr            $472k              $525k
    ...and after that, with the reinvestment of the cash income, REI leaves BC in the dust.

     Joe you do realize btc has returned over 80,000% over the last 7 years? 

     To one person?

  • Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2015 · 346 posts · 170 votes
    5y

    @Kevin H.

    My opinion:

    I invest in Multifamily for the cash flow

    I’m cash flowing more than 20% per month

    I got the properties cheap and rents are high.

    Once my NOI get lower than 8% then I'll probably consider crypto maybe to diversify asset classes.

    I do see a lot of potential with crypto in the near future of what it could be so for that reason is very hard to ignore it.

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Matt R.:
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Kevin H.:

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Hi Joe, I’m not part of any affiliate group, nor am I shilling specific cryptos as Bitcoin is way to main stream for me to move the needle. I will give you numbers though and pardon me if my math is wrong, as it should be close though if it is. First off you’re right blockfi isn’t fdic backed, I feel like the risk is worth it as I have done my own research and am comfortable with the risk. Let’s go into my scenario. I invested into btc in may of 2020, we’ll say after I bought, I put it into blockfi and haven’t sold. This is what my returns are:

    Blockfi pays a 6% APY, monthly payout that is able to be compounded and my interest is paid out in BTC:

    May 1st 2020 - purchase price: 1 BTC = $87771.57

    June 1st 2020 - BTC price $9564.95: 1.005 BTC, .BTC interest = $47.82 and my total holdings = $9612.77

    July 1st 2020 - BTC price $9153.95: 1.01 BTC, BTC interest = 45.77 and my total holdings = $9245.72

    Aug 1st - BTC = $11354.16: 1.015 BTC, BTC interest = $56.77 and total holdings = 11582.95

    Sept 1st - BTC = $11964.21: 1.02 BTC, BTC interest = $59.82 and total holdings = $12205.29

    Oct 1st - BTC = $10626.6: 1.025 BTC, BTC interest = 53.13 and holdings = $10894.93

    Nov 1st - BTC = 13662.97: 1.03 BTC, BTC interest = $68.81 and holdings = $14181.05

    Dec 1st - BTC = $29391.78: 1.035 BTC, BTC interest = $146.96 and holdings = $30436.05

    Jan 1st - BTC = $33543.77: 1.04 BTC, btc interest = $167.72 and holdings = $34909.24

    Feb 1st - Btc = $45159.5: 1.045 btc, btc interest = $225.8 and holdings = $47232.8

    Interest alone I’ve made $872.6 for 10 months, I accumulated.045 more btc which is now worth $2032.18 and my initial investment is up 438%. Again I’m not saying I am done with rei, I just feel at the moment if I $100k today and was looking to invest it, real estate has too many risk and is less attractive (excessive government printing, unemployment, high housing prices, eviction moratorium’s, etc) I personally feel it would be hard for me to yield a nice return on my money and don’t want to deal with the headaches. As stated, I can put that 100k and earn 8.6% compounded yield and can borrow on it. Yes I miss out on the appreciation of the home and tax benefits, but at the moment bitcoins roi is way better than what real estate could do for me.

    OK, first, REI has far less risk than this...mainly because you have enough control to be able to input risk controls with REI, but with this you don't.

    OK second, and this is going to be fun. Take the same $10k you invested here and multiply it by 10 to equal that $100k starting point. Now multiply your interest return by that same 10 then extrapolate it out to cover a full 12 months, and you would get a projected interest return of around $10k. That would be the same type of return as cash flow from REI.

    You would end up after 1 full year of (if I'm reading this correctly) of about $45k in value, starting from $10k...or $450k starting from $100k.

    OK. Now, I can take that same $100k, and by RE at 20cents on the dollar (20% down), which means my PV starts out $500k, and my CF would be around $6k/$100k DP per year....that's starting our at $30k/year in CF. So, if after 1 year my REI appreciated only 5% in value, my holdings would be worth $525k..which is an increase of $25K.

    Let's compare:  Both starting at $100k in cash.

