4-Family - Rehab Advice

Member since 2022 · 30 posts · 8 votes

2. Define full "systems" rehab ? I would seek a different loan and appraisal, seek a private appraisal since your a architect draft elevations and plans of after repaired combine with your SOW. I've had 30-60 percent differences in appraisals based on different banks.

appraisers work for the banks even if they are subbed/contracred they "talk" and know what loans should hit and they can vary based on if a bank truly wants to do the loan or not, they can also vary due to lack of experience or knowledge, a lot of times if something is too far out out of an appraiser's wheelhouse, they can very greatly. and the more specialized something is the more expensive it is to have an appraisal done. for example, I had a project where somebody that was highly specialized in doing what I was doing was $15,000 for the appraisal but then somebody that could do It was $4000 and there was a lot of appraisers that were around that in the pool that the bank sends a request for appraisal to, my banker told me and he chose the $4000 guy then I had a private one done for 11,000 and the difference was $600,000 on a $1.2 million project. find somebody that specializes in it, and that is very confident in it, get it done and then turn that into a bank, even though they will still use their own Appraiser sometimes bankers will give you options of using a more specialized firm that still report reports to them. but in today's day and age for the lower and appraise project comes back the less they give you the less they're on the hook for and they're being more conservative in these days with these rates. just like buying a used car. They're just moving numbers around. this is coming from somebody with over a decade and experience who is done over 500 projects for myself and for other others utilizing Construction loans on residential commercial and historic projects. I'm a contractor, a real estate agent and a home inspector so I've seen a lot of aspects of it. two of my best friends are commercial loan officers, and so they get to tell me the ends and out

0 Reply

Caleb Brown

Real Estate Agent · Kansas City · Member since 2018 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes

7mo

If you can get a loan through a different bank, lender then that'd be your best bet. They'll either do formal appraisals or desk ones. If you can have comps handy that'd help your case. In the meantime doing 1 unit at a time wouldn't be terrible. Seems like a hefty project so many lenders or banks won't touch it or will be very conservative

0 Reply

Matthew Bernal

Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2021 · 497 posts · 127 votes

6mo

The $210K appraisal is your real problem — not the financing itself. Local banks are constrained by that number. A different appraisal or a different lender approach solves this.

You actually have strong evidence to challenge it. Your own recent refi in the same neighborhood came in at $131/sqft in August 2025. At 3,000 square feet of finished space your 4-family should appraise significantly higher than $210K once renovated. That comp is directly relevant and worth pushing on with a new appraisal ordered through a lender who understands value-add multifamily.

On the lending side, asset-based bridge lenders focus on total project cost and sponsor experience rather than current as-is value. With your architecture background, prior rehab experience, and a GC already pricing the work, your sponsor profile is strong for exactly this type of lender.

I work with investors on bridge and construction financing for value-add multifamily and this deal structure is familiar territory.

What's the total square footage across all four units?

0 Reply

Pierre Guirguis

Lender · Marlboro, NJ · Member since 2025 · 243 posts · 150 votes

6mo

Local banks aren’t going to stretch on a vacant building with no comps and an existing first mortgage. They’re underwriting what’s there today, not what it could be after a full rehab, so the $210k appraisal is kind of expected in that context.

Renovating one unit at a time will technically work, but it’s going to drag this out and make it harder to ever get a clean valuation. Partial rehabs don’t get rewarded the same way a fully stabilized property does.

The cleaner path here is usually short-term rehab/bridge capital that’s built for this exact situation. Finish all four units, lease them up, then refinance once you have actual income to support value. At that point, lenders care a lot more about the rent roll than the lack of comps.

On the appraisal side, I’d also make sure you’re bringing your own data. Rent comps, nearby 2–4 unit sales (even if you have to go slightly outside the immediate pocket), and a tight scope of work can make a big difference in how the deal gets viewed.

If you really want to avoid outside capital, then yes, doing it in phases is the fallback. Just go in knowing you’re trading speed and potentially valuation for control.

0 Reply

Drew SygitBusiness Member

Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 12k+ posts · 9k+ votes

6mo

Quote from @Dylan Kennedy:

Looking for some input from more experienced investors on financing strategy for a current deal.

I recently purchased a 4-family property for $125,000 in an up and coming rental area. I put 25% down, so I have an existing loan balance of roughly $94,000.

The property is vacant and needs a full systems rehab, but has great interiors (intact plaster, beautiful trim, 11 foot ceilings, hardwood floors, great windows, doors). My estimated rehab budget is $200,000 to update infrastructure of the brick building and turn each 750 sf unit into a 2 bedroom 1 bath.

Once stabilized, I believe the property could be worth somewhere in the $375k-$425k range, depending on final rents and level of finish. Estimated rents after rehab are roughly $1,200-$1,400 per unit. (and the rental I just cash out refinanced appraised at $131 a sq ft in the same neighborhood 8/2025). However, due to lack of comps in the neighborhood, and historic disinvestment, the ARV appraisal came back at $210,000...

