Property Manager · Gatlinburg, TN · Member since 2020 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
Seems like once a week, someone asks about whether this or that property will "make money."
What does "make money" mean? Does it mean a positive monthly cash flow? If yes, then a vacation rental is an incredibly poor investment, regardless of price. While there are properties in the Smokies that will "make money" (positive yearly NOI), that's not as much my objective with this type of investment. I buy QUALITY real estate in the Smokies (or anywhere else) knowing it's going to rise in value significantly over time, and other people are going to service the majority of that debt for me. So if I'm having to kick in $1000 a month, it's no worry to me. If it "makes" $1,000 a month, not a big deal either. Neither of those amounts are moving my needle, and if they are moving yours, you shouldn't be buying real estate.
Serious question: How many of us are dutifully stashing $2,000 a month into a 401K with zero current income, and we are perfectly content to do so until we are old people?
My first cabin in the Smokies, I bought in 2005. I was negative $1,000 a month for a while. But the renters have long since paid that asset off, and it's now free and clear doing $50K in annual rents, and the value us probably $700K. What's wrong with that investment?
Now, I also own five Great Clips franchises. I did buy these for income. They've helped me...buy more cabins! Different investments, different objectives.
Search out what your investment objectives are. If monthly income is at the top of your list, forget about vacation rentals and buy a Great Clips franchise.
I used to preach the same thing.. but I was telling folks to buy a subway or pizza franchise.. There is just this on going idea that folks can buy rentals and all of a sudden in a few short years be making enough on positive cash flow to quit their day job. that can happen if you have very low to no debt. thats when it gets good like your paid for cabin. for me the day job is renting one to others and building new homes.. both are business's that just happen to be anchored by real estate but its not real estate investing per se. just like great clips is not real estate investing its cash flow investing.
Great points, Collin. I think the problem with those investments is not everyone starting out in real estate has the bank account to bankroll $1k in losses/month/property. Perhaps a more realistic assumption when folks are buying their first property these days is breaking even or having a plan to change the equation in those first 5 years? Maybe that’s purchasing with a higher interest rate and with a plan to lower expenses, pay off debt, increase income streams, reduce vacancies, improve PM, or whatever other special sauce an investor may bring to the table to improve the income/expense scales in their favor.
And perhaps that’s just another way of saying: know a way to find and improve an underperforming asset. 😀
Yeah, I think if you can't afford to subsidize for a few years, it's best just to buy stocks and REITs until you can. I didn't buy my first STR until I was 40 years old or so.
I used to preach the same thing.. but I was telling folks to buy a subway or pizza franchise.. There is just this on going idea that folks can buy rentals and all of a sudden in a few short years be making enough on positive cash flow to quit their day job. that can happen if you have very low to no debt. thats when it gets good like your paid for cabin. for me the day job is renting one to others and building new homes.. both are business's that just happen to be anchored by real estate but its not real estate investing per se. just like great clips is not real estate investing its cash flow investing.
@Collin Hays I think the useful part of this is that "make money" needs a definition before anyone can answer it. Cash flow, appreciation, and debt paydown are different goals, and they call for different properties. Your cabin is a good example of a long-term appreciation play that worked.
I'd add two things for newer investors. A plan like this works best when you can comfortably cover a negative month without stress, and when you can hold through a slow stretch, since appreciation is never guaranteed and a 2005 purchase had a long runway. Vacation rentals also swing with seasons, regulations, and insurance costs, so reserves matter more than the label on the strategy. Being clear about your objective up front, and sizing the deal to match, is the real lesson.
Collin, I really like the distinction you're making between cash flow and actually building long-term wealth. A property doesn't necessarily have to produce a huge monthly number to be a great investment if it's building equity, appreciating, and fitting the investor's overall plan.
I'd add one more piece to the equation: after-tax return. Depreciation and other tax benefits can meaningfully affect the real return on a vacation rental, especially when someone also has income from active businesses. And on the other side, the eventual sale and depreciation recapture matter too.
So I think the better question is not just “How much cash does this property make?” but “What is this investment doing for my wealth after tax, over the entire hold period?”
Collin, I really like the distinction you're making between cash flow and actually building long-term wealth. A property doesn't necessarily have to produce a huge monthly number to be a great investment if it's building equity, appreciating, and fitting the investor's overall plan.
I'd add one more piece to the equation: after-tax return. Depreciation and other tax benefits can meaningfully affect the real return on a vacation rental, especially when someone also has income from active businesses. And on the other side, the eventual sale and depreciation recapture matter too.
