Should I Invest Passively in Real Estate Syndications?

Should I Invest Passively in Real Estate Syndications?

Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes

Perhaps you currently work a 9-to-5 job that’s wearing you down, and you’re looking for an escape. Perhaps you’re tired of the long commutes and don’t want to miss any more of your son’s baseball games. Perhaps you’re ready to take control of your life and start making your money work for you, rather than the other way around.

Traditionally, when people think of real estate investing, they think of buying a rental property. This is exactly what I did when want to get into real estate for the first time!

You might have $50,000 to invest, so you use that $50,000 as a down payment on a rental property. You get a loan for $150,000 and buy a $200,000 property. You then find a property manager who helps you to find a good tenant and collect the rent every month.

If the roof leaks, you're responsible for the repairs. If the tenant moves out, you're responsible for finding a new tenant. On the flip side, you get to keep all the profits, and you get to decide how long to hold the asset, when and whether to make improvements, and when to sell. You have all the control.

Fair warning - Managing your own rental portfolio can quickly turn into a part time job. As a working professional, your time is valuable. You most likely have a spouse, kids, and have very limited time in the evenings, if any, to focus on real estate.

On the opposite end of the spectrum are passive real estate investors, those who want to invest in real estate but don’t want to deal with the hassles of being a landlord. In this model, instead of you buying a whole property with your $50,000, you put that $50,000 into a group investment. Someone else has $50,000 to invest too, a third investor puts in $100,000, and so on.

Now, instead of a single-family rental property, you pool your resources together with a group of investors in order to buy an apartment building. As a passive investor, you put in your money, and that’s the end of your active role in the investment. You don't have to do anything else. You can focus on living your life. You will be able to attend your kid’s sporting event on Saturday instead of spending your day off painting your duplex because the tenants just moved out.

6Reply
198 views

Most Popular Reply

Jim PfeiferBusiness Member
Investor · Dublin, OH · Member since 2014 · 241 posts · 495 votes
5y

@Justin Goodin

I got into passive syndication investing a few years ago - I sold all of my active multifamily and SFH properties because I got tired of managing property managers. I found that even though I was not actively managing, this was nowhere near the passive investing that I wanted.

Syndications has been very different.  It is active in the beginning as you are vetting sponsors and learning the markets, but once you invest you leave it up to the professional manager to handle the asset.  The returns have been similar to my active investments, but the amount of time and effort I need to put into it is considerably lower.

It is intimidating to start as you have to wire $50,000 to someone you may have only talked to on the phone a few times, but once you start developing relationships and a network and once you find a Community, you gain confidence and it becomes much easier.

See this reply in the discussion

29 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Coral Gables, FL · Member since 2016 · 199 posts · 266 votes
    5y

    @Justin Goodin  Good summary of some of the considerations that have to be thought through by real estate investors. I started as an LP in several syndications and like that option to learn more about the investments and people in the business. 

  • Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @E. C. "Stony" Stonebraker:

    @Justin Goodin  Good summary of some of the considerations that have to be thought through by real estate investors. I started as an LP in several syndications and like that option to learn more about the investments and people in the business. 

    Awesome! What are a few things you learned about being an LP in your first syndication investment? What gave you the idea to invest in apartments?

  • Jim PfeiferBusiness Member
    Investor · Dublin, OH · Member since 2014 · 241 posts · 495 votes
    5y

    @Justin Goodin

    I got into passive syndication investing a few years ago - I sold all of my active multifamily and SFH properties because I got tired of managing property managers. I found that even though I was not actively managing, this was nowhere near the passive investing that I wanted.

    Syndications has been very different.  It is active in the beginning as you are vetting sponsors and learning the markets, but once you invest you leave it up to the professional manager to handle the asset.  The returns have been similar to my active investments, but the amount of time and effort I need to put into it is considerably lower.

    It is intimidating to start as you have to wire $50,000 to someone you may have only talked to on the phone a few times, but once you start developing relationships and a network and once you find a Community, you gain confidence and it becomes much easier.

  • Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    5y

    @Jim Pfeifer I completely agree! It can be really daunting to wire someone a huge amount of your HARD EARNED capital. This is why I always preach to evaluate the sponsor, their team, and their track record first...then the deal. 

    Glad to hear your syndication investments are working out for you. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Coral Gables, FL · Member since 2016 · 199 posts · 266 votes
    5y

    @Justin Goodin, as an LP, I found out quickly that trust in the sponsor is the ultimate requirement. The right sponsor & team relieves an investor, after thorough DD, of nearly all tasks involved in CRE investments. An LP should still always study the offerings and ask the sponsor any questions the LP has about offerings. And the LP should expect regular communications about a property's performance during the ownership period, but the sponsor is paid to improve the investor returns as much as safely possible.

