How much profit do you consider when underwriting fix and flips by price range?
I am in Memphis Tn. Memphis has very dynamic market. Meaning, there is a sub 100k market, sub 250k market, 250-400k market, 400-600k market, 700-1m and $1m+ market. While each market operates very differently. as well they come with different expectations.
A standard 15% - 20% profit margin doesn't work across these markets. A standard 50k in profit doesn't work across all markets.
Speaking in terms of Profit after:
Financing Origination
Carrying Cost
Closing Cost
Holding time 6, 12, or 18 months.
How do you approach determining your projected profits.
From the lending side, I'd frame it as profit per dollar of your own cash and per month of hold, not a flat percent or a flat dollar number. A $90K Memphis house might only net $25K, but if a loan covers most of it you might have $20K in and be out in four months. A $650K flip netting $70K can tie up $90K or more of your cash for nine or ten months once you count down payment, closing, interest and the gap before each draw reimburses you. Both look like good deals, with very different returns on time and money.
A few things shift by price band. Financing cost scales with loan size and hold time, so on the bigger houses a two or three month slip on resale eats a much bigger share of the margin. The buyer pool shrinks as price goes up, so I'd budget more days on market above $400K than below it. And lenders get pickier at the top end. Once ARV gets into the high six figures, most want to see you've already sold at a similar price, so leverage can drop and your cash in goes up, which changes the math again.
Full disclosure, I'm a lender, and I see a lot of flip budgets that worked at 6 months and didn't at 10. Running profit at 6, 12 and 18 months like you're doing is the right instinct.
Jamie, great question, and you're right that one number doesn't fit every band. What we see work best is setting a minimum dollar profit for the low end and a percentage for the higher end, then stress testing both against time. Under 100K, a percentage target can look fine on paper and still leave you with too few dollars to absorb one surprise, so a dollar floor matters more there. Above 400K, carrying cost becomes the big swing, because every extra month of interest and taxes on a larger loan eats margin fast. We'd run every deal at your planned hold and again at six months longer, and only take the ones that still clear your floor on the longer timeline. How are you seeing days on market differ across those bands right now?
Lindsay and Ryan with Futures Funding
Jamie, great question, and you're right that one number doesn't fit every band. What we see work best is setting a minimum dollar profit for the low end and a percentage for the higher end, then stress testing both against time. Under 100K, a percentage target can look fine on paper and still leave you with too few dollars to absorb one surprise, so a dollar floor matters more there. Above 400K, carrying cost becomes the big swing, because every extra month of interest and taxes on a larger loan eats margin fast. We'd run every deal at your planned hold and again at six months longer, and only take the ones that still clear your floor on the longer timeline. How are you seeing days on market differ across those bands right now?
Lindsay and Ryan with Futures Funding
Your analysis makes sense. Me personally, I am not comfortable with properties, under 100k. Thats is due to the items you describe. CAPeX is the same across the board until you get to houses over 1500 sqft. Systems have to be dialed in with Estimating repair cost.
I will look to make sub 100k Offers on properties in the 250k+ range. To answer your question; I don't even consider making an offer if the average days on market is over 90 days. If the average days on market is over 90 days, that mean that this area, price point, or sub market is being effected strongly by market conditions OR is not as desirable for fix and flip product.
How much profit do you consider when underwriting fix and flips by price range?
I am in Memphis Tn. Memphis has very dynamic market. Meaning, there is a sub 100k market, sub 250k market, 250-400k market, 400-600k market, 700-1m and $1m+ market. While each market operates very differently. as well they come with different expectations.
A standard 15% - 20% profit margin doesn't work across these markets. A standard 50k in profit doesn't work across all markets.
Speaking in terms of Profit after:
Financing Origination
Carrying Cost
Closing Cost
Holding time 6, 12, or 18 months.
How do you approach determining your projected profits.
I agree that one profit target doesn't work across every price range. I usually look at the actual dollars left after all costs, holding time, and a cushion for unexpected repairs rather than relying on a fixed percentage. The higher the risk and the longer the hold, the more profit I'd want to justify the deal. I've also seen investors explore the Midwest for flips where lower acquisition costs can create some good opportunities, especially off-market deals.
How much profit do you consider when underwriting fix and flips by price range?
I am in Memphis Tn. Memphis has very dynamic market. Meaning, there is a sub 100k market, sub 250k market, 250-400k market, 400-600k market, 700-1m and $1m+ market. While each market operates very differently. as well they come with different expectations.