So I think the better question is not just “How much cash does this property make?” but “What is this investment doing for my wealth after tax, over the entire hold period?”
Great perspective.
Good thoughts. I've never used tax consequences as a factor in investment decisions, but I know that isn't the norm. Depreciation is one of those things that is more of a tax deferment. Uncle Sam will get that money sooner or later.
Great point Colin. When I was in my 20s I was chasing cash flow, so I could use that to pay my bills. At that age did not really care much about the future I was very focused on the now. Now in my late thirties I have income for monthly expenses and buy real estate for the future, I only care about cash flow to make sure Im not losing money preferably, and in aggregate the cash flow lumped can help fund down payments for more. I also now buy because I can claim the tax benefits :)
Yeah same really for me. I began STR investing in 2005. Obviously knew that wasn't going to generate income to replace my salary at work, so I began stockpiling cash to start opening up Great Clips locations. My calendar looks pretty much like this:
2005 First cabin
2010 Second cabin
2011 First Great Clips
2011 Started Property Mgt. Co.
2012 Second Great Clips
2014 Third and fourth cabins
2015 Third Great Clips
2018 Fourth Great Clips
2021 Fifth and Sixth Cabins
2022 Sold the sixth cabin
2022 Fifth Great Clips
We opened up another business in 2025, a 3D/4D Ultrasound Clinic for expectant mommas. Also looking at purchasing some UPS Stores currently.
Agree on the long game. Your 2005 cabin is the proof. The piece I'd add for newer buyers reading this: "I'm fine kicking in $1,000 a month" only works if you know that number BEFORE you buy, and you can cover it for years without stress. Most of the regret stories I see aren't from people who chose appreciation. They're from people who thought they were buying cash flow, used a best-case income guess (a full calendar at peak rates), and found out they were feeding it $1,500 a month by surprise. So run it honestly first: plan for realistic booked nights (around 55–65%), subtract fees, cleaning, and management (20–25% if you hire one), and look at what's left after the mortgage. If that's negative and you're okay with it as your "401k contribution," great, that's a real strategy. Just make it a choice, not a surprise.
You make some great points, and your first cabin is certainly a testament to the benefits of long-term real estate ownership here in the Smokies!
Being in this market ourselves, I think we can agree that the Smokies offer some unique investment opportunities. However, I don't necessarily agree that vacation rentals are poor investments for someone seeking positive cash flow.
Every investor has different goals, financial resources, and risk tolerance. Some are building long-term wealth through appreciation and equity, while others are looking for income today. There's room for both strategies.
What concerns me is when buyers assume that appreciation will eventually make up for a property that doesn't perform financially. The market today is very different from 2005, and not every investor has the financial flexibility to carry a negative cash flow indefinitely.
For me, it's about the right property, at the right price, with the right amenities, location, and management strategy. I believe a well-purchased STR can provide both cash flow and long-term wealth-building opportunities.
Your success is a great example of what real estate investing can accomplish over time. I'm curious, though, if you were purchasing your very first Smoky Mountain cabin today, with today's prices and financing costs, would you still be as comfortable carrying a $1,000 monthly loss?
You make some great points, and your first cabin is certainly a testament to the benefits of long-term real estate ownership here in the Smokies!
Being in this market ourselves, I think we can agree that the Smokies offer some unique investment opportunities. However, I don't necessarily agree that vacation rentals are poor investments for someone seeking positive cash flow.
Every investor has different goals, financial resources, and risk tolerance. Some are building long-term wealth through appreciation and equity, while others are looking for income today. There's room for both strategies.
What concerns me is when buyers assume that appreciation will eventually make up for a property that doesn't perform financially. The market today is very different from 2005, and not every investor has the financial flexibility to carry a negative cash flow indefinitely.
For me, it's about the right property, at the right price, with the right amenities, location, and management strategy. I believe a well-purchased STR can provide both cash flow and long-term wealth-building opportunities.
Your success is a great example of what real estate investing can accomplish over time. I'm curious, though, if you were purchasing your very first Smoky Mountain cabin today, with today's prices and financing costs, would you still be as comfortable carrying a $1,000 monthly loss?
If I really liked the property, I'd do that all day!
@Collin Hays Your 401k comparison stuck in my head so I tried to put a number on it.
