My Brother’s Scared Home Prices Will Drop – What Can You Do to Mitigate That Risk

My Brother’s Scared Home Prices Will Drop – What Can You Do to Mitigate That Risk

Nathan P TannerPro Member
New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes

My Brother’s Scared Home Prices Will Drop – What Can You Do to Mitigate That Risk as an Investor?

Had an interesting conversation with my brother recently — he’s hesitant about getting into real estate right now because he’s worried home prices are going to keep dropping. 

His concern is valid. No one can perfectly time the market, and real estate does move in cycles. But it got me thinking — for those of us who are actively investing, how do you mitigate the risk of buying in a declining or uncertain market?

Here are a few strategies I’ve been learning about (and would love more insight on):

-Focus on cash flow over appreciation – If the numbers make sense today with positive cash flow, temporary dips in value hurt less.
- Buy with equity – Off-market deals, distressed sellers, or value-add opportunities can give you a discount and some built-in protection.  - - -- Use conservative underwriting – Run the numbers with worst-case scenarios in mind (higher interest rates, lower rents, etc.)
- Stick to fundamentals – Strong rental markets, job growth, low vacancy areas — these stay resilient even in downturns.
- BRRRR carefully – If done right, you’re recycling capital and not locking yourself into an over-leveraged position.
- Have multiple exit strategies – Rent it, flip it, sell it wholesale — flexibility is key in uncertain times.

I’m curious — how are other investors thinking about this right now? What advice would you give to someone like my brother who’s nervous about getting in at the “wrong time”?

Would love to hear your thoughts and connect with others who are navigating this market with strategy and caution.

2Reply
178 views

Most Popular Reply

Doug SmithPro Member
Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
1y

If you look at the biggest historical drop in home prices during the last crash at the end of the 2000s decade, prices bounced back within 6 years. If you bought at that peek, held onto the property and collected your rent, and sold it 6+ years later, you were more than fine. It's those that freak out and panic that 1) lose money and 2) make us that know better a lot of money. Never has there been a time since the Fed has been tracking home prices that you would have lost money if you just held on, took care of the house, collected your rent, and didn't panic. That would be my answer. 

See this reply in the discussion

28 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Doug SmithPro Member
    Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1y

    If you look at the biggest historical drop in home prices during the last crash at the end of the 2000s decade, prices bounced back within 6 years. If you bought at that peek, held onto the property and collected your rent, and sold it 6+ years later, you were more than fine. It's those that freak out and panic that 1) lose money and 2) make us that know better a lot of money. Never has there been a time since the Fed has been tracking home prices that you would have lost money if you just held on, took care of the house, collected your rent, and didn't panic. That would be my answer. 

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Doug Smith:

      If you look at the biggest historical drop in home prices during the last crash at the end of the 2000s decade, prices bounced back within 6 years. If you bought at that peek, held onto the property and collected your rent, and sold it 6+ years later, you were more than fine. It's those that freak out and panic that 1) lose money and 2) make us that know better a lot of money. Never has there been a time since the Fed has been tracking home prices that you would have lost money if you just held on, took care of the house, collected your rent, and didn't panic. That would be my answer. 


       Thank you Doug, I recently told my brother something similar. Your words are spot on in my book, makes a lot of sense. My only thought on this would be in that time prices did drop would rents go down as well and possibly lose tenants, have to re rent at lower price that didnt cash flow ? loose the house or have to sell?

  • Denise SuppleeBusiness Member
    Realtor · Willow Grove, PA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 662 votes
    1y

    Hi @Nathan P Tanner nice to meet you here on BP and Great points..especially focusing on cash flow and conservative underwriting. I always remind new investors that trying to time the market perfectly often leads to missed opportunities. If the deal works today with solid fundamentals, it’s worth considering. For someone like your brother, starting small with a low-risk rental or partnering on a deal could help him ease in and build confidence.

    Spark Rental Co-Investing Club584 Reviews
    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Denise Supplee:

      Hi @Nathan P Tanner nice to meet you here on BP and Great points..especially focusing on cash flow and conservative underwriting. I always remind new investors that trying to time the market perfectly often leads to missed opportunities. If the deal works today with solid fundamentals, it’s worth considering. For someone like your brother, starting small with a low-risk rental or partnering on a deal could help him ease in and build confidence.