A standard 15% - 20% profit margin doesn't work across these markets. A standard 50k in profit doesn't work across all markets.
Speaking in terms of Profit after:
Financing Origination
Carrying Cost
Closing Cost
Holding time 6, 12, or 18 months.
How do you approach determining your projected profits.
I agree that one profit target doesn't work across every price range. I usually look at the actual dollars left after all costs, holding time, and a cushion for unexpected repairs rather than relying on a fixed percentage. The higher the risk and the longer the hold, the more profit I'd want to justify the deal. I've also seen investors explore the Midwest for flips where lower acquisition costs can create some good opportunities, especially off-market deals.
My first flip was found on the market. I am pursuing other opportunities that are listed. On Market deals are just as good, if I get at or close to my price. Going off market my offer more flexiblity but in my experience "cost to lead" is inflated if Im prospecting for my self. Paying a wholesaler isnt a bad proposition, Im just not ready for that step at this time.
When you say midwest, are you including Ohio?
I'd set a dollar floor first and let the percentage fall out of it. On a sub 100k Memphis house a 15% margin is only about 12k, and one surprise roof wipes that out, so I'd want 25k to 30k minimum there. In the 250k to 400k range I'd want 40k or more, and above 600k the carry on the loan swings things most, so I'd care more about the percent and the timeline. Run every deal at six months longer than planned and only buy it if it still clears your floor.
I'd set a dollar floor first and let the percentage fall out of it. On a sub 100k Memphis house a 15% margin is only about 12k, and one surprise roof wipes that out, so I'd want 25k to 30k minimum there. In the 250k to 400k range I'd want 40k or more, and above 600k the carry on the loan swings things most, so I'd care more about the percent and the timeline. Run every deal at six months longer than planned and only buy it if it still clears your floor.
When your expected outcomes, I am tracking very similarly with your numbers. 50k Flips in the 250k-400k ARV range is like a home run. I have learned to add closing cost, carrying cost, into my offer at all price points. My concern as properties move to higher price points, is the holding cost. In Memphis 500k-700k can be considered luxury. 800k+ starts the ultra luxury homes price points.
I made an offer on a 700k+ ARV with a swimming pool. 100k in rehab, I wanted 75k-100k in profit because of the pool Do you think thats a little too ambitious, even considering the pool?
Hi Jamie, I'd add one more lens on top of a dollar floor, which is profit per month that your cash is tied up. A 40k profit on a 6 month hold and a 40k profit on an 18 month hold are completely different deals, but they look the same if you only set one number per price band. So I set a floor for the band, then check what the deal pays per month of hold and per dollar of my own cash in it.
Quick example. If you have 60k of your own money in a deal and net 30k in 6 months, that's 5k a month and a 50% return on your cash. The same 30k over 12 months is half that per month, and you also gave up the next deal you could have done with that money. On the higher end the dollars look bigger, but your cash in, carry, and time on market all grow too, so the return per month can end up lower than on a sub 100k house.
I'd also run the sale side honestly, with commission, seller concessions, transfer costs, and a couple of extra loan payments built in, because that's where most margins quietly disappear. If a deal still clears your floor at the longer hold and still pays you a monthly number you'd be happy with, it's a buy.
Redgy
Jamie, I am in Memphis too, but I do not flip, I hold. So my profit test is different from a flip margin. I buy single-family under $100K, rehab it to an ARV of $180K-$265K, and rent it for $1,395-$1,950 for a 3BR+ on Section 8. That spread is the profit, and it has to leave rent that covers vacancy, repairs, management through my in-house team at Memphis Passive, taxes, and insurance, and a DSCR refinance at 70-80% LTV. If the spread does not do that, I pass, even in the sub-$100K band where a flip margin looks thin. For a hold, the question is not how much profit at sale, it is whether the rent after the rehab carries the house. Are you looking at these Memphis houses to flip, or to hold?
Jamie, I am in Memphis too, but I do not flip, I hold. So my profit test is different from a flip margin. I buy single-family under $100K, rehab it to an ARV of $180K-$265K, and rent it for $1,395-$1,950 for a 3BR+ on Section 8. That spread is the profit, and it has to leave rent that covers vacancy, repairs, management through my in-house team at Memphis Passive, taxes, and insurance, and a DSCR refinance at 70-80% LTV. If the spread does not do that, I pass, even in the sub-$100K band where a flip margin looks thin. For a hold, the question is not how much profit at sale, it is whether the rent after the rehab carries the house. Are you looking at these Memphis houses to flip, or to hold?