Here's where I'm running into challenges:

Local banks are hesitant to lend additional rehab funds because the property is currently vacant and already has a first mortgage.

I don't want to bring in partners if possible.

I'm trying to decide between:

1: renovating one unit at a time with equity and credit.
2: seeking a different loan, and or appraisal.

What do I do?

For context, I have prior rehab experience on 2 single family rentals and live/work very close to the property, so 1 can oversee construction regularly. I'm an architect by trade and have a GC pricing different alternatives.

What is each unit now, if you're going to turn into 2/1?

What is your, "full systems rehab" consist of?

What did it appraise for when you bought it?
- If its ARV is actually $375k-$425k, it's highly likely it would have appraised for more than the $125k purchase price.

The appraiser may be right and your assumptions wrong:(

[email protected]248-209-6824

Logical Property Management4.9460 Reviews

Website View Page

0 Reply

Jesse Byrer

Lender · Chicago, IL · Member since 2008 · 54 posts · 34 votes

6mo

@Dylan Kennedy where is the property located? Just need state. If your credit is over 740+ I have a high leverage rehab product. The key seems to be your ARV. I could do up to 75% of your ARV. We do need at least a 1.05 DSCR ratio. Long story short there are guidelines that have to be met, but need more information. Happy to run the numbers with you. Message me your contact info and I can see if we have a solution.

0 Reply

Bo SmithPro Member

Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 1k+ posts · 373 votes

6mo

This is a tough spot, but it's solvable. Your appraisal is conservative because the comparables are weak in that neighborhood -- that's actually normal for transitional markets. But here's the reality: banks lend on appraisals, not potential, so you've got three real options, not two.

Option one, renovating unit-by-unit with equity, is doable but slow. You'll be managing construction on an occupied building, dealing with tenant disruptions, and your cash flow will be inconsistent as units come online one at a time. Since you're an architect with GC experience, you can oversee this, which is a huge advantage -- most investors can't. The advantage is you avoid debt and partners.

Option two is to challenge the appraisal. Get a second opinion from another appraiser. If that first appraiser missed comparable rents (you mentioned your other property appraised at 31/sf in the same neighborhood just last year), you have grounds to request a reconsideration. Some lenders will work with you here, especially if you can show recent comps that support higher values. The cost is 00-500 but could unlock 50-100K in lending capacity.

Option three, which nobody mentions, is creative financing. Some community banks or portfolio lenders will finance rehab projects differently than your original mortgage lender. They underwrite based on the after-rehab value, not the current appraisal. It costs more in interest, but you stabilize faster and then refi into a conventional loan once it's stabilized and appraising correctly. This is where your deal actually makes money instead of breaking even across three years.

What are you planning for a hold strategy -- is this a long-term rental or are you exiting after stabilization?

0 Reply

Vijay FriedmanBusiness Member

Miami, FL · Member since 2026 · 766 posts · 123 votes

5mo

Quote from @Dylan Kennedy:

Looking for some input from more experienced investors on financing strategy for a current deal.

I recently purchased a 4-family property for $125,000 in an up and coming rental area. I put 25% down, so I have an existing loan balance of roughly $94,000.

The property is vacant and needs a full systems rehab, but has great interiors (intact plaster, beautiful trim, 11 foot ceilings, hardwood floors, great windows, doors). My estimated rehab budget is $200,000 to update infrastructure of the brick building and turn each 750 sf unit into a 2 bedroom 1 bath.

Once stabilized, I believe the property could be worth somewhere in the $375k-$425k range, depending on final rents and level of finish. Estimated rents after rehab are roughly $1,200-$1,400 per unit. (and the rental I just cash out refinanced appraised at $131 a sq ft in the same neighborhood 8/2025). However, due to lack of comps in the neighborhood, and historic disinvestment, the ARV appraisal came back at $210,000...

Here's where I'm running into challenges:

Local banks are hesitant to lend additional rehab funds because the property is currently vacant and already has a first mortgage.

I don't want to bring in partners if possible.

I'm trying to decide between:

1: renovating one unit at a time with equity and credit.
2: seeking a different loan, and or appraisal.

What do I do?

For context, I have prior rehab experience on 2 single family rentals and live/work very close to the property, so 1 can oversee construction regularly. I'm an architect by trade and have a GC pricing different alternatives.

@Dylan Kennedy

This looks like a capital structure problem more than just a rehab question. Since the property is vacant, already has a first mortgage, and the appraisal came in low, local banks may be cautious even if the stabilized value is much higher.

I'd focus on documenting the full value-add story: current payoff, rehab scope, contractor bids, as-is value, ARV support, rent comps, timeline, permits, and exit plan. If the numbers support it, a bridge/private money structure or phased rehab plan could make more sense than relying only on local bank financing.

Renovating one unit at a time can work, but I’d be careful not to underestimate carrying costs and timeline risk while the rest of the building remains vacant.

786-656-0387

DreamPoint Capital

Website View Page

0 Reply

4-Family - Rehab Advice

8 Replies