5 rules that keep my rental rehabs on budget

Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes

1. Scope before price. I walk every room with the contractor and write a line-item scope, so every bid is apples to apples.

2. Rental grade, not retail grade. I use durable LVP, neutral paint, and mid-grade fixtures. The goal is lower turnover cost, not a magazine finish.

3. Draw schedule tied to finished milestones, with photos. I never pay far ahead of the work.

4. 10–15% contingency. Older Columbus houses always have something behind the walls.

5. Permits and lead-safe practices on pre-1978 homes. Shortcuts cost more at the refi or the first tenant complaint.

What's the costliest surprise you've found mid-rehab?

4 Reply

612 views

Most Popular Reply

Richard NeesePro Member

Rental Property Investor · South Vinemont, AL · Member since 2026 · 51 posts · 18 votes

Great advice and it fits our model down here in North Alabama. I have my own construction crew but its almost word for word what we do. We even backed off of the finishes on our flip properties because we were spending an additional 5-10% on things that "sold better" we found that pricing accordingly led to similar sales and cut down on the last 5% which is usually the most costly. White box paint, contractor grade finishes. Good home at a good price . Thank you for contributing to the community !

1 Reply

See this reply in the discussion

17 Replies

Jump to latestLatest

Sort by

Richard NeesePro Member
Rental Property Investor · South Vinemont, AL · Member since 2026 · 51 posts · 18 votes
3d
Great advice and it fits our model down here in North Alabama. I have my own construction crew but its almost word for word what we do. We even backed off of the finishes on our flip properties because we were spending an additional 5-10% on things that "sold better" we found that pricing accordingly led to similar sales and cut down on the last 5% which is usually the most costly. White box paint, contractor grade finishes. Good home at a good price . Thank you for contributing to the community !
1 Reply
- BJ Everson
  OP
  Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes
  3d
  Always good to focus in on the numbers at your level and see what’s actually beneficial to the bottom line and what’s not!
  0 Reply
Mark UpdegraffBusiness Member
Real Estate Broker · Rochester, NY · Member since 2010 · 1k+ posts · 713 votes
2d
@BJ Everson I’d add change control as a sixth rule. The line-item scope works until a hidden condition appears or someone says, “while you’re there.” Before approving a change, I want the added cost, schedule impact and the original scope item it replaces documented. Otherwise the contingency quietly becomes a second budget and nobody can explain where it went. In older Rochester housing stock, surprises are expected; undocumented decisions are the part that usually makes them expensive.
Podcast Guest on Show #112
Updegraff Group Realty4.742 Reviews
Website View Page
0 Reply
- BJ Everson
  OP
  Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes
  2d
  That’s a good add for older housing stock. We have a few neighborhoods in Columbus where this would be beneficial as well.
  0 Reply
Divin KanyamaBusiness Member
Accountant · Seattle, WA · Member since 2025 · 640 posts · 268 votes
2d
@BJ Everson Great framework—especially scoping before pricing and tying draws to completed milestones. Hidden water damage would be high on my list of costly surprises: what looks like a small leak can turn into repairs to framing, subfloors, and plumbing once things are opened up.
I’d add one guardrail: document and price every change order before approving the extra work. A contingency helps absorb surprises, but it shouldn’t become permission for the scope to drift.
[email protected]
WEMBO CPA532 Reviews
Website View Page
1 Reply
- BJ Everson
  OP
  Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes
  2d
  This is a great add for the contingency use.
  0 Reply
Vladimirs Veiss
Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 132 posts · 21 votes
2d
@BJ Everson Great list, BJ, and nice to meet someone working in Columbus! That's where we plan to start in the US.
Our costliest surprise was in Switzerland: a burst pipe flooded a ceiling, and we ended up repainting the whole floor at our own cost. Since then we price the "what if" scenarios before the job starts: as is, if the pipes need replacing, if the wiring does too. The owner sees every number upfront, and no stage gets paid until it's checked with photos.
Rule 3 is my favorite too. A draw tied to a finished, photographed milestone keeps everyone honest.
Since you know the housing stock there: if you had to price one "what if" upfront on a typical Columbus rental, which would it be: cast iron drains, old wiring, or the foundation?
