@Daniel LaMontagne feel free to reach out when you get into town. I will tell you for the reasons you mentioned above (Walmart & Tysons) the entry level rental market (residential and commercial) is pretty saturated and there is a lot of folks over paying for property. Not to say there aren't still deals out there but most I've seen actually get listed get run up to where the numbers don't make sense. I think there will be more opportunity here in the new 2-3 years but right now people are being silly with money... I'd encourage you to do some research into whats going on here in regards to building and where we are in the cycle as well as vacancy of some of the newer apartments that have been built in Rogers and Springdale. Don't get me wrong, I'm not telling you to not invest here just advising caution and due diligence. PM me if you have any thing I can help with.
@Daniel LaMontagne I'm another San Diegan that invests in Arkansas, but central rather than NWA. If I were a guessing man, NWA is going to grow a good clip faster than Central Arkansas over the next 10-20 years. However, the mid-sized multis that I have looked at in NWA tend to be on the outskirts. It's not a "bad" thing but I don't think it has the same shot as appreciation as if you were - hypothetically - investing in the core of Fayetteville. Once you look at the core of Fayetteville you do end up with some (as @Dustin Davis notes) some prices that aren't exactly cheap.
One other thing to keep in mind is that "increasing values" doesn't 100% always correlate to appreciation. What I have notest (and this is a little on the anecdotal size) is that a lot of the new developments in Arkansas (NWA and Central) are nicer. The homes are bigger, wood floors, slab granite, etc. Some of them just look like the same standard mini-Orange County look. It's great that the sales prices are higher and it's awesome that the economic growth can support it, but sometimes it's fit-and-finish as much as it's "dirt" appreciating.
So what would I do in your shoes? Sell the Oceanside place and go heavy into NWA. Go for a small scale commercial apartment building so that you can get appreciation through nudging rent increases. I really like Arkansas but I don't want to depend on the dirt increasing in value. But that's just me. It's not a market where I'd buy SFRs. Well, okay, I would but it would have to be a heck of the deal.
@Daniel LaMontagne ... @Andrew Johnson is pretty accurate in saying that dirt appreciation is limited to the "core" areas... I'll detail it a bit more just to keep us all on the same page... I view the 2 cores in NWA as the University of Arkansas and downtown Bentonville/WM Home Office. These are areas where some of the appreciation we are seeing currently will continue and maintain (it's where the money is)... Just to note on a quick exception, housing in DT Bentonville cannot continue to demand $200+ /sqft long term, just sayin'.
Then you have working class cities like Rogers and Springdale where a lot of blue collar folks live and need affordable housing... You won't see the appreciation in these areas continue very long because wage rates for the hourly folks are not following the same upward path and that will naturally keep the balance.
If I had the money and the time, I'd be looking at Tulsa first, then over to Ft Smith... 2-3 years ago would have been the time to jump on NWA property, now with the inventory level about to correct and values WAY over what they should be caution is highly advised.
Thank you @Dustin Davis and
@Andrew Johnson for your replies in light of my failure to ensure proper formatting.
My goal is cash flow; the appreciation is merely a bonus. The numbers simply have to make sense. I’m on board with the fact that a plethora of investors seems to be driving prices sky high at this point across the country. This is why I’m doing my due diligence to find the few areas where investing has the potential to make sense.
There has been a development surplus across the country in A class apartments as @Dustin Davis noted, which has already led to a minor rent correction in this upscale apartment class. The fact that the working class hourly wage is not following the appreciation trend is a significant concern. I will dig deeper into specific market research and look into Tulsa as well. @Dustin Davis I will contact you when I get my travel plans sorted out.
@Andrew Johnson I appreciate your thoughts regarding my decision, and I plan to push forward with the small - midsize commercial apartment building as you suggest.
I would also be interested in hearing how the property management situation has played out for you in AR as I am working towards a similar investment setup to what you have. If you have some time at some point I would love to take a few mins to pick your brain.
- Danny LaMontagne
@Daniel LaMontagne Property management for me has been fine. In two out of my three purchases there were stabilization issues for the first year. Tenants move out even with no rent increases. You find out funky little things that you didn't know before like random "verbal promises" about a 13th month of free rent...that aren't on the lease...and aren't "confirmable". And I don't know if "great" property management can get those under control any quicker than mine did but those issues just pop-up...par for the course. That said, I tend to focus on newer buildings with above-average rents so I'm not dealing with bottom-of-the-barrel tenants. While I wouldn't say my units are "upscale" (no amenities like pools or gyms) they definitely aren't the "1971 build in need of new kitchens" if that makes sense. So I'm stacking the deck a little more in my favor. The rents aren't as high as going down-market but it's a little more predictable and much less hassle.
I, honestly, don't know how median income has fared in much of Arkansas. It's ticked up where I invest but not like much of the rest of the country. So I don't think it's viable to assume I can raise rents $50/year or something of that nature. But maybe nudge them $5-$15 at unit turnover and see how that progresses over time. At least then I'm "forcing appreciation" through rent raises (however slight) rather than depending on dirt. If I was investing in Fayetteville, I do think it would make much more sense to look at "the dirt" as there's been development there, gentrification, etc.
And all of that is going on while the football program is in a reboot and the Hogs basketball team losing to LSU :-/
Free eBook from BiggerPockets!
Join BiggerPockets and get The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing for FREE - read by more than 100,000 people - AND get exclusive real estate investing tips, tricks and techniques delivered straight to your inbox twice weekly!
- Actionable advice for getting started,
- Discover the 10 Most Lucrative Real Estate Niches,
- Learn how to get started with or without money,
- Explore Real-Life Strategies for Building Wealth,
- And a LOT more.
Sign up below to download the eBook for FREE today!
We hate spam just as much as you
Join the Largest Real Estate Investing Community
Basic membership is free, forever.