As a first time home buyer should i forget about the investor mindset

As a first time home buyer should i forget about the investor mindset

Member since 2020 · 178 posts · 54 votes

I been house hunting since August of last year and just recently took a halt as i want to save up more money for a down payment, Im 1099 tax and had an issue with IRS that is resolved now but because of it i only qualify with bank statement loans. Im looking for semi move in ready single family homes in Phx,Az and surrounding areas (avoiding west glendale and south of indian schl), when i go see a house im interest with my realtor the numbers never make sense as if i would rent out i would not even be breaking even , id be loosing money. Being my 1st home , should i live in it first and pay a price im comfortable paying the rent, and when rent goes up which will eventually happen, rent it out then.

2Reply
959 views

Most Popular Reply

Flipper/Rehabber · CA · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
1d

You can't forget the investor mindset lol, its too late. You can’t unknow what yknow. Definitely buy your 1st house, you'll learn alot. Its a very long game.

See this reply in the discussion

27 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 246 posts · 93 votes
    2d

    Jimmy, I would keep the investor mindset, just use it as a check instead of a reason to force a deal. If the rent today would not cover the payment, I would not buy it hoping rent catches up later. That hope is what gets people stuck.

    For a first home I would look at it this way. Live in a place you like and can afford month to month, and only buy it if the rent it could bring in is close to the payment. If the numbers are far off on every house you see, pausing to save more was a good call. I am still learning myself, and the lesson I keep coming back to is that the payment has to fit the rent, not the other way around. When you find one that is close, your realtor and a lender who knows bank statement loans can help you check the rest before you move ahead.

  • Lender · Vernon, CT · Member since 2026 · 30 posts · 5 votes
    2d

    Jimmy, it depends on why you're buying the house.

    Are you buying the house because you want it to be an excellent investment?

    Are you buying the house because you want a yard for your dog/kids/self?

    There are emotional and financial reasons to buy a house. Neither is right or wrong.

    If you want to buy the house purely from a financial perspective, then it might make sense to start looking at 2-4 units. They tend to not be too much more expensive than single family homes, but often have much better monthly cash flow.

    A single family might sell for $300,000 and a duplex for $400,000. But the duplex might bring in @2,000 in each unit while the single family brings in $2,500 for the single unit. (Rough numbers from where I live).

    I can promise you this though: you won't find a house that is both perfect for you to live in it and perfect to rent out to others.

    So what's the reason for buying a house?
    And we can figure out what makes the most sense for you from there.

    As a side note, there's no reason that you have to buy your primary residence and own rentals in the same place.
    Most investors I know don't live in the same neighborhoods they invest in.

    • Member since 2020 · 178 posts · 54 votes
      1d

      I guess a little of both, i want my pie and be able to eat it too but in todays market that is like finding a unicorn, I live in Phx,Az and a standard 3br 1000sft house, 6k lot, in average neighborhood rents for $1800, condos, apartments and shared duplex go for less.

  • Ryan BakerBusiness Member
    Lender · Strongsville / Cleveland, OH · Member since 2026 · 208 posts · 54 votes
    2d

    Jimmy, bank statement loans are a normal path for 1099 earners, and an IRS issue that's resolved doesn't shut that door. They usually look at 12 or 24 months of deposits to figure your income, so keep your business and personal accounts clean and avoid big unexplained deposits.

    On the buy-or-wait question, I'd agree with the others. If the payment is way over what the house would rent for, living in it first is fine, as long as the payment fits your budget with room to spare. Get your numbers run before you make offers so you know the price range and cash needed.

    I do bank statement loans and every other type in-house. Give me a call (my number's in my signature below) and we can see what you'd qualify for.

    – Ryan

  • Lender · Peoria, AZ · Member since 2026 · 84 posts · 18 votes
    2d

    Hey Jimmy,

    For a first home, I think it's totally fine to buy it as a home first and a rental later. The trick is picking the payment you're comfortable with before you fall for a house, not after. With a bank statement loan the payment can look a little different than what the online calculators show, so I'd get a real Loan Estimate at the price range you're shopping in Phoenix and use that as your ceiling.

    Then when you're touring with your realtor, look at two things: does the payment work for you living there, and roughly what would it rent for down the road. It doesn't have to cash flow on day one. You just want to know how far off it is.

    I'm a mortgage broker licensed in Arizona, California, Colorado, Kansas, Texas, and Arkansas, and I like helping investors. Happy to be a resource. No pressure at all!

    How much longer are you planning to save before you jump back in? And are you mostly looking at 3 bedrooms?

  • Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 2 votes
    2d

    Jimmy, I'm in the valley too. Honestly for a first home its ok if it doesnt work as a rental today, you're buying a place to live. Just make sure the payment fits your budget, not some future rent number.