    When I looked into CRE to invest, I read a lot of books, listened to podcasts and interviewed people I knew in the business for about 18 months. From that background, it was clear that the recession-resistant multifamily sector was where I wanted to invest my family's money to get good returns with low risk. Finding out about the Sharpe ratio and studying true rates of return, true costs of mutual funds, etc. all helped in my decision.

  • Jim PfeiferBusiness Member
    Investor · Dublin, OH · Member since 2014 · 241 posts · 495 votes
    5y

    @E. C. "Stony" Stonebraker @Justin Goodin

    I completely agree with both of you - the sponsor is the most important part.  A quality sponsor can't make a bad deal good, but a bad sponsor can certainly make a good deal bad.  First evaluate the sponsor - then dig into the market and the deal.  I wish I had that advice when I first started investing in syndications - I spent too much time chasing the shiny object and investing with sponsors I had met briefly, but hadn't completely vetted.  Fortunately, most of those deals are performing OK, but there are quite a few that I wouldn't invest in today knowing what I know now!

    I also believe strongly in finding a Community and a network so you can leverage the experience of others.  BP is a great place to start and there are also plenty of groups that focus on syndications exclusively.  That has been a big help along my journey.

  • Lender · Houston · Member since 2018 · 18 posts · 18 votes
    5y

    @Justin Goodin - Very nice and simple pitch for passive syndications.

    I entered passive multifamily investing after doing several single-family rental rehabs.  I also self-managed the properties, so it was very time intensive while working a FT job.  

    Like @E. C. "Stony" Stonebraker, I did a lot of research into multifamily before committing to my first passive syndication.  I read books and went to every meetup I could find.  I planned follow-up conversations with General Partners and got a feel for how they evaluated deals. It can be intimidating looking over an investment proposal and figuring out what to watch out for, but as long as the incentives between GP and LPs are aligned, it is a great way to create truly passive income.

  • Rental Property Investor · Coral Gables, FL · Member since 2016 · 199 posts · 266 votes
    5y

    @Jamie Grubb, @Jim Pfeifer, we all go through a learning process, and the quickest way, by far, to learn is by doing, hopefully with people you trust and who may coach you along the way.  Whether that is by investing as an LP, investing in smaller properties, or investing in a coaching program, they can all work.  

    The main advantage of investing in syndications as asked by @Justin Goodin, is the passive nature of them.  It is an excellent method to invest and has largely been unknown to the general public until recent years.  Mostly syndications have been known and available primarily to knowledgeable, full-time investors and friends of the wealthy.  Thanks to the internet and online platforms such as BP, the word is spreading!

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2021 · 48 posts · 17 votes
    5y

    @E. C. "Stony" Stonebraker what is the range of ROI?

    What methods have you used to vet syndicated investment companies?

  • Rental Property Investor · Coral Gables, FL · Member since 2016 · 199 posts · 266 votes
    5y

    @Rebekah Hitt, I've seen ROIs for LPs promoted from 6% or 8% for conservative institutional investments to 15% and higher IRRs, especially a few years ago.  Today, returns are compressing because of competition so you won't see as many of the higher returns offered. 

    We check backgrounds, referrals, regulatory databases, online searches, etc.  Mostly, we want to get to know the sponsor and their team to be sure we are compatible with our investment strategies and personalities and that we can trust them. 

  • Investor · Passiveadvantage.com · Member since 2019 · 166 posts · 91 votes
    5y

    @Rebekah Hitt It can be overwhelming at first to learn how to vet syndication deals.  I have now invested in over ten syndications in the last 4 years, and we are always learning.  The upfront education process as a passive investor is certainly not passive at all but it is worth it for someone who is serious about having a portion of their portfolio focused on passive real estate syndications.  When I first started out I committed to a full year focused solely on educating myself on vetting deals, and learning metrics and qualities to look for such as the sponsor, market and the deal.  There are many resources out there with the primary medium being books such as @Brian Burke Hands off Investor, Blogs and Forums such as Bigger Pockets, and a number of good podcasts on passive investing such as @Taylor L. who has a show called "Passive Wealth Strategies".  Please let me know if I can answer any other questions.  Best of luck.

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2021 · 48 posts · 17 votes
    5y

    @Duke Giordano thank you….I am interested and will follow up on your recommendations!

    What is the percent you usually give up to get into each deal with the syndicate? I’m curious how much of a spread and what the entry capital would be for most deals?

    $100k? More?