    .                                                     Coins               REI
    Cash at start                                  $100k              $100k
    STarting Value of Investment          $100k              $500k
    Cash Flow/Interest 1st year           $  10K              $25k
    Note:  this means it takes 10 years to recover your cost, but I can do it in 4, so from year 5 - 10 (6 yrs) my CF is pure profit equal to $150k, but you haven't actually made a profit yet since you're still recovering your cash/cost until year 10.
    Apprec/increase value 1 yr            $472k              $525k
    ...and after that, with the reinvestment of the cash income, REI leaves BC in the dust.

     Joe you do realize btc has returned over 80,000% over the last 7 years? 

     To one person?

    To more than one person. The entire btc asset is at 80k% appreciation last 7 years. There is an immutable record of those exact numbers of individual wallets on the btc ledger. Many are public and most remain anonymous. It is in the 1000s. If you are beating btc with rentals that is quite the accomplishment. Hats off! 

  • Real Estate Agent · Allentown, NJ · Member since 2014 · 39 posts · 44 votes
    5y

    You can't live inside a bitcoin. Enjoy the ride but diversify. 

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    Fidelity here is investing as VC/LP to those company that's trying to build infrastructure for crypto, there're about 20 companies.

    Also Auntie Cathie of ARKK keeps promoting bitcoin as well thru SQ.

  • Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Kevin H.

    Just closed on a little rental today.seller told me he’s putting the money into crypto. Thinks Bitcoin will hit 200k by year end.

  • Member since 2019 · 32 posts · 12 votes
    5y

    @Kevin H. I use blockfi GUSD to save for my real estate. The reason to own real estate with debt is that you are best preparing for inflation. Ideally, you have hard assets that maintain their value and you pay off your inflated away debt. But real estate investing with BBBR smokes other assets and anyone that says bitcoin is the future may be right but don't mistake a speculation with an investment. The BTC/USD rate versus something that generates cash are two different things. Also expect that more entrants will compete away an 8.6% stable coin return over time, it's probably only good for the next couple of year. While it's there I'm taking it. But don't count out IRR versus cash return. IRR for a Houston property I own is renting for 4200 a month with a 3000 mortgage. The equity pay down + cash flow ends up being 17% that will grow to 26% IRR per year over time.

  • Chris HenryPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Cottonwood, AZ · Member since 2020 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    5y

    @Kevin H. Why not have your tenants pay you in crypto?

  • Lender · Tucson, AZ · Member since 2016 · 20 posts · 7 votes
    5y

    Great comments on this thread! I dig it!

    @Kevin H. Bitcoin is great, blockchain is here to stay. However, there is a lot of uncertainty with the latest SEC ruling of XRP. This ruling will continue to set precedence over the crypto market. I hope that by other nations continuing to adopt crypto our officials will choose to gain a solid understanding before making any drastic decisions. Ill attach a link at the end that should help those interested gain a good understanding of the obstacles. In addition, in my opinion Bitcoin will continue to be a novelty item. When it comes to utility there are other coins that exceed Bitcoin's capabilities. I see Bitcoin as the first flip phone vs the latest smart phones for more reasons we can continue to discuss if desired.

    Every wealth accumulator for these specific reasons and much more stress the importance of diversification. Lets not forget the power of leverage through real estate which multiple commenters already touched on. Sure we can leverage our crypto but those staking pools are unregulated and in my option attached to more risk. If you were talking about companies like Blockfi you may want to be cautious in the amount of money you are willing to lend. I wouldn't put any amount of money into lending that I wasn't comfortable with potentially never seeing again. https://blockfi.com/interest-a... I think this link will work but see "Terms of Service" section "H - Consent to Utilize". You are giving up your right as an owner of the asset. Some can argue that theoretically getting a loan from the bank would be somewhat similar but the real estate market is far less volatile and therefore less risky.

