3 Steps to Choosing Quality Tenants for Your Rentals

by | BiggerPockets.com

Before we get into the secret hot-sauce tip for picking good tenants, I just want to cover these three basic ways to evaluate if a tenant is going to be a good fit for your property. Before we get into this, you have to get rid of the mindset that all tenants are bad. I mean, these folks are ultimately your business partners.

They put money in your pocket every single month. So treat them with respect. Send them the gift card or gift basket. Wish them a Merry Christmas (and so on). Do you get my drift? You have to do it. You have to try to treat these people with respect.

Ultimately, they are going to be the ones allowing you to live the lifestyle that you desire.

Download Your FREE guide to evicting a tenant!

We hope you never have to evict a tenant, but know it’s always wise to prepare for the worst. Navigating the legal and financial considerations of an eviction can be tricky, even for the most experienced landlords. Lucky for you, the experts at BiggerPockets have put together a FREE Guide to Evicting Tenants so you can protect your property and investments.

Click Here For Your Free Tenant Eviction Guide

1. Income Verification

Ok, let’s get into it. The first thing you need to do when screening potential tenants is check their income. This is also known as an income verification. The tenant needs to be earning at least three times the monthly rent—that’s kind of a guideline my property management company and I like to follow.

To make things very simple for you, if the rent is $1,000 per month, your tenants’ combined income (whether they’re husband and wife or their pets have a job or whatever) should be $3,000 per month. That should be the absolute minimum: $1,000 in rent, they should be bringing home $3,000 net. What we really like to see though, is tenants bringing in $3,000 net even if the rent is less than $1,000. It’s just nice to have a little bit of an additional cushion there.

Now what’s really mesmerizing, and I just want to touch on this, is I just came back from Korea and Japan, and over there the rent that folks pay is only a quarter of their monthly income. That’s why there are zero evictions in Korea and Japan.

Related: How to Find a Tenant in Any Market: A Comprehensive Guide

2. Background Check

Anyway, the second thing that you need to do is a background check. You need to make sure that these folks don’t have a criminal background. Unfortunately, even though what happened in the past is not necessarily an indication of what’s going to happen in the future (because people change and people make mistakes) it’s still a pretty good indication of what someone’s personality is like, or what their character may be like. So you need to do a background check.

Dealing with Background Check Results

You definitely don’t want to put someone in your property who has a severe criminal background with multiple felonies. Now, if its a 15–20-year-old felony, I would maybe try to turn a blind eye or work out a deal. Maybe ask the tenant to put down three months rent in advance, or pay an additional deposit. Ultimately, try to figure out a way that you can proactively protect yourself by getting additional funds in advance.

I remember renting to a few tenants with criminal backgrounds. In those cases, we were able to get six months rent in advance. I’ll take that deal every single day of the week, because the simple fact that someone can save six months (or even a year) of rent in advance speaks volumes to me.

3. Eviction History

The third thing to check is eviction history. This is an automatic no fail. If you’ve been evicted once, you’re done. I don’t want to rent my property to you.

Food and shelter are the two most important things to humanity. I was broke once upon a time. I was starving. But I couldn’t eat because I had scraped every single dollar together to afford the roof over my head. So if a tenant got evicted once upon a time, in my opinion, they weren’t just disrespecting the landlord, they were disrespecting themselves. This is something we tell all of our tenants. So, in my opinion, anyone who has an eviction on his or her record—and I don’t care if it’s 257 years old—they are automatically disqualified.

However, if they tell me there was a miscommunication with the court, that they actually paid out the remainder of the lease and vacated the property but somehow the court accidentally still filed the eviction, I try to confirm that with the landlord. I know that sounds a little suspect, but we have rented to people who have had evictions on their record. They sold us on a good story that made sense. In those cases, believe it or not, it actually worked out. Those tenants stayed and paid for quite a long time. So keep in mind it’s possible for there to be inconsistencies with the filings when it comes to the justice system. Just make sure that what the tenant is telling you is accurate.