  • Investor · Passiveadvantage.com · Member since 2019 · 166 posts · 91 votes
    5y

    This varies by type of investment and the medium on which the investment s offered.  On crowdfunding sites you may find minimums as small as 1-5K, whereas for many private placement offering the minimums most commonly are in the 25-50K range but some are higher in the 75-100K.  I generally invest the minimum when first investing with a sponsor and then if I feel that the dealings with that sponsor have been positive such as communication, response to questions, deal performance etc. then I would invest more on the next deal for that sponsor.  Hope that helps.

  • Rental Property Investor · RVA · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Duke Giordano:

    @Rebekah Hitt It can be overwhelming at first to learn how to vet syndication deals.  I have now invested in over ten syndications in the last 4 years, and we are always learning.  The upfront education process as a passive investor is certainly not passive at all but it is worth it for someone who is serious about having a portion of their portfolio focused on passive real estate syndications.  When I first started out I committed to a full year focused solely on educating myself on vetting deals, and learning metrics and qualities to look for such as the sponsor, market and the deal.  There are many resources out there with the primary medium being books such as @Brian Burke Hands off Investor, Blogs and Forums such as Bigger Pockets, and a number of good podcasts on passive investing such as @Taylor L. who has a show called "Passive Wealth Strategies".  Please let me know if I can answer any other questions.  Best of luck.

     Thank you for the shout!

  • Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Duke Giordano:

    This varies by type of investment and the medium on which the investment s offered.  On crowdfunding sites you may find minimums as small as 1-5K, whereas for many private placement offering the minimums most commonly are in the 25-50K range but some are higher in the 75-100K.  I generally invest the minimum when first investing with a sponsor and then if I feel that the dealings with that sponsor have been positive such as communication, response to questions, deal performance etc. then I would invest more on the next deal for that sponsor.  Hope that helps.

     Great points, I agree that starting with the minimum is a safe way to go. Once you gain confidence in the sponsors ability to execute, then you can invest more in the long run. Building wealth is a long term play for sure. 

  • Ian IppolitoBusiness Member
    Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Rebekah Hitt:

    @E. C. "Stony" Stonebraker what is the range of ROI?

    What methods have you used to vet syndicated investment companies?

     For vetting a syndication, different investors do it differently because every investor comes from a different financial situation and has different goals and risk tolerance. For me, I'm a very conservative investor and may look through a hundred deals a month, and at the end of the year only invest in 4-5. So things that are a red flag for me may be fine for someone more aggressive. Here's how I do my due diligence:

    1) Portfolio matching: (takes 30 seconds per deal)

    a) Have an educated opinion on where I think we are in the real estate cycles (financial and physical market cycles)

    b) Then and only then do I pick the strategies, capital stack, and specialized asset subclasses that make sense for that opinion. For example, I am a little concerned about some aspects of the business cycle recovery and a potential for a double-dip so I lean toward the safest part of capital stack which is debt (or low-debt equity). I won't go with the riskiest opportunistic strategies, and will stick to core and core plus mostly with some value-added. I won't be investing in the riskiest/most supportable asset subclasses such as hotels, and tilt my portfolio the ones that have historically been more stable such as multifamily and single-family housing. I also don't want refinancing risk, so any deals with only 3 to 5 year debt are out for me. For someone that's not as conservative, or a different view on the cycle, they might have a different opinion than me on all of this.

    2) Sponsor quality check: (takes about 45 minutes per deal)

    I believe that a great sponsor can take an average looking deal and make it great, and that in mediocre sponsor can take a fantastic looking deal and make it bad (especially if there is a severe recession). So I start with the sponsor first. Again, others might disagree.

    a) Track Record: Get the entire track record for the strategy. As easy as this sounds, it's not simple and usually like pulling teeth. Many times they will claim it's wonderful and then try to hide their worst deals by only showing completed deals. Make sure to get unexited deals. Or if they are doing value-added multifamily, they will show you their hotel experience. That doesn't cut it for me. I want a specialist that's an expert, and not a jack of all trades and master of none. Also, in a mainstream asset class like value-added multifamily, I see no reason to take a risk on a sponsor that doesn't have full real estate cycle experience and didn't lose money. Again, other might feel differently here.

    b) Skin in the game: as a conservative investor, I understand that the dirty secret of industries that the waterfall compensation is in the line with me and incentivizes sponsors to take more risk. So I require skin in the game (average is 5% to 15%) to offset this. Contrary to popular belief, this is not set because I believe it will give me a higher return. I believe it tends to give me a slightly lower return, because the sponsor is going to be more careful, and if there is a severe downturn will prevent me from taking catastrophic losses. Someone that is more aggressive, may want lesser even though skin in the game. Also, if the sponsor is new, I am fine with less skin in the game as long as it is significant to their net worth. On the other hand if they are a sponsor that is experienced in stopping a skin in the game, that's a huge red flag for me.

