My borrower budgeted $70K for rehab. The contractor-priced number was $98.5K.

My borrower budgeted $70K for rehab. The contractor-priced number was $98.5K.

Lender · Houston, TX · Member since 2026 · 127 posts · 27 votes

Ran into this on a west Houston flip this week and thought it was worth sharing.

Under contract at $215K, 1996 one-story brick, about 2,600 SF. Ten closed comps in the subdivision put ARV around $331K. The borrower's rehab budget was $70K.

I priced the borrower's own 39 photos at what a hired contractor would charge and got $98,500. The range ran from $58K if every system passes to $162K if the roof and an AC unit go. Clean-out and pet contamination cleanup alone were $16K, and that's the stuff that almost never makes it into a buyer's budget.

Here's why it matters. With $100K in the bank, on the $70K number the borrower had about $17K of cushion at closing. On the $98.5K number they were about $11.5K short at 70% of ARV. The price that actually pencils dropped from around $148K to around $120K.

Lenders size rehab on what it'd cost to finish if you couldn't, not on what you'll actually spend. If you come in under, the unused draw money comes back to you at payoff, so it isn't lost. But you still need the cash to close on the higher number.

I wrote up the full breakdown on my website, which you can find through my profile.

For those of you flipping in Houston, do you budget rehab at your own cost or at what a GC would charge you? And has a lender's repair number ever killed a deal you thought worked?

0Reply
939 views

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Mark UpdegraffBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Rochester, NY · Member since 2010 · 1k+ posts · 715 votes
    2w

    @Steve Waller , I’d carry two numbers from the beginning: the operating scope we expect to execute and the third-party completion budget the lender has to protect against. The gap is not automatically padding; it often comes from scope that was never defined, labor priced at the investor’s own cost, or cleanup and systems risk treated as somebody else’s problem. I’d reconcile the 39-photo estimate line by line with a site walk, then identify which items are required to make the property financeable, insurable and sellable. If the deal only works when every system passes, the lower budget is a best case, not an underwriting case.

  • Lender · Houston, TX · Member since 2026 · 127 posts · 27 votes
    2w

    Mark, agreed. "Financeable, insurable and sellable" is the right test.

    That's why the summary we give the client starts with a line-by-line repair and remodel scope, which protects both the borrower and the lender. Too often the borrower signs a contract without ever walking the property, working only from photos or the seller's word. Vetting with an appraiser, an inspector and a feasibility study, plus the client's own review, confirms the real repairs and costs. If the big three (HVAC, roof and foundation) check out, those costs come off. The scope is also the buyer's best tool for negotiating the purchase price.

    Everyone should remember that a lender doesn't make money if the loan doesn't close. But a lender that skips a thorough repair estimate won't be a lender for long.

    When the investor's number and the walk-through come in far apart, do you go back to the seller on price, or have the buyer bring the difference as reserves?

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    2w

    Steve, I hold instead of flip, but the same trap applies: a rehab budget is only real at the price somebody else would charge to finish it. I underwrite every house so the exit still works at the contractor number, not my best case. My exits are tight — buy under $100K, ARV $180K to $265K, rent $1,395 to $1,950, refi at 70 to 80% LTV. If the honest rehab pushes the all-in past what that refi returns, the purchase price has to come down or I pass. The $28.5K gap in your example doesn't get absorbed by hope. It gets absorbed at the offer, or it gets absorbed by you.

  • Mayo GilfurtPro Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Connecticut Ct · Member since 2026 · 171 posts · 37 votes
    2w

    Steve, excellent breakdown of the rehabilitation budget and its impact on the borrower's required equity.

    Your point about underwriting rehabilitation costs based on professional contractor pricing rather than solely on an investor's projected expenses is particularly important.

    I'm with Gilfurt Capital, where I focus on commercial and business-purpose financing.

    I'm currently expanding my professional relationships within the Texas market and would welcome the opportunity to connect with experienced lending professionals.

    Do you primarily originate fix-and-flip loans directly, or does your company also work with independent mortgage brokers?

    Mayo Gilfurt

  • Lender · Houston, TX · Member since 2026 · 127 posts · 27 votes
    2w

    James, "it gets absorbed at the offer, or it gets absorbed by you" is the whole post in one line. On a hold the refinance is the exit, so the appraisal and the rent both have to work at the contractor number. Before closing, the purchase price is the only lever left.

    How much cushion do you leave above the contractor number for what the scope misses?

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 613 posts · 174 votes
    2w

    Pricing the borrower's own photos at hired rates is a habit more buyers should pick up. The piece I'd add is time. When an investor self-performs to save on labor, the job usually runs longer, and on a flip every extra month is another month of interest, insurance, utilities and taxes. A slow rehab can eat most of what the cheaper labor saved, and it also pushes the sale further from the date the comps were pulled. So the fair comparison isn't my cost against a GC's cost. It's my cost plus the extra months against the GC's price on the GC's schedule. Cheap labor only stays cheap if it's also fast.

  • Lender · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2021 · 6 posts · 2 votes
    2w

    The appraisal can change the conversation pretty quickly too. We see deals where the rehab budget looks fine, but if the ARV doesn't come in where expected, the borrower may need to bring more cash or the deal has to be reworked. There are a few moving parts on these deals.

  • Lender · Houston, TX · Member since 2026 · 127 posts · 27 votes
    1w

    Sorry for the slow reply on this one. Several good points here, so I'll take them together.

    Mark, "the lower budget is a best case, not an underwriting case" is the right line. Carrying both numbers from day one is how it should work, and the line-by-line reconcile on a site walk is usually where the gap explains itself: scope nobody defined, and labor priced at the investor's own cost.

    Noah, time is the piece most self-performed budgets leave out. On a five or six month hold, every extra month of interest, insurance, taxes and utilities comes straight out of whatever the cheaper labor saved.

    Brian, agreed. The appraisal is the other half. If the ARV comes in light, the advance shrinks and the borrower brings the difference at closing, so a thin rehab budget and a thin ARV compound each other.

    Mayo, yes, I work with brokers. Happy to compare notes by message.

    For the flippers here: when the contractor number comes in this far over yours, do you go back on price or cut scope?

  • Investor · Member since 2026 · 92 posts · 18 votes
    11h

    Budget at the GC number, every time. My own cost is a hope, the GC number is what it costs to finish if I can't.

    The part that saved me more than once is getting that GC-priced scope as line items before closing, with roof, HVAC and foundation on their own lines. Then I know exactly what falls away if they pass, and draws get checked against the same list — walk the work, match it to the line, then release the money. Final payment waits until permits and any violations are closed out.

    That $16K clean-out line is the tell. If a cost like that isn't its own line item, it isn't really in the budget.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.