I'm looking at a 9 unit deal in California. It's two buildings. First unit is a 4 plex all 2 bed 1 bath with coin op laundry room, Second unit is a 5 plex with 4 - 2/1 units and fifth is a 1/1 with coin op laundry. Owner pays water, trash and hot water about $21k in 2025.
2025 collected rent was $136k three of the units are way under priced, one tenet has been in place for 37 years!!! Market rent would be about $3700 a month more than collected now.
What is this worth?
The family angle changes everything on the negotiation side, for better and worse. Better because you'll probably get honest financials and first shot at the deal. Worse because if something goes sideways with the property it's sitting at the Thanksgiving table with you.
Knowing the 37-year tenant doubles as the handyman is actually a bigger deal than the below-market rent. When he eventually leaves, you're not just losing rent and doing a make-ready on that unit, you're also losing your on-site maintenance. Factor in the cost of replacing that function when you model the turnover.
20 years managing SFRs is solid. Coin-op laundry and shared utilities add operational complexity you might not have dealt with on houses, but you'll figure that part out.
On calculators, I've never found one that captures a deal like this well. Too many moving pieces with the staggered rent raises and the long-tenured turnover. I'd build a simple year-by-year spreadsheet that tracks in-place income against projected income after each unit turns, alongside actual expenses. That way you can model the 3-4 year rent raise path and see what the cash flow looks like at each stage instead of just the endpoint.
There are plenty of calculators to run the numbers, but the real value is in asking the right questions. Can you reasonably raise rents without causing vacancy? Who owns the washer/dryer, and who’s responsible for maintenance? What does it mean that tenants pay for water and hot water — are there separate meters, or is it shared? What capex (roof, HVAC, plumbing, etc.) should you expect? Who is managing the property and who will in the future? Map out your month-one expenses, then run a few scenarios for the first 12 months and out to 1–3 years.
Also, consider the bigger picture: is the property in the path of progress, or is the area stagnant with little growth? What are the alternative properties?
I'm looking at a 9 unit deal in California. It's two buildings. First unit is a 4 plex all 2 bed 1 bath with coin op laundry room, Second unit is a 5 plex with 4 - 2/1 units and fifth is a 1/1 with coin op laundry. Owner pays water, trash and hot water about $21k in 2025.
2025 collected rent was $136k three of the units are way under priced, one tenet has been in place for 37 years!!! Market rent would be about $3700 a month more than collected now.
What is this worth?
Why haven't you used one of the BiggerPockets Calculators?
The thing I'd push back on is starting from "what's this worth at market rents." That's not what it's worth today. That's what it could be worth after you've turned every tenant, made every renovation, and survived every eviction. Two different valuations.
Run it on the actuals first. $136k collected rent, less the $21k owner-paid utilities, less your real operating expenses. On a small commercial deal like this I'd budget at least 35-40% expense ratio off gross rent before debt service, and that's before you touch capex. You probably don't have a T-12 yet, but ask the seller for it and look at what was actually spent on R&M, insurance, taxes. California taxes alone will eat a chunk depending on how Prop 13 works on this transfer. That's your in-place NOI. Cap that at whatever 9-units trade for in your specific submarket and you've got a value the bank and an honest appraiser will support.
Then run the pro forma separately. $44k of additional rent annually is real upside, but it costs money to capture. The 37-year tenant is the biggest line item in that calculation. Someone who's been in place that long pays well below market because they want to and nobody made them move. When you turn that unit you're paying for capex on a place nobody has touched in decades, on top of legal costs, lost rent during the turn, and whatever just-cause or rent control rules apply. California is not a friendly state for that. I'd probably underwrite that unit at zero rent for 6-9 months and a $15-25k make-ready before counting any of the new rent. The other under-rented units are easier but still take 3-6 months and a few thousand each.
Look, the deal isn't necessarily bad. There's real upside there. But you only get hurt if you pay the seller for the upside before you've earned it. I've made that mistake on a smaller scale and it stings for years. Pay for what's actually there now. Whatever you capture above that is your reward for doing the work.
The thing I'd push back on is starting from "what's this worth at market rents." That's not what it's worth today. That's what it could be worth after you've turned every tenant, made every renovation, and survived every eviction. Two different valuations.
Run it on the actuals first. $136k collected rent, less the $21k owner-paid utilities, less your real operating expenses. On a small commercial deal like this I'd budget at least 35-40% expense ratio off gross rent before debt service, and that's before you touch capex. You probably don't have a T-12 yet, but ask the seller for it and look at what was actually spent on R&M, insurance, taxes. California taxes alone will eat a chunk depending on how Prop 13 works on this transfer. That's your in-place NOI. Cap that at whatever 9-units trade for in your specific submarket and you've got a value the bank and an honest appraiser will support.
Then run the pro forma separately. $44k of additional rent annually is real upside, but it costs money to capture. The 37-year tenant is the biggest line item in that calculation. Someone who's been in place that long pays well below market because they want to and nobody made them move. When you turn that unit you're paying for capex on a place nobody has touched in decades, on top of legal costs, lost rent during the turn, and whatever just-cause or rent control rules apply. California is not a friendly state for that. I'd probably underwrite that unit at zero rent for 6-9 months and a $15-25k make-ready before counting any of the new rent. The other under-rented units are easier but still take 3-6 months and a few thousand each.
Look, the deal isn't necessarily bad. There's real upside there. But you only get hurt if you pay the seller for the upside before you've earned it. I've made that mistake on a smaller scale and it stings for years. Pay for what's actually there now. Whatever you capture above that is your reward for doing the work.
Victor, Thank you for running through this deal with me. I have walked the units and the 37 year tenet was the handy man for the owner (BTW is my mother in law). They will be a 3-4 year project for raising his rents. I will be managing the units, I have 20 years experience managing 6-8 SFR's.
Thanks Jay
PS what is the best calculator to use for a deal like this?
When you turn that unit you're paying for capex on a place nobody has touched in decades, on top of legal costs, lost rent during the turn, and whatever just-cause or rent control rules apply. California is not a friendly state for that. I'd probably underwrite that unit at zero rent for 6-9 months and a $15-25k make-ready before counting any of the new rent. The other under-rented units are easier but still take 3-6 months and a few thousand each.
I'm sure you already considered this but I agree 100% on the rent control considerations, especially given that rent control is a moving target that is never in the investors' favor. There's state level control (AB1482) and then there's local rent control specific to a county/city/etc. (e.g., in 2026 Los Angeles will implement stricter Rent Stabilization Ordinance (RSO) rules....).
The family angle changes everything on the negotiation side, for better and worse. Better because you'll probably get honest financials and first shot at the deal. Worse because if something goes sideways with the property it's sitting at the Thanksgiving table with you.
Knowing the 37-year tenant doubles as the handyman is actually a bigger deal than the below-market rent. When he eventually leaves, you're not just losing rent and doing a make-ready on that unit, you're also losing your on-site maintenance. Factor in the cost of replacing that function when you model the turnover.
20 years managing SFRs is solid. Coin-op laundry and shared utilities add operational complexity you might not have dealt with on houses, but you'll figure that part out.
On calculators, I've never found one that captures a deal like this well. Too many moving pieces with the staggered rent raises and the long-tenured turnover. I'd build a simple year-by-year spreadsheet that tracks in-place income against projected income after each unit turns, alongside actual expenses. That way you can model the 3-4 year rent raise path and see what the cash flow looks like at each stage instead of just the endpoint.