Have a great Sunday!
0 Reply
- BJ Everson
  OP
  Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes
  1d
  Covering the “what ifs” is a must. And I point my clients to value add properties so we’re doing some of the needed work ourselves and know it’s done right before putting a tenant in place. That takes a lot of the “what ifs” off the table. But do like a contingency account in place for my client so they are covered for something happening , esp if they use the cash flow for their everyday uses.
  0 Reply
Bennett Vinson
Real Estate Consultant · Alabama | SFR Operations Nationwide · Member since 2026 · 39 posts · 9 votes
2d
BJ, rule 3 is the one I'd push hardest. Over 20 years of renovations and turns, the money I've seen leak wasn't from bad bids, it was from paying a draw on "done" that nobody actually walked. Mark's change control point fits right in: each change order should carry its own dated photo of the condition before and after, tied to the scope line it changed. Then the contingency has a paper trail. I built Eyes On the House™ (patent pending) to lock those photos to each draw. Happy to compare notes on what you check before releasing a draw.
0 Reply
- BJ Everson
  OP
  Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes
  1d
  I like this approach! I’m an open book so always happy to compare notes and best practices!
  0 Reply
- Vladimirs Veiss
  Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 132 posts · 21 votes
  1d
  @BJ Everson, thank you, and I'd really like to take you up on comparing notes!
  Doing the needed work yourselves before a tenant moves in makes a lot of sense: you know what's behind the walls before day one. And a contingency account for clients who live on the cash flow is a smart detail.
  One thing I'm curious about in Columbus: which exterior and roof work do you try to finish before the first freeze, and what waits until spring?
  I'll send you a connection request here so we can stay in touch. Have a great week!
  0 Reply
Muyees Ayilara
Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 150 posts · 64 votes
1d
BJ this is solid. I'm in Delray 33446 Monarch Lakes - townhouse rehabs $60k range. Rule 1 and 2 saved me - scope before price and rental grade not retail. I was pricing retail LVP and $400 faucets and it killed my $242k to $420k ARV math. Now mid-grade, same rent $2100 low end comps. Rule 4 is real too - 10% contingency always goes.
0 Reply
- BJ Everson
  OP
  Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes
  20h
  Great pivot!
  0 Reply
Asif Khan
Real Estate Agent · Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 1 vote
15h
Great breakdown, BJ! Point 3 and 4 are absolute lifesavers for keeping rehabs on track. As someone handling remote support, seeing how smart investors protect their margins is fascinating. Thanks for sharing these insights.
1 Reply
Juan Hasbun
Lender · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2020 · 58 posts · 13 votes
6h
From a lender perspective, I'd add a 6th rule: validate your exit before you swing the first hammer.
I've seen plenty of rehabs go over budget because investors focused on construction costs but didn't verify rents, ARV, or refinance requirements upfront.
As for the costliest surprise, it's usually not the cosmetic stuff. It's the hidden items:
Foundation issues
Sewer line replacements
Knob-and-tube or unsafe electrical discovered mid-project
Structural damage hidden behind walls
Water damage that's spread further than expected
The common theme is that they're expensive, unavoidable, and rarely improve the property's perceived value dollar-for-dollar.
That's why I like your contingency rule. On older properties, a 10-15% reserve isn't a luxury, it's part of the budget. The investors who stay profitable aren't the ones who avoid surprises. They're the ones who plan for them before they happen.
0 Reply
- BJ Everson
  OP
  Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 67 posts · 16 votes
  3h
  Great comment! I always have 2 exit strategies before offering. Had a flip I was doing and everything that could go wrong went wrong in rehab so the margin wasn't there for the sale. But penned as a good rental so we just pivoted and didn't lose money.
  0 Reply
Bennett Vinson
Real Estate Consultant · Alabama | SFR Operations Nationwide · Member since 2026 · 39 posts · 9 votes
4h
BJ, taking you up on that. I spent 20 years running institutional SFR rehab, 300-plus homes a year, and your rule 3 is where most of the money goes. Paying on done when nobody walked it.
I've got a way to verify the walk without the drive and I'd rather hear how you handle it than pitch you. On a rehab two hours out, who actually walks it before you release a draw, and what makes you trust them?
0 Reply

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.