    One thing to ask about tho. Bank statement loans usually cost more than a regular loan. Once the IRS stuff is fully behind you and your tax returns show the income, a full doc loan might open back up. Have a lender look at both now so you know if waiting for one more return actually saves you money, or if you buy now and refi later.

    LO with Barrett Financial, just so you know.

  • Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 205 posts · 76 votes
    2d

    @jimmyr58 Jimmy, keep the investor check, but don't let it talk you into a house whose rent can't support the payment today. Hoping rents catch up is how people get stuck with a payment they can only justify on a spreadsheet.
    For a first home, live in a place you actually want and can afford month to month. If you later rent it, underwrite today's rent minus vacancy, maintenance, taxes and insurance, not a future number. If every house you see is far apart on that math, pausing to save a larger down payment is a reasonable call, not a failure.
    Bank-statement loans are a normal path for 1099 income once the IRS issue is resolved. I'd still get a live quote and run the payment at that rate, then again a half point higher, before you go back out with your realtor.

  • Jim BlackburnBusiness Member
    Lender · Florida Based (48 states Puerto Rico) · Member since 2017 · 344 posts · 130 votes
    2d

    Investor mindset means that you live lean and you think long term. Every purchase you make is with the intention of ideally holding it forever unless you need to cash out to 1035 exchange into a bigger deal. So if you’re a first time buyer, the best thing to do is look for a property that is the worst property in the neighborhood and look for a renovation deal because you’re gonna add value and you’re gonna get equity instantly so that when you move out and turn it into a rental, you’ve already got equity in the property and now you can buy another property as a primary residence with low down payment.

    Stairway Mortgage, a Division of NEXA Mortgage LLC598 Reviews
  • Real Estate Broker · Rochester, NY · Member since 2026 · 54 posts · 19 votes
    2d

    Quality investment properties usually aren’t sitting around on the market waiting to get purchased. You have to hunt for them. You have to get creative with redesigning floor plans or adding bedrooms/bathrooms.

    Best advice I can give, because I did it, buy a duplex, live in one side (the ugly side), fix it up, rent it out, and move into the other and repeat.

    Do that with 4 properties over the next 4-6 years and you’ll be off to a great start.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Miami FL, USA · Member since 2024 · 21 posts · 10 votes
    2d

    How old are you?

  • Houston, TX · Member since 2013 · 485 posts · 189 votes
    2d

    you should definately keep an investor mindset. instead of asking where the TV should be, ask yourself, If sh*t happened, can i sell and break even? can i rent it out either Long Term, Midterm or do Short term legally and make money or break even?

    Homeowner buy based on emotion thinking that's their forever home with no exit strategy . Investor always have exit strategy, if not two or three. Good luck

  • Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    2d

    I would keep the investor mindset, Jimmy, but use it as a filter rather than the deciding factor. For a first home, the monthly payment has to work for your life right now, and you need an exit if things change — can you rent it, or sell without a big loss? That is the investor check that matters most. A duplex or house hack is a good middle ground if the numbers work in Phoenix, but I would not force a deal just to tick the investor box. Saving a bit more and buying a home you can actually live in comfortably for a few years sounds like a sensible plan.

  • Technology · Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 5 votes
    2d

    Jimmy, one Arizona detail for the "live in it first, rent it later" plan that I haven't seen in the thread: the property tax changes when you move out.

    As far as I know, while it's your primary residence it's classed as owner-occupied and gets the state homeowner rebate on part of the school tax (capped at a few hundred dollars a year). Once you rent it out, it moves to the rental class, that rebate goes away, and you're supposed to register it as a rental with the county assessor. In Maricopa that's a short form on the assessor's site, and skipping it can lead to fines once they notice.

    It's not a huge number, but when you run the "rent it later" math, use the tax bill without the rebate, not the one you paid while living there. Same idea for insurance: a landlord policy usually costs more than a homeowner's policy on the same house.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    2d

    Two IMPORTANT things to keep in mind:

    • If you buy a Class A property, it will usually take 3-5 years for rent appreciation to get it to cashflow

    • Unless, you buy under market!

    We recommend looking ONLY at properties on the market for 120+ days and offering 80% of asking price.

    • Your agent will HATE this and will say it's a waste of time

    • Member since 2020 · 178 posts · 54 votes
      1d

      Lol, dry humor or are you serious 😄

  • Investor · Charlotte, NC · Member since 2026 · 54 posts · 7 votes
    2d

    Financing can definitely make or break deals like that. Shoot me a connect request when you get a minute. I partner with a lender who structures custom loan terms and would love to make an intro.

  • Ryan BrownPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2022 · 141 posts · 47 votes
    1d

    A first time homebuyer is an investor. Unless you plan to live there forever and raise your family there, the only thing that matters about your first house is how much you can make off of it. That doesn't mean it has to cash flow as a rental on day one. It means buying the house you'll make the most money on when you move, whether you sell it or rent it out.

