My borrower budgeted $70K for rehab. The contractor-priced number was $98.5K.
Ran into this on a west Houston flip this week and thought it was worth sharing.
Under contract at $215K, 1996 one-story brick, about 2,600 SF. Ten closed comps in the subdivision put ARV around $331K. The borrower's rehab budget was $70K.
I priced the borrower's own 39 photos at what a hired contractor would charge and got $98,500. The range ran from $58K if every system passes to $162K if the roof and an AC unit go. Clean-out and pet contamination cleanup alone were $16K, and that's the stuff that almost never makes it into a buyer's budget.
Here's why it matters. With $100K in the bank, on the $70K number the borrower had about $17K of cushion at closing. On the $98.5K number they were about $11.5K short at 70% of ARV. The price that actually pencils dropped from around $148K to around $120K.
Lenders size rehab on what it'd cost to finish if you couldn't, not on what you'll actually spend. If you come in under, the unused draw money comes back to you at payoff, so it isn't lost. But you still need the cash to close on the higher number.
I wrote up the full breakdown on my website, which you can find through my profile.
For those of you flipping in Houston, do you budget rehab at your own cost or at what a GC would charge you? And has a lender's repair number ever killed a deal you thought worked?