      Thank you Denise, I appreciate the help. Cash flow and conservative underwriting is what im working on the most. Looking to get a great first deal so the property has some longevity and resilience. 
    • Denise SuppleeBusiness Member
      Realtor · Willow Grove, PA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 662 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Nathan P Tanner:
      Quote from @Denise Supplee:

      Hi @Nathan P Tanner nice to meet you here on BP and Great points..especially focusing on cash flow and conservative underwriting. I always remind new investors that trying to time the market perfectly often leads to missed opportunities. If the deal works today with solid fundamentals, it’s worth considering. For someone like your brother, starting small with a low-risk rental or partnering on a deal could help him ease in and build confidence.

      Thank you Denise, I appreciate the help. Cash flow and conservative underwriting is what im working on the most. Looking to get a great first deal so the property has some longevity and resilience. 

       You're welcome! That’s a great focus..cash flow and solid underwriting set the foundation for long-term success. Wishing you the best on your first deal!

      Spark Rental Co-Investing Club584 Reviews
  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    It is very smart to have an exit strategy which will help you on the front end also. If you go into it looking for a property you can get out of quickly in a pinch the property you purchase will be solid. 

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Jules Aton:

      It is very smart to have an exit strategy which will help you on the front end also. If you go into it looking for a property you can get out of quickly in a pinch the property you purchase will be solid. 


      Makes a lot of sense, what is an example of a smart exit strategy? Im working on holding properties for as long as they cash flow and still make sense.  

    • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Nathan P Tanner:
      Quote from @Jules Aton:

      It is very smart to have an exit strategy which will help you on the front end also. If you go into it looking for a property you can get out of quickly in a pinch the property you purchase will be solid. 


      Makes a lot of sense, what is an example of a smart exit strategy? Im working on holding properties for as long as they cash flow and still make sense.  


       In my opinion an exit strategy is fairly simple if the neighborhood is declining sell yesterday or today for whatever you can get and be done. That direction doesn't tend to end well. Other than a neighborhood decline if you plan to hold long term you should be in good shape. 

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    1y

    House prices could go down, but most people are in this for the long term. So if they do go down, hold on and wait for them to go back up.

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Theresa Harris:

      House prices could go down, but most people are in this for the long term. So if they do go down, hold on and wait for them to go back up.


       Short and sweet way of thinking about things, thank you for your reply.

  • Ned CareyPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2008 · 17k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    1y

                                 Don't buy stupid deals

    It is amazing how many investors miss that.  @Nathan P Tanner your list is s pretty good one. there's not much more to it. 

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Ned Carey:

                                   Don't buy stupid deals

      It is amazing how many investors miss that.  @Nathan P Tanner your list is s pretty good one. there's not much more to it. 


       Im very new to this but have been taking notes and trying to talk to the right people, been gaining 5-10 new contacts daily and taking as many calls as possible.  Working on starting this the correct way, thank you for agreeing. Im still hard at work to find my first deal. 

    • Ned CareyPro Member
      Moderator
      Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2008 · 17k+ posts · 13k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Nathan P Tanner:
      Quote from @Ned Carey:

                                   Don't buy stupid deals

      It is amazing how many investors miss that.  @Nathan P Tanner your list is s pretty good one. there's not much more to it. 


       Im very new to this but have been taking notes and trying to talk to the right people, been gaining 5-10 new contacts daily and taking as many calls as possible.  Working on starting this the correct way, thank you for agreeing. Im still hard at work to find my first deal. 

       While my reply was some what "tongue in cheek" I saw you had already had a pretty good plan.   

      I wrote the previous post as a warning to the new investors that come here and want to invest money without investing the time to really learn the market, how the number work and to understand the risks and hidden costs.  Good luck

  • Investor · DFW, TX · Member since 2014 · 18 posts · 18 votes
    1y

    It Always comes back and real estate is for the long term.   Make sure it cash flows with long term renters.    Rules can change in any city with higher taxes or even making them illegal.  

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Roger O.:

      It Always comes back and real estate is for the long term.   Make sure it cash flows with long term renters.    Rules can change in any city with higher taxes or even making them illegal.  


       Those are huge key points im going to add to my notes thank you. 

  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    Also important to tend your garden which is another reason to consider investing in your local area of expertise. There are early signs in the mostly rare event a solid neighborhood is headed for a negative change. Would a PM tell you if things were changing for the worst and its time to get out? Possibly, IDK but for me I wouldn't count on that. 

  • Investor · Madison WI · Member since 2021 · 177 posts · 103 votes
    1y

    Price drops only matter if you need to sell before prices recover. Make sure you have a healthy margin on rents to keep being able to make payments and just wait it out - then a delay in returns is the worst thing you have to worry about. 

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Chris Barrett:

      Price drops only matter if you need to sell before prices recover. Make sure you have a healthy margin on rents to keep being able to make payments and just wait it out - then a delay in returns is the worst thing you have to worry about. 