Related: Tenant Screening Failure: How to Avoid a Similar Fate

The Secret Sauce

Last but not least is Dingo’s hot sauce. I want you to evaluate someone’s character. I’m not sure the legality on this, but we’ll talk about legals in another blog post. If someone complains about a light bulb in one of your rentals that was recently renovated, they need to move to Beverly Hills. By all means, try and live in the Taj Mahal. I’m telling you guys, tenants like these are a recipe for disaster. You are going to get a lot of miscellaneous little complaints. These people are going to nag on your life and on your soul. You don’t want that. Trust me.

It doesn’t matter how much money they make. It doesn’t matter how much of a deposit they’re willing to put down. I don’t care if they are willing to pay rent 17 years in advance. You’ll never hear the end of these miscellaneous “problems” that are nonexistent. When someone is not happy with themselves from within, they won’t be happy with anything or anyone else. I promise you that.

Guys, that pretty much concludes my post for today. I hope you enjoyed it.

Comment below! I’d love to hear any additional tips that you guys might use when picking good tenants for your property.

About Author

Engelo Rumora

Engelo Rumora, a.k.a.”the Real Estate Dingo,” quit school at the age of 14 and played professional soccer at the age of 18. From there, he began to invest in real estate. He now owns real estate all over the world and has bought, renovated, and sold over 500 properties. He runs runs Ohio Cashflow, a turnkey real estate investment company in the country (Inc 5000 2017 & 2018) and is currently in the process of launching a real estate brokerage called List’n Sell Realty. He is also known for giving houses away to people in need and his crazy videos on YouTube. His mission in life is to be remembered as someone that gave it his all and gave it all away.


  1. Marina Spor

    Thanks for an important article. Another thing that I look for is the amount of debt that they have. This gives me an indication of financial responsibility and also if they’re living beyond their means (meaning that they will have issues paying their rent at some point).

    Question regarding the 3 times income criteria… is this income before or after taxes? I usually look at gross income (before taxes) but maybe that’s too lax?

      • I would not assume that most people have additional income.

        Requiring 3 times the rent turns the standard guideline on its head, and everyone is doing it now so no one even remembers the standard guideline. Look at the typical tenant income for the location of the unit and the rent should be no more than 7-10 days salary. The purpose is to not price out the people most likely to be your tenants.

  2. Bernie Neyer

    Your Dingo’s hot sauce is dead on. A tenant’s attitude and personality will tell you more about them than even a background check may tell. If previous landlords have done cash-for-keys there may not be any record for evictions, nor a credit down grade. Almost always the perspective tenant will give you clues as to their occupancy, and all to often I’ve only recognized them in hind sight.

  3. JL C.

    Good article. One comment about the tenant with a criminal record paying 6 months in advance: I would have a conversation with them about how they managed to “save” that much. Conversationally, not an interrogation – but I would be highly suspicious unless their work history and rental history and credit report made it very clear their income outpaced their debt. Otherwise, I would assume that 6 month’s rent came from ill-gotten gains.

      • I know a landlord who took a year’s rent in advance. A year went by with no further contact, no complaints, no maintenance requests, no nothing. A year and a day later, no rent. When the landlord eventually went into the house, he discovered the living room had two feet of dirt in it and the house had evidently been used as a grow site. The landlord threw in the towel and walked away from the house. It eventually sold at auction.

    • Engelo Rumora

      Hi David,

      It seems like you’re the type of person that needs a tonne of disclaimers, etc…

      Please see below something I pulled from my website.