For example, let's say we have USD 800k cabin, with 25% down payment at 6.75% interest rate - about USD 229k cash-in with closing costs. The owner kicks in USD 1k a month for 10 years and then sells the property and pays 6% selling costs. The yearly return on everything put in comes out at about following:
2% appreciation a year - 1.8%
3% appreciation a year - 4.4%
4% appreciation a year - 6.7%
5% appreciation a year - 8.8%
To get 10% a year, which is about what the stock market is usually quoted at long-term, it needs about 5.6% appreciation every year. At USD 2k a month - it needs about 7%. I held rents and expenses flat and left taxes out, so it's rough.
So I agree it can be a real strategy, but the whole return is the appreciation, and the purchase price decides how much appreciation you need. @Karen Cubberley asked if you'd still carry USD 1k a month at today's prices and you said all day, so my question is the other side of it - What appreciation do you count on when you buy in the Smokies today?
@Rati Meskhishvili That’s exactly the question I was getting at. Being comfortable contributing $1,000 a month is one thing. What you’re counting on that contribution to produce is another.
From my perspective working with buyers in the Smokies, I wouldn’t want a purchase to depend on 5–7% annual appreciation to make sense. I’d want to look at how it performs with conservative rental income, realistic expenses, and little or no appreciation.
There’s room for someone to accept lower returns because they also want personal use of the cabin. That has value, but I’d separate that from the investment return.
Your example brings the conversation back to something buyers can control: the purchase price. Loving the Smokies and believing in their long-term appeal doesn’t mean every cabin makes sense at today’s asking price.
@Karen Cubberley Agreed! And I like the way you split it - personal use has real value, but it is a separate thing from the investment return. When your buyers do want some personal use, how do they usually put a number on it? Do they think of it as the vacations they would otherwise pay for?
Absolutely! I encourage buyers to look at personal use as a separate lifestyle benefit rather than counting it toward their investment returns.
One way to quantify it is to compare what they would normally spend renting a similar cabin for their vacations. However, I also remind them that using their own property comes with an opportunity cost, especially during peak seasons when rental revenue is highest.
Here in the Smokies, that distinction matters. A week of personal use in January has a very different financial impact than a week in October.
My advice is to underwrite the property based on realistic rental income, expenses, and the nights actually available to rent. Then evaluate the personal enjoyment separately.
The goal is to own a cabin you love without having to justify a poor investment with vacation savings.
I'm curious, Rati, do you think investors sometimes overvalue personal use when evaluating a vacation rental?
@Karen Cubberley I think so, yes. Part of it is emotional - when owners picture staying there themselves, it is easy to value the cabin with the heart instead of the numbers. The other part is timing. Owners usually want the same weeks guests pay the most for - October, Christmas, summer holidays, etc. So a week they block in October costs them October's rent, not January's. And the vacation savings only count if they would really have taken that trip anyway. Your January versus October point is the one I would want every buyer to hear before they decide.
Here in the Smokies, if you already know you want the same October week every year, I’d block it out when we run the numbers before you make an offer. I’d use what that specific week could realistically bring in after booking fees and expenses tied to the stay.
Then I’d ask, “If you didn’t own this cabin, what would you actually spend on that trip?” If you would have booked a place for $1,500, that’s the vacation savings I’d use. If you would have stayed home, there’s still real value in getting away with your family, and you can decide what that’s worth to you.
I love when buyers want to enjoy their cabin. I just want them to know how it’s likely to perform with the calendar they actually plan to keep.
It's that difference between short term income and long term asset value.
Lots of people get into Real Estate thinking it's going to give them a bunch of short term income.
And some strategies can, particularly wholesaling and doing smaller flips really quickly.
But the "I'm going to buy rentals and quit my job without having to do anything except drink margaritas on a beach, all within 3-5 years" mindset is out of touch.
Lots of people want the easy, perfect answer.
Then they start doing it and find out it's not the easy, perfect answer. So they go find the next one and repeat that cycle forever.
My two favorite questions to ask people getting into real estate:
Why are you buying it?
What are you trying to accomplish?
There's usually a lot of nonsense in those answers that we've got to work through first, before they can actually make progress.
Investments are generally either microwave or crock pot.
If you want to buy income for minimal investment, buy a service business. A dry cleaner, restaurant, dog grooming, phone repairs. Lots of income, very few assets, hence very little appreciation of those assets.