    I think it is great that you are pivoting to digital assets I have my modest portfolio as well and am balancing between stocks and real estate. I think your desired returns in real estate should also be assessed with your desired involvement. Those two components are directly correlated. It is my interpretation by reading your posts that you desire a more passive strategy. If I read this right and this is the case, hiring a local property manager or accumulating enough real estate to hire property manager that works solely for you might b the answer. I also think that what type of real estate asset is a huge component. I choose to view SFR as a glorified savings account, its just not for me. With SFR I don't expect much cashflow if any because in my market they don't. And hope nothing breaks or needs repair aiming to hold onto it for as long as possible to make enough money to turn a profit after all sale expenses/taxes are paid. When comparing a situation like the one above to crypto it seems like a no brainer to me. But, I like small to large multifamily. If you can find a mismanaged under rented asset, can force equity, refinance, and hold then your overall returns and wealth accumulation are much higher. Also you can find companies like Brandon Turner's who are already doing this. You obviously don't see the potential returns if you don't do it yourself nor do you get the tax benefit depending on if you invest in partnership or a fund. But it all comes back to your desired level of involvement. Real estate is tried and true. People have been doing it for decades before we were born and will continue to. I choose to play in both asset classes to hedge and to further guarantee my success of wealth accumulation. Just a thought. I hope it gives some perspective. Thanks!

  • St. George, UT · Member since 2021 · 6 posts · 3 votes
    5y

    @Kevin H. The question I always ask people when it comes to the Bitcoin or crypto vs real estate, gold, etc is this: What is the ratio of people who are actually using or buying Bitcoin, eth, etc to use as intended vs the people that are purely speculating on it? Just a thought 🤷‍♂️

  • Marysville, WA · Member since 2018 · 60 posts · 35 votes
    5y

    @Robert DiFranco

    The last time everyone was talking about bitcoin like this was 2017. It crashed from 19k to 4k pretty rapidly.

    I would be pretty shocked if we don't see a similar sell off very soon.

    I have been in bitcoin since 2016. I like it, but not for any reasons anyone else does. To me, 1btc is going to be a michael jordan rookie card someday.

    It will never in my lifetime be a payment system. It will never in my lifetime be a store of value. But it will be a collectible. Because of the limited supply.

  • Lender · United States · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 499 votes
    5y

    Bitcoin only holds value from a trading point of view. The purpose of Bitcoin, or any other cryptocurrency was to "replace the USD". 10 Years later and it's failed to do that. Less than 1% of purchases are completed with the use of a cryptocurrency. The price is determined by day traders, and day traders are indecisive, bi-polar, and half the time newbies.

    Real estate is a real asset.

  • Rental Property Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2017 · 51 posts · 33 votes
    5y

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Joe, your monthly cash flow seems a bit high, but I’ll go along with it. You’re insinuating that the home you purchased has no mortgage to it. In one year we’ll say your total investment is now 140k, mine is worth 400k, I could go and buy 4 properties now and you might be able to buy 1 by doing a re-fi. Let alone all the fees and time you will have to pay to complete that process. Also my return so far is less than 1 year of holding, I won’t say it’s never happened, but how often does a house appreciate 400% in a year? I honestly expect my investment to 10x by May. There have been a lot of good points by people and I didn’t want to go down the rabbit hole that some posts did. A lot of the information people are stating is false or not 100% about Bitcoin as things are changing so quickly. When do you stop calling an asset speculative? It’s market cap is worth over 1 trillion dollars at the moment and even though there are rumblings of possible laws or regulations, nothing is finite and if I worried about what if’s everyday I would be a miserable person. Again, I ask you joe at what point would you consider to take the money that you would normally invest in real estate and put it into another asset that has a much better yield, less maintenance and far more liquid? Yes you can factor in the risk, volatility, as I said before since it’s inception on avg it’s yearly return is over 200%, I can’t say that will continue, I do believe it will for a few more years as the industry is evolving and growing rapidly and to make this interesting and hypothetical, we’ll say for the next 5 years btc will continue to see 200% yearly returns, would you consider investing differently?

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Kevin H.:

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Joe, your monthly cash flow seems a bit high, but I’ll go along with it. You’re insinuating that the home you purchased has no mortgage to it. In one year we’ll say your total investment is now 140k, mine is worth 400k, I could go and buy 4 properties now and you might be able to buy 1 by doing a re-fi. Let alone all the fees and time you will have to pay to complete that process. Also my return so far is less than 1 year of holding, I won’t say it’s never happened, but how often does a house appreciate 400% in a year? I honestly expect my investment to 10x by May. There have been a lot of good points by people and I didn’t want to go down the rabbit hole that some posts did. A lot of the information people are stating is false or not 100% about Bitcoin as things are changing so quickly. When do you stop calling an asset speculative? It’s market cap is worth over 1 trillion dollars at the moment and even though there are rumblings of possible laws or regulations, nothing is finite and if I worried about what if’s everyday I would be a miserable person. Again, I ask you joe at what point would you consider to take the money that you would normally invest in real estate and put it into another asset that has a much better yield, less maintenance and far more liquid? Yes you can factor in the risk, volatility, as I said before since it’s inception on avg it’s yearly return is over 200%, I can’t say that will continue, I do believe it will for a few more years as the industry is evolving and growing rapidly and to make this interesting and hypothetical, we’ll say for the next 5 years btc will continue to see 200% yearly returns, would you consider investing differently?

