$7M on one deal and it's out there for the whole world to see.
Now, all you naysayers, please have a seat because we're tired of you talking out your back.
I just want to know what website he got his $106mm POF letter from.
Aaron, go fish!
Assumptions. Notice that he or she who makes them may very well be making themselves out to be the first 3 letters of that word. Get the facts Jack.
After I purchased Aaron's wholesaling course for the one day only price of $1995, I turned that investment into hundreds of thousands of dollars in my first year! - That is a joke for those who take everything so literally!!!!!!!
In all seriousness, Aaron posted a link to a story in which it describes a high profile big number transaction to point out that wholesaling is alive and well, even in big numbers, likely because wholesaling as a strategy often gets bashed on BP and elsewhere. I know Aaron has wholesaled his fair share of deals and this is likely a defense to a strategy he has enjoyed, and by enjoyed, I mean profited from! Nothing wrong with that and likely the only agenda as the only thing I know him to have for sale is a property.
I created a thread (found here) http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/93/topics/5838... which is likely one of the most popular, and in my bias opinion, best wholesaling threads on BP. After reading a few posts, many came on to believe I was bashing the strategy or perhaps the investors utilizing it. As I quickly pointed out, nothing could be further from the truth. I have wholesaled several deals and made good money doing it. The reason for my thread was to point out what one wholesaler (and several subsequent wholesalers) did wrong so that others would do it right. Some of the very best lessons are learned from mistakes of others. Nothing more complex than that with no other hidden agendas.
So like Aaron, I hope this thread leads others to mine where they can learn how a small, medium, or large time investor can wholesale both legally, properly, ethically, and profitably.
Now I will pick up my box of half eaten popcorn . . . . . . .
This topic never disappoints
@James Wise Its interesting you would post that reply..
Will, this thread doesn't have much value, it doesn't make any case as the title implies, it simply shows a much more sophisticated investor did a contract assignment, that deal is about as far away from the ploys attempted by wholesalers here as you could possibly get. BTW, there was no mention of that guy being licensed or having representation and I'm sure there was more than one attorney at the table.
Nothing wrong with assigning a contract, if done properly, usually, as a business model where that's all you do, you'll have other issues, which is what the wholesaler in Florida (a member here) was getting nailed for a few weeks ago.
Reminds me of something we said in the Army......The Army is a great institution, it's the people in it that are the problem.
What we get in this niche are the beginners trying to break in. They go for the advertised pitch, no money, no credit, nor other knowledge, just a quick step program to be a success. What we also get are young, naïve, misinformed, ambitious, cocky, super star attitudes who have found that pushing others into this realm is a great way to make contacts with those naïve wannabes to prey upon them. We have the wannabe gurus as well as the gurus, the lack of experience makes the wannabe guru even worse out in public.
The real truth about wholesaling is that it takes RE skills that are just as demanding as any other aspect of RE, it's not an easy strategy, in fact, it can be more challenging as wholesalers work in a small market niche compared to what they could be doing if they had the knowledge to do well at wholesaling and do it right.
I was wholesaling transactions before some guru gave it a name. And, if you're calling flipping contracts to an end buyer wholesaling, no, I doubt anyone in wholesaling has flipped as many contracts as I have, for Pete's Sake, all the bad loans, installment contracts, failed rehab projects by homeowners and new contractors that came across my desk.....really, there is no way any bush beater or wanabe guru could generate that type of activity looking for buyers and sellers.
I'm actually seeing my contribution is this thread and other wholesaling threads as counter productive, it just fans their little flames to continue. So, with that, you all carry on in this public forum where anyone can post just about anything.