Real estate is a crock pot. You buy it, pay a lot for it, hold it, but don't really get to enjoy the fruits of income for a long time. But when that time comes, there's nothing quite like a roast that's been in the crockpot all day. And those assets have appreciated substantially over time.
I've structured my investments to have some of both. I leveraged cabin equity to open my first Great Clips, then began using Great Clips profit to pay that note off and begin buying more cabins. Now I have 5 properties, and, you guessed it, 5 Great Clips. No debt on the Great Clips, mortgages remaining on 2 of the 5 cabins. I started all of this about 20 years ago.
@Stephen Ballard Those two questions can save a buyer a lot of time. If someone tells me they want to replace their paycheck with a Smoky Mountain cabin, I ask, “How much do you need it to put in your pocket each month, and who’s answering when the heat goes out on a Saturday night?”
That usually gets us to a more honest conversation about cash flow and how involved they want to be. I’ve seen beautiful cabins with impressive gross revenue that still come up short once you account for the mortgage, management, repairs, and slower months.
If their goal is to build equity over time, I still want to know what it’ll cost them to hold the property in a lean year. That’s a conversation worth having before they fall in love with the view.
@Collin Hays I like the crock-pot analogy, especially because you showed what 20 years of building actually looked like. You used the equity in a cabin to open your first Great Clips, then used the profits from the business to pay down that debt and buy more cabins. The two investments helped you grow each other.
When I’m helping someone look at their first cabin here in the Smokies, I want to know what it takes to hold it through a slower year. If the buyer can comfortably cover those months, they have more room to give the investment time to do what they bought it for.
Looking back, what gave you the confidence to tap the cabin equity for that first Great Clips?
@Collin Hays I like the crock-pot analogy, especially because you showed what 20 years of building actually looked like. You used the equity in a cabin to open your first Great Clips, then used the profits from the business to pay down that debt and buy more cabins. The two investments helped you grow each other.
When I’m helping someone look at their first cabin here in the Smokies, I want to know what it takes to hold it through a slower year. If the buyer can comfortably cover those months, they have more room to give the investment time to do what they bought it for.
Looking back, what gave you the confidence to tap the cabin equity for that first Great Clips?
I found out that banks don't like to lend for venture capital! ;)
No, the equity loan was much more favorable terms. I was back in the hole monthly obviously on the vacation rental, but it was funding my Great Clips. That's another great thing about real estate. As you build equity, it's a tool that can be used for other investments.
I always look at the numbers behind the deal first, especially the tax side, like @Ashish Acharya mentioned.
The gurus and Instagram ads have sold everyone on cash flow. It’s out there, but it’s easier said than done. Sure, cash flow is nice. With vacation rentals, you can buy a mini resort or put a ton down and boom, you’re cash flowing. But then the trade-offs show up: your cash-on-cash return is low and a lot of your money is tied up in one property.
On STRs, I’m with you. @Collin Hays . In this rate environment, if the property covers 75% of its expenses and it’s in a location you believe in, that’s a win.
My mindset is to pay the debt down faster so the property starts cash flowing sooner. Make extra principal payments to shorten that 30-year mortgage, refinance when rates come down and keep building equity. Peace of mind, less leverage, and a stronger position to buy the second one. That said, leverage is the path to growth!
I’m aggressive on tax strategy and more conservative on leverage. Both approaches work. It comes down to your goals and how much stress you’re willing to carry.
I like how you're looking at the bigger picture here. Cash flow is important, but so is understanding how much of your own money you're tying up in a property and what you're actually getting in return.
Here in the Smoky Mountains, I see beautiful cabins with impressive revenue projections that still don't make financial sense once you factor in financing, operating expenses, and realistic occupancy.
I would push back a little on considering a property that covers only 75% of its expenses as a win. Appreciation and tax benefits can certainly be part of the strategy, but I believe investors need to be very comfortable with how much they're contributing out of pocket and for how long.
I've always believed tax advantages should make a good investment better, not make a bad investment look good.
With 25+ years in the vacation and hospitality industry, I've learned that STRs are operating businesses, not simply real estate investments.
I'm curious, Christopher, when you're evaluating an STR, how much weight do you give potential tax advantages versus the property's ability to support itself financially?
Thats a great way of thinking for year 1 buy quality and look for total return but reality is actually the areas where the real estate appreciates the most will create the highest sustainable cashflow after a few years, in fact much higher year 5 cashflow then if bought a worse area property with day 1 on paper cashflow. So I do not think it has to be one or the other of total return vs cashflow they actually go together over time.