  • Lender · Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 0 votes
    1d

    Jimmy, you do not have to abandon the investor mindset, but the first test should be whether the payment is comfortable for you as a home. Since you qualify through bank statements, I would have the actual income calculation and cash-to-close estimate completed before restarting tours. Then compare that real payment with likely future rent instead of relying on an online estimate. If the gap is large, saving longer or considering a small two-to-four-unit property may be more practical than hoping rent catches up later. I’m Kris with EquityNest Capital. This would be a residential referral rather than an EquityNest investor loan, but I would be glad to help you identify the information a qualified Arizona bank-statement lender should review before you start making offers again. No pressure.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · CA · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1d

    You can't forget the investor mindset lol, its too late. You can’t unknow what yknow. Definitely buy your 1st house, you'll learn alot. Its a very long game.

  • Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    1d

    Jimmy, here's the math on your $1,800 number so you can check any house in a minute.

    A 3-bed renting for $1,800 breaks even as a rental (rent covers the mortgage, taxes, insurance, repairs, vacancy, management and a small reserve) at roughly:

    • $226,000 with 25% down on a bank statement loan near 8%

    • $191,000 with 10% down on a bank statement loan near 8%

    • $245,000 with 25% down if you could get a conventional rate around 7.1%

    That assumes property tax around 0.6% of the price, $1,200 a year for insurance, 5% vacancy, 8% management and repairs at 5% of rent. Like Andrew said, use the tax bill without the owner-occupied rebate and get a landlord insurance quote, since both go up once it's a rental.

    So the quick check is monthly rent divided by price. On a bank statement loan you need roughly 0.8% to 0.95%. If the houses you're touring are well above $190k to $225k, they won't break even as rentals, and rent growth won't close that gap fast.

    That doesn't mean don't buy. Buy the one you want to live in, at a payment you're comfortable with, and treat renting it out later as a bonus, not the plan.

  • Lender · McKinney, TX · Member since 2026 · 24 posts · 10 votes
    22h

    Jimmy, the $1,800 rent you mentioned for a standard 3/1 on a 6k lot is the most useful number in this thread. Before you tour anything else, get the full monthly payment on a bank statement loan at your price range, including taxes, insurance and any HOA, and put it right next to that $1,800.

    A couple of things specific to your situation: bank statement programs usually want more down than conventional and price off your credit score and down payment, so the extra savings you're building does double duty. Ask each lender whether they use 12 or 24 months of statements and what expense factor they apply to your deposits, because that can swing your qualifying income quite a bit.

    On living in it first: an owner-occupied loan generally expects you to live there at least a year, and converting it to a rental after that is common. Down the road a DSCR refinance, which qualifies off the rent instead of your income, is one way some people move a former primary into rental status. Full disclosure, I'm a lender. With Phoenix rents where you described, buying a home you'd be happy living in for several years and treating the rental option as a bonus sounds like a solid plan.

  • Lauren CutchenBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · The Woodlands, TX · Member since 2019 · 244 posts · 92 votes
    22h

    @Jimmy Rojas don't forget it, just change the test a little. For a first home, I'd ask whether the payment is comfortable to live in and whether it would at least come close to breaking even as a rental down the road, not whether it cash flows on day one. That's how I got started, house hacking, and living in it first buys you time to grow into the numbers. A floor plan that could take a roommate or a future tenant goes a long way.

    • Member since 2020 · 178 posts · 54 votes
      19h

      Im just to comfortable now living in a 3k sqft house all by myself paying $450 a month all util incl lol!

    • Flipper/Rehabber · CA · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      19h

      Then use that to your advantage, keep your hustle on. Flip some more cars, attract more customers for your sales. Its not easy being self employed, gotta keep grinding lol

    • Member since 2020 · 178 posts · 54 votes
      19h

      That is exactly what im doing, im saving to put down a bigger down payment on a house.

  • Specialist · I give advice - [email protected] - I focus on states where investing is profitable, reasonably safe & secure · Member since 2026 · 218 posts · 75 votes
    19h
    Quote from @Jimmy Rojas:

    I been house hunting since August of last year and just recently took a halt as i want to save up more money for a down payment, Im 1099 tax and had an issue with IRS that is resolved now but because of it i only qualify with bank statement loans. Im looking for semi move in ready single family homes in Phx,Az and surrounding areas (avoiding west glendale and south of indian schl), when i go see a house im interest with my realtor the numbers never make sense as if i would rent out i would not even be breaking even , id be loosing money. Being my 1st home , should i live in it first and pay a price im comfortable paying the rent, and when rent goes up which will eventually happen, rent it out then.

    You don't actually need a bank. Right now buying a house and taking over the loan will save you from 7% to probably 4%. For instance one available right now in Goodyear is at 4% on ($380,000) or $1400 a month which if you used a bank it would be $2100 a month. You just need to ask the right questions to the right people and shop around or you could pay 7% if you prefer banks and fees.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.