      I’m sure Bigger Pockets has their own also 🙂

      Much success

      Terms Of Use

      About this web site
      The Ohio Cashflow network of websites comprising its national and regional zone sites, blogs and social media (“Ohio Cashflow Sites”), including, but not limited to ohiocashflow.com, ohiocashflowelite.com, engelorumora.com, realestatedingo.com, sellyouhousetoledo.com and getpaidtolearn.today, is owned and operated by Ohio Cashflow, LLC (“Ohio Cashflow”, “us” or “we”).
      About these terms and conditions
      These are the terms and conditions upon which we permit you to use the Ohio Cashflow Sites. By using any of the Ohio Cashflow Sites, you agree that you have read and agree to be bound by these terms and conditions. If you do not agree to be bound by them, you must refrain from using the Ohio Cashflow Sites. These terms and conditions apply together with any other terms stated to govern your use of particular parts of the Ohio Cashflow Sites, such as the Privacy Statement. We may amend these terms and conditions at any time and therefore recommend that you periodically review them so that you remain informed of any changes. These terms and conditions are governed by the law of the State of Ohio. By using this site you agree to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Courts of that State in respect of any proceeding involving this site. Any dispute concerning the use or content of the Ohio Cashflow Sites shall be litigated in the state or federal courts located in Lucas County, Ohio.
      The information, opinions and publications available on our website, blogs and social media channels (Ohio Cashflow Sites) are broad guides for general information only. They are solely intended to provide a general understanding of the subject matter and to help you assess whether you need more detailed information. The material on this website and other Ohio Cashflow Sites is not and should not be regarded as legal, financial or real estate advice. Users should seek their own legal, financial or real estate advice where appropriate. Every effort is made to ensure that the material is accurate and up to date. However, we do not guarantee or warrant the accuracy, completeness, or currency of the information provided. You should make your own inquiries and obtain independent professional advice tailored to your specific circumstances before making any legal, financial or real estate decisions. Results may vary and are not typical of every individual. Engelo Rumora is a real estate investing expert. Any income or earnings depicted are not to be interpreted as common, typical or expected. The variables that impact results of real estate investing are so numerous and uncontrollable that Ohio Cashflow Sites makes no guarantee as to your income or earnings from real estate investments. Just like any other investment, you could lose money on a real estate investment.
      Limitation of liability
      To the extent that the law allows:
      we (including our officers, employees, agents and members) are not liable for any special, indirect, incidental, punitive, exemplary, aggravated, economic or consequential loss or damage, howsoever caused, including, but not limited to, loss of data, loss of use, loss of savings and/or loss of profits, which you may directly or indirectly suffer in connection with your use of the Ohio Cashflow Sites or your reliance on any information contained on them; and any condition or warranty which would otherwise be implied into these terms and conditions is hereby excluded. We cannot and do no warrant that the use of Ohio Cashflow Sites or any material downloaded from it will not cause damage to any property, including, but not limited to, loss of data, computer viruses, and other types of electronic data contamination You understand that your use of the Ohio Cashflow sites is entirely at your own risk.
      Copyright and Ownership
      The rights to all information, text, graphics, logos, button icons, images, digital downloads, data compilations, software, advertisements, sound recordings and software on the Ohio Cashflow Sites (“Content”) are owned by Ohio Cashflow or its members or suppliers. The Content is protected by United States and international copyright and trade mark laws. You are not permitted to use, modify, copy, reproduce, hyperlink, frame, up-load to a third party, post, transmit, on-sell or distribute any Content except as is expressly permitted by these terms and conditions, or unless Ohio Cashflow consents in writing. Any third-party trademarks, service marks and logos are the property of their respective owners. By submitting any content to Ohio Cashflow Sites, you grant
      Your rights to use the Ohio Cashflow Sites
      So long as you comply with these terms and conditions, you may:
      download, view and/or print any of the Content for your personal use; or if you are an Internet service provider or Internet access provider, supply the Content to your subscribers; or if you are a Ohio Cashflow member, interact with the Ohio Cashflow Sites for the purpose of your business activities, provided such interaction is consistent with both these terms and conditions and any relevant policies or agreements between you and Ohio Cashflow.
      Linked Sites
      Some of the sites listed as links to this site (“links”) are not under the control of Ohio Cashflow (for example, the web sites of our independently owned and operated members). Ohio Cashflow makes no representations whatsoever concerning the content of those sites. Ohio Cashflow assumes no responsibility for the condition or content of third party sites that may be linked to or accessed from Ohio Cashflow Sites. YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THE CONTENT OF SUCH SITES MAY NOT BE CURRENT, UP TO DATE, COMPLETE OR NOT TAMPERED WITH AND THEREFORE, IS NOT TO BE RELIED UPON. Links are provided for your convenience only and may not remain current or be maintained. The fact that we have provided a link should not be construed as an endorsement, approval, recommendation or preference by Ohio Cashflow of the owners or operators of the linked sites or of any information, products or services referred to on those sites, unless we expressly state that this is the case.
      Specific Obligations for Ohio Cashflow Members
      The Ohio Cashflow Sites may from time to time contain facilities which enable you to submit content for posting to the site (“Listing Facilities”). When using the Listing Facilities you must:
      ensure the content you submit is not unlawful or for an improper purpose and is not misleading or deceptive, defamatory, in breach of any copyright, trade mark or obligation of confidentiality, and not contrary to privacy legislation or any other applicable law; and not submit or transmit anything containing a virus or other harmful component.
      You acknowledge that:
      you must take your own precautions to ensure the process you use to access the Ohio Cashflow Sites does not expose you to risk of viruses or other forms of interference which may damage your data or computer systems; you are responsible for the contents of any web site that we permit you to link to the site; by submitting content to any of the Ohio Cashflow Sites, you freely grant Ohio Cashflow a non-exclusive right to use, reproduce and adapt that content to the extent necessary to operate and promote the Ohio Cashflow Sites; we may, from time to time in our absolute discretion, edit, refuse to post or remove any content (in whole or in part) that you have submitted to the Ohio Cashflow Sites; and we have no responsibility for the content posted or transmitted by you or other users of the Ohio Cashflow Sites.
      We may in connection with your use of the Ohio Cashflow Sites, provide you with a password, username and/or similar access code (“Password”). By using the Ohio Cashflow Sites, you acknowledge that:
      your Password must not be shared, transferred, or used by any person other than your authorized personnel; you are responsible for keeping your Password confidential; and you are liable for all costs, liability and expense incurred in connection with the use of that Password (whether or not authorized by you), except to the extent caused by any negligence on the part of Ohio Cashflow.

