You have 6 months to liquidate your assets

You have 6 months to liquidate your assets

Accountant · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2019 · 28 posts · 129 votes

I’ve been doing a lot of research lately and I wanted to share with you guys what I have found about the correlation between unemployment, delinquencies and housing prices. During the 2008 housing crisis the housing market bottomed about 2 years after the peak in delinquencies. Note that delinquencies are very much so correlated with unemployment rates (see graph on link below). Unemployment is already about twice the peak in 2008 so it is very likely that delinquencies will follow, which will lead to increased supply of housing.

See data here, gathered by stanford researches: https://web.stanford.edu/~pavelkr/jmp_slides.pdf

Conclusion: You have about 6 months to sell off your assets until the market will be flooded with fire sales and forclosures.

53Reply
3,143 views

Most Popular Reply

Specialist · Riverside, CA · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
6y

@Thor Sveinbjoernsson as my statistics teacher said almost every day

correlation does not equal causation

The last recession was driven by the housing sector, and subprime mortgages.  This time around with all the forbearance being offered it seems unlikely things will take a nose dive even equal to that of 2008.

See this reply in the discussion

380 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Hawthorne, CA · Member since 2018 · 655 posts · 900 votes
    6y

    @Jim K.

    I was going to make the same comment and ask him what he has to liquidate because I’m ready to acquire some liquidation. I believe there are many people who are poised to do so.

  • Handyman · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Damaso Bautista:

    @Jim K.

    I was going to make the same comment and ask him what he has to liquidate because I’m ready to acquire some liquidation. I believe there are many people who are poised to do so.

    We paid debt down and crammed the war chest full Jan 2018-December 2019. Got lucky, but I think a lot of small DIY guys like me were doing the same.

    I think @Scott Trench nailed it in an earlier post about the nature of institutional debt. The big guys relying on volume and two-dimensional deal pipelines were overextended. I know more than one good-sized local landlord and flipper in my area who was still flipping just to keep his small maintenance crew busy and paid, almost zero-profit flips all the way. Sure, many of the small guys were also overextended, especially the ones who believed that their immediate rental cash flow should fund their inflated lifestyles, but I'm pretty sure there's a very solid block of married couples who are in this to lock down things like F-U money, financial independence, savings for their families, not to live large.

    It's our time. And it's going to be a pretty good thing for affordable housing in America.

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    A few contrarian thoughts:  Supply also has decreased along with demand, creating some price stability in the residential housing market.  Forbearance opportunities will mute the spike in foreclosures.  Lending continues as well as the purchase of mortgage backed securities.  So financing liquidity stands.

    Yet I do not see a healthy market in the near future as unemployment levels will remain high.  A "V" shaped recovery looks to have been a fantasy.  We'll see if this ends up as a stagnant / soft market or even price declines.  I prefer looking at the facts as they emerge.  I know what I'll do if I see bargains emerging.

    For those who invest in commercial real estate, it is easier to see deeper problems within that market.  The pandemic has wrecked the income of certain assets including hotels, nursing homes and certain retail real estate.

  • Handyman · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Brian Ploszay:

    A few contrarian thoughts:  Supply also has decreased along with demand, creating some price stability in the residential housing market.  Forbearance opportunities will mute the spike in foreclosures.  Lending continues as well as the purchase of mortgage backed securities.  So financing liquidity stands.

    Yet I do not see a healthy market in the near future as unemployment levels will remain high.  A "V" shaped recovery looks to have been a fantasy.  We'll see if this ends up as a stagnant / soft market or even price declines.  I prefer looking at the facts as they emerge.  I know what I'll do if I see bargains emerging.

    For those who invest in commercial real estate, it is easier to see deeper problems within that market.  The pandemic has wrecked the income of certain assets including hotels, nursing homes and certain retail real estate.

    For that matter...anybody who was betting big on cruise ships -- that industry's never coming back under business models that look anything LIKE what they used to have. I have a tenant who had a side hustle selling stuff at Penguins games -- that business is gone.

    I fully concur. You expect a V-shaped recovery, you might as well expect Copeland's going to blow away the virus with the breath of God.

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    6y

    @Thor Sveinbjoernsson what you have put out is the single worst, most incorrect over-simplification of the " 08/09 Housing Collapse", written with complete and total ignorance of every financial and investment market mechanism involved INCLUDING the actual housing market data and factors involved. And the fact that your calling yourself an accountant! I am totally blown away and terrified for business persons who may be looking to you for sound business advice that they would catalyze into actual actions. 