       I'm in it for the long hall so seems like you don't need to worry if you can weather the storms.  thank you for your reply.  

  • Member since 2025 · 4 posts · 5 votes
    1y

    A declining market is the perfect time to buy. 

    It's just like Warren Buffet says "Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful"

     When the market is on a decline buyers are able to beat up the sellers on prices, concessions, etc.

     Remember, in the short term, prices don't really matter.

     As long as the cash coming in is more than the cash going out, he'll be just fine.

     Over the long run prices will continue to rise.

  • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    My plan is to buy as many SFH's as I can this year. This is where we are seeing the biggest opportunities. I just had a conversation with a business partner this morning about freeing up liquid capital and buying more SFH's. I am hoping and praying that the market continues to drop, even though my net worth will drop drastically. As a B&H investor, as long as you buy in a very stable area the market WILL come back.

    For simplistic purposes, let's say I buy the same exact house in the same exact area over the course of a year at - $100k, then $75k, then $50k, and $25k. My average purchase price is $62,500. My risk continues to diminish as the market decreases and I purchase properties. If I bought one house at $100k and the market decreases I would have to wait for it to go above $100k. Since I continued to buy I only have to make it to $62,500 before making money. By the time it gets to $100k I would have made a 60% return.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · CA · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    Investing comes with risk, there's always some level of risk. Simply put don't risk what you’re not willing to lose.

    There were some areas of California that took 14 years to get back to pre GFC numbers 

    Know your market, don't overleverage.

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Alan F.:

      Investing comes with risk, there's always some level of risk. Simply put don't risk what you’re not willing to lose.

      There were some areas of California that took 14 years to get back to pre GFC numbers 

      Know your market, don't overleverage.

      Thank you Alan


  • Nathan P TannerPro Member
    OP
    New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
    1y

    Adam thank you for your example and also the reply.  Im new to the real estate investing world and I do see a lot of opportunity. Just working on my first deal and getting in the game so I can continue to buy and continue to learn. If you don't mind I was planning to send you a direct message to speak more. 

  • V.G JasonPro Member
    Investor · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y

    The answer is simple you buy right.

    You do that by paying an appropriate price for a house that you add immediate value to, has consistent & persistent rental demand, and then have enough capital to weather the yo-yo aspect for at least 7 years. If you didn't buy with those conditions, then you are at a higher risk and likely can't survive it. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2018 · 828 posts · 811 votes
    1y

    I think the difference of viewpoints is primary between those who are investing vs those who need the cash flow for income purposes. If you're looking at this as an investor, the fundamentals of cost averaging and diversifying applies. 

    if you need real estate for income purposes, then CF becomes a higher focus. Regardless of situation, having adequate reserves is a must. 

  • Member since 2024 · 24 posts · 8 votes
    1y

    I prefer to buy in a market that has declined, its less expensive.

  • Rental Property Investor · Malvern, PA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 938 votes
    1y

    Your brother shouldn't really be focused on, "Should I invest in real estate?" at the outset, if he is at the outset. He should first focus on having or getting a financial plan for his goals. Identify specific goals with dollars and income streams associated with them over time. That sets the roadmap. Next comes income and investments to achieve the goals. Does your brother have this in place?

    For most people, a W2 and savings plan are the first vehicles. Investments, such as funds, stocks, etc come next and a lot of folks stop there which is fine. What part of the plan is pushing your brother towards real estate? I would recommend pausing if it is "just make a buck." Real estate involves much more commitment in timeline and wealth than just "trying" the stock market or something like that. He has passive/active to think about, types of investments, etc. In short, it's real work unlike the stock and fund investments.

    Does he genuinely want to be a flipper or landlord? Does he have a lot of cash or willingness to take on debt for a long term investment? Does he have patience and perseverence? There are a 1,000 more questions to ask, but none of them really matter without the plan and driver. The driver has to be beyond just make money. A REIT might be better if he isn't interested in these things.

    A lot of folks get that "it might crash!" sentiment since virtually everything has crashed at some point. It's important to understand the drivers of a drop, as well as an increase, versus constantly worrying into paralysis.

    Think of the stock market. There is massive data out there on it and no one knows what will happen tomorrow. It seems to have a big drop every 5-10 years, then comes back, but no one can reliably predict the inflection points. What if it didn't come back? Oh no, I'm paralyzed and just missed a great 10-year run. The long term track record is compelling, but investors have to think long term. Comparing the stock market to real estate shows the stock market wins, but sometimes at great stress. It can feel like a ponzi scheme in which folks hope they aren't the last fool in.