     My monthly CF is right in line, and it DOES include financing.

    If I spent $140k on RE, the property, or properties, would be worth $600k or more at the time I buy them (actually, with the strategies I'm using, they would be worth over $1.4M...and no, that's not a typo).  That means that if they appreciate at only 5% in the first year, my TPV is worth $1.47M.  The CF would be at least $100k/yr, which I could reinvest every year if I wanted to, or just keep as income.

    So I'd start at $140k, and after the first year my investment would be at $1.57k.  Now what % return is that?

    From year 2 and beyond, that number exponentially increases, partly because I'm periodically selling the properties to recover all of the assets (the asset isn't the property, it's the cash in the form of equity), and then reinvesting that cash at the same cost to PV ratios. This allows me to more than double the property values, and the CF with the increase in the number of properties (actually, the increase is in the value of the properties...I'm not interested in also doubling the number of tenants). It's called leverage, and REI takes leverage to the extreme.

    You're getting lost in percentages, and losing sight of the actual dollars...how they move through you, and the power that cash has when you control the movement of it...not watch the "dead" accumulation of it in the form of a percentage.

    REI has been around since there was ownership of property. It has a proven track record, and as long as people need homes to live in, it will always be there. It has had its ups and downs, but it also has the ability to withstand the downs due to the positive CF. As long as you have positive CF, you can wait for the PV to recover.

    REI also has the ability to continue to receive income from it...without having any of your money (cost recovery) left in it...thus your risk is gone.

  • Rental Property Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2017 · 51 posts · 33 votes
    5y

    @Joe Villeneuve

    Joe thanks for the back and forth insight and feedback, at first glance your numbers don't make sense to me. I'll have to look more into it when I have time, if true and valid I understand why you would stick with REI, I think they removed this thread as it has disappeared completely form the site. I don't get those kind of returns with my current properties, but inflation will make it more affordable to own my properties and rent will increase my roi. I'm fortunate my tenants have been paying during this pandemic, but don't know if I would be able to stay afloat if 2 properties stopped paying for a year, let alone the government forbidding me from evicting them and current prices in my markets feeling extremely inflated. I'll continue to look for opportunities and will most likely continue purchasing rentals, I just feel at the moment my returns in other investment channels will outperform rei.

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    That's right @Kevin H. 

    In my rental  I paid the mortgage bill from my options trading mostly by naked put, I do this every month. Assuming the tenant not paying, I can still pay it via money out of thin air.

    I'm investing at crypto too but at a different level and indirectly, from ETF to LP/VC investments.

  • Investor · Charleston, SC · Member since 2019 · 112 posts · 126 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jim K.:
    Originally posted by @Ross Bowman:
    Originally posted by @Jim K.:

    I am really getting sick of the crypto-cryptocurrency-pimping on this site.

     If you think this is crypto-currency-pimping, you should check out reddit and twitter.

    I actually think the discussion about it is pretty even-keeled here and I've never seen any outright shilling. 

    It's something we SHOULD be talking about it, as you can already borrow against your bitcoin and use it for RE projects. It will only become more relevant to the RE world over time, so it's good to learn about it. 

    POWER IS NEVER INNOCENT. Cryptocurrency WILL be shut down. FDR robbed the rich of their gold holdings. You will be robbed of your Bitcoin holdings, one way or the other. You live under a repressive social order that will crush you when you challenge it. Your neck has yet to feel the government's jackboot on it, that's all. You are all soft ivory-tower dreamers imagining you live in a fair and just society that will gradually give way to an even fairer, more just society, because it's best for its people. For the children. For all mankind. Happy days in a happy land of endless flowing rivers of milk and honey and Bitcoin.