I do suggest reading Will's thread. :)
The funniest part about this topic surfacing yet again is that when people like me come in from overseas, (and there are hundreds if not thousands of us), we all get legal advice on the do's and don'ts etc. Not once have I ever heard anybody be told they need to get licensed. We spent thousands on lawyers to check everything and it is not an issue in any state I have operated in. So whilst people want to make it an issue I can't find anyone who thinks it is :-)
SALES AND PURCHASE AGREEMENT
Date: / /
I / We will give for the following described property located in (NAME) County, in the state of (STATE), and legally known as: (INSERT FULL LEGAL DESCRIPTION)
Address: 123 Any St. Any City, Any State. Any Zip Code
Purchase Price: Seventy-two Thousand ($72,000.00)
Payment: Cash at closing.
Earnest Money Deposit: A deposit in the sum of (Twenty-dollars) ($20) will be paid by buyer and held in escrow at:
( NAME) Title/Escrow Company. Whose address is: (ADDRESS).
Closing: Closing will be no sooner than 45-days and no longer than 60-days from the date of acceptance this contract as demonstrated by buyer and seller signing this agreement. 45-day date: 60-day date:
Title: An unencumbered, marketable title to said property to be conveyed by deed of General Warranty, with the usual covenants such as any title company will insure, except easements of record, restrictive covenants of record as to use and improvement of said property, and except applicable regulations imposed by any planning and zoning commission.
Contract Stipulations:
-Outstanding property taxes shall be pro-rated between Buyer and Seller as of closing date.
-Property is being purchased in “AS-IS” condition. Seller is not responsible for any repairs.
-Seller shall maintain property in good working order until Buyer takes possession.
-All closing costs to be paid by Buyer.
-Contract to purchase property is contingent upon satisfactory property inspection and final business associate approval.
-A lock-box will be discretely affixed to the property to permit access upon proper notification to seller.
Possession: At closing
We have read the entire contents of this agreement and acknowledge receipt of same. We are not relying on verbal statements not contained herein.
The above proposition is accepted this ________ day of ____________________, 20__.
Seller
Seller Signature: ___________________________________
Seller Printed Name: ________________________________
Buyer
Buyer Signature: ___________________________________
Buyer Printed Name: ________________________________"
Saw this,
Oh James, I thought you had a license and would be using an approved contract!
$20, LOL use an earnest money note and save the lunch money, bet the escrow agent loves that, accounting entries of $20.
Any insurance issues, what happens if a tree falls on the place while under contract? I happens! Who get insurance proceeds, who elects to repair.....many other insurance issues.
Any disclosures required there?
Title requirements are a bit unorthodox, Seller shall grant title by a General Warranty Deed acceptable to any Title insurance company conducting business in the State of GA as may be selected by the buyer excepting only those maters customary under ALTA (spell it out) requirements.
Another covenant not with title: The property shall conform to all applicable zoning and building regulations imposed by proper jurisdictions at the time of settlement as a residential property.
What happens if the seller backs out, any remedies? An option allows you and a buyer to walk away.
Seller to maintain the property but selling "as is" some conflict there` as worded, if an outdoor faucet blows a washer and water starts running out, the seller doesn't fix it? Just lets the water run? If he doesn't the property is being maintained. Tons of other examples, could apply.
I see you have your weasel clause, put it off on the undisclosed business partner.....
I think your contract needs some revision, sorry, I wouldn't use it. :)
The funniest part about this topic surfacing yet again is that when people like me come in from overseas, (and there are hundreds if not thousands of us), we all get legal advice on the do's and don'ts etc. Not once have I ever heard anybody be told they need to get licensed. We spent thousands on lawyers to check everything and it is not an issue in any state I have operated in. So whilst people want to make it an issue I can't find anyone who thinks it is :-)
That's really absurd Dean, it can be an issue in all states, it depends on how you go about it. All states have RE license laws, those representing or facilitating sales, the laws are not consistent and do vary, some with wider doors than others, but wholesaling can become an issue.
I also see you teach, that may explain it. :)
I don't teach any more haven't for years. Georgia, Tennessee and Arizona have no issues so it isn't absurd it is just the facts. I can't find an attorney who says there is any issue wholesaling. In fact BP is the only place I have ever heard of anybody complaining about it :-)
@Jason Farmer why?