    c) how open to scrutiny are they? I always discuss investments with others in an investor club because other people might think of things that I might miss. And even though virtually every sponsor agreement allows me to share investment information with others who might be advising me on it (especially when club members are bound by an NDA), I still ask the sponsor if I can share it, because it's a test. Most are fine with that, but a few will have problems with it and claim there are legal issues, etc.. That's a red flag for me.

    d) death by Google: I Google everything I can about the sponsor. I check the SEC, FINRA, ratings websites for inside information on the principals in the company. I also look for lawsuits and see what happened in them. Many times it's an easy red flag. Sometimes it's ambiguous, but even then, why should I bother with the company that has numerous unresolved lawsuits, versus another company that is virtually the same but has none. Again, others might feel differently here.

    3) property level due diligence: (takes seconds to weeks per deal): here is where I drill in with the low-level details.

    a) pro forma popping: I examine all the assumptions, and see if they are overoptimistic or not. I look at every single item in the pro forma and imagine that it is complete BS, and see if I can challenge it. If there's a hole, it may be a red flag.

    b) sensitivity analysis: I examine all the assumptions, and make sure I can live with the worst case scenarios.

    c) "Stall and see": if they are getting money over multiple years, and there is no penalty for investing later, I would usually wait so I get some real performance data, versus having to look at theoretical pro forma information.

    d) Recession stress test: I will not invest in anything, until I subject it to recession level stress and see if I can live with the result. And I take the worst recession I can find in the recent past. Sometimes there is only great recession data, and that recession was pretty mild on some asset classes, versus previous recessions. So I will usually 1.5x or 2.0x the stress. If the deal collapses and I would lose everything, I'm out. Others might be fine with taking risk, but least by doing this a person can get an idea of what might go wrong.

    e) Legal document analysis: it will usually take a few days to go through the legal document properly, as almost inevitably there are tons of gotchas that either have to be explained, or mitigated with a side letter.

    That is the very short summary of what I do. If you want more information, p.m. me and I can give you a lot more details.

    The Real Estate Crowdfunding Review
    View Page
  • Bernadeau C.Pro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Orlando, FL · Member since 2014 · 540 posts · 230 votes
    5y

    @Justin Goodin i am looking to invest actively because i am planning on doing this full time in the near future. i would invest as an LP if i could shadow and learn the process from the GP. 

  • Investor · Smyrna, GA · Member since 2016 · 58 posts · 16 votes
    5y

    @Bernadeau C. What markets are you interested in?

  • Bernadeau C.Pro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Orlando, FL · Member since 2014 · 540 posts · 230 votes
    5y

    @Michael Penny i am currently interested in major metros in fl but i have since been branching out to the southeast. 

  • Rental Property Investor · St. Paul, MN · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Ian Ippolito:
    Originally posted by @Rebekah Hitt:

    @E. C. "Stony" Stonebraker what is the range of ROI?

    What methods have you used to vet syndicated investment companies?

     For vetting a syndication, different investors do it differently because every investor comes from a different financial situation and has different goals and risk tolerance. For me, I'm a very conservative investor and may look through a hundred deals a month, and at the end of the year only invest in 4-5. So things that are a red flag for me may be fine for someone more aggressive. Here's how I do my due diligence:

    1) Portfolio matching: (takes 30 seconds per deal)

    a) Have an educated opinion on where I think we are in the real estate cycles (financial and physical market cycles)

    b) Then and only then do I pick the strategies, capital stack, and specialized asset subclasses that make sense for that opinion. For example, I am a little concerned about some aspects of the business cycle recovery and a potential for a double-dip so I lean toward the safest part of capital stack which is debt (or low-debt equity). I won't go with the riskiest opportunistic strategies, and will stick to core and core plus mostly with some value-added. I won't be investing in the riskiest/most supportable asset subclasses such as hotels, and tilt my portfolio the ones that have historically been more stable such as multifamily and single-family housing. I also don't want refinancing risk, so any deals with only 3 to 5 year debt are out for me. For someone that's not as conservative, or a different view on the cycle, they might have a different opinion than me on all of this.