    Think of real estate. I don't know that there has been a 10-year period in which real estate investing has lost money in aggregate, but there have certainly been scary times. I don't think they were nearly as scary as the stock market steep declines though because real estate values change slowly and vary by region. 2008 And COVID showed us the stock market can lose a third or half its value in a matter of days.

    People don't invest in aggregate except in funds. It's a bad experience if someone doesn't do their homework and buys a bad stock. Likewise, buying in a bad area or a bad property will also be a bad experience. Real estate has more exposure to this since entry and exit is much harder and slower than a stock or fund. A stock investor might never know the company had a problem with a building. A real estate investor will be intimately familiar with the problem.

    The driver for residential real estate is largely personal incomes. Interest rates get a lot of well deserved attention, but are largely short term noise. They are high until they are low, then back up again. There is a lot of recency bias with rate opinions. We are currently at about the historical norm for rates, but you wouldn't know that from the market sentiments.

    Incomes are the primary driver for prices and rents. They tend to rise over time and with age. The typical 75-80% LTV mortgage limits mean a buyer can leverage income 4:1 or 5:1 depending on other debts, so someone making $100k might afford a $400k home, but a raise next year to $105k and maybe more savings may mean they can afford a $420k home - the same home! As bidders are stronger, prices and rents tend to go up. There are also a lot of first time homebuyer programs that support value and increase these ratios.

    Home affordability gets a lot of attention and it always has. Younger buyers say housing is unaffordable. This has been a popular news topic for decades and there is always data to prove it and show that it is worse now than ever before. Maybe it is, but prices continue to rise and those younger people find ways to buy, then move up. Keep in mind there are many more property owners than buyers. I have never heard a property owner wish their property wasn't so valuable.

    What does this mean for your brother or anyone? In brief, housing prices and rents are not going down in aggregate over longer time frames unless there is a radical change in USA economics. This will vary by region, but the drivers are directionally consistent.

    Incomes are almost always rising. Rents and mortgage payments are related to each other. Incomes are rising and people can afford more which is an inflation driver. Inflation is almost always 2%+ per year and pushes up property values and rents. Housing demand exceeds supply and there is nothing on the horizon to change that. "They" aren't making any more land, so buyers/renters have a very difficult time getting a better place in-region without paying more or commuting further, a trade-off.

    I bought my 1st rental in 2013. What a lousy time to invest. I heard lots about risks. We were coming out of the mortgage fraud debacle and prices were just starting to sustainably turn upward (2010 might be the ideal year to buy), but would it last? Everything might happen, just like today. It was actually an awesome time to invest!!! That property I bought for $67k is now worth about $200k. I pulled out more than I invested through refi's and it has great cash flow. Yet, at the time, there were plenty of people saying, "I dunnno.....it might go down...rates might go up....that clogged toilet on Christmas day...jobs, inflation, war, boogie man..." Those people always exist and are especially vocal to every new business owner. Listen, but tune them out. I now have 14, but none of them were slam dunk "This can't lose" investments.

    There is always risk and hesitancy - and there should be! Starting a business is a big decision. Your brother should keep in mind that this is starting a business and he should want a business and understand the implications before starting one. Local real estate investor groups are great places to start getting exposure without commitment.

    • Nathan P TannerPro Member
      OP
      New to Real Estate · Bay Area California · Member since 2022 · 34 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @James Mc Ree:

      Your brother shouldn't really be focused on, "Should I invest in real estate?" at the outset, if he is at the outset. He should first focus on having or getting a financial plan for his goals. Identify specific goals with dollars and income streams associated with them over time. That sets the roadmap. Next comes income and investments to achieve the goals. Does your brother have this in place?

      For most people, a W2 and savings plan are the first vehicles. Investments, such as funds, stocks, etc come next and a lot of folks stop there which is fine. What part of the plan is pushing your brother towards real estate? I would recommend pausing if it is "just make a buck." Real estate involves much more commitment in timeline and wealth than just "trying" the stock market or something like that. He has passive/active to think about, types of investments, etc. In short, it's real work unlike the stock and fund investments.

      Does he genuinely want to be a flipper or landlord? Does he have a lot of cash or willingness to take on debt for a long term investment? Does he have patience and perseverence? There are a 1,000 more questions to ask, but none of them really matter without the plan and driver. The driver has to be beyond just make money. A REIT might be better if he isn't interested in these things.