  4. Jerry W.

    This is probably the best article you have written. At least for how your investing style fits with mine. The absolute worst mistake you can make as a buy and hold landlord is getting the wrong tenants. No one can afford to wait for the top 1% tenants out there, but identify the train wrecks and stay away. You will still get burned once in awhile, but be careful. My local market has been hammered from loss of jobs and cuts in pay due to the oil price drop. I had a house open for nearly 3 months that was a nice house. It killed me to turn down 3 or 4 applicants in a row for it. I have another house that opened up because the renters bought their own house. I am having the same problem with it. I may end up with a bad tenant, but I will avoid the ones I know are wrecks. I have no problems saying it is perfectly legal to not rent to whiners. You have to be careful if they are from a protected class, but whiners are not a protected class. I have rented to folks who I convicted of a felony, but I knew the circumstances. The character of a person and their ability to pay rent are the biggest factors. Thanks for taking the time to share your knowledge.

  5. Joohn Cliiford on

    Hi, Nice video. 3 Steps for Choosing Quality Tenants for Your Rentals. Really helpful for landlords. So before going to choose any tenant for your home must go through this post. Landlords get a lot of miscellaneous little complaints from their tenant but you have to manage the issues at your level. Some days before I got to know about Rocket Eviction as an eviction service provider of Las Vegas. Thanks for sharing such information with us.

  6. Manon Sheiman

    I like the amplified version you have posted on YouTube. 10 criteria plus a bonus, I recommend that folks look it up.

    What I want to know is if it is legal to judge a person by one’s instincts, or character. I’ve been interviewing to find a PM in San Antonio (wish I’d gone to the Midwest instead, taxes are sky high in TX), and he told me that it was crossing the line to use instincts as a criteria for whether to rent or not to an applicant.

    As I self managed in the past, in my naive days, I always used my instincts, and partly as a result, I loved my tenants. They never moved out and I never had an eviction, or any maintenance requests, for that matter. I say naive because I never dreamed I wouldn’t be allowed to do that.

    There are lots of ways to judge a person’s character, from their ability to communicate articulately to how neat or messy the inside of their purse and car are. Are these things illegal? When I mentioned them to the prospective PM, he got touchy, said he couldn’t use his instincts, only the criteria such as credit check, income, record, etc, the standard things. But I read the purse tip in an apartment owners’ trade magazine, thought it was pretty good, tho not the whole ball of wax.

    • Engelo Rumora

      Thanks Manon,

      You pose a great question.

      It’s a touchy subject and there could be implications with the fair housing authority.

      All of the blogs I do are just my opinion and please do your due diligence.

      Much success

Leave A Reply

Pair a profile with your post!

Create a Free Account


Log In Here