    2) Sponsor quality check: (takes about 45 minutes per deal)

    I believe that a great sponsor can take an average looking deal and make it great, and that in mediocre sponsor can take a fantastic looking deal and make it bad (especially if there is a severe recession). So I start with the sponsor first. Again, others might disagree.

    a) Track Record: Get the entire track record for the strategy. As easy as this sounds, it's not simple and usually like pulling teeth. Many times they will claim it's wonderful and then try to hide their worst deals by only showing completed deals. Make sure to get unexited deals. Or if they are doing value-added multifamily, they will show you their hotel experience. That doesn't cut it for me. I want a specialist that's an expert, and not a jack of all trades and master of none. Also, in a mainstream asset class like value-added multifamily, I see no reason to take a risk on a sponsor that doesn't have full real estate cycle experience and didn't lose money. Again, other might feel differently here.

    b) Skin in the game: as a conservative investor, I understand that the dirty secret of industries that the waterfall compensation is in the line with me and incentivizes sponsors to take more risk. So I require skin in the game (average is 5% to 15%) to offset this. Contrary to popular belief, this is not set because I believe it will give me a higher return. I believe it tends to give me a slightly lower return, because the sponsor is going to be more careful, and if there is a severe downturn will prevent me from taking catastrophic losses. Someone that is more aggressive, may want lesser even though skin in the game. Also, if the sponsor is new, I am fine with less skin in the game as long as it is significant to their net worth. On the other hand if they are a sponsor that is experienced in stopping a skin in the game, that's a huge red flag for me.

    c) how open to scrutiny are they? I always discuss investments with others in an investor club because other people might think of things that I might miss. And even though virtually every sponsor agreement allows me to share investment information with others who might be advising me on it (especially when club members are bound by an NDA), I still ask the sponsor if I can share it, because it's a test. Most are fine with that, but a few will have problems with it and claim there are legal issues, etc.. That's a red flag for me.

    d) death by Google: I Google everything I can about the sponsor. I check the SEC, FINRA, ratings websites for inside information on the principals in the company. I also look for lawsuits and see what happened in them. Many times it's an easy red flag. Sometimes it's ambiguous, but even then, why should I bother with the company that has numerous unresolved lawsuits, versus another company that is virtually the same but has none. Again, others might feel differently here.

    3) property level due diligence: (takes seconds to weeks per deal): here is where I drill in with the low-level details.

    a) pro forma popping: I examine all the assumptions, and see if they are overoptimistic or not. I look at every single item in the pro forma and imagine that it is complete BS, and see if I can challenge it. If there's a hole, it may be a red flag.

    b) sensitivity analysis: I examine all the assumptions, and make sure I can live with the worst case scenarios.

    c) "Stall and see": if they are getting money over multiple years, and there is no penalty for investing later, I would usually wait so I get some real performance data, versus having to look at theoretical pro forma information.

    d) Recession stress test: I will not invest in anything, until I subject it to recession level stress and see if I can live with the result. And I take the worst recession I can find in the recent past. Sometimes there is only great recession data, and that recession was pretty mild on some asset classes, versus previous recessions. So I will usually 1.5x or 2.0x the stress. If the deal collapses and I would lose everything, I'm out. Others might be fine with taking risk, but least by doing this a person can get an idea of what might go wrong.

    e) Legal document analysis: it will usually take a few days to go through the legal document properly, as almost inevitably there are tons of gotchas that either have to be explained, or mitigated with a side letter.

    That is the very short summary of what I do. If you want more information, p.m. me and I can give you a lot more details.

     Great list Ian! One thing I found curious though was this: "I see no reason to take a risk on a sponsor that doesn't have full real estate cycle experience and didn't lose money."

    Why do you want to invest with sponsors that lose money? I get wanting to work with sponsors that have had experience and gone through trials, but if they did that and still made money or at least broke even, wouldn't that be better? What comes to my mind is - "well if they lost money once and bounced back from it, then will they be ok with losing money again, knowing that they can bounce right back once more?"

  • Ian IppolitoBusiness Member
    Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Todd Dexheimer:
    Originally posted by @Ian Ippolito:
    Originally posted by @Rebekah Hitt:

    @E. C. "Stony" Stonebraker what is the range of ROI?

    What methods have you used to vet syndicated investment companies?

     For vetting a syndication, different investors do it differently because every investor comes from a different financial situation and has different goals and risk tolerance. For me, I'm a very conservative investor and may look through a hundred deals a month, and at the end of the year only invest in 4-5. So things that are a red flag for me may be fine for someone more aggressive. Here's how I do my due diligence:

    1) Portfolio matching: (takes 30 seconds per deal)

    a) Have an educated opinion on where I think we are in the real estate cycles (financial and physical market cycles)

    b) Then and only then do I pick the strategies, capital stack, and specialized asset subclasses that make sense for that opinion. For example, I am a little concerned about some aspects of the business cycle recovery and a potential for a double-dip so I lean toward the safest part of capital stack which is debt (or low-debt equity). I won't go with the riskiest opportunistic strategies, and will stick to core and core plus mostly with some value-added. I won't be investing in the riskiest/most supportable asset subclasses such as hotels, and tilt my portfolio the ones that have historically been more stable such as multifamily and single-family housing. I also don't want refinancing risk, so any deals with only 3 to 5 year debt are out for me. For someone that's not as conservative, or a different view on the cycle, they might have a different opinion than me on all of this.