Are you using Ai?
From the lending side, I'd frame it as profit per dollar of your own cash and per month of hold, not a flat percent or a flat dollar number. A $90K Memphis house might only net $25K, but if a loan covers most of it you might have $20K in and be out in four months. A $650K flip netting $70K can tie up $90K or more of your cash for nine or ten months once you count down payment, closing, interest and the gap before each draw reimburses you. Both look like good deals, with very different returns on time and money.
A few things shift by price band. Financing cost scales with loan size and hold time, so on the bigger houses a two or three month slip on resale eats a much bigger share of the margin. The buyer pool shrinks as price goes up, so I'd budget more days on market above $400K than below it. And lenders get pickier at the top end. Once ARV gets into the high six figures, most want to see you've already sold at a similar price, so leverage can drop and your cash in goes up, which changes the math again.
Full disclosure, I'm a lender, and I see a lot of flip budgets that worked at 6 months and didn't at 10. Running profit at 6, 12 and 18 months like you're doing is the right instinct.
I'd let the band set the floor, then add margin based on how soft the ARV is. The lower bands usually have more recent sales to pin the resale price, so the margin mostly has to cover rehab surprises. At 500k and up a neighborhood can have only a few true comps, and one sale can move the ARV by more than your whole margin. So I'd want more cushion there even at the same percent.
The other line I'd price on any 12 month bridge is the extension. Most of the lenders I shop charge a fee in points to extend past maturity, and some also step the rate up. That's on top of the monthly interest you're already carrying, so it belongs in the projection before you need it.
How many sold comps are you finding in the 500k+ bands right now?
Great question. I'll be following. I'm in North Alabama and we have a standard flip number of 20k . Our buy box is 60-100k with 30-60k in repairs. We do volume so it allows for production instead of one offs. Thank you for contributing to our community !
Great question. I'll be following. I'm in North Alabama and we have a standard flip number of 20k . Our buy box is 60-100k with 30-60k in repairs. We do volume so it allows for production instead of one offs. Thank you for contributing to our community !
20k in profit on 100k isn't bad. However at that price point are all your purchase cash? How of may deals do typically do in a year? Does that price point work more effectively than say 250-350 in your area?
Jamie, for that pool deal, I'd separate the pool risk from the house rehab before deciding what profit floor makes sense. Get a pool-specific inspection that checks equipment, shell or surface, plumbing and leaks, and confirm permits, barrier requirements and what an insurer will require. A pool that looks fine on a walkthrough can still become a separate repair line or slow a sale. Then compare closed sales with pools in similar condition and the same price band; don't assume a pool adds its full replacement cost or draws the same buyers as a no-pool comp. I'd run the sale with the pool repaired and with a conservative contingency if it isn't, while carrying utilities, maintenance and a longer marketing period in both cases. If the flip only clears the target with a perfect pool and top-end ARV, that's a thin deal. Are your strongest comps also pool homes, or is the target profit counting the pool as extra value?
Jamie, for that pool deal, I'd separate the pool risk from the house rehab before deciding what profit floor makes sense. Get a pool-specific inspection that checks equipment, shell or surface, plumbing and leaks, and confirm permits, barrier requirements and what an insurer will require. A pool that looks fine on a walkthrough can still become a separate repair line or slow a sale. Then compare closed sales with pools in similar condition and the same price band; don't assume a pool adds its full replacement cost or draws the same buyers as a no-pool comp. I'd run the sale with the pool repaired and with a conservative contingency if it isn't, while carrying utilities, maintenance and a longer marketing period in both cases. If the flip only clears the target with a perfect pool and top-end ARV, that's a thin deal. Are your strongest comps also pool homes, or is the target profit counting the pool as extra value?
mentioning the pool makes me think; do you do the same formula for property with a fireplace also? Basically for a "standard" property, repair numbers as usual. However if the property has a chimney, add on top of the "standard" property numbers. In this recent Fix and Flip a maxed out chimney rehab would be 10k. If I was running my numbers again cosmetic rehab $22/sqft and 10k for the chimney work. The property is 1405sqft so $22/sqft comes out to 30k in repairs then 10k for the chimney work on an estimate.