@Bill Gulley sarcasm, or did you not read the whole post?
@Aaron Mazzrillo , I wish I had the foresight to study something so relevant to my current line of business, so I am going to take that as a compliment.
I believe in the value of wholesalers like yourself, recently purchased a deal from a buddy who is also a buy and hold investor in my same area and was short on cash, so I paid him a $15K assignment as the property still met my acquisition criteria. However I get so frustrated looking at 'deals' sent to me buy newbie wholesalers, and I feel for their sellers who often get burned.
I am also working on a larger commercial redevelopment deal where we are raising capital in the low 7 figure amount that we also picked up from another investor who got his hands on an even bigger deal and kicked this one to us for a small equity kicker. Instead he is doing a 200,000 sq-ft mixed use development in a class A town and they are raising capital in the mid 8 figures and I can tell you that on any development deal investors putting their money up are expecting a certain rate of return. Companies don't get into the mega development business without delivering returns to their investors. Given the cost of the due diligence, legal process, plans, approvals, ect, there is a good chance this $7M 'wholesale deal' was closer to a net zero then a huge win for the developers after covering fees, expenses, and paying out investors.
BTW My post is in no was meant to bash REAL wholesaler, but this deal is not related to residential transaction wholesale deals where wholesalers have a screw the seller clause hidden in their contract somewhere. A real wholesaler adds value to an investors business and we work closely with them as part of our acquisition strategy. But most people who are newbies and try to go out on their own and start a wholesale business are time wasters.
This topic should be off limits before 9am.
I didn't read one thing in every page of the thread. The only interesting thing, and funny that made it worth it was the GIF's by @Account Closed Keep em coming. :)
@Jason Farmer why?
@Bill Gulley sarcasm, or did you not read the whole post?
Honestly James, I missed "typically we get something like the following" really that was just a few words out of that entire post, so you got me! Yes, we could take it as sarcasm, but I'm rarely sarcastic :)
I'm relieved that you aren't using that contract, I didn't want to tear it up that bad since it was you, but you're right, that's much of what we get. I'll read your posts slower and more carefully. :)
Steve...."real wholesalers" really, here, in this thread? I'm not convinced yet. I here fish bait flying by, but nothing has been pulled out from the depths yet :)
I don't teach any more haven't for years. Georgia, Tennessee and Arizona have no issues so it isn't absurd it is just the facts. I can't find an attorney who says there is any issue wholesaling. In fact BP is the only place I have ever heard of anybody complaining about it :-)
Dean, I am going to use an analogy here that I have used for this topic many times. Is it illegal to drive a car? No, but if you do so and speed, run a red light, drive while intoxicated, etc. it becomes illegal. It is not illegal to wholesale, but you can wholesale illegally, unethically, etc. There are the correct ways to do it and then there are the wrong ways to do it, go down that road and you may find yourself in legal troubles. That is the main point here.
Bill, I will give you the fact that the title of this thread does not prove wholesaling is legal, moral, etc, however, people need to stop taking things so literally and keep in mind that coming up with creative and catchy thread titles helps drive attention and traffic to them, it was even recommended by BP at some point. For example, there is a thread title with "Don't do business with Will Barnard" - everyone came to it thinking perhaps I screwed someone or something and the first post was "Because today is his Birthday so give him a day off". In other words, not everything is as the title seems, nor should it. I believe the only point was to enlighten and encourage, nothing more. And thanks for recommending my thread, it is intended for those who want to learn how to do it the right way.
I don't teach any more haven't for years. Georgia, Tennessee and Arizona have no issues so it isn't absurd it is just the facts. I can't find an attorney who says there is any issue wholesaling. In fact BP is the only place I have ever heard of anybody complaining about it :-)
Yup. Trouble is that most here on BP are unable to cite relevant info regarding this supposed unlawful activity outside of possible brokering violations. Some post articles about realtor boards and RE depts. going after those brokering without a license. Some post citations of disciplinary actions by realtor boards or RE depts. Putting brokering issues aside, where is the evidence or case law that shows that those optioning or contracting to buy and then assigning or double closing are acting unlawfully. Where is the case law that shows a buyer must have intent or funds to close. Brokering issues are real. But so is contract law.