    2) Sponsor quality check: (takes about 45 minutes per deal)

    I believe that a great sponsor can take an average looking deal and make it great, and that in mediocre sponsor can take a fantastic looking deal and make it bad (especially if there is a severe recession). So I start with the sponsor first. Again, others might disagree.

    a) Track Record: Get the entire track record for the strategy. As easy as this sounds, it's not simple and usually like pulling teeth. Many times they will claim it's wonderful and then try to hide their worst deals by only showing completed deals. Make sure to get unexited deals. Or if they are doing value-added multifamily, they will show you their hotel experience. That doesn't cut it for me. I want a specialist that's an expert, and not a jack of all trades and master of none. Also, in a mainstream asset class like value-added multifamily, I see no reason to take a risk on a sponsor that doesn't have full real estate cycle experience and didn't lose money. Again, other might feel differently here.

    b) Skin in the game: as a conservative investor, I understand that the dirty secret of industries that the waterfall compensation is in the line with me and incentivizes sponsors to take more risk. So I require skin in the game (average is 5% to 15%) to offset this. Contrary to popular belief, this is not set because I believe it will give me a higher return. I believe it tends to give me a slightly lower return, because the sponsor is going to be more careful, and if there is a severe downturn will prevent me from taking catastrophic losses. Someone that is more aggressive, may want lesser even though skin in the game. Also, if the sponsor is new, I am fine with less skin in the game as long as it is significant to their net worth. On the other hand if they are a sponsor that is experienced in stopping a skin in the game, that's a huge red flag for me.

    c) how open to scrutiny are they? I always discuss investments with others in an investor club because other people might think of things that I might miss. And even though virtually every sponsor agreement allows me to share investment information with others who might be advising me on it (especially when club members are bound by an NDA), I still ask the sponsor if I can share it, because it's a test. Most are fine with that, but a few will have problems with it and claim there are legal issues, etc.. That's a red flag for me.

    d) death by Google: I Google everything I can about the sponsor. I check the SEC, FINRA, ratings websites for inside information on the principals in the company. I also look for lawsuits and see what happened in them. Many times it's an easy red flag. Sometimes it's ambiguous, but even then, why should I bother with the company that has numerous unresolved lawsuits, versus another company that is virtually the same but has none. Again, others might feel differently here.

    3) property level due diligence: (takes seconds to weeks per deal): here is where I drill in with the low-level details.

    a) pro forma popping: I examine all the assumptions, and see if they are overoptimistic or not. I look at every single item in the pro forma and imagine that it is complete BS, and see if I can challenge it. If there's a hole, it may be a red flag.

    b) sensitivity analysis: I examine all the assumptions, and make sure I can live with the worst case scenarios.

    c) "Stall and see": if they are getting money over multiple years, and there is no penalty for investing later, I would usually wait so I get some real performance data, versus having to look at theoretical pro forma information.

    d) Recession stress test: I will not invest in anything, until I subject it to recession level stress and see if I can live with the result. And I take the worst recession I can find in the recent past. Sometimes there is only great recession data, and that recession was pretty mild on some asset classes, versus previous recessions. So I will usually 1.5x or 2.0x the stress. If the deal collapses and I would lose everything, I'm out. Others might be fine with taking risk, but least by doing this a person can get an idea of what might go wrong.

    e) Legal document analysis: it will usually take a few days to go through the legal document properly, as almost inevitably there are tons of gotchas that either have to be explained, or mitigated with a side letter.

    That is the very short summary of what I do. If you want more information, p.m. me and I can give you a lot more details.

     Great list Ian! One thing I found curious though was this: "I see no reason to take a risk on a sponsor that doesn't have full real estate cycle experience and didn't lose money."

    Why do you want to invest with sponsors that lose money? I get wanting to work with sponsors that have had experience and gone through trials, but if they did that and still made money or at least broke even, wouldn't that be better? What comes to my mind is - "well if they lost money once and bounced back from it, then will they be ok with losing money again, knowing that they can bounce right back once more?"

     Thanks Todd. Sorry that's a typo. I should have said I personally require my sponsors have full real-estate cycle experience and "little to no money lost". I'm fine with them losing a little bit of money if they have learned from it but and perfectly happy if they have lost none.