      A lot of folks get that "it might crash!" sentiment since virtually everything has crashed at some point. It's important to understand the drivers of a drop, as well as an increase, versus constantly worrying into paralysis.

      Think of the stock market. There is massive data out there on it and no one knows what will happen tomorrow. It seems to have a big drop every 5-10 years, then comes back, but no one can reliably predict the inflection points. What if it didn't come back? Oh no, I'm paralyzed and just missed a great 10-year run. The long term track record is compelling, but investors have to think long term. Comparing the stock market to real estate shows the stock market wins, but sometimes at great stress. It can feel like a ponzi scheme in which folks hope they aren't the last fool in.

      Think of real estate. I don't know that there has been a 10-year period in which real estate investing has lost money in aggregate, but there have certainly been scary times. I don't think they were nearly as scary as the stock market steep declines though because real estate values change slowly and vary by region. 2008 And COVID showed us the stock market can lose a third or half its value in a matter of days.

      People don't invest in aggregate except in funds. It's a bad experience if someone doesn't do their homework and buys a bad stock. Likewise, buying in a bad area or a bad property will also be a bad experience. Real estate has more exposure to this since entry and exit is much harder and slower than a stock or fund. A stock investor might never know the company had a problem with a building. A real estate investor will be intimately familiar with the problem.

      The driver for residential real estate is largely personal incomes. Interest rates get a lot of well deserved attention, but are largely short term noise. They are high until they are low, then back up again. There is a lot of recency bias with rate opinions. We are currently at about the historical norm for rates, but you wouldn't know that from the market sentiments.

      Incomes are the primary driver for prices and rents. They tend to rise over time and with age. The typical 75-80% LTV mortgage limits mean a buyer can leverage income 4:1 or 5:1 depending on other debts, so someone making $100k might afford a $400k home, but a raise next year to $105k and maybe more savings may mean they can afford a $420k home - the same home! As bidders are stronger, prices and rents tend to go up. There are also a lot of first time homebuyer programs that support value and increase these ratios.

      Home affordability gets a lot of attention and it always has. Younger buyers say housing is unaffordable. This has been a popular news topic for decades and there is always data to prove it and show that it is worse now than ever before. Maybe it is, but prices continue to rise and those younger people find ways to buy, then move up. Keep in mind there are many more property owners than buyers. I have never heard a property owner wish their property wasn't so valuable.

      What does this mean for your brother or anyone? In brief, housing prices and rents are not going down in aggregate over longer time frames unless there is a radical change in USA economics. This will vary by region, but the drivers are directionally consistent.

      Incomes are almost always rising. Rents and mortgage payments are related to each other. Incomes are rising and people can afford more which is an inflation driver. Inflation is almost always 2%+ per year and pushes up property values and rents. Housing demand exceeds supply and there is nothing on the horizon to change that. "They" aren't making any more land, so buyers/renters have a very difficult time getting a better place in-region without paying more or commuting further, a trade-off.

      I bought my 1st rental in 2013. What a lousy time to invest. I heard lots about risks. We were coming out of the mortgage fraud debacle and prices were just starting to sustainably turn upward (2010 might be the ideal year to buy), but would it last? Everything might happen, just like today. It was actually an awesome time to invest!!! That property I bought for $67k is now worth about $200k. I pulled out more than I invested through refi's and it has great cash flow. Yet, at the time, there were plenty of people saying, "I dunnno.....it might go down...rates might go up....that clogged toilet on Christmas day...jobs, inflation, war, boogie man..." Those people always exist and are especially vocal to every new business owner. Listen, but tune them out. I now have 14, but none of them were slam dunk "This can't lose" investments.

      There is always risk and hesitancy - and there should be! Starting a business is a big decision. Your brother should keep in mind that this is starting a business and he should want a business and understand the implications before starting one. Local real estate investor groups are great places to start getting exposure without commitment.


       I think my brothers comment was completely valid getting into this industry its on everyone's mind. I agree with your words above and makes a lot of sense.  doing research, meeting investors, speaking with people like yourself, speaking with lenders, agents, going to meet ups. these are all things ive been doing for 3 years now and i have done this well continuing to grow my personal consulting business.  I now have contracts signed with an SLE and need to find a property for them to occupy with a 5 year lease. 

      I've spent endless hours gaining knowledge in this industry and for me the regular SFH rental market just doesn't make sense for now. Later down the road I plan to have a handful of SFH rentals but for now im working on monthly cash flow and the SLE is how im going to do that.

      its always going up and down but always goes up. Just working on getting some boats in the water for when the water rises i'll be in and ready. 

       Thank you for your concise reply I appreciate your knowledge.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.