The State of Ohio has apparently decided that it is time to provide you guys with some case law. Here's a nice thread on this:
http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/93/topics/9578...
Don't know if they've succeeded yet, but just the fact that they are talking about it openly sorta pushes me away...
The State of Ohio has apparently decided that it is time to provide you guys with some case law. Here's a nice thread on this:
http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/93/topics/9578...
Don't know if they've succeeded yet, but just the fact that they are talking about it openly sorta pushes me away...
I remember that thread pretty well. There is some interesting stuff there with the OH trying to prevent activities that tie-up properties, such as options, in order to protect consumers from buyers not able to close, or from buyers planning to profit on a spread. I doubt we'll see any enduring case law out of it. The State can and should go after brokering activities. It'll be interesting to see what they come up with to prevent people from participating in regular, everyday contract activities, such as assignments. It would have bizarre unintended consequences, unless the exemptions were a mile long.
Contract law is real, to be sure. It does not necessarily control. And many questionable wholesaling practices are not even absolved by reference to contract law.
For example, intent is important in contract law. The parties must mutually intend to enter into a contractual relationship. This can trip wholesalers up in several ways. One way is that if the intent is itself illegal or contrary to public policy, no contract is created. So, for example, if the intent of the parties was to circumvent valid brokerage regulations, there may not be a valid contract.
Another way intent matters is that the parties must mutually intend something, and that meeting of the minds must be supported. A purported contract where one party intends to sell a house and the other party intends in effect to create an option may be unenforceable. That is the reason for the frequent advice that a wholesaler make sure she is able to demonstrate that she has the means to actually close.
Even where there is a valid contract, there are many wrinkles to contract assignment. This is a matter of contract law, not real estate law per se. I have consulted with companies that have assigned contracts (specifically, telecom companies assigning to another company their contracts to provide cable television to certain municipalities.) It is not as simple as,"We have a contract, it doesn't forbid assignment, we're good!" For one thing, contracts have to specify that they are assignable, or they will be held not to be assignable (the reason for the "and/or assigns" advice. But that doesn't necessarily cover it either. The fact is that contract law is not necessarily superior to other law. Regulations promulgated under valid enabling legislation will trump general provisions of contract law. For example, regulations of the Public Utilities Commission in the case of telecom contracts. Or brokerage regulations in the case of real estate.
There are other areas of concern as well. Is assignment of contracts legal? Yes, generally. Can it be illegal? Yes, certainly.
The notion that, "But, but, but...the law of Contract!!!" is a get out of jail free card is simply inaccurate.
Now established people like Aaron and yourself might well be fine. You have the resources to get professional legal assistance when needed, you could probably show that you had the ability to close (which makes proving you never intended to much harder), you are experienced enough that you can probably stay on the right side of the law and beneath the radar.
But there are hundreds if not thousands of posts on this very website from "wholesalers" who have absolutely no idea what they are doing. And when you tell people like that not to worry, it's all good, this is perfectly legal...you are doing them and the people they will be dealing with a grave disservice. Telling an idiot who is about to break the law and screw over a seller to pause for a minute, and not screw over a seller, that's not "naysaying."
Wholesaling can be done legally and ethically. So can selling aluminum siding door to door, or payday lending, or a whole bunch of other things. But they are often not. And encouraging people to actually learn something about what they are doing before mucking about in things they do not understand is not a bad thing.
The State of Ohio has apparently decided that it is time to provide you guys with some case law. Here's a nice thread on this:
http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/93/topics/9578...
Don't know if they've succeeded yet, but just the fact that they are talking about it openly sorta pushes me away...