    The Real Estate Crowdfunding Review
    View Page
  • Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    5y

    @Ian Ippolito Interesting point but that's why many people bring on experienced partners and mentors to the deal. So yes, one or more GPs members may not have gone 'full cycle' but their partners have. 

  • Ian IppolitoBusiness Member
    Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Justin Goodin:

    @Ian Ippolito Interesting point but that's why many people bring on experienced partners and mentors to the deal. So yes, one or more GPs members may not have gone 'full cycle' but their partners have. 

    In my experience there aren't very many people who have actually gone full real estate cycle (even if you limit the criteria to just one partner).

    Also those who have gone full cycle have usually developed an enthusiastic investor base over many decades and have more money being thrown at them then they can find good deals to deploy and. So these people usually don't have much economic incentive to partner up with a newbie partner (who would also only increase the chance of something going wrong and damaging their own reputation and track record...which would be problematic for them).

    Also personally I'm not a fan of deals that have too many "chefs in the kitchen" (who can potentially argue and "spoil the soup"). I want one person in charge and want them to be the most experienced possible. That way there's no arguing and the decisions have the highest chance of being the correct ones.

    I also haven't seen very many newbies who are fortunate enough to be mentored by a full cycle sponsor (most very experienced sponsors don't want to give away processes they have created and honed over decades and are a competitive advantage for their firms). But if a newbie is so lucky, I personally would consider that to be a long way from having the actual experience necessary to be equivalent. And I personally I'm not going to put my money with someone like that when I can just go with the "real thing".

    But, someone else coming from a different place (especially if they love the sponsor and deal) will feel completely differently and be fine with alot less experience than I am.

    The Real Estate Crowdfunding Review
    View Page
  • Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Ian Ippolito:
    Originally posted by @Justin Goodin:

    @Ian Ippolito Interesting point but that's why many people bring on experienced partners and mentors to the deal. So yes, one or more GPs members may not have gone 'full cycle' but their partners have. 

    In my experience there aren't very many people who have actually gone full real estate cycle (even if you limit the criteria to just one partner).

    Also those who have gone full cycle have usually developed an enthusiastic investor base over many decades and have more money being thrown at them then they can find good deals to deploy and. So these people usually don't have much economic incentive to partner up with a newbie partner (who would also only increase the chance of something going wrong and damaging their own reputation and track record...which would be problematic for them).

    Also personally I'm not a fan of deals that have too many "chefs in the kitchen" (who can potentially argue and "spoil the soup"). I want one person in charge and want them to be the most experienced possible. That way there's no arguing and the decisions have the highest chance of being the correct ones.

    I also haven't seen very many newbies who are fortunate enough to be mentored by a full cycle sponsor (most very experienced sponsors don't want to give away processes they have created and honed over decades and are a competitive advantage for their firms). But if a newbie is so lucky, I personally would consider that to be a long way from having the actual experience necessary to be equivalent. And I personally I'm not going to put my money with someone like that when I can just go with the "real thing".

    But, someone else coming from a different place (especially if they love the sponsor and deal) will feel completely differently and be fine with alot less experience than I am.

    You don’t see very many people that have gone full cycle on real estate syndications? Meaning buying and selling the property and exiting the syndication? Where are you looking? They are not hard to find. 

    To your point about too many chefs in the kitchen. Multi family is a team sport. On these large syndication deals, there are sometimes many GPs involved. Doesn’t mean they are all making the decisions but it takes more than 1 person to take down a huge asset. 

    My first mentor had 20 years of syndication experience and owned over 7,000 multi family units. And of course went full cycle on an abundance of deals. You don’t get to 7,000 units by doing something wrong. 

    I think you have many incorrect misconceptions about multifamily syndications but I respect your opinion. Let me know if you would like to hop on a call so I can help clear the air on some of these things. 👍

  • Ian IppolitoBusiness Member
    Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Justin Goodin:
    Originally posted by @Ian Ippolito:
    Originally posted by @Justin Goodin:

    @Ian Ippolito Interesting point but that's why many people bring on experienced partners and mentors to the deal. So yes, one or more GPs members may not have gone 'full cycle' but their partners have. 

    In my experience there aren't very many people who have actually gone full real estate cycle (even if you limit the criteria to just one partner).

    Also those who have gone full cycle have usually developed an enthusiastic investor base over many decades and have more money being thrown at them then they can find good deals to deploy and. So these people usually don't have much economic incentive to partner up with a newbie partner (who would also only increase the chance of something going wrong and damaging their own reputation and track record...which would be problematic for them).

    Also personally I'm not a fan of deals that have too many "chefs in the kitchen" (who can potentially argue and "spoil the soup"). I want one person in charge and want them to be the most experienced possible. That way there's no arguing and the decisions have the highest chance of being the correct ones.

