If you bought the property for 50K with 10K down and 30K rehab. ARV is 100K and you refinance with a 70K loan. You have a LTV of 70%. Yes you have 10K stuck in. If your cash flow is $500 per month you would have generated $6000 of cash flow giving you an annual 60% cash on cash return. In 8 months you will have all of your money back out and from that point on you have infnite return. In some cases you can get a Refi at 75% or 80%. In theory you could get all your money out based on the lender.
I don't understand your calculation. In 8 months I would have $4000 if I cash flow $500 a month. Not $10k. I would need 20 months to get back the $10k invested. Am I missing something?
@Uneeq Khan I think of BRRRR as two investments, so 2 separate IRR or return calcs.
First period is through refi, so up until any return of capital, or refi’d cash back.
During this time, all cash inflows and all cash outflows count for the return calculation. All of them.
Second is post refi, which can essentially be infinity if you get all your money since you have 0 net contributions being put in, but have returns.
I’m assuming your occupancy, capex, and maintenance is covered in your rent, so 0 net contribution.
Most common mistake I see: calculating IRR over the full time investment, incl after refi, so many many months or years down the line.
Issue is IRR calcs generally assume you are reinvesting your returned capital at the same return. That is a big assumption and likely not correct.
Chances are you are getting some money back, maybe more or less, holding it for some time, probably a month or week while hunting the next deal, then reinvesting it in something with a different investment profile. Might be better, might be worse. It almost certainly is not the same.
This is why I like XIRR, or running just one simple return calc through up until refi. Careful if your period is not exactly 1 year.
Probably overkill on this topic but wanted to help.
Im still hunting my first deal btw - just so happens I have some experience in related finance fields.
Work on Wall Street, so see this stuff all the time although in a different context.
Will invest in Austin or LA in case anyone wants to chat.
Or discuss good returns :)
Just out of curiosity - how are you running your moh? What resources (calculators/spreadsheets) are you using?
I'm currently developing my own spreadsheet. It's nothing special but I designed it in a way to help me understand if the deal is good or not and includes other things like 1% rule, holding cost, cost of projects, and other details that aren't found the BP calc. I could also work backwards and figure out what the purchase price would need to be to get an ROI of 12%. My understanding of ROI was off so numbers didn't make sense.
I prefer making my own spreadsheet vs BP calc because I want to understand the formulas. This is the best way to do it. This way I can make proper adjustments for specialized situations. Once I fully understand all the formulas, I will use the BP calc for simplicity.
You simply need the estimated dates, cash outflows and cash returns. A calculator, MS excel, or similar type resource will do the calculation for you. You do not need to do it by hand (and shouldn’t)
I use my HELOC for my BRRRR rehabs. When I refinance, I pay my HELOC down to $0 with an 80% Loan to value. I am trying to calculate my ROI now, 3 years later and measure them again my stock market returns....Please advise!
1. The cash on cash (in this case you are calling it ROI). The property needs to cashflow to keep your business plan going.
2. The DSCR (debt service coverage ratio). To keep getting lending, keep this above 1.25. This number is a factor of the income of the property covering the expenses. For me... even if I get good cashflow, since I rely on lending, if the property falls below 1.25 DSCR, I will think twice about the business plan.
3. The ROE (return on equity). BRRRR investing actually bumps up your ROE because you are pulling equity out. this number will also drop as your tenant pays down the loan AND as the market appreciates.
Keep an eye on these 3 numbers to drive your investment!