I remember that thread pretty well. There is some interesting stuff there with the OH trying to prevent activities that tie-up properties, such as options, in order to protect consumers from buyers not able to close, or from buyers planning to profit on a spread. I doubt we'll see any enduring case law out of it. The State can and should go after brokering activities. It'll be interesting to see what they come up with to prevent people from participating in regular, everyday contract activities, such as assignments. It would have bizarre unintended consequences, unless the exemptions were a mile long.
I expect the thing they will trip up most people on is the advertising provisions. The law there is very clear and explicit. You cannot advertise or otherwise market a house you do not own without a license. Putting "FOR SALE (a contract to purchase) A 3BDR..." in front of standard listing language in a letter or on a website is unlikely to absolve you.
I expect the thing they will trip up most people on is the advertising provisions. The law there is very clear and explicit. You cannot advertise or otherwise market a house you do not own without a license. Putting "FOR SALE (a contract to purchase) A 3BDR..." in front of standard listing language in a letter or on a website is unlikely to absolve you.
So how will equitable interest vs ownership be differentiated?
I expect the thing they will trip up most people on is the advertising provisions. The law there is very clear and explicit. You cannot advertise or otherwise market a house you do not own without a license. Putting "FOR SALE (a contract to purchase) A 3BDR..." in front of standard listing language in a letter or on a website is unlikely to absolve you.
So how will equitable interest vs ownership be differentiated?
Easily, as they are not the same thing. You don't have title, you don't own it. Ohio is particularly clear: You need to have the written consent of the actual owner of the property to advertise.
@K.
@Account Closed undefined
Interestingly, they are taking the argument of "it's legal to assign/sell equitable interest" off the table by specifically focusing on marketing - you can't market. I'm a licensee in Ohio and this smells like realtors want no competition...
Also, focus on "marketing" sort of takes not only the property, but potentially paper off the table. Marketing a contract - could an argument be made that this is unlicensed marketing of a security...? Is that the implication past real property...
I think that by focusing the language on "unlicensed activities" foundation is being laid for something...
I expect the thing they will trip up most people on is the advertising provisions. The law there is very clear and explicit. You cannot advertise or otherwise market a house you do not own without a license. Putting "FOR SALE (a contract to purchase) A 3BDR..." in front of standard listing language in a letter or on a website is unlikely to absolve you.
So how will equitable interest vs ownership be differentiated?
Easily, as they are not the same thing. You don't have title, you don't own it. Ohio is particularly clear: You need to have the written consent of the actual owner of the property to advertise.
So you just have the sellers sign something giving you permission to advertise the sale of your contract.
No idea why the hell everyone always have to make stuff so damn complicated for no reason...
The State of Ohio has apparently decided that it is time to provide you guys with some case law. Here's a nice thread on this:
http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/93/topics/9578...
Don't know if they've succeeded yet, but just the fact that they are talking about it openly sorta pushes me away...
I remember that thread pretty well. There is some interesting stuff there with the OH trying to prevent activities that tie-up properties, such as options, in order to protect consumers from buyers not able to close, or from buyers planning to profit on a spread. I doubt we'll see any enduring case law out of it. The State can and should go after brokering activities. It'll be interesting to see what they come up with to prevent people from participating in regular, everyday contract activities, such as assignments. It would have bizarre unintended consequences, unless the exemptions were a mile long.
I expect the thing they will trip up most people on is the advertising provisions. The law there is very clear and explicit. You cannot advertise or otherwise market a house you do not own without a license. Putting "FOR SALE (a contract to purchase) A 3BDR..." in front of standard listing language in a letter or on a website is unlikely to absolve you.
I agree. Going after marketing by those with options and contracts to buy is the low hanging fruit of brokering without a license activities.
Even so "compensation" is a complicating factor in brokering regs and laws. It might not be that easy to take somebody down who is not being compensated for their supposed brokering activity (a sign placed for no compensation to the buyer). Or someone who is not marketing the real property (but rather a "contract for sale"). IMO you can make yourself an easy target if you call your asking price for your contract a "fee". Fee indicates fee for service. Fee for service in RE is often thought of as a licensed activity. Why go there.