    First off, the housing collapse was (in a simplified manner) 2 MAIN actions: a housing SURPLUS (and a massive one at that) AND a significant monetary contraction. Thats it, NOTHING like today, nothing at all. 

    The monetary contraction was a ticking time bomb, it's was destined to happen by the sheer design of it and as you were oblivious to all of this I will not attempt to get into the finer detail of mortgage-backed securities and the layering of tranches. Short story, the securities were destined to fail AND those securities had factors of x20/x40.x50+ of funds gambled upon them so each security that went down took a grossly disproportionate amount of capital down with it. 

    At this point you may be asking "this guy seems to know a bit more than average on this", yeah, because I was actually there, and I spent a time as a Mortgage Banker to boot. The housing collapse was a monster sized freight train that many fo us saw coming miles away, not to the full extent of what it was BUT many of us in the business knew a correction was coming, knew lending was hugely inflating the market, knew the math of over-supply and on and on all meant correction was coming, we just didn't know when and how bad. 

    Today, we are in a housing SHORTAGE. We do NOT have the same crazy system on mortgage-backed securities we had in 08/09, or to be more accurate the Jenga stack of gambles is not built in a way as it was. 

    There is so much distortion in your post and promotion that it verges on criminal. For example, saying everyone better hurry and sell in next 6 months "or else" there will be mass flooding of market with sales, your telling people to flood the market genius. Thats inciting a run on the market. Your inciting fear and panic. 

    Your correlating unemployment with housing market collapse, well guess what, pre 08/09 collapse unemployment was under 4%. So by your logic low unemployment = housing collapse, because thats what it was. It was the housing collapse that made unemployment rise, not the other way around. 

    i gotta stop, because I could literally write pages of false information and false premise in your doom pandering, with matching pages of actual economic and financial reality, basically all those things actual accountants learn in a university which is why I am confused by your stated position and statements, they don't match at all. 

    Will unemployment effect mortgage defaults and the economy, absolutely, and not in the manner stated because we DON'T have a declining market we have a restricted market from regulation suspension. What the difference, well a declining market is one where the whole is reducing from fundamental factors, a restricted one, which we are in, is where desired economic activity is restricted and with that it builds tension, like a spring, and as restriction are removed that tension is expressed by massive economic boom. Don't believe me, just look everywhere that is opening and removing restrictions. 

    Look, I'm not an economist, but I did study economics, and all this I am saying is a combination of life business experience and that economics study and basic principles, all of which are and have proved true over and over again. There is NO collapse coming like this ya-hoo is trying to incite. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Jacksonville, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    I am not seeing the coming fire sale.  The fed is going to step in and allow mortgage modifications sometime in late 2021.  The only real winners in the great recession were the hedge funds who bought houses in packs of 1,000 from Fannie Mae.  This was at the cost of the average home owner and tax payer, since Fannie Mae and others were bailed out with your money and mine.   Unless you had 7 figures and first was not a '1', you were not the big winner.  American Homes 4 Rent, which owns 52,776 single-family rentals across 22 states, they were a big winner.  This is not a zero sum game.  For there to be a fire sale someone has to lose and lose badly.  My strategy has always been to buy opportunistically and I will continue to do so.

    I don't know what will happen, but I assure you it will not be a replica of '08

    Generals(Soldiers, etc.) always fight (prepare to fight, are condemned to fight) the last war.

    In the soft spoken words of Mike Tyson:

    "Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth"

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Brian Ploszay:

    A few contrarian thoughts:  Supply also has decreased along with demand, creating some price stability in the residential housing market.  Forbearance opportunities will mute the spike in foreclosures.  Lending continues as well as the purchase of mortgage backed securities.  So financing liquidity stands.

    Yet I do not see a healthy market in the near future as unemployment levels will remain high.  A "V" shaped recovery looks to have been a fantasy.  We'll see if this ends up as a stagnant / soft market or even price declines.  I prefer looking at the facts as they emerge.  I know what I'll do if I see bargains emerging.

    For those who invest in commercial real estate, it is easier to see deeper problems within that market.  The pandemic has wrecked the income of certain assets including hotels, nursing homes and certain retail real estate.