    I also haven't seen very many newbies who are fortunate enough to be mentored by a full cycle sponsor (most very experienced sponsors don't want to give away processes they have created and honed over decades and are a competitive advantage for their firms). But if a newbie is so lucky, I personally would consider that to be a long way from having the actual experience necessary to be equivalent. And I personally I'm not going to put my money with someone like that when I can just go with the "real thing".

    But, someone else coming from a different place (especially if they love the sponsor and deal) will feel completely differently and be fine with alot less experience than I am.

    You don’t see very many people that have gone full cycle on real estate syndications? Meaning buying and selling the property and exiting the syndication? Where are you looking? They are not hard to find. 

    To your point about too many chefs in the kitchen. Multi family is a team sport. On these large syndication deals, there are sometimes many GPs involved. Doesn’t mean they are all making the decisions but it takes more than 1 person to take down a huge asset. 

    My first mentor had 20 years of syndication experience and owned over 7,000 multi family units. And of course went full cycle on an abundance of deals. You don’t get to 7,000 units by doing something wrong. 

    I think you have many incorrect misconceptions about multifamily syndications but I respect your opinion. Let me know if you would like to hop on a call so I can help clear the air on some of these things. 👍
     

    Justin, You said:

    >>You don’t see very many people that have gone full cycle on real estate syndications? Meaning buying and selling the property and exiting the syndication? Where are you looking? They are not hard to find.


    No that's not what I said. I said my personal criteria is a sponsor that has gone through at least one full *real estate cycle* (which typically takes decades and is an exclusive club)...not simply going through the cycle of buying and selling a property (which someone can do in a matter of days and virtually anyone can do).

    And a real estate cycle is not the same thing as a business cycle either. It requires a real estate recession, meaning falling real estate prices. So simply going through the Covid 19 recession is not full real estate cycle experience either because that was just a business cycle recession without falling real-estate prices.

    A sponsor that has gone at least one full real estate cycle had to endure the brutal great recession, and survived. And I personally know of less than 20 sponsors who can say this.

    And then a sponsor who has multiple real estate cycle experience has gone through multiple versions of this. I personally know of less than 10 who can say this.

    I'll add that I'm sorry that it seems my personal criteria has hit a sore spot for you. (And I'll point out that you didn't make it clear from the title of this thread and your initial post that you are actually a sponsor and the purpose is to market your services).

    Either way: please don't take it personally that I require full-cycle experience. 99% of sponsors don't meet it and it's just business and not personal. And I'm just a very conservative investor and there are plenty of other investors who very have different criteria that's less strict. In fact most investors are much less picky than I am (and you can still have plenty of people that you can market to).

    >> To your point about too many chefs in the kitchen. Multi family is a team sport. On these large syndication deals, there are sometimes many GPs involved. Doesn’t mean they are all making the decisions but it takes more than 1 person to take down a huge asset.


    You're entitled to your opinion. In my opinion this shows how you both your experience and resources are very limited compared to some other sponsors (and too limited to be a match for me to invest in, personally). But again, this is just my own criteria and there are many investors that are different and require less experience (who you can market to).

    So you know: Sponsors that have been successful enough to go full real estate cycle have been growing for decades and are generally able to take down assets completely on their own. And there are actually many, many sponsors who have far less experience that that and still have the resources to take down properties costing hundreds of millions of dollars completely on their own.

    It is only has to be a team sport to those who don't have the resources to do it on their own (which isn't every sponsor).

    Again please don't take it personally as all of this is just my own criteria and there are many, many others that feel differently (and who you can still market to). For me I know that in the great recession there were a lot of sponsors that went bankrupt because the banks weren't lending, money was tight and they didn't have the personal resources to dig deep and save deals. So I want to deep-pocketed sponsor to avoid that risk. But there are plenty of other investors who don't mind, and who you can market to.

    >>My first mentor had 20 years of syndication experience and owned over 7,000 multi family units. And of course went full cycle on an abundance of deals. You don’t get to 7,000 units by doing something wrong.


    I'm glad you found a mentor although as I said above there's a big difference between a full real estate cycle and simply going through the cycle of buying and selling a property.

    Also there were also plenty of sponsors who bought thousands of units and still went belly up in the great recession. 

    But again, full real estate cycle experience is just my personal criteria. And there are many other investors who do not require that (who you can still market to).

    >>I think you have many incorrect misconceptions about multifamily syndications but I respect your opinion. Let me know if you would like to hop on a call so I can help clear the air on some of these things. 👍


    Thanks but we are very clearly not a fit. I wish you good luck with your marketing and your business.
    The Real Estate Crowdfunding Review
    View Page
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.