    The only way to shutdown bitcoin is by shutting down the internet itself, which the US government cannot actually do without crippling the economy. 

    Please dont take this as an insult - anyone who thinks bitcoin can be "shut down" simply does not actually understand what bitcoin is. You literally cannot shut it down. 

  • Handyman · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    5y

    @Ross Bowman

    Until about twelve months ago, no one believed the US government could effectively impose a nationwide moratorium on evictions, either.

    Until FDR forced everyone with in-country gold holdings to sell to the US government in 1933 at a set price, no American citizen believed that they could be forced to give up their depository-held gold against their will.

    In my personal experience, absolutely no one in Greece in 2014 believed foreign, unelected bureaucrats could keep Greek citizens them from withdrawing their own money from their own Greek bank accounts the next year.

    You believe Bitcoin is bulletproof because a series of circumstances JUST CAN'T HAPPEN. So I don't take what you've saying as an insult. I would ask you to consider that you might not know much about how institutional force, violence, or repression works. It's certainties like yours that get people in the most trouble.

  • Investor · Charleston, SC · Member since 2019 · 112 posts · 126 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jim K.:

    @Ross Bowman

    Until about twelve months ago, no one believed the US government could effectively impose a nationwide moratorium on evictions, either.

    Until FDR forced everyone with in-country gold holdings to sell to the US government in 1933 at a set price, no American citizen believed that they could be forced to give up their depository-held gold against their will.

    In my personal experience, absolutely no one in Greece in 2014 believed foreign, unelected bureaucrats could keep Greek citizens them from withdrawing their own money from their own Greek bank accounts the next year.

    You believe Bitcoin is bulletproof because a series of circumstances JUST CAN'T HAPPEN. So I don't take what you've saying as an insult. I would ask you to consider that you might not know much about how institutional force, violence, or repression works. It's certainties like yours that get people in the most trouble.

     Some answers below:



    Until about twelve months ago, no one believed the US government could effectively impose a nationwide moratorium on evictions, either.  The government is able to directly control property because property is tied to the US monetary system. 

    Until FDR forced everyone with in-country gold holdings to sell to the US government in 1933 at a set price, no American citizen believed that they could be forced to give up their depository-held gold against their will. Without your private keys, there is literally no way for anyone to take your bitcoin from your cold storage. As an example, this is why the German government was never able to take the bitcoin from that hacker in the recent arrest. Without the keys, there is literally nothing you can do. And the keys can be kept in your memory. 

    In my personal experience, absolutely no one in Greece in 2014 believed foreign, unelected bureaucrats could keep Greek citizens them from withdrawing their own money from their own Greek bank accounts the next year.  Same answer as above. Your bitcoin is not kept in a bank - there is no technological way for any nation state to do this. 

    You believe Bitcoin is bulletproof because a series of circumstances JUST CAN'T HAPPEN. So I don't take what you've saying as an insult. I would ask you to consider that you might not know much about how institutional force, violence, or repression works. It's certainties like yours that get people in the most trouble.

    I'm not saying it can't happen due to a series of circumstances.

    I'm saying it due to a deep understanding of the bitcoin protocol. There are somethings that are actually impossible - this is one of them. 

    As long as you control your private keys, nobody can touch your bitcoin without your consent. This is why bitcoin is so fundamentally disruptive and should not be ignored by any investor. 

  • Handyman · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    5y

    @Ross Bowman

    You keep focusing on Bitcoin's technological invulnerability in an ordered world that has rules of polite behavior. I keep telling you technological invulnerability doesn't matter, and polite behavior goes by the wayside in times of crisis.

    So to put it another way, as long as those codes can be tortured out of you, your Bitcoin can be taken away from you.

  • Investor · Charleston, SC · Member since 2019 · 112 posts · 126 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jim K.:

    @Ross Bowman

    You keep focusing on Bitcoin's technological invulnerability in an ordered world that has rules of polite behavior. I keep telling you technological invulnerability doesn't matter, and polite behavior goes by the wayside in times of crisis.

    So to put it another way, as long as those codes can be tortured out of you, your Bitcoin can be taken away from you.

    Honestly, your views on the state and state violence align pretty closely with the bitcoin community and how we think too. 

    Maybe check it out before writing it off? 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.