Alexandria, IN · Member since 2016 · 38 posts · 7 votes
I had an electrician address a problem with my hot water heater, he fixed the wiring, but referred me to a plumber to replace the heating element and thermostat. The plumber wants to replace the entire unit for $2,800 (no idea where he came up with that number) because "it's 10 years old and parts are going to continue to break."
To replace all of the parts except the storage tank would cost less than $200, and only $40 for what I need to replace now.
You tube it and replace ur self.
Or get a new plumber
You should be able to replace a heating element your self. Just make sure you fill tank with water before turning electric back on or you will fry the new element.
For that price I will fly out and show you how
Where is this located. Most here are in unfinished basements with floor drains. I agree a new one is probably a better choice if they lime and scale up like here. A softener before the heater helps.
What other posters have not said,,,they make a metal pan that fits under the heater. With a fitting to run to a drain,just in case. Both for finished and unfinished spaces. Good protection for the next dripper
They also have neat flex lines to connect that years ago never had and that was the major fight. I knew an unhandy guy about 67 years and 100 pounds too heavy and he thought it was really easy with the flex pipes. (he couldnt change a stool flapper). Draining the OLD tank is the hard part, dont let the crap inside run into the floor drain. Dont ask how I know
Just thought of something. They do make a lifetime warranty tank now. I think they are called Marathons. they are alot more expensive,,,like 1200 to 1400 bucks. Never bought one but heard they are good. If its a tough install with bad access on a Holiday weekend emergency basis we are closer on his bid vs real world. But I would never buy it.
I didn't read the entire thread but, If you decide to repair yourself, there are typically 2 heating elements per tank, a top and bottom element. Best bet is to replace both at once. If you have trouble unscrewing them use a wash cloth soaked in white vinegar and wrap it around the element for 24hrs. Should unscrew easily after. Also, based on the age of the tank, the anode rod could be gone. It'd be a good idea to check and replace that as well.
Just replace the water heater. Here in expensive Bergen County, New Jersey, a 40 gallon brand name heater, with an excellent warranty, should cost $1,200 installed (by a Licensed Master Plumber).