ARV, LTC, and Exit Strategy: The Numbers That Make or Break Fix & Flip Deals

ARV, LTC, and Exit Strategy: The Numbers That Make or Break Fix & Flip Deals

Lender · Nationwide · Member since 2022 · 46 posts · 28 votes

ARV, LTC, and Exit Strategy: The 3 Numbers That Decide Whether a Fix & Flip (or Fix & Hold) Works

One of the most common mistakes I see investors make isn’t the rehab budget or the contractor.

It’s misunderstanding ARV, LTC, and the exit — and how tightly they’re connected.

ARV (After Repair Value)
ARV isn't what you hope the property is worth.
It’s what today’s appraiser and lender can support with real comps.

If your ARV is off:

  • Your loan size shrinks
  • Your cash-to-close grows
  • Your refinance may not work at all

LTC (Loan-to-Cost)
Many investors hear “90% financing” and assume:

That’s rarely true.

LTC is based on:

  • Purchase price
  • Rehab budget
  • The lender's ARV (not yours)

If ARV comes in light, LTC caps kick in fast — and that's where deals blow up before or after closing.

Exit Strategy Is Not Optional
Flip or hold, the exit must be underwritten before you buy.

For a fix & flip:

  • Can the ARV support resale comps after time, price reductions, and market shifts?

For a fix & hold:

  • Can the property qualify for a DSCR refinance at today's rates?
  • Does stabilized rent actually cover the debt?
  • How much cash stays in the deal after refi?

A property can be:

  • A great flip
  • A terrible DSCR exit

And that’s where investors get stuck with too much cash in the deal.

The Right Order of Operations
Experienced investors don’t ask:

They ask:

Then they reverse-engineer:

  • ARV
  • Loan structure
  • Purchase price
  • Rehab scope

Same house.
Same renovation.
Very different outcome — because the exit was designed, not guessed.

Curious how others here are underwriting ARV and exits in today's market — especially for fix-and-hold deals.

3Reply
119 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Paramus, NJ · Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 4 votes
    8mo

    Even if the deal is a fix and hold we typically require it to make sense both ways (holding or selling). We want you to have exits. For example a fix and hold would still require a 12.5% profit (after all fees, points, interest, etc) in the event of a sale. 

  • Kenneth GarrettPro Member
    Investor · Florida Panhandle/Illinois · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    8mo

    @Paul Garwol

    I reverse engineer every deal. It's the only way I can tell whether the deal makes sense. I don't care much about asking prices, I only care about what it could be. I'm mostly a BRRRR investor (buy and hold). I look at a property that is being sold for $150K and I put 50K or less in and the ARV is greater than $250K we have a possibility.

    You have to be realistic about ARV. Are there multiple comps or just one outlier. If the other comps are $235K, but you have one comp at $260K your ARV will probably under $250K. You have to average them to be conservative. I had a property where the ARV was a little low, but there was a property that went under contract for $20K higher. I had to wait for that property to sell before I could refinance, because the current comps would not support my number. Did I get lucky yes. It doesn't hurt to get lucky, but don't count on it. Remember the only comps that count are solds. Active or pending don't help for ARV. They can help when you're flipping for activity, but then DOM is important.

    In simple terms; purchase, plus rehab, plus closing cost and holding cost need to be 75%-80% of your realistic ARV. No cash out just refinancing your money out or your hard money lender or private money.

    Be realistic on rental income as well. Comps are important. Don’t go for the highest comp. Again be conservative. Find a tenant who will stay multiple years. That’s not so easy. No one knows for sure.

    Best of Luck.

  • Lender · Nationwide · Member since 2022 · 46 posts · 28 votes
    8mo

    @Kenneth Garrett

    Well said — that's exactly how disciplined BRRRR investors avoid getting trapped. Reverse-engineering from a realistic ARV and refinance terms, not asking price or best-case comps, is the difference between repeatable deals and lucky ones. Waiting on sold comps, not hope, is the move.

    We see this daily doing value reports on properties across the country, working off the most current comps lenders and appraisers actually use.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.