Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
A $105,000 refinance on a $73,000 purchase doesn't tell you how much of the investor's own money is still in the property.
Here's the breakdown from a closed deal I helped arrange as a mortgage broker:
• Purchase: $73,000, financed with a short-term hard money loan.
• Investor's cash at the purchase closing: $20,323.71.
• Approved rehab budget: about $26,300, with roughly $20,000 reimbursed through draws.
• Refinance: a $105,000, 30-year DSCR loan seven weeks later, without a seasoning wait on this deal.
• Cash returned to the investor at the refinance closing: $14,336.85.
• Appraisal paid separately by the investor: $865.
The closing-document math is:
$20,323.71 + $865 - $14,336.85 = $6,851.86.
That's about $6,850, plus whatever the investor spent on rehab beyond the draw reimbursements. It is not a verified all-in cash-left-in-the-deal figure. The approved rehab budget and actual rehab spending aren't the same thing.
That's the part worth checking on any BRRRR breakdown: does the headline number include unreimbursed rehab, or only the purchase and refinance cash flows?
The seven-week refinance was specific to this file, not a promise that every DSCR program allows the same timeline. Plan the refinance before buying, and check the seasoning requirements before assuming your cash will come back on a particular schedule.
When you calculate cash left in a BRRRR, do you track rehab reimbursements separately from your total rehab spending?
Erik, good breakdown — and the honest answer is at least $6,850 left in, not zero, once you count everything. The $105K refi on a $73K purchase looks like a full pull-out until you add the $20,323 in cash at the purchase closing, the $865 appraisal, and the rehab spending that never came back through draws. That's the piece most BRRRR breakdowns skip. On my Memphis deals the same math applies: I buy single-family under $100K, rehab it, rent it Section 8 at $1,395-$1,950 for a 3BR+, then refi at 70-80% LTV against an ARV of $180K-$265K. Cash left in is all-in minus refi proceeds — every dollar, not just the closing figures. A deal with $6,850 left in and a rented house is still a good deal. The question is whether the rent covers the new payment with room to spare.
Laying the closing figures out this way is more honest than most BRRRR posts, and to your question, the $6,850 only covers the two closings. Anything paid out of pocket between them belongs in the number too. Rehab spent beyond the roughly $20,000 in draws is the big one, but seven weeks of carrying never shows up on either closing statement either: insurance, utilities, and hard money interest paid monthly, unless it was prepaid or held back at the purchase closing. The cleanest way to think about it is that cash left in the deal is everything that left the investor's account and didn't come back, whichever document it sits on. Did the receipts come in above or below the $26,300 approved budget?
The borrower didn’t take the full draw at the end. He only spent the $20,323.71 and the remaining cash was not used, so the payoff was lower at the end.
Thanks for breaking this down Erik. A lot of people see a $105k refi on a $73k purchase and think it is all profit. They forget the $6,850 still left in the deal plus the rehab money that did not come back. And that 7 week refi with no seasoning wait, that is the part people miss. Not every DSCR program will allow that. Appreciate you sharing the real numbers.
Erik, good breakdown — and the honest answer is at least $6,850 left in, not zero, once you count everything. The $105K refi on a $73K purchase looks like a full pull-out until you add the $20,323 in cash at the purchase closing, the $865 appraisal, and the rehab spending that never came back through draws. That's the piece most BRRRR breakdowns skip. On my Memphis deals the same math applies: I buy single-family under $100K, rehab it, rent it Section 8 at $1,395-$1,950 for a 3BR+, then refi at 70-80% LTV against an ARV of $180K-$265K. Cash left in is all-in minus refi proceeds — every dollar, not just the closing figures. A deal with $6,850 left in and a rented house is still a good deal. The question is whether the rent covers the new payment with room to spare.
@Erik Estrada - All great points. There are rehab costs, transaction costs (of both loans), and holding costs that all add up to the total cost of capital still left in the deal. I've always thought getting "all your money back" on BRRRs deals was a lot harder than people make it out to be. And, of course, you have some BRRRs where you leave more in the deal and some where you leave less in the deal. If you're leaving ,$10k or so in the deal (after the refinance) I would consider that a successful BRRRR. Thanks!
Your math is right: $20,323.71 in minus $14,336.85 back is $5,986.86, plus the $865 appraisal gets you $6,851.86. The number people forget is rehab and holding costs paid in cash, since those usually aren't in the closing statements. Add those, then compare cash left against the annual cash flow after the new DSCR payment. That ratio tells you if the refi did its job. What did the rehab run?