    This is going to be a very interesting "recovery" as since it is a regulatory inflicted economic decline, so to will recovery and performance be connected. The most interesting part is how unique this is as it is directed at state level, we will see V shaped, W, stagflation and so on in a state by state case all given the various regulator's actions. How all that comes out in the wash in a national macro picture is anyone guess. 

    What I see coming is those states who have the greatest V-shaped recoveries will be viewed upon by those in stagflation states with great jealousy, and those citizens will lash out at their local governance. Those local governance will lash out at states with less regulation caps and greater recovery. I think we are in for a very interesting round robin. 

     Then take into account the global economy also interacting in a similar fashion at the national geo-political level.... 

  • Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    6y

    Buying in troughs and selling at peaks is a fairy tale.  No one buys during the troughs...that's WHY prices fall.  And we can't sell our life savings in assets on a guess that the market will crash.

    What we can do is buy properties in decent locations, use prudent debt, have cash flow, and maintain reserves and our properties will weather economic down turns.  In fact, investment properties support our families and provide security during those times.  We can sell challenging properties during good times.  And we can buy more when there are more opportunities...and buy less when prices are high.  What we can't do is time the market, never buy a property and then expect to when the market is in chaos, and sit on sidelines waiting for conditions to determine our future.

    Many investors started positioning their portfolios and balance sheets for a down turn years ago.

  • Accountant · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2019 · 28 posts · 129 votes
    6y

    @James Hamling

    Thank you for your reply. I am in fact an accountant and I have passed all 4 parts of the cpa exam, no need to get personal here.

    I am simply pointing out the correlation that I noticed with unemployment, delinguincies and housing prices. There are multiple other factors that come in play. I do not know what will happen to housing prices nor does anyone else. The title was chosen to get a traction of comments (which worked).

    Most people here are long housing so it was expected that people would disagree with the post. However it is healthy to look at your investment from all angles in order to minimize risk to the downside.

    Would you mind please explaining how reduced housing prices leada to unemployment?

  • Investor · Salt Lake City, UT · Member since 2019 · 38 posts · 20 votes
    6y

    @Thor Sveinbjoernsson agree with you. It’s going to get very bad. In February I had offers out on 3 homes in Arizona market (a very hot market with multiple offers per home) then March happened. I took my offers off the table. Those same 3 homes are still available and are now 30% cheaper.

    Commercial and Residential markets are going to get hammered big time.

    Oh and Kiyosaki tweeted this today - https://twitter.com/therealkiyosaki/status/1264584780462436353

  • Member since 2020 · 5 posts · 26 votes
    6y

    Throughout this thread, I see a lot of really great analysis of the economics of where we are. But it seems like we may be ignoring factors that haven’t been in play in the past. Recessions are always started by some kind of bad economics on the part of giant banks, giant government, or giant business, or a combination of all three. And then small business and consumer confidence brings us back out.

    This downturn is unusual in two ways. It was caused by the wholesale destruction of the small business economy, which doesn’t show up on most economists big picture maps, and has never been a factor in the beginning of any American or global recession. And second, consumer confidence this time, is not going to be tied to jobs, housing, availability of money, inflation, or any other traditional  economic marker. Consumer confidence is going to be tied to a vaccine, which is somewhere between eight months and five years off, and to Irrational fear that is unrelated to any economic factor of any sort. This has destroyed consumer confidence in a way that no economic marker has factored for.

    If Small biz and especially consumer confidence brings us out of recessions, we’re in for a long slog. Factor in 42% of jobs projected to be lost permanently (twice the number lost temporarily in 2009), and the fact that small business will be on life support for years (48% of our GDP), and things could get very interesting. None of this shows up in a traditional analysis of a recession, and I think will be a much bigger factor this time than macro-economics, housing supply, money supply, Fed actions, stimulus packages, etc. I hope I’m wrong.

  • Real Estate Agent · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2019 · 448 posts · 320 votes
    6y

    Depends on which sector of the real estate market you are following.  Commercial for example traditionally has always trailed the single family housing market, which typically trails some of the metrics referenced in the OP such as unemployment etc.  So we may be looking at the peak fallout from the current situation in terms of fire sales and price reductions in the commercial sector 1-2 years from now, or possibly never if there are strong enough countermeasures released.  I recall never seeing the glut of great deals on the market around 2008 that may were predicting.  That may be different this time around with certain product types such as shopping centers and office buildings because of social distancing, but others like apartment, self storage, industrial, etc may actually increase in value due to investors shifting their capital to those product types.  

  • Rental Property Investor · Mesa, AZ · Member since 2019 · 138 posts · 144 votes
    6y

    @Thor Sveinbjoernsson

    Sorry, Thor but your theory omits the unknown effect stimulus dollars will have. 2008 is nothing like now. Creditors were extremely healthy before the pandemic, unlike the direct hit they took in 2008. With both the Treasury and Fed spending trillions on propping the economy up and a major supply glut in housing, there is no indication there will be a major hit to real estate prices.

    The "eviction" bubble is well known throughout the country and chances are this will be addressed in the next stimulus bill.

    Long term Buy/Hold investors aren't terribly worried about a drop in property prices, unless they made poor decisions or poorly manage their business. They, like Nemun Marcus, Hertz, and JCP brought the risk on themselves and deserve the downside consequence.

    I wonder if your motivation of this post is to scare investors into liquidation so you and your friends can take advantage?

  • Accountant · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2019 · 28 posts · 129 votes
    6y

    @Matthew Terry

    I think you might be overstating the effect a forum post can have on real estate prices. There is no second motive here, I simply wanted to start a conversation around the correlation between delinquiencies, unemployment and housing prices. Thank you for your input.

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Thor Sveinbjoernsson:

    @James Hamling

    Thank you for your reply. I am in fact an accountant and I have passed all 4 parts of the cpa exam, no need to get personal here.

    I am simply pointing out the correlation that I noticed with unemployment, delinguincies and housing prices. There are multiple other factors that come in play. I do not know what will happen to housing prices nor does anyone else. The title was chosen to get a traction of comments (which worked).

    Most people here are long housing so it was expected that people would disagree with the post. However it is healthy to look at your investment from all angles in order to minimize risk to the downside.

    Would you mind please explaining how reduced housing prices leada to unemployment?

     No, I won't and can't explain that because reduced housing prices don't lead to unemployment. Why you asked me to explain such a thing I can't riddle. 

    Everything I read of what you say is financially wrong. To be honest I don't believe you'r an accountant, and especially not a CPA, I am sorry I just don't believe you. 

    I have CPA's who manage my accounting, have worked with CPA's for decades, have CPA's as friends. I have 99.5% certainty you are trolling. 

    With that, no point answering the ridiculousness. 

  • Accountant · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2019 · 28 posts · 129 votes
    6y

    @James Hamling

    Sounds good! Keep buying and don’t even consider any other possibility than that housing will go up.

    I am sure you will do great.

    Also, in your earlier post you said: “it was the housing collapse that made unemployment rise, not the other way around”. Which is why I asked you how reduced housing prices cause unemployment.

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Thor Sveinbjoernsson:

    @Matthew Terry

    I think you might be overstating the effect a forum post can have on real estate prices. There is no second motive here, I simply wanted to start a  conversation around the correlation between delinquiencies, unemployment and housing prices. Thank you for your input.

     There is no such correlation. 

    If you'd like to argue there is any correlation please feel free to list the rule of correlation you are citing and or the year and instance of historical date in application fo such. 

    There has never been a correlation of causality or factoring between housing prices, unemployment and delinquencies. never, not one time ever. 

    Collapse of 08/09 housing prices had zero correlation with anything. Great depression, no correlation. The wiemark republic, danish tulip collapse, soviet collapse, E. german collapse, Zimbabwae, on and on and on, never has housing prices had a creation to any of these things your saying. 

    Housing prices are a RESULT of inputs, thats it. The price of a house is Florida does not rise and fall with the DOW. Housing price is affected by cost of inputs, and the factor of supply and demand. Price is a reflection never a causality, much like your car never runs out of gas because the gauge says E, we don't stop and wind our fuel gauge to fill the tank do we? No, it is simply a gauge of other factors. Every accountant I have ever meet on earth has known this. 

    Can we please end this fairy tale of BS now? "6 months to sell your properties OR ELSE..... muah ha ha ha ha haaaaaaaaaaaaa". It's just ridiculous nonsense. 

  • Bjorn AhlbladPro Member
    Investor · Shelton, WA · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    6y

    @Thor Sveinbjoernsson Great name! Every day you see contradicting headlines put our by outlets like Forbes, Zillow and others. Some doom and gloom while others saying everything is going along great. There are so many segments to this game you need to be differentiating between commercial-storefront, commercial residential, SFH, SF rental, geographic location and so on. I think we are in for a rough/not so rough time for the next 24 months depending on what segment you are in. Personally, I'm not selling anything and very likely not aggressively buying either. All the best!

  • Rental Property Investor · Klamath Falls, OR · Member since 2016 · 146 posts · 213 votes
    6y

    Let's assume for second that your claims are correct. That still gives me zero reasons to liquidate my assets. My properties cash flow heavily and are minimally leveraged. Now is the time to assess the health of each individual asset and consider selling any low hanging fruit, but I do that several times a year anyways. What the market and unemployment conditions are telling me is to stockpile cash feverishly in case opportunities arise. I am not however naïve enough to believe that good properties will be on fire sale. It's more of the same, those poorly managed properties come up for sale with value add opportunities. Unlike 2008, there are thousands of people waiting to purchase. It won't be what you want it to be. 

  • Accountant · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2019 · 28 posts · 129 votes
    6y

    @Mary White

    Sounds like you are in a great position with your investing and that you are doing things the right way! I don’t want things to go one or the other way, just wanted to open up the discussion.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Tony Blasioli:

    I was a building contractor/developer in 2008 when the bottom fell out of the market. We had several million dollars in spec residential construction underway. Not a pretty picture. The current "crisis" has the same look and feel. I have now rebuilt my portfolio as well as I could and am facing foreclosure on a short-term mortgage if I can't find a refi. I am only leveraged at about 25% on the portfolio which I will eventually lose if I can't find a refi. These properties cash flow very well and if and when we lose them, my wife and I will have lost our main source of income and could potentially become homeless. That is just the reality. Can anyone provide a link on the extended forbearance programs? And, by all means, if anyone can refer me to a lender who can help, I will be forever grateful. Thanks.

    Tony if your that worried sell half the portfolio and pay off the other half..  

  • Real Estate Agent · Austin · Member since 2019 · 100 posts · 28 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Thor Sveinbjoernsson:

    I’ve been doing a lot of research lately and I wanted to share with you guys what I have found about the correlation between unemployment, delinquencies and housing prices. During the 2008 housing crisis the housing market bottomed about 2 years after the peak in delinquencies. Note that delinquencies are very much so correlated with unemployment rates (see graph on link below). Unemployment is already about twice the peak in 2008 so it is very likely that delinquencies will follow, which will lead to increased supply of housing.

    See data here, gathered by stanford researches: https://web.stanford.edu/~pavelkr/jmp_slides.pdf

    Conclusion: You have about 6 months to sell off your assets until the market will be flooded with fire sales and forclosures.

     Please God, hear this man's voice and let the market recover after the drop!  

    In reality, the forbearance will likely not make it happen. It is given for 6 months and then 6 months and maybe another 6. But we dont know the future, we can just hope.

  • Real Estate Agent · Austin · Member since 2019 · 100 posts · 28 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Tony Blasioli:

    I was a building contractor/developer in 2008 when the bottom fell out of the market. We had several million dollars in spec residential construction underway. Not a pretty picture. The current "crisis" has the same look and feel. I have now rebuilt my portfolio as well as I could and am facing foreclosure on a short-term mortgage if I can't find a refi. I am only leveraged at about 25% on the portfolio which I will eventually lose if I can't find a refi. These properties cash flow very well and if and when we lose them, my wife and I will have lost our main source of income and could potentially become homeless. That is just the reality. Can anyone provide a link on the extended forbearance programs? And, by all means, if anyone can refer me to a lender who can help, I will be forever grateful. Thanks.

     Call your bank, wait 2 hours for someone pick up the phone and tell you: "do you need free money", reply:"yes" and you are done. I am totally serious, this is how it works.

    Any comments on spec in Austin?

  • Specialist · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    Have you not been paying attention?

    The Treasury has just printed $6T. Housing prices and rents are going to go up. It's called inflation. Even if some areas get a temporary 10-15% pullback, people will still need a place to live. They will either pay rent, or the government will pay it for them. (See the $4000/mo. people are being paid to sit at home)

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2014 · 173 posts · 121 votes
    6y

    @Brian Ploszay

    Commercial